Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you hate out adventure activities?

189 replies

user1496262496 · 19/02/2023 13:30

I run an outdoor centre which is primarily for young people. The sort of place schools book in to for a week and the young people do climbing, mountain walks, canoeing and bushcraft etc.

The culture of outdoor activities such as rock climbing, mountaineering and paddle sports has traditionally been male dominated. Participation has traditionally been male dominated. British Canoeing’s web site and Mountain Training’s website have loads of figures about this. There is research… but no one seems to ask the women who don’t engage, or who got put off for some reason at a young age.

I want the activities my centre runs to be as appealing as possible and for the young people to have the best time.

Where do outdoor centres etc go wrong?

I am interested to hear from women who don’t like outdoor adventure activities. What was it that put you off them? What is it that means they aren’t something you would do as an adult?

I don’t think I am unreasonable to think there is a problem in my industry.

If your DC didn’t like their school residential, why didn’t it work for them?

OP posts:
OriGanOver · 19/02/2023 14:43

I love outdoor activities but they're quite scary if you haven't done them. I was terrified doing GoApe but the sense of achievement I felt after was amazing!

It's also an income level issue. If you want to be outdoorsy with dc it's expensive to get the kit especially as they grow!

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 19/02/2023 14:43

Anything involving strength seems to default to male, so from the off you’re on the back foot. I don’t have the upper body strength to haul myself up walls/paddle for ages and I always just feel shit when doing these kinds of activities. I’m a confident runner so it’s not a fitness issue. Male instructors have no idea, frankly.

Also the UK is shit for this kind of thing. I’ve swum for ages in Alpine lakes in the summer, where it’s warm so when you get out you’re dry quickly and changing facilities are great. In the UK with crappy facilities, shitty communal equipment an when it’s cold and windy? Ha, no thanks.

The Uk does fetishise outdoor pursuits though and attaches weird moral superiority to tramping about in the wild.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:40

Remembering Barbara Woodhouse for the brisk outdoorsy woman

Siiiiit

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/02/2023 14:40

@MelaniesFlowers

The women into these types of things always claim they’re feminine and not at all tomboy. It’s rarely true.

Er, even if that were true, why is it relevant?

And why should being "feminine" (whatever that means) be more important for girls than trying new things/learning new skills?

Thelnebriati · 19/02/2023 14:39

I love them but when I was fit enough to do anything like that I had kids and no childcare. I had jobs that were inflexible and poorly paid, and I don't think there's anything you can do about that.
There wasn't much about the activities that would have put me off. Some women might like taster classes that are aimed at novices, or women only groups.

DonttouchthatLarry · 19/02/2023 14:38

I hated this kind of thing when I was a child and refused to go on our school residential trip - I stayed at school and read in the library (I would also prefer that over P.E. any day 😄). I was a very bookwormy, indoorsy child yet somehow I have turned into a very outdoorsy active adult! I had horses for 20 years and managed to look after them in cold, wet weather and now I love hiking up mountains, trail running, cycling and open water swimming. I've tried ice climbing, canoeing and shooting. I would love an outdoor activity holiday now but as a teenager it was a definite no.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:38

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 19/02/2023 14:31

Cold, wet, lack of privacy for changing/showers, ghastly brisk hearty women who remind me of dreaded school PE teachers. The only outdoor activities I enjoy are walking in nice scenery, and swimming in the sea(even in the UK) or a suitable lake.

