Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is time to extend Sunday opening hours?

635 replies

Sundayopeningplease · 19/02/2023 09:32

It really is time for the restrictive Sunday trading hours to be lifted. The archaic laws have not kept up with modern society.

Sunday may traditionally have been a family day but there have been a lot of changes since then. People are in increasingly different family set ups. The working hours have changed for a lot of people and being able to shop on a Sunday morning would improve things greatly. It would help trade for businesses too.

Sunday is now a major shopping day and the hours need to reflect this.

OP posts:
Teamountain · 20/02/2023 23:24

BabyOnBoard90 · 20/02/2023 09:46

I'm perplexed that anyone would disagree with this.

Of course the opening hours should be extended. If people wish to stay home on a Sunday they still can.

People want to stay at home but they seem to want others to stay at home too which is nonsensical.

Teamountain · 20/02/2023 23:22

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 20/02/2023 17:12

I always see the same arguments on these threads:

”Awwh, what about the poor retail workers and their families? THEY deserve time off too you know!”

That's all well and good if all retail workers want to spend each and every Sunday at home with their families, all day. If, however, they want to go out for Sunday lunch, or to the cinema, or a theme park or to the football, it’s a bit hypocritical to suggest their own working hours should be legally restricted while others work. Why are retailers a special case, yet bar and waiting staff, door and security staff etc. don’t deserve the same thing?

”If you’re that desperate to shop, just do it online!”

Do people think online orders are managed by magic pixies? Apparently the only retail workers who deserve time off are those who work in a physical store. Sainsbury’s are offering delivery slots from 6.30am to 11.30th this Sunday. Who do you think picks, packs and delivers those orders? Amazon also delivers on Sundays now - and yes, that means drivers and warehouse staff work too.

You said it way better than I could! I’m pretty sure those who don’t want Sunday opening never just sit at home and not go anywhere.

Teamountain · 20/02/2023 23:19

Jackofallsorts · 20/02/2023 20:31

I think all Sunday trading should be stopped but for small convenience stores to open for a few hours. Given workers time with their families.

But cafes, restaurants, cinemas, pubs, bars, parks should stay open because their staff don’t need time with their families right?

melj1213 · 20/02/2023 21:56

AnnoyedFromSlough · 20/02/2023 21:18

Given that this is legally a Christian country, I really don't see that they would take away the right not to work, without a huge backlash. They haven't taken away the right to opt out of Sunday working in Scotland.

If someone didn't want to work Sunday, surely they would apply for roles that don't include sunday shifts? I've just looked at the jobs available at my most local Tescos, and out of the first 7 jobs, 3 included Sunday shifts.

You're missing the point that employers can change working patterns when they want and it rarely is for the staff's benefit. And if they're going to change the law to allow longer Sunday trading then retail companies are going to lobby for Sunday opt out to end too due to their business needs - ie if they have to treat Sunday like every other working day then there shouldn't be a blanket ability to opt out to Sundays when there isn't an ability to unilaterally opt out of any other working day. There would be a backlash but it would be twisted by the companies to say "We'd love to open longer but we can't get the staff as they all opt out of Sunday working, it's all their fault not ours"

When I started working for my store we got a double time premium for working Sunday, night rate (time and a half) started from 10pm until 7am and we only had to work a maximum of two bank holidays a year. In less than a decade we have lost the Sunday premium, night rate now only applies between 12am and 5 am and we have to work a minimum of 3 bank holidays a year.

They have stripped those things away year after year, they're not going to lobby to keep the Sunday opt out if they're having to open longer/later.

Also just because you don't apply for certain roles/days etc doesn't mean the job won't change whilst you're there - once you're employed by the company, providing they ensure you get your contracted hours most retail contracts have a clause that essentially says "We can ask you to do any and all days/hours as required for the needs of the business". Unless you then formally opt out of Sunday working (which then potentially loses you hours), if your company changes your working pattern from Thurs/Fri/Sat to Sun/Mon/Tues your options are to work Sun/Mon/Tues or potentially lose the hours they want you to do on Sunday as they don't have to offer you hours at another time.

