Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you hate out adventure activities?

189 replies

user1496262496 · 19/02/2023 13:30

I run an outdoor centre which is primarily for young people. The sort of place schools book in to for a week and the young people do climbing, mountain walks, canoeing and bushcraft etc.

The culture of outdoor activities such as rock climbing, mountaineering and paddle sports has traditionally been male dominated. Participation has traditionally been male dominated. British Canoeing’s web site and Mountain Training’s website have loads of figures about this. There is research… but no one seems to ask the women who don’t engage, or who got put off for some reason at a young age.

I want the activities my centre runs to be as appealing as possible and for the young people to have the best time.

Where do outdoor centres etc go wrong?

I am interested to hear from women who don’t like outdoor adventure activities. What was it that put you off them? What is it that means they aren’t something you would do as an adult?

I don’t think I am unreasonable to think there is a problem in my industry.

If your DC didn’t like their school residential, why didn’t it work for them?

OP posts:
reluctantbrit · 19/02/2023 16:54

I can only say that this kind of thing wasn't offered when I was a teen and didn't even think about this as an adult apart from the odd occassion going kayaking or ziplining.

I am also wearing glasses with high prescription, can't wear contacts and can't afford to replace them when they break.

DD is 15, started scouting at 10 and is now an Explorer. She loves these things but, it's not a lot of fun when the gear doesn't fit and you have E cup size breast, you can't change in the open, you have your period and even with decent swimwear nowadays, it's not the same.

Luckily her senior Explorer leader is female. She knows where to go, what to arrange for the girls in the group and takes their issues very serious. She herself was stuck without proper provision on a camp herself and hated it.

DD was a week in the Lake District last August, a week of watersport and absolutely enjoyed it. And the main reason - the organisation took females into account, had instructors who were supportive and not making jokes about some of them (incl. boys) being hesitant and - the important bit - offered proper changing facilities for both sexes with lots of hot showers.

Tinseltown2 · 19/02/2023 16:52

I absolutely love doing activities and always enjoyed residentials as a young person; however, there were always a couple of issues that caused stress and for me those were the toilet situation and periods. I absolutely hate having to do a wild wee and still have never got the hang of it even though I'm a geologist and sometimes have to be out on a mountain all day. When I was a teenager I didn't use tampons so if my period coincided with an activity weekend I wouldn't be able to partake in any water based activity which was gutting. These days I'd just use a tampon and that wound be fine so maybe education could assist with that. Other things I hated where using smelly damp clothes and not being able to dry things out properly.

stargirl1701 · 19/02/2023 16:45

Nice changing facilities - heated floors, roomy cubicles with hooks and a bench, showers that are not push button, warm ambient temperature, etc.

Cosy space for afterwards - wood burning stove, comfortable sofas, excellent coffee, etc.

Opportunities advertised for the unfit. Gentle options - I am not fit enough to do much but I don't want to 'push' myself!

tobee · 19/02/2023 16:44

Alconleigh · 19/02/2023 16:18

The horror and humiliation of games lessons in the 1980s / 90s did for me, as for some PP. Teachers who had no idea how to motivate or engage the non sporty, and didn't try. It took until I was in my late thirties to discover I actually liked some physical activity and am now fairly fit. I don't do team sports though.
I am not a huge fan of being cold / uncomfortable, and I am small and fairly cack handed and struggle with spatial awareness type tasks. None of which disposes me towards the sort of stuff offered by an outdoor activity centre.

Yes it's all about getting everyone to join in - In theory. In practice it's giving attention to those who get in the school team to win cups and make the school look good 🤷🏻‍♀️

tsmainsqueeze · 19/02/2023 16:41

DisplayPurposesOnly · 19/02/2023 13:40

It's not for me, and never has been. Struggling to pinpoint why though.

Even when I've tried and succeeded in doing something that has been difficult for me (eg climbling a steep slope, going on a major hike), I don't get any sense of achievement from it. So not enjoying it in the first place + no sense of achievement = hard no from me.

Bushcraft might be fun. I've happily paddled on a lake in a canoe.

