Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull away from my close friendship because of her kids

285 replies

abouttimeforu · 19/02/2023 03:56

My close friendship is with my sister. We are extremely close. My child can be very challenging , currently waiting on ASD assessment , attention seeking and has a hard time managing his anger although this has improved greatly .
My child struggles socially and doesn't have many friends.
He is also so kind and loving, very sensitive , thoughtful and funny He is 11.

My sister's two children are by and large, rude and moody. Their mother will often put this down to tiredness and hunger but reality is they are actually just rude and moody, mostly

They will engage with my child when there's no other option but if there are other kids around, they will practically ignore him.
So for example if we were grouping up for an activity, they will purposely say that they want to do x with 'Jen' and completely omit to mention my child's name or include him.
Despite him being the only one left out.
My sister does not intervene or correct them. I would be disgusted if my kids did this and very ashamed tbh.

Her attitude is that they don't have to socialise with people they don't want to socialise with .... until they have no one else and then ask to socialise with my
Child .He has been too available .. my fault.

To me he seems only good enough for them as a stand in but tbh I'm highly sensitive about this issue and biased.
I am very protective of himSo at times I am guilty of overthinking and over reacting when it comes to how I view his interactions with others , when In fact, he is absolutely fine with being on his own sometimes.

My child is always with me when we see my sister and her family. I generally make the effort more as her kids are younger and I have the time.

I think that for my sons self esteem and general happiness, I need to move away from the intensity of the contact , when with my child. He craves their attention and his self worth is so low that he will tolerate being second choice or not a choice at all, as the case may be.
This has only developed recently and I'm
Disgusted if I'm honest but then again , I'm highly sensitive when it comes to him.

My sister has zero insight with her own kids and has never once stepped in and said to her children, for example, to include my child or insist that he be part of a specific group that they were creating. They feel
Very Comfortable leaving him out and she feels very comfortable enabling that .
So, can you advise me here. I really need objectivity thanks.

I will add again that I can be very defensive as he was always labelled the 'troublemaker' which he was mostly, but not always, and always the one that was blamed when there was trouble among them... again, it was mostly him but not always. He has that label now though sadly as it has stuck.
Thanks .

OP posts:
Mabelface · 19/02/2023 09:43

Pull back on the kids being together rather than your relationship with your sister. He doesn't want to continue feeling like a consolation prize, nor feel like they're just putting up with him. That makes you feel shit. They're all at that age of working out friendships and social awareness and no kid is going to get it right all the time. I'm autistic and remember that age well.

Redebs · 19/02/2023 09:38

ASimpleLampoon · 19/02/2023 08:03

Your son will be given the message throughout his life that he needs coaching to have "social skills" to fit in with Neuro typical \ abled kids. There will be little no education for NT children on on how to be inclusive to others who are different.

I would seek out other ND families who get it , and find activities that he enjoys and can focus on.

Fewer friends who are truly valuable friends and who treat your son with respect he deserves will bring much more happiness .

Every child needs to learn social skills, but many neurodivergent children (and adults) find it harder to learn.
There's no way you can get around the issue that being able to cope in a social situation is essential. Other people and institutions can be aware and make limited accommodation, but the focus will ultimately need to be on learning to cope socially to whatever extent you can.

As for expecting tolerance and accommodation from other neurodivergent children, in my experience they often find it even harder than neurotypical ones to get along together. The ideal of shared experience leading to understanding applies more to the parents than to the youngsters in most cases.

EnidSpyton · 19/02/2023 09:35

I have about 30 cousins - both my parents have multiple siblings, who all have multiple children.

I am not friends with any of them. I barely see them. We have very little in common. I used to dread forced family time as a child, having to spend afternoons playing with my cousins. If my parents had tried to push us on each other regularly, I would have hated it.

Just because you and your sister's children are the same age, doesn't mean they should be friends or enjoy each others' company. As an adult, how would you feel, if someone made you spend every weekend with someone you had nothing to say to, and who made you feel stressed or anxious? You're doing the same to your own child, and your sister's children.

You need to get some perspective on this. Your child's additional needs clearly make him a challenge for other children to be around, and asking an 11 and 12 year old to be sensitive to his needs and essentially tread on eggshells around him all the time isn't fair on them. They should be free to spend time with who they like, when they like, and while I think your sister should be more proactive in ensuring they're at least polite and as inclusive as they can be with your son, as letting them be outright rude and unkind isn't ok, I do also think she has a point in saying it's not fair for her to force them to spend time with someone they clearly don't feel comfortable around.