We have so little consistency and so few guarantees in retail, Sunday working is one of the few we have left so most of us are not giving it up willingly.

CherryHouse · 20/02/2023 21:24

Sunday opening hours are annoying. We were out early for breakfast this past Sunday. Around 10:15am we decided to go for a wander around the town and the few shops we wanted to visit and buy things from were shut till 11am. Would have been lovely to “shop local”, but yet again Amazon filled the gap.

AnnoyedFromSlough · 20/02/2023 21:18

Oh, and despite my username suggesting otherwise, I live in Scotland.

AnnoyedFromSlough · 20/02/2023 21:18

melj1213 · 20/02/2023 20:18

Currently we do but if they took away Sunday Trading Laws that restricted the hours shops can open, I'm fairly certain that they would take away the law that allows retail workers to opt out of Sunday working too.

Also there are many ways employers can get round the rules ... For example if my employer said "You have a 18hr contract, we need you to work 3×6hr shifts Sunday, Monday and Tuesday". If I opt out of Sunday working then they are not legally obliged to give me a 6hr shift on another day (and of they really need people to work on Sundays they will definitely not offer other hours) instead so my choice is lose a third of my hours or work on Sundays ... Most of us working in retail are on NMW (or just above) and we can't afford to lose money and often can't "just get another job" (as many people often suggest, as though jobs are abundant for everyone, everywhere)

Given that this is legally a Christian country, I really don't see that they would take away the right not to work, without a huge backlash. They haven't taken away the right to opt out of Sunday working in Scotland.

If someone didn't want to work Sunday, surely they would apply for roles that don't include sunday shifts? I've just looked at the jobs available at my most local Tescos, and out of the first 7 jobs, 3 included Sunday shifts.

Flounder2022 · 20/02/2023 20:32

Flounder2022 · 20/02/2023 20:17

I think the important thing here though is how a change like this would be brought in. So with proper negotiation/ consultation with staff and unions. Adequate legislation etc.

I know people who still work to their original contracts enshrining their right not to work Sundays for example

This gives a sense of the legislation that covers Sunday working

https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/whatyouushouldknow/codesspractice/cop9/#:~:text=Employees%20who%20have%20a%20minimum,adequate%20notice%20to%20the%20employer.

Jackofallsorts · 20/02/2023 20:31

I think all Sunday trading should be stopped but for small convenience stores to open for a few hours. Given workers time with their families.

SwordToFlamethrower · 20/02/2023 20:27

I spent loads of time in Istanbul and it was fantastic for shopping. Shops open 7 days a week from early till very late.

Felt sorry for the workers though!

melj1213 · 20/02/2023 20:18

AnnoyedFromSlough · 20/02/2023 20:02

Currently we do but if they took away Sunday Trading Laws that restricted the hours shops can open, I'm fairly certain that they would take away the law that allows retail workers to opt out of Sunday working too.

Also there are many ways employers can get round the rules ... For example if my employer said "You have a 18hr contract, we need you to work 3×6hr shifts Sunday, Monday and Tuesday". If I opt out of Sunday working then they are not legally obliged to give me a 6hr shift on another day (and of they really need people to work on Sundays they will definitely not offer other hours) instead so my choice is lose a third of my hours or work on Sundays ... Most of us working in retail are on NMW (or just above) and we can't afford to lose money and often can't "just get another job" (as many people often suggest, as though jobs are abundant for everyone, everywhere)

Flounder2022 · 20/02/2023 20:17

I think the important thing here though is how a change like this would be brought in. So with proper negotiation/ consultation with staff and unions. Adequate legislation etc.

I know people who still work to their original contracts enshrining their right not to work Sundays for example

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 20/02/2023 20:13

AnnoyedFromSlough · 20/02/2023 20:02

Completely misses @melj1213 's point. No employer has ever coerced an employee to work for pay and conditions they don't want, ever!

AnnoyedFromSlough · 20/02/2023 20:02

melj1213 · 20/02/2023 19:43

Yes we would be forced to as employers would just change people's hours using the "needs of the business" clause. Pretty much every major retailer has this clause in their contracts to justify changing days/hours employees have to work and if they objected then they'd just lose the hours or be given other inconvenient hours (or in the case of temps/zero hours workers just wouldn't be scheduled again) which will essentially force people to work Sundays or be left worse off.