This is the same for me - i have no desire to 'achieve' something like this, but i do love boats and the sea.
In general i would much prefer a national trust type property ,a gorgeous garden or a garden centre to explore in any precious spare time i have.
My 2 sons have enjoyed outdoor adventure when younger and my daughter is quite keen to have a go ie school trips etc ,but none of them have ever asked to pursue them regularly.

tobee · 19/02/2023 16:40

It was also often the case that people who ran these activities often couldn't understand why some people didn't also love it. I did love it but wasn't naturally brilliant. Some of my school friends were very uncomfortable

tobee · 19/02/2023 16:37

tobee · 19/02/2023 16:36

I don't know if someone's mentioned it on here or not but it was often Sod's Law that this kind of activity would always occur when my period was happening. Feeling like there were good shower facilities, privacy in those places and so on would maybe make a difference. I loved these activities when I was younger but you could feel stuck in the middle of nowhere sometimes. Not an issue for everyone but was for me as a teenager sometimes.

Oh I see someone else has said this. So there's at least two of us. Smile

tobee · 19/02/2023 16:36

I don't know if someone's mentioned it on here or not but it was often Sod's Law that this kind of activity would always occur when my period was happening. Feeling like there were good shower facilities, privacy in those places and so on would maybe make a difference. I loved these activities when I was younger but you could feel stuck in the middle of nowhere sometimes. Not an issue for everyone but was for me as a teenager sometimes.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 16:29

And mine

AngelinaFibres · 19/02/2023 16:28

Alconleigh · 19/02/2023 16:18

The horror and humiliation of games lessons in the 1980s / 90s did for me, as for some PP. Teachers who had no idea how to motivate or engage the non sporty, and didn't try. It took until I was in my late thirties to discover I actually liked some physical activity and am now fairly fit. I don't do team sports though.
I am not a huge fan of being cold / uncomfortable, and I am small and fairly cack handed and struggle with spatial awareness type tasks. None of which disposes me towards the sort of stuff offered by an outdoor activity centre.

You are my twin. I could have written exactly this.

AngelinaFibres · 19/02/2023 16:26

When I was a young teen we had the week from hell at a local field centre. Hopefully things are different now. It was more than 45 years ago but I can remember every bit of it. The lack of privacy. It had originally been a TB hospital so the plumbing was Victorian. Whatever you put in the toilet went along a drain across the floor. The drain was very long and covered with a decorative grill. It meant that if you pooed /flushed a sanitary product it was clearly visible floating along the drain in front of all the other people in the toilet block. My bum clamped shut for the entire week and I prayed and prayed that my period wouldn't come . The food was vile. The drying rooms didn't dry anything and the cool kids thought it was funny to dump other people's stuff into the water filled trough below, so you put wet kit on every day. If you struggled to get wet stuff on you were laughed at.The female teacher who took us was vile, utterly vile. It was physical stuff all day every day. If you didn't join in you were laughed at. If you did join in and were not up to the standard of the sporty kids you were laughed at. The male instructors liked the pretty girls and gave them lots of attention. Those of us who were spotty and awkward and plain were invisible. We weren't allowed to be in friendship groups. They put us in groups of their choosing. Day 1 I was with the 2 girls who bullied me mercilessly through secondary school. Day 2 put with the cool , macho boys who couldn't have look more appalled if they'd tried. I didn't speak for the entire day, I just wanted it to be over. My mother thought it was character building. It put me off outdoor activities until I had my own children. I hope things are different but I bet a lot of the things above are just the same as they ever were.

Ponderingwindow · 19/02/2023 16:19

Sunburn
motion sickness
not a fan of dirt and bugs

fear isn’t something that holds appeal as a recreational pursuit

Alconleigh · 19/02/2023 16:18

The horror and humiliation of games lessons in the 1980s / 90s did for me, as for some PP. Teachers who had no idea how to motivate or engage the non sporty, and didn't try. It took until I was in my late thirties to discover I actually liked some physical activity and am now fairly fit. I don't do team sports though.
I am not a huge fan of being cold / uncomfortable, and I am small and fairly cack handed and struggle with spatial awareness type tasks. None of which disposes me towards the sort of stuff offered by an outdoor activity centre.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 16:18

ThoseDamnCrows · 19/02/2023 16:08

Re wearing glasses, I'm a paddle boarder and a specs wearer. I bought an extra pair of specs, just the cheapest I could find basically, and a £10 floating strap to attach them to.
Every session I have I deliberately fall off, because it's actually more fun if you can take the mickey out of yourself, and I like to keep checking my self-rescue abilities, I have to say I've never (yet) lost my specs.