As others have said above, you may not have the ability to see how your son's behaviour has impacted on your nephews over the years. While I am sure he has plenty of wonderful and loveable qualities, your nephews have obviously experienced a lot of difficult, negative and perhaps even abusive behaviour from him, and it's unreasonable of you to continue to expect two children to put up with that. Why should they? As an adult, you wouldn't, so why would you expect children to do so? I have come across this a lot in teaching, when parents with children with severe SEND resulting in negative behavioural traits are outraged that other children won't play with their child and why aren't I doing more about it to force socialisation - and my answer is always I will never force children into a situation where they feel unsafe or uncomfortable - I will encourage kindness and understanding, but I will not enforce children having to put themselves in a position of harm in order to meet the needs of another.

It's a sad situation and I do sympathise, but I think perhaps you need to be a little more open to seeing your sister's view on this as a parent to her own children who she is trying to protect and support, just as much as you are trying to protect and support yours. I think it's time you started spending more time together without your children, as then you will be able to focus on your relationship without your differences about your children coming between you.

What I think is saddest about the whole thing is that neither of you seem to love each others' children. My nephews - my sisters' children - are the joy of my life. I adore them, warts and all. I assumed everyone would feel the same about their nephews/nieces. Perhaps I just got lucky.

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 09:27

It sounds very difficult all round, and I have empathy for all. I don't understand the posters who seem to think they are the righteous ones by being horrible to the cousins and calling them horrible and spoiled etc. They are just kids too so why no understanding of the fact that they have had years of having no choice with interaction with someone who is (from their perspective) mean, aggressive and and bullying of them?
The fact that there's posters putting things like family stick together no matter what is ludicrous, am assuming they've never read the 'Stately Homes' threads or do the cousins feelings and opinions not count because they're children?

MargaretThursday · 19/02/2023 09:24

I suspect they engage when there are 1-2-1 because they don't have the fear that your ds will embarrass them in front of their friends and their friends will pull away from them.

I mentored a young girl, about your ds age, on a holiday once. She had a slightly older sister who had learning difficulties. Nice girl (the sister) but very attention seeking, and expected everything to fit round her.
The younger sister told me in tears that she found making friends very difficult because her dm always expected her to take her sister to everything she was invited to, or if she had friends round her sister had to join in.
Her friends very quickly got bored of being told what they had to do by the sister, and then wouldn't invite her and didn't want to come round.
She genuinely loved her sister and wanted to help, but she also wanted to make her own friends and not always to have her sister there. I would see that the love was going to turn into resentment.
I know the group leader (after I spoke to him) spoke to the dm and tried to explain and all she'd say was "it's good for the younger one to take responsibility".

The other thing, as others said, children have long memories.
I remember the first time I met one set of dh's cousins. His brothers spent the time in the car going there telling me not to phased by the behaviour of one of them, he'd be rude, selfish....
Well, we arrived, and he had perfect manners, lovely lad. On the way back I asked them if they'd been winding me up, and they thought about it and then realised that he hadn't really been like that for some time.
If he has caused issues with them in the past then they are going to be nervous, even if he has totally changed.

howmanybicycles · 19/02/2023 09:23

I don't think the effect of spending a decade regularly in the company of a child who is 'very challenging', attention seeking and aggressive should be underestimated. Some empathy towards the cousins too is also required. All of these children have some maturing to do and perhaps some recovery from the trauma related to previous interactions. To better understand, when you say 'hard time managing his anger' - has your child hit their cousins or damaged any of these things, or it is just verbal aggression (which in itself can be scary)?

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 09:22

If you think most posters be sympathetic towards your autistic son, rather than his NT cousins, don't hold your breath.

I'd feel the same as you about wanting to create some distance.

BigHeadBertha · 19/02/2023 09:21

I had a nephew who had behavior issues that caused my son not to want to be around him when they were kids. It was enough that I backed off from those relatives and kept my time with them to a minimum because of it.

But whether my kid was the one with the behavior problems or on the receiving end of another kid's behavior problems to a serious degree, I would put my child's best interests first, because I was responsible for his wellbeing.

So to answer your question, to me it sounds like being around these relatives is detrimental to your son. And your sister has denied your requests to change the situation in any way. Therefore, I would back off from them.

That might mean just short occasional visits or structured activities, as has been mentioned, but not vacations or long visits. And if you see your son is being left out, maybe invite him to come sit by you and include him in the adult conversation, or take it as a cue that it's time to leave. If your sister's kids feared your son, I really doubt they'd come play with him whenever there weren't any other kids there to play with.

I agree that your sister is teaching her kids poor manners. Whenever I hosted guests, my son knew he was expected to host any of their children who attended. And when we were guests at someone else's house, I expected him to behave like a guest. He would not have been allowed to ignore a guest's or host's child or single them out for exclusion while including other kids who were there. To me, that's very rude.