😅

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:37

But in comparison it's fine to humiliate people and kids in sports and these outward bound debacles

I also get p* off with someone bossing me around. Obviously different if it's in paid work

AngelinaFibres · 19/02/2023 14:36

As a teenager my biggest stress was periods. Heavy and very painful. So being halfway up a hill, in a tent overnight etc would have freaked me out for weeks beforehand.
Creepy male instructors. Far more prevalent in the 70s and 80s when I was made to do outward bound stuff but still possible I dare say.
My parents hating anything that involved getting cold and wet or out of breath or dirty or remotely adventurous. We were frequently told it wasn't something we would be any good at , even though we had never had a chance to be good or bad at it or to even try it. That ,and the idea that you must be good and kind and girly is a powerful deterrent.
Confident , loud ,noisy kids shouting at you to hurry up etc . Teachers laughing rather than splitting you into different groups so the less confident could do the tree walking etc in their in bloody time instead of showy off boy taking the mickey out of you.
I am part of a walking group now. We walk, we chat we change the person we are chatting with naturally as the walk goes on. I have the right clothing and shoes. I am fit. New alpha male types quickly realise that no one is impressed with how fast they can walk, how many ultra marathons they have done.

pinkstinks · 19/02/2023 14:34

Just existing in this body is hard enough let alone having to explain to usually a man that my body won’t fit in the things offered.
have had a man bark at me to shout my dress size so he could look for a wetsuit then didn’t ask the men this. Again ended up in n I’ll fitting gear for boobs and hips etc.
that always sets things offf badly tbh

deplorabelle · 19/02/2023 14:33

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:28

Yes depolrabelle

I like things you do at your own pace and are not under pressure because of the team. I do like a quiz though or music related stuff

I could happily do the spelling task btw

Me too! I would eat a spelling test for breakfast. And quizzes I love. But we don't generally fire general knowledge questions at people and make them go down on one knee if they don't get the answer. (At least I hope not. There is a sort of academic cut and thrust behaviour that's also very exclusionary and we should stop doing that too)

TheGoogleMum · 19/02/2023 14:33

I'm fat and unfit, it's expensive and I'm not willing to spend the money if I might not enjoy it, I'm unusually proportioned and very small so most things the average person can do I will find far more difficult (never tried a wetsuit but doubt i coukd find one that would fit), don't much like being cold and wet, not a strong swimmer, I'm quite shy so wouldn't feel brave enough to go on my own

Stompythedinosaur · 19/02/2023 14:32

Also, on a more practical front, not having access to appropriate toilet facilities during activities is far more restricting to women than men (especially when on periods).

Also, I remember never being able to access equipment from shared stores that fitted properly e.g. wetsuits. Sometimes this was handled in a very humiliating way e.g. an expectation that if you are short you must also be super super skinny, which I was not.

theblackradiator · 19/02/2023 14:32

lack of confidence and my terrible fear of heights. I couldn't even bring myself to go down a slide a couple of years ago at an outdoorsy place with the kids as it was just too high, I ended up having to come back down the steps! I felt like a right fool. Teen dd seems to have a similar fear of heights and lacks confidence this kind of thing would not be for her either. my son would love it though and would do this activities with dad.

GettingStuffed · 19/02/2023 14:32

I'm scared of heights and hate my head being in tight places plus I'm not confident in water.

On the other hand my daughter's sister-in-law is an outdoor pursuits instructor and has recently emigrated to Canada to work in the Rockies

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 19/02/2023 14:31

Cold, wet, lack of privacy for changing/showers, ghastly brisk hearty women who remind me of dreaded school PE teachers. The only outdoor activities I enjoy are walking in nice scenery, and swimming in the sea(even in the UK) or a suitable lake.

Thepurplelantern · 19/02/2023 14:31

Adore these type of activities always have in spite of the fact that I am terrified of heights.

Improbablecat · 19/02/2023 14:31

I went on to these often as a teen. I actually really enjoy kayaking and doing it as an adult in a hot country where I just had to put on a buoyancy aid over my swimsuit was a revelation.

I echo what others say - clean well equipped changing and toilet facilities would make such a difference. Decent degree of privacy to squeeze into the wetsuits. I used to go kayaking at a place with one open shower and open changing rooms. Even though it was sex segregated us girls were always mortified and would just take turns in the communal shower so getting changed after took forever. I recognise that we need to get away from feeling judged/judgemental about ourselves and others bodies but I really do think this plays into it.