Re wearing wetsuits, the first time I put one on I was overweight and menopausal, a short dumpy 49 year old with a big bust. Once I got into the hobby and wanted my own gear I bought separates, they were easier to get into and a better fit than an all-in-one. I also then had an incentive to actually lose weight so that I could fit into a standard suit

I don't try and keep up with any men, they're usually stronger and faster. I did pick it up much quicker than my DH though, my balance was far better than his, maybe being shorter actually helps as lower centre of gravity. It's really nice to have a shared hobby, good fun, good exercise in the fresh air, we take the dog with us. It's also really sociable, loads of Facebook groups so you can find people to tag along with, it's a very friendly community.

Good idea or wearing an older pair with a strap

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 19/02/2023 16:17

I share your frustrations and concerns @user1496262496 . I used to be involved in youth cycle coaching. The drop off of girls after going to secondary school was massive. Their return rate was very low.

I love outdoor pursuits, from the first time I was plucked from my inner London comp
In the mid 80s and dragged up some Welsh mountains for a week. I've continued to climb mountains, walk hills, ski, cycle, kayak a bit etc etc etc all my life. Rock climbing fell by the wayside when my partner moved to Oz. Then I had dc... and my adventures were reduced, but continued.

DD (11) hates all this stuff though! I'm not sure it's about being cold and wet because she plays grassroots football on some horrific waterlogged pitches! At least with cricket rain stops play!

I do think it's puberty- female bodies don't lend themselves easily to prolonged outdoor activity, away from flush toilets and other home comforts, wee-ing behind a bush etc. I imagine it's very easy to stop once you have to start dealing with periods and sports bras and PMT, and not necessarily easy or obvious to get back into - especially when your males peers are at their fittest and strongest. I only got into outdoor activities at about 15, but I remember very clearly sitting on a belay 200 feet above the Llanberris Pass trying to work out how to change my sanitary towel (well before Mooncups and period pants).

Something I have noticed with my DD is that she has really begun to feel the cold as she enters puberty. She used to be that child who wore shorts all year, even when school has the windows open all summer. Now she wear thermals under her school trousers and shirt. Maybe the cold had got something to do with it after all.

Letstaketotheskies · 19/02/2023 16:16

Improbablecat · 19/02/2023 14:31

I went on to these often as a teen. I actually really enjoy kayaking and doing it as an adult in a hot country where I just had to put on a buoyancy aid over my swimsuit was a revelation.

I echo what others say - clean well equipped changing and toilet facilities would make such a difference. Decent degree of privacy to squeeze into the wetsuits. I used to go kayaking at a place with one open shower and open changing rooms. Even though it was sex segregated us girls were always mortified and would just take turns in the communal shower so getting changed after took forever. I recognise that we need to get away from feeling judged/judgemental about ourselves and others bodies but I really do think this plays into it.

I think this also extends to the other stuff - weight based climbing equipment for example. I recently did a Go Ape type thing. You got weighed going in then someone yelled your weight across the room to the bit they were distributing harnesses from. Then they were colour co-ordinated. It was so cringe and I wouldn't go back just for that reason.

Gosh the yelling your weight across the room thing is so easily solved it’s laughable. - if the equipment is already colour coded then they could just yell your harness colour instead.
so if 40-60kg = green yell ´green’. If 80-110 = orange, yell ´orange!’.

Fairislefandango · 19/02/2023 16:09

I like being outdoors and live just on the edge of the Lake District, so outdoor activities are huge here. I like walking, don't mind a leisurely canoe and like swimming in the lakes in the summer, but I am not at all keen on anything more adventurous than that. I don't like heights and am not keen on getting muddy or bruised. Caving is my idea of hell! I also hate the idea of being in a group situation where I might feel pressured to do an adventurous activity I wasn't comfortable with.

ThoseDamnCrows · 19/02/2023 16:08

Re wearing glasses, I'm a paddle boarder and a specs wearer. I bought an extra pair of specs, just the cheapest I could find basically, and a £10 floating strap to attach them to.
Every session I have I deliberately fall off, because it's actually more fun if you can take the mickey out of yourself, and I like to keep checking my self-rescue abilities, I have to say I've never (yet) lost my specs.

Re wearing wetsuits, the first time I put one on I was overweight and menopausal, a short dumpy 49 year old with a big bust. Once I got into the hobby and wanted my own gear I bought separates, they were easier to get into and a better fit than an all-in-one. I also then had an incentive to actually lose weight so that I could fit into a standard suit

I don't try and keep up with any men, they're usually stronger and faster. I did pick it up much quicker than my DH though, my balance was far better than his, maybe being shorter actually helps as lower centre of gravity. It's really nice to have a shared hobby, good fun, good exercise in the fresh air, we take the dog with us. It's also really sociable, loads of Facebook groups so you can find people to tag along with, it's a very friendly community.

woodhill · 19/02/2023 16:08

Supernova23 · 19/02/2023 16:04

I can't bear anything like this, far too much effort, cold, miserable weather, competitiveness with people vying to be the best. Would rather sit on the sofa with chocolate and a glass of wine.