I have known people be told they need to do a 6hr shift on a particular day and when they refused, the manager then offered a split shift of 2×3hr blocks as that was "the only option to keep their hours as there's no other hours available" ... The staff member ended up agreeing to the 6hr shift because they couldn't afford to lose the hours but the split shift just wasn't practical due to their circumstances. So whilst nobody held a gun to their head to make them take the hours, the manager knew which buttons to push to force the hours they wanted through.

I took a job knowing that my hours would be any time between 6am and 11 pm Monday to Saturday and 11am to 5pm Sunday. So I knew that, no matter what days/hours I was scheduled and whether or not my days off were the same every week, every week I was guaranteed to always have a lie in on a Sunday morning and also be guaranteed to be home to have dinner and spend the evening with my DD.

If stores were not restricted on Sundays that guarantee is gone and the hours I am expecting to work (and that I signed up to work) are changed. So the fact I took the job, knowing the hours, means nothing because they can just be changed unilaterally and I have no say on the matter.

Nobody I work with want more hours with customers on the stores, especially on a Sunday as that's the day we can get the most work done as the store is closed longer, and if you want "bonus hours" then there are always overtime shifts for stocking/home shopping picking etc that are jobs done when the store is closed. Additionally things like annual stock taking, inventory management, display changes, maintenance to machinery/fixtures etc are all scheduled, as much as possible, on Sundays as it gives the teams the longest time possible without customers in the building, which makes it safer and less inconvenience for everyone.

You couldn't be forced to.

Shop workers legally have the right to opt out of working on Sundays.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/work/working-hours-and-rest-breaks/check-if-you-have-to-work-on-sundays/#:~:text=Giving%20notice%20to%20opt%20out,sign%20and%20date%20the%20notice.

melj1213 · 20/02/2023 19:43

BabyOnBoard90 · 20/02/2023 18:27

They wouldn't be forced to. No one takes a job not knowing the hours they'll be expected to work.

And actually I'm sure many would appreciate the bonus hours.

Yes we would be forced to as employers would just change people's hours using the "needs of the business" clause. Pretty much every major retailer has this clause in their contracts to justify changing days/hours employees have to work and if they objected then they'd just lose the hours or be given other inconvenient hours (or in the case of temps/zero hours workers just wouldn't be scheduled again) which will essentially force people to work Sundays or be left worse off.

I have known people be told they need to do a 6hr shift on a particular day and when they refused, the manager then offered a split shift of 2×3hr blocks as that was "the only option to keep their hours as there's no other hours available" ... The staff member ended up agreeing to the 6hr shift because they couldn't afford to lose the hours but the split shift just wasn't practical due to their circumstances. So whilst nobody held a gun to their head to make them take the hours, the manager knew which buttons to push to force the hours they wanted through.

I took a job knowing that my hours would be any time between 6am and 11 pm Monday to Saturday and 11am to 5pm Sunday. So I knew that, no matter what days/hours I was scheduled and whether or not my days off were the same every week, every week I was guaranteed to always have a lie in on a Sunday morning and also be guaranteed to be home to have dinner and spend the evening with my DD.

If stores were not restricted on Sundays that guarantee is gone and the hours I am expecting to work (and that I signed up to work) are changed. So the fact I took the job, knowing the hours, means nothing because they can just be changed unilaterally and I have no say on the matter.

Nobody I work with want more hours with customers on the stores, especially on a Sunday as that's the day we can get the most work done as the store is closed longer, and if you want "bonus hours" then there are always overtime shifts for stocking/home shopping picking etc that are jobs done when the store is closed. Additionally things like annual stock taking, inventory management, display changes, maintenance to machinery/fixtures etc are all scheduled, as much as possible, on Sundays as it gives the teams the longest time possible without customers in the building, which makes it safer and less inconvenience for everyone.

Mrsfussypants1 · 20/02/2023 19:26

Ah thanks for the reply. I just found an article explaining it and it was the SNP who put the blocks on the uk opening hours because they were worried Scottish retail workers would no longer get sunday premium pay from the big names if they had to pay the same premium across the whole of the UK.

slashlover · 20/02/2023 19:17

I've never been paid extra for working on a Sunday, although I'm sure some do. Previous jobs are supermarket, discount retail and currently charity shop retail.

Although when I first started working we opened Christmas Day and I got triple time for working that, but that was almost 30 years ago.

Mrsfussypants1 · 20/02/2023 19:13

slashlover · 20/02/2023 18:51

I work in retail in Scotland, currently part time but previously full time.

Sunday working was just part of our routine, we had it set up that everyone worked one Sunday in four and nobody was traumatised. I actually liked working on a Sunday as it was quieter than during the week and it meant I had a free day during the week for any appointments etc.

Hi just interested do Scottish workers get a premium for working Sunday? I'm sure I read somewhere they do, I haven't any Scottish friends in retail to.ask.
Perhaps if uk retailers payed a premium Sunday rate that might boost the economy and fill the jobs? Of couse that cost would end up being passed to the consumer, whether that's in the supermarket or the clothing store etc.

Mrsfussypants1 · 20/02/2023 18:58

Would extended Sunday trading be of financial benefit to the retailer? Would the consumer have extra money to spend on Sundays? Who would fill all these extra jobs? The last few years more and more shops are joining the not open Boxing day group at probably a big hit to their profits as a way of giving back to their staff, although I suspect its also for publicity. I worked in retail in my student year for extra money, there were quite a few of us weekend workers with a high call in sick rate on a Sunday, either someone had partied to hard or someone's kid was ill. Even though people knew the hours involved it happened every single weekend. Hats of to anyone who works in retail, I've been there.

slashlover · 20/02/2023 18:52

We had several people who requested to work Sunday, especially in preference to Saturday.

slashlover · 20/02/2023 18:51

I work in retail in Scotland, currently part time but previously full time.

Sunday working was just part of our routine, we had it set up that everyone worked one Sunday in four and nobody was traumatised. I actually liked working on a Sunday as it was quieter than during the week and it meant I had a free day during the week for any appointments etc.

BabyOnBoard90 · 20/02/2023 18:27

Plumbear2 · 20/02/2023 10:33

Disagree with this. The people working in retail carnt just stay at home.

They wouldn't be forced to. No one takes a job not knowing the hours they'll be expected to work.

And actually I'm sure many would appreciate the bonus hours.

tiger2691 · 20/02/2023 17:56

There's enough slavery already, think of the workers. People can shop on a Sunday morning, from 10am usually, earlier and for longer than 6 hours, if it is a business with a smaller premises, plus some retailers open half an hour earlier for browsing, before the checkouts open.

Boomboom22 · 20/02/2023 17:16

This thread is a perfect example of the very low comprehension of many people. It precisely captures that literact test like how would you feel this morning if you hadn't had dinner yesterday? But I did.

It's like that level of understanding over and over again. But I work in retail (only as a checkout assistant in a big store not any warehouse or shelf stacker or delivery driver or shop smaller than 280sf) and I want to see my family so the current law should stay. Pretty clear why these people work in retail 🙄.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 20/02/2023 17:12

I always see the same arguments on these threads:

”Awwh, what about the poor retail workers and their families? THEY deserve time off too you know!”

That's all well and good if all retail workers want to spend each and every Sunday at home with their families, all day. If, however, they want to go out for Sunday lunch, or to the cinema, or a theme park or to the football, it’s a bit hypocritical to suggest their own working hours should be legally restricted while others work. Why are retailers a special case, yet bar and waiting staff, door and security staff etc. don’t deserve the same thing?

”If you’re that desperate to shop, just do it online!”

Do people think online orders are managed by magic pixies? Apparently the only retail workers who deserve time off are those who work in a physical store. Sainsbury’s are offering delivery slots from 6.30am to 11.30th this Sunday. Who do you think picks, packs and delivers those orders? Amazon also delivers on Sundays now - and yes, that means drivers and warehouse staff work too.