I think this also extends to the other stuff - weight based climbing equipment for example. I recently did a Go Ape type thing. You got weighed going in then someone yelled your weight across the room to the bit they were distributing harnesses from. Then they were colour co-ordinated. It was so cringe and I wouldn't go back just for that reason.

zingally · 19/02/2023 14:30

I like being outdoors, but for me I'm put off because about 6 or 7 years ago I had a nasty asthma attack on a hike with my mum. It was the worst one I've ever had.
I'm not medicated for them, because they are very, very rare for me. I've only had 4 attacks in my entire life.
But the fear of having another puts me off the idea of very strenuous activity.

Stompythedinosaur · 19/02/2023 14:29

I loved outdoor activities as a teen, but was put off by the toxic culture I often encountered e.g. making everything a competition, "roughing it" as the only valid choice and ridiculing people who might choose less extreme options. I also found there was quite an unpleasant culture in many men who favoured those experiences, where they would only be willing to except women if they were super fit, slim and willing to be sexually objectified.

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 14:29

SweetSakura · 19/02/2023 14:27

I mean I am looking back on myself 20 years ago so am quite confident in what the photos show. A girl equally at home in a ballgown or a drysuit.

Anyway, of all the reasons to miss out on anything this seems the most unfortunate. But fair enough if that is honestly your priority in life I guess, to fit a perceived version of feminine at all time

I said rarely true. Not never. There are always exceptions.

And as I’ve already stated, there are multiple reasons I don’t like outdoor activities. The main ones being that it’s usually cold, wet, hard work and dull.

deplorabelle · 19/02/2023 14:29

MojoMoon · 19/02/2023 14:07

I still remember being mocked by the instructors at activity camp when I climbed to the top of a tree and then had to abseil down.

Went up confidently, then looked down (my first ever abseil) and froze with fear.

There was a very strong sense of militarism in all the outdoor camps we did as kids (and I did a fair number) - "you will suffer, you will be humiliated because you are not brave and strong enough so we will break you. "

A very crap version of the SAS challenge programme on channel 4 essentially. Usually run by sad men who thrived on making kids fear them.

So in my mind, outdoor adventures are entwined with humiliation and militarism!

That said as an adult I do outdoor swimming and have camped and even abseiled....but in female led groups only.
I've also done geo aching and navigation training trips and enjoyed them.

If the outdoor activities at kids camps had been more about the outdoor world - animal tracking, natural navigation, wildlife habitat building, I think a much wider range of kids could have engaged with the hiking and camping part of it as being a means to get to the activity.

Crossed posts with you but YES! Only pe and sometimes maths is taught by public humiliation and it's an awful way to go on. Actually music is sometimes taught this way too and it's why many adults say they can't sing when many actually can

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:28

Yes depolrabelle

I like things you do at your own pace and are not under pressure because of the team. I do like a quiz though or music related stuff

I could happily do the spelling task btw

FairyBatman · 19/02/2023 14:27

woodhill · 19/02/2023 14:24

@Fairy

Do they stay on ok?

I was thinking of the Kayak drill

Yes. They grip to the sides of your head, I've sailed and kayaked in them and capsized a few times. They also have polycarbonate lenses to protect your eyes and a polarised filter for glare and they float, although I wear a floating strap on them too.

Absolute game changer for me, although painfully expensive!

SweetSakura · 19/02/2023 14:27

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 14:15

Nope not trolling. This is a very common view, people are just too afraid to admit it.

The women into these types of things always claim they’re feminine and not at all tomboy. It’s rarely true.

I mean I am looking back on myself 20 years ago so am quite confident in what the photos show. A girl equally at home in a ballgown or a drysuit.

Anyway, of all the reasons to miss out on anything this seems the most unfortunate. But fair enough if that is honestly your priority in life I guess, to fit a perceived version of feminine at all time