Same here

However my dds younger one in particular seem to like outdoor pursuits and paddle boarding.

Supernova23 · 19/02/2023 16:04

I can't bear anything like this, far too much effort, cold, miserable weather, competitiveness with people vying to be the best. Would rather sit on the sofa with chocolate and a glass of wine.

Ketchupwee · 19/02/2023 16:00

Another one saying weight, there is never any information about weight limits on these things and I wouldn't want to put myself in a position to be embarrassed

Toilet facilities, usually a bit gross and never enough. If you suffer from bad periods you need to be confident that you won't be caught out

Things are very male focussed and women have different bodies, so equipment is often uncomfortable as it's been designed for the male body

People can often be very competitive and make you feel a bit shit if you are scared, can't do something, or do something wrong

EyesOnThePies · 19/02/2023 15:51

OP, I have always enjoyed loads of outdoor stuff, my relaxation these days is fell walking, ‘back to basics’ camping (e.g cooking over the fire) , and sea swimming (May to Oct. I’m not that hardcore!).

And I am part of a big friendship group who enjoy the same things and whose kids, teens and young adults of both sexes now enjoy the same things. (They also like ballet / reading / music lessons / doing their nails etc). (And would consider comments like those by @MelanieFlowers as idiotic)

Our Scout group which had loads of girls and did bushcraft camps, expeditions that were more challenging than the spoon fed trip that is Bronze DoE these days, loads of outdoor adventurous stuff.

The scout leader was female.

So I would say:

Your industry is swimming upstream against loads of socialisation . Of course some kids of both sexes will hate outdoor sports, but only girls are socialised against it.

Mothers who grew up being humiliated and otherwise put off will put their DD’s off.

Few encouraging / inclusive images of girls and women having a great time doing these things. Is there stuff on TikTok and Insta showing female leaders encouraging girls having a great time?

MelaniesFlowers · 19/02/2023 15:50

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 19/02/2023 15:18

Sorry, you'd discourage your daughters from doing fun, healthy, outdoors activities because the outfits are ugly? Seriously?

No, that is not the reason I would discourage, but feel free to think it if it suits your narrative.

thelongroad · 19/02/2023 15:49

It's cold, wet, uncomfortable and boring.
Like a PP, I don't get a sense of achievement or a "high" from doing things like this.
Hate getting wet and dirty. Hate looking and feeling like shit while doing an activity (I mean things like my hair frizzing or going in my face, I don't mind if I look silly dangling off a zipwire etc). I loathe having to change into special clothing.
Toilets and periods. In fact, periods have dictated masses of what I've chosen to do and when.
I love being outdoors, and I'm reasonably fit, but you're never going to get me doing sporty adventure activities.

Someone earlier mentioned geocaching/orienteering, which I've never tried but I could see myself going for something like that.

Leirvassbu · 19/02/2023 15:49

I am a long-distance hiker - spend up to a month at the time trekking in the wilderness with a tent. I love it. Love being outdoors and I'm not bothered about being cold and wet.
However, I know that I need to be completely in control of the situation - obviously you can't control weather etc, but I can control how I react to it. I hike alone because I am in control of how far I go, when I take a break, where I pitch the tent, when to cut a hike short and so on.
I didn't go to outdoor centres as a kid but I was in the Air Training Corps - and the two issues for me were that
a) I had no control and because I have always been quite slow at hiking and had asthma at the time, I felt pushed beyond my limits and really didn't like that. We were called pathetic and mocked by men and boys if we couldn't keep up.
b) Men and boys attitudes to the girls participating (see also point a) - not just about not being able to keep up, but also about appearance and whether you were hot or not. And seemingly no understanding whatsoever that there are physical differences between girls and boys which does influence performance.

I think a good outdoor centre should offer activities for girls and boys separately, as well as mixed activities. Female instructors are also important as role-models and also because they have an understanding of what it is like to be a girl, going through puberty for example.
And I think all children should be able to say enough is enough and that there are plans in place for kids who really can't keep up or who are genuinely really terrified of heights etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread