Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surname drama after marriage

85 replies

Piglet34 · 19/02/2023 08:54

Me and my DH got married in April 2022 and we are having trouble deciding on our surname. We both definitely want to have the same surname as any potential future children.

We don't really like either of our surnames, however we do prefer mine and DH is totally happy to take mine. However the issue is that his surname happens to be my DMs surname/maiden name. From my perspective my surname is MY surname, but DM sees it as my DFs name. They divorced 20 years ago and there is still bitterness there, he cheated at the time and has now been remarried for 15 years (not to the OW) and she didn't meet someone else.

She would be upset if we took my name and went against the "tradition" of me taking DHs/her surname. We really don't like that name though, it's very common and corporate sounding. So now not sure what to do!

YABU - take DH surname to keep everyone happy even if you don't like it
YANBU - take your surname even though it will cause family upset

The other option we have been considering is creating a whole new surname (I.e. something meaningful to us) but it is very hard to think of! We can't double barrel our surnames unfortunately as they both end in "ey"

Help appreciated! 😊

OP posts:
FinnRussell · 19/02/2023 10:39

Your update makes it even more unreasonable of your mum. Ok for her to keep her maiden name but not you?

SeulementUneFois · 19/02/2023 10:39

Take your name.
It's got nothing to do with your mum.

Cherrysoup · 19/02/2023 10:38

Your mother has nothing to do with your surname. Why does her opinion count?

Piglet34 · 19/02/2023 10:37

Thanks everyone! I think we will either go with my name or the grandparents name.

To answer people asking if she's been upset about my surname before, the answer is probably yes. She never took my fathers name and always kept her maiden name (sorry if that wasn't clear). I think she's sad we weren't always called her name as she's the one who we were with most growing up. Obviously 30 years ago it was just standard for kids to take dads name so that's what we have.

OP posts:
Blueblell · 19/02/2023 10:36

I think it is better to keep your own names and double barrel but some names just don’t go together. I would keep in mind future travel with small kids. If you all have the same name it will be easier.

Robinni · 19/02/2023 10:27

Mother’s opinion doesn’t matter. You and children/grandchildren will have the name long after she is gone. So suit yourselves.

Could you do an anagram of sorts, using the letters of both names (or some of them)?

WeWereInParis · 19/02/2023 10:27

She should be glad that by keeping your name and giving that to your children you will never end up in the situation she's in, where she seems to strongly dislike her child's surname.

TreacleMcDoo · 19/02/2023 10:22

Either blend your two names together start of one end of the other, use letters from both to create a new name or choose a new name altogether.

My sister and her wife created a new surname, something that was special to them and I think that is lovely.

I wouldn't choose either family name, just create a new one. I took Dh's because it was easy to spell and my maiden name was misspelt constantly, even when I spelled it out to people. So glad to get rid of it.

2013isback · 19/02/2023 10:20

Off topic, but - this thread reminds me of the "Sylvia Smith-Smith" series of YA books from the '80s. Sylvia's parents both happened to have the surname Smith, but they thought that if they just used Smith people would assume it was the husband's/dad's name and therefore sexist, so they hyphenated to Smith-Smith.

If you and your husband were happy with the decision to use your name before your mother spoke up, I'd stick with that. It's been your name for your whole life; there was always a good possibility you wouldn't change it/would pass it on in some form to your children.

NoMoneyForEducation · 19/02/2023 10:15

You are over thinking this. Probably due to your mum.

But, aside from that, I am also wondering if you think people will judge? Particularly with your comment about future children.

I work in education - and there is no need to all have the same surname. It doesn't mean you will automatically be better parents/happier family/better behaved children. It means fuck all (not directed at you/meaning to be rude).
There are so many mixes of surnames/double-barrelled/students with surnames that are different to both parents. Or everyone has the same surname. None of these give me any information about the family...whether it is happy/parents still married...nothing. All I need to know is what to call a parent if I need to email/phone them and if they have parental responsibility. Different surnames could mean a divorce, a woman keeping her maiden name, not married....all irrelevant. Same surname could be a happy marriage - or a miserable one. Previously married but now divorced but the woman has kept her married name. Or just fluke (both had the same name when they met). Same surname...beautifully behaved children, academic, polite. Or troubled, worried, rude, anxious. Different surnames....beautifully behaved children, academic, polite. Or troubled, worried, rude, anxious.
You see?

It may not help your dilemma (or the situation with your mum) but I thought I would put my two penneth worth in.

AlmostSummer21 · 19/02/2023 10:14

there have been discussions about us taking DHs mothers maiden name (she doesn't use it anymore but his grandparents do). It is a very unique/nice surname but that causes the same upset really as is taking his mums history instead of my mums

Tough. You've listened to her feelings of hurt over using your Dads surname (bit odd, but whatever) but there's a limit to how many options she gets to get upset over.

using DH's grandparents name sounds lovely.