But when this nephew of mine was around, I also kept a close eye on the kids and stayed ready to intervene when necessary. I'd have them play near where we adults were visiting, not outside or in a far part of the house. Good luck with it.

NumberTheory · 19/02/2023 09:20

Sister’s perspective[…]My two children can be rude and moody. This is often down to tiredness and hunger.

They will engage with their cousin when there's no other option but if there are other kids around, they will practically ignore him.

My sister thinks I should intervene or correct them. I feel like she is disgusted with my kids and very ashamed.

My attitude is that they don't have to socialise with people they don't want to socialise with .... when they have no one else and then they ask to socialise with their cousin. He is always available .. my sister is always available

That might be the sister’s perspective or it might be more along the lines of:
”I tell my sister they’re moody because they’re tired and hungry, but that’s just to save her feelings. They never want to come to these family gatherings - because he will be there. He made their time miserable when they were younger and now that’s what they associate with these family gatherings. He brings out the worst in them because they expect him to shout and upset them. I have to threaten and bribe to get them here at all. If I told them they had to play with him they’d spend the whole holiday crying.”

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 09:18

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 19/02/2023 09:01

If I was your sister I would be talking to my kids about handling this situation because it needs nuance and it sounds like she just finds out easier to say they don't have to do anything they don't want to. I'd be

  • helping them understand what behaviour is in his control and what isn't.
  • telling them they don't have to meekly accept themselves being on the receiving end of outbursts but they way to handle it is xyz and getting adult help if need be etc (balancing self protection with understanding)
  • Informing them he is their cousin so while they don't have to be drawn to him or like him they do have to find some basic courtesy and civility when they are in his company which would mean things like including him as a matter of course.
  • Explaining that being shown courtesy and understanding goes a long way to helping someone be the best version of themselves they can be, so if he finds social skills difficult they would make things worse by treating him disrespectfully and that isn't ok
  • I'd be actively aware of their interactions and be ready to intervene if needed, like, helping with needed distance (like getting your son to give me a hand with something if things looked like they might be getting bumpy) or change of activity to help things go smoothly. I would also be aware of if they need help acting on the chat we'd had and adding that on if needed.
  • Sometimes we'd talk about how things were afterwards if it was appropriate. Maybe if draw their attention to something that went well because of thoughtful care, or how or choices had influenced things etc.
  • Considering the above and the health of the relationship getting them to tell me if they need to see him a bit less often so it is achievable and not unrealistic (as it might be of they spent too much time with him and he was very challenging)
  • None of this is onerous or heavy, it would be chats at brekky or in the car on the way or whatever, just raising awareness and setting expectations in age appropriate language that's all. No big deal imo. My kids are 12 and 10 and if we are going into a social situation which requires this kind of understanding I do all the above and tell them to let me know if they're struggling so I can help, they would do this because they've been raised to understand that one person's wants don't trump another's (both ways) and equity means sometimes individuals needs extra help to be in the club than others. They understand that and happily do it.

So I think it is sad that your sister either doesn't have the skills or motivation to do this for your child.

This is a really lovely and encouraging post.

There is a big difference though between treating someone with respect and being friends with them. As a child I understood all of the above and treated people with kindness but I still didn’t want to spend time with other kids whom I did not feel comfortable with and no amount of adult intervention would fix that. Having to constantly have time outs or call an adult to intervene would not endear me to being friends with another child if I had to do this just to feel comfortable with them.

The cousins absolutely have a responsibility to treat their cousin with kindness but they are absolutely not under an obligation to be “friends” with someone they don’t want to be. Friendship is not something that can be enforced by others, it just can’t. It’s natural and organic.

That equally applies to the OPs son- there could be plenty of kids his age that he might get along with splendidly. If it were me, I’d stop focusing solely on family for sourcing friendships and focus on finding other children he gets along with and shares common interests with. Finding friendships that naturally work for him will be far more fruitful in the long run than trying to force friendships only within the narrow range of his family group.

Smoothlines · 19/02/2023 09:16

No child is going to want to spend time with an aggressive, troublemaker cousin, especially one that is older than them. Of course they will be wary of him. Even if he is managing his behaviour better now, the cousins will have had years of poor behaviour from him, and no doubt they won’t be keen to engage with him. Your child needs to form new friendships without all that baggage.

liveforsummer · 19/02/2023 09:13

abouttimeforu · 19/02/2023 05:00

Thames for the insight.
Can I ask why you think they like to engage with him when there no other option in that case ? Should I pull him away from his cousins also?

It may not be that they like to but as you've stated, there is t another option. Maybe (likely) your dad copes better in situations where it's 1:1 and does not dispassionate much of the loud, problematic behaviour you describe so is more fun to be around?

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 19/02/2023 09:13

That is, the bullet points are just for the benefit of this thread, my kids don't get that version. 😁

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 19/02/2023 09:10

theleafandnotthetree · 19/02/2023 09:04

This is all very worthy but my children would consider me to be making very heavy weather of things if I went around like this. I think it would be more likely to turn them off than anything 🤔

It's not worthy or heavy it's just using adult understanding to have a helpful chat and do small practical things which speak for themselves. No biggy.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 19/02/2023 09:06

Clymene · 19/02/2023 05:21

I Wouk absolutely withdraw. Autistic children's mental health is so fragile at the best of times and they really don't need poorly parented unpleasant children in their lives, even if they are related.

Your child has a disability. A fact which is being overlooked by your sister and most of the posters on this thread. As ever, the disablism on MN is alive and well.

I'm sorry you and he are going through this.

But regardless of whether or not he has additional needs, if he is aggressive and bossy, then children aren't going to want to play with him. And why should they allow themselves to be treated badly?

theleafandnotthetree · 19/02/2023 09:04

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 19/02/2023 09:01

If I was your sister I would be talking to my kids about handling this situation because it needs nuance and it sounds like she just finds out easier to say they don't have to do anything they don't want to. I'd be

  • helping them understand what behaviour is in his control and what isn't.
  • telling them they don't have to meekly accept themselves being on the receiving end of outbursts but they way to handle it is xyz and getting adult help if need be etc (balancing self protection with understanding)
  • Informing them he is their cousin so while they don't have to be drawn to him or like him they do have to find some basic courtesy and civility when they are in his company which would mean things like including him as a matter of course.
  • Explaining that being shown courtesy and understanding goes a long way to helping someone be the best version of themselves they can be, so if he finds social skills difficult they would make things worse by treating him disrespectfully and that isn't ok
  • I'd be actively aware of their interactions and be ready to intervene if needed, like, helping with needed distance (like getting your son to give me a hand with something if things looked like they might be getting bumpy) or change of activity to help things go smoothly. I would also be aware of if they need help acting on the chat we'd had and adding that on if needed.
  • Sometimes we'd talk about how things were afterwards if it was appropriate. Maybe if draw their attention to something that went well because of thoughtful care, or how or choices had influenced things etc.
  • Considering the above and the health of the relationship getting them to tell me if they need to see him a bit less often so it is achievable and not unrealistic (as it might be of they spent too much time with him and he was very challenging)
  • None of this is onerous or heavy, it would be chats at brekky or in the car on the way or whatever, just raising awareness and setting expectations in age appropriate language that's all. No big deal imo. My kids are 12 and 10 and if we are going into a social situation which requires this kind of understanding I do all the above and tell them to let me know if they're struggling so I can help, they would do this because they've been raised to understand that one person's wants don't trump another's (both ways) and equity means sometimes individuals needs extra help to be in the club than others. They understand that and happily do it.

So I think it is sad that your sister either doesn't have the skills or motivation to do this for your child.

This is all very worthy but my children would consider me to be making very heavy weather of things if I went around like this. I think it would be more likely to turn them off than anything 🤔

HiccupHorrendousHaddock · 19/02/2023 09:02

They aren’t friends, they are cousins. They aren’t choosing to spend time together, it’s imposed on them by you and your sister. They are getting to an age where they make and maintain friendships independently rather than playing with whoever’s in front of them.

If their perception of your DS is someone angry, aggressive and controlling who has difficulty controlling his temper, they will naturally pull back.

Disengaging for a good while seems sensible to me. Then when you do all see each other communally, they will be more likely to see how he’s changed.

SoCunningYouCanStickATailOnItAndCallItAFox · 19/02/2023 09:01

If I was your sister I would be talking to my kids about handling this situation because it needs nuance and it sounds like she just finds out easier to say they don't have to do anything they don't want to. I'd be

  • helping them understand what behaviour is in his control and what isn't.
  • telling them they don't have to meekly accept themselves being on the receiving end of outbursts but they way to handle it is xyz and getting adult help if need be etc (balancing self protection with understanding)
  • Informing them he is their cousin so while they don't have to be drawn to him or like him they do have to find some basic courtesy and civility when they are in his company which would mean things like including him as a matter of course.
  • Explaining that being shown courtesy and understanding goes a long way to helping someone be the best version of themselves they can be, so if he finds social skills difficult they would make things worse by treating him disrespectfully and that isn't ok
  • I'd be actively aware of their interactions and be ready to intervene if needed, like, helping with needed distance (like getting your son to give me a hand with something if things looked like they might be getting bumpy) or change of activity to help things go smoothly. I would also be aware of if they need help acting on the chat we'd had and adding that on if needed.
  • Sometimes we'd talk about how things were afterwards if it was appropriate. Maybe if draw their attention to something that went well because of thoughtful care, or how or choices had influenced things etc.
  • Considering the above and the health of the relationship getting them to tell me if they need to see him a bit less often so it is achievable and not unrealistic (as it might be of they spent too much time with him and he was very challenging)
  • None of this is onerous or heavy, it would be chats at brekky or in the car on the way or whatever, just raising awareness and setting expectations in age appropriate language that's all. No big deal imo. My kids are 12 and 10 and if we are going into a social situation which requires this kind of understanding I do all the above and tell them to let me know if they're struggling so I can help, they would do this because they've been raised to understand that one person's wants don't trump another's (both ways) and equity means sometimes individuals needs extra help to be in the club than others. They understand that and happily do it.

So I think it is sad that your sister either doesn't have the skills or motivation to do this for your child.

MissMarplesbag · 19/02/2023 09:01

I’d start gradually going low contact and socialising with other people. Enrol your son in Autism activity groups in your area so he can make similar friends. Check your local SEND parent cater forums & charities such as MENCAP etc for clubs etc.

both of you need to socialise with more disability accepting people. It’s not healthy to entwine your family and social life together. Start making close friends out of your family circle.

Fundays12 · 19/02/2023 09:01

Fundays12 · 19/02/2023 08:58

I am on the fence here. I actually agree with your sister in the sense that children should pick their own friends but letting them be rude is unfair.

Though equally as a mum of a 11 year old autistic child I understand your concerns. Honestly I would pull back a bit and spend time with your sister more when the kids are at school.

I haven't really encouraged my DCs to be close friends with cousins etc as it would come with too much family drama attached as it's DH family. I am glad as they have their own friends.

I should have also said me and DH pulled ourselves and kids back from his family due to their toxic behaviour. Its no healthy for kids to be treated like second class citizens and this is what was happening to ours. They deserve to grow up believing they are valued for them

XelaM · 19/02/2023 08:59

Sorry, but I wouldn't force my kid to spend time with someone whose behaviour is challenging and who has difficulty controlling their anger. My own daughter is 13 and has cousins who are very close in age (two are a few months older and one is a year younger) and she doesn't like spending time with them, as they have nothing in common and she finds them boring and weird. Forcing her to spend time with them doesn't change the fact that she doesn't enjoy it.

Fundays12 · 19/02/2023 08:58

I am on the fence here. I actually agree with your sister in the sense that children should pick their own friends but letting them be rude is unfair.

Though equally as a mum of a 11 year old autistic child I understand your concerns. Honestly I would pull back a bit and spend time with your sister more when the kids are at school.

I haven't really encouraged my DCs to be close friends with cousins etc as it would come with too much family drama attached as it's DH family. I am glad as they have their own friends.

Livelovebehappy · 19/02/2023 08:51

I don’t think it’s necessary for you to pull away from your sister. It’s possible to have a close relationship without always including your children. A meal out. A walk. Shopping trip. My children when little didn’t get on with my closest friend’s children. 20 years later we are still have a strong friendship, and have managed it with doing stuff together without involving our children. Children see things in black and white. Your child in the past has not been pleasant around your sisters children, and even though you say he is different now, it will take a while for them to accept that. You can’t make a child like someone just because they’re family.

swayingpalmtree · 19/02/2023 08:50

Why do you even want your son to hang out with what you describe as "rude and moody" children? It sounds like you intensely dislike them so its a bit odd you seem to want to insist they be friends with your son.

I agree with PP- of course you feel defensive of your son but it seems like you are excusing his aggressive behaviour and yet holding his cousins to a far higher standard- theyre kids. All kids struggle at times, ND or not and kids friendship groups are constantly shifting and changing. It doesnt mean the kids are inherently horrible or nasty. Maybe his cousins are picking up on your obvious dislike for them?

Pinkdelight3 · 19/02/2023 08:49

they sound horrible and spoilt

They may be horrible and spoilt and also loving and sensitive and funny... as per the OP's DC and everyone else, they'll have a mix of good and bad qualities. The bottom line is whether there's any good to come of saying something to the sister about this and I don't see how it can help matters. The relationship between the cousins is what it is and can't be forced or controlled as they get older. Better to not jeopardise the OP's closeness with her sister and to let the DCs be their own people and develop more appropriate bonds.