WeWereInParis · 19/02/2023 10:10

The more I think about it, the more unreasonable I think your mother is. I assume she hasn't been upset by your surname every day since she divorced your father? So why is it suddenly an issue for you to not change your name?

Tinkerbyebye · 19/02/2023 10:07

Double barrel? If not do whatever you want it’s got nothing to do with your mother

SpongeBob2022 · 19/02/2023 10:07

I do feel for your Mum but she is being unreasonable and it really annoys me when separated parents do petty things that make life difficult for their children. He's your Dad...you wouldn't be here if it wasn't for him and her issues with him are not your issues. In any case if I'm reading this right you're not changing your name to your Dad's...your just keeping your existing one.

You've said you don't like the idea of double-barrelled so I don't understand why so many people are suggesting it.

I wouldn't overcomplicate it. You both prefer your name and it's nice for your children to have the best sounding name and the same name for all of you.

For your sake I hope that when you do have children, they can set their differences aside to avoid issues at family occasions etc.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 19/02/2023 10:06

Use your mums name.

RealBecca · 19/02/2023 10:05

Just take her out of the conversation and do what you want.

Tell, dont ask. Its not a consultation and it's not for you to heal her past hurt. The name was good enough for her once upon a time and is it's your time to make your decisions and she should be helping you to enjoy that and it making it about her.

EyesOnThePies · 19/02/2023 10:04

but that causes the same upset really as is taking his mums history instead of my mums

Honestly OP, if you allow your Mum’s unreasonable ‘upset’ to affect decisions about YOUR marriage like this your DH has a DW problem.

MaireadMcSweeney · 19/02/2023 10:03

Your mum is being childish. She shouldn't have assumed you'd take your husband's name and she's given herself a moment of disappointment but that's all it is. The idea that you'd make such a significant decision as to what you and your kids will be called based on your mum's momentary disappointment is daft.

pinkyredrose · 19/02/2023 10:01

Pick a new name if both of you don't like your names.

EyesOnThePies · 19/02/2023 10:01

If your Mum were to post an AIBU thread about this she would be told yes, SIBU.

She might have a little pang of disappointment, but really she has no business to put her upset on you. Your DH wants to change his own name and it is hardly your Mum’s business to insist he keep it. Your name IS your name, and it was your Mum, as well as your Dad, that gave it to you.

She has (I hope) loved you all these years with your name and if she can’t do the same for any grandchildren with the same name, there is something very wrong with her.

You keeping your name, and your DH changing it, makes no difference to your support for her over the behaviour of your Dad towards her. Tell her that.

Meanwhile, good for your DH. So many men remain stuck in patriarchal tradition and baulk at changing their names. He shouldn’t be pressured by your Mum’s bleating ‘tradition’.

Drop the drama, just do it, be matter of fact about it with your Mum.

musicalgymball · 19/02/2023 10:00

Piglet34 · 19/02/2023 09:46

Maybe corporate was the wrong word, I more just mean very common and boring sounding. He was/is a great dad but my mum definitely did more of the work in raising us as we only saw him one night a week and every other weekend.

@LlynTegid there have been discussions about us taking DHs mothers maiden name (she doesn't use it anymore but his grandparents do). It is a very unique/nice surname but that causes the same upset really as is taking his mums history instead of my mums 🤦🏻‍♀️

DH's grandparents' name sounds lovely!

If it's a nice unique name, then that combined with the fact that it is a family name so has history behind it would sell me on it. It completely sidesteps the issue of your mum not wanting your DFs name. So it won't be hurtful to someone very close to you either.

It doesn't use your father or mother or husband's surnames so it's as close to apolitical as you'll get with a name that has history from the family. If DM is still unhappy then I think that's going too far.

Go for the unique and pretty and meaningful name, that's lucky to have that available.

MsSupineLickspittle · 19/02/2023 09:58

My friend married someone with the same surname as hers which saved no end of trouble. However it might be a bit late for you Wink

How would your mother feel if you said you'd been through all the potential names and their advantages but kept coming back to her married name as The One and really explained why? My own mother would have still gone apeshit but apparently there are some more reasonable people around.

harriethoyle · 19/02/2023 09:57

Your mum sounds way OTT and very bitter about your dad. Good luck when you have children. I can foresee all sorts of issues about your dad being allowed to be a grandparent. I'd nip this in the bud right now if I were you. You're an adult and can do whatever you and your DH agree is best.

GoodChat · 19/02/2023 09:52

I'd combine the two to make a new name

plumduck · 19/02/2023 09:48

Your mum will probably die before you and you'll be stuck with a name you chose to please her.

If you're old enough to get married you're old enough to choose your own name.