Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull away from my close friendship because of her kids

285 replies

abouttimeforu · 19/02/2023 03:56

My close friendship is with my sister. We are extremely close. My child can be very challenging , currently waiting on ASD assessment , attention seeking and has a hard time managing his anger although this has improved greatly .
My child struggles socially and doesn't have many friends.
He is also so kind and loving, very sensitive , thoughtful and funny He is 11.

My sister's two children are by and large, rude and moody. Their mother will often put this down to tiredness and hunger but reality is they are actually just rude and moody, mostly

They will engage with my child when there's no other option but if there are other kids around, they will practically ignore him.
So for example if we were grouping up for an activity, they will purposely say that they want to do x with 'Jen' and completely omit to mention my child's name or include him.
Despite him being the only one left out.
My sister does not intervene or correct them. I would be disgusted if my kids did this and very ashamed tbh.

Her attitude is that they don't have to socialise with people they don't want to socialise with .... until they have no one else and then ask to socialise with my
Child .He has been too available .. my fault.

To me he seems only good enough for them as a stand in but tbh I'm highly sensitive about this issue and biased.
I am very protective of himSo at times I am guilty of overthinking and over reacting when it comes to how I view his interactions with others , when In fact, he is absolutely fine with being on his own sometimes.

My child is always with me when we see my sister and her family. I generally make the effort more as her kids are younger and I have the time.

I think that for my sons self esteem and general happiness, I need to move away from the intensity of the contact , when with my child. He craves their attention and his self worth is so low that he will tolerate being second choice or not a choice at all, as the case may be.
This has only developed recently and I'm
Disgusted if I'm honest but then again , I'm highly sensitive when it comes to him.

My sister has zero insight with her own kids and has never once stepped in and said to her children, for example, to include my child or insist that he be part of a specific group that they were creating. They feel
Very Comfortable leaving him out and she feels very comfortable enabling that .
So, can you advise me here. I really need objectivity thanks.

I will add again that I can be very defensive as he was always labelled the 'troublemaker' which he was mostly, but not always, and always the one that was blamed when there was trouble among them... again, it was mostly him but not always. He has that label now though sadly as it has stuck.
Thanks .

OP posts:
Smoothlines · 19/02/2023 11:38

Why is everyone saying about neurodiversity or autism or SEND or disabled ? The child hasn’t even been diagnosed as any of these. He’s on a waiting list for assessment, that’s all.

Penguinsaregreat · 19/02/2023 11:38

I agree that just because they are cousins this does not mean they are good friends.
Many, many family members do not get on.
I would pull back too. Perhaps your sister is being polite and not telling you that actually, her dcs don’t like your son that much.

Shelby2010 · 19/02/2023 11:37

This is difficult to solve because you are both right and it is also common with siblings.

So for example, my 2 DDs will be happy to hang out together but if one of them has a friend round then they would rather be with their friend & sibling is excluded.

It sounds like your DS benefits from having cousins that he feels safe with. So perhaps you could carry on with the situations where he isn’t excluded- presumably when it’s just the 3 kids, but avoid larger gatherings?

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:36

So you think some children should put themselves in harms way because if they don't they're being seen as 'more important'?

Oh yeah, that's completely what I said 🙄

I'm not even really talking about what children should or shouldn't do, I'm talking about adults' attitudes. Stop pretending there isn't a whole lot of ableist shit on this thread.

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 11:34

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:27

Some of the attitudes on here are unrealistic. While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out. As a teacher, I've found it so challenging and heartbreaking over the years to see the loneliness of neurodiverse children whose behaviour pushes other children away, but there really is only so much you can ask of other children in terms of kindness, patience and understanding before their own needs need to come first.

Yes, like the majority on the thread, you feel that NT children are more important. Thank fuck there are people who are committed to focusing on and improving life for disabled individuals. They're just not on this thread. 😆

So you think some children should put themselves in harms way because if they don't they're being seen as 'more important'?

EnidSpyton · 19/02/2023 11:33

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:27

Some of the attitudes on here are unrealistic. While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out. As a teacher, I've found it so challenging and heartbreaking over the years to see the loneliness of neurodiverse children whose behaviour pushes other children away, but there really is only so much you can ask of other children in terms of kindness, patience and understanding before their own needs need to come first.

Yes, like the majority on the thread, you feel that NT children are more important. Thank fuck there are people who are committed to focusing on and improving life for disabled individuals. They're just not on this thread. 😆

No, that's not what I'm saying.

No one is more important than anyone else. What is important, though, is people's wellbeing and safety.

If a ND child's social interactions consist of constantly hitting other children, where would you draw the line at expecting other children to put up with being hit, kicked and so on?

It's not about privileging 'NT' (if such a thing exists) over 'ND' children. It's about ensuring safety and wellbeing. No one - no matter what needs they have - has the right to hurt someone else, and no one - no matter what needs they have - should have to accept being hurt by someone else.

Cocobutt · 19/02/2023 11:30

It is really really offensive to suggest that teaching children to be inclusive of differently abled children means they will have poor boundaries and be prey to abusers as adults.

Being inclusive and kind to everyone should be encouraged.

Putting up with shitty behaviour regardless of whether they are ND or not, should NOT be encouraged.

I hate the idea that if someone is ND they are allowed to be badly behaved or treat someone like shit and it’s offensive if you say that someone doesn’t deserve to be treated like that.

How many threads are there on here where women are in abusive relationships and then say her DH is ND or other posters say he could be and it completely excuses his behaviour.

There are so many people who are ND or who have trauma but just haven’t been officially diagnosed.
OP’s nieces and nephews could have ND which is why they’re moody.
OP’s child hasn’t even had an official diagnosis yet either, so to suggest that he can have challenging behaviour and be aggressive is ok but for the sisters children to not want to play with him isn’t, is not ok and its not being inclusive to them.

If you want children to be kind and inclusive then that needs to include everyone, not just the one that is suspected of being ND.

All of the children I work with have ND.
None of them are forced to play with anyone who is challenging or aggressive.

Not only would this teach them poor boundaries (and ND children often need to be taught about their own boundaries more than NT children).
But it also doesn’t help the child who is aggressive, if they think they can act like that but still say who plays with them and when.

There is a fine line between being kind and inclusive vs having no boundaries and putting up with inappropriate behaviour.

Teaching your kids to not have boundaries with someone because that person could potentially have ND is not ok.

FlowerPows · 19/02/2023 11:29

Do you have any other friends at all?

This is why families are so difficult, I have a lot of sisters, there are 5 of us . I have always got on much better with two of them than the other two. This was not a choice we just have more in common than just DNA. Actual friends that you choose can mean so much more to you than family.

I do feel very sorry for your DS but sounds like he upset them a lot in the past.I actually think other comments about why would you put your DS through it are valid. I think overall backing away would be good.

@NumberTheory has made a really decent post.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:27

Some of the attitudes on here are unrealistic. While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out. As a teacher, I've found it so challenging and heartbreaking over the years to see the loneliness of neurodiverse children whose behaviour pushes other children away, but there really is only so much you can ask of other children in terms of kindness, patience and understanding before their own needs need to come first.

Yes, like the majority on the thread, you feel that NT children are more important. Thank fuck there are people who are committed to focusing on and improving life for disabled individuals. They're just not on this thread. 😆

OhmygodDont · 19/02/2023 11:25

There’s be nice don’t leave little jimmy out because he has strange to you ideas about play or favourite things.

Then there’s oh no sweeties yes I no jimmy shouts at you and has violent outbursts but you must play with him even if a lot of times you get shouted at or hurt. It would be rude not to.

RaininginDarling · 19/02/2023 11:22

Emma543 · 19/02/2023 10:39

Am I the only one who grew up with a sibling that would drop them like a stone the sooner a better option came along ha?!

I honestly think choosing friends over family is quite a normal part of childhood

Well, indeed. I think the anger on this thread towards the cousins is quite disheartening. As many people have pointed out: you can't force friendships and being cousins does not equal friends (ND or not). Of course, children have preferred peers they'd chose to hang out with. Don't you? I certainly grew up being dropped by family members when a friend was available. Yes, they should be being kind and respectful, but perhaps they are? And, as others have said, perhaps they are wary after previous aggressive outbursts? There was an excellent post earlier about engaging with children and explaining what is and isn't within your son's control. Are these conversations you can have with the cousins? Be a bridge, as it were in their communication? I'm sure it's hard not to leak your heartfelt disappointment and your understandable defensiveness when the cousins don't act as you'd like. Children pick up on those cues too. I sense what's really driving the distress here is the pain of realising DS and cousins are not close. That must be very painful and my heart goes out to you. You're probably noticing what your son is losing out on - but, if they're not close, is he losing out? Does he even want to hang out with them? There does appear to be a muddling of expectations re: family and friends as the sister is called a friend in the thread title. That says something about the dynamics at play and a possible muddying of boundaries. It's great you and your sister would choose each other as friends if you weren't related. I don't think that's necessarily true of many families and certainly is too high an expectation to put on the cousins.

Others have suggested finding other resources, support and friendships for your son. I would want to focus on that, myself. What does he engage with? What does he want? What interests does he have?

I wouldn't be pulling away from my sister but I would be more realistic about my expectations of that relationship and that of the cousins.

Wishing you the best (and yes, plenty of neuro-divergence in my family: siblings, cousins and their children).

EnidSpyton · 19/02/2023 11:21

There is a difference between being taught to understand that everyone is different and some people will see the world differently to others, and that kindness, acceptance and respect are important, and being taught that it's acceptable and even desirable to put yourself in a position where you are being hurt or upset by someone else because they're not able to control their behaviour and you are.

Neurodiversity and all forms of additional needs exist and we all have to be able to rub along with one another in this world with kindness, respect and understanding. But some people's neurodiversity or other additional needs cause them to behave in ways that are violent, cruel and harmful to others. Asking children to accept being hit, shouted at, called names, manipulated etc by others because those other children have additional needs and they therefore need to be kind and accepting and just put up with it is not fair.

Some of the attitudes on here are unrealistic. While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out. As a teacher, I've found it so challenging and heartbreaking over the years to see the loneliness of neurodiverse children whose behaviour pushes other children away, but there really is only so much you can ask of other children in terms of kindness, patience and understanding before their own needs need to come first.

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 11:20

Pinkdelight3 · 19/02/2023 11:15

You seem ridiculously determined to be offended. As I said upthread, my DS is autistic. I'm not 'suggesting' anything about autistic people, children or adults.

Absolutely what people are saying, well what I've seen is, it's not fair on children to be told 'it doesn't matter if someone had been aggressive, violent or threatening to you, it's all on you to #bekind and ensure their feelings aren't hurt'. This guidance/direction is of course circumstantial as to whether its always appropriate.

Pinkdelight3 · 19/02/2023 11:15

Clymene · 19/02/2023 11:05

It is really really offensive to suggest that teaching children to be inclusive of differently abled children means they will have poor boundaries and be prey to abusers as adults.

Fucking hell, I thought I'd read some revolting shit in my time on here about autistic people but that one is right up there.

You seem ridiculously determined to be offended. As I said upthread, my DS is autistic. I'm not 'suggesting' anything about autistic people, children or adults.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:14

VirtualRealitee · 19/02/2023 11:13

It's crystal clear (to me anyway) that's not what's being said.

How unexpected, here on MN 🙄

gemloving · 19/02/2023 11:13

Have you spoken to your child about it? He's 11 and should be able to tell you how he feels about it all or is this all coming from you?

What's it like at school?

I don't think there is much you can do but he's your only DS which I notice people have more time only focussing on one, possible special needs, you will always be more overprotective I suppose.

VirtualRealitee · 19/02/2023 11:13

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 10:53

Sorry, I dunno if you're saying that abusers are autistic or something?

It's crystal clear (to me anyway) that's not what's being said.

Fixed · 19/02/2023 11:12

My sisters child is in the same situation as your son, and same age. Seeing this from the other side.....

Her son is always causing issues amongst any group he is in. He is destructive, things have to be his way, he is rude, he was awful with all of this when he was younger but has got better with it now. I can totally see why people take a back step with him. As much as people understand he has issues etc, he would always ruin every game and everything would end in tears. That is not fair to everyone.

He is very happy in his own space, he chooses not to be around people now as he says he doesn't really like people.

Having said all of the above, my kids never left him out because they didn't have the heart to. And he always had a better relationship with them than others, because they were very patient of him.

It's an awkward one, but I think you need to see it from both sides.

Smoothlines · 19/02/2023 11:08

BadNomad · 19/02/2023 10:57

That's not what's happening though. They're choosing to play with him sometimes and leaving him out at other times because it suits them. That is using someone.

Eh? That makes no sense. That is not how social interactions work. If you are at a party, do you speak/engage with every person there equally? You have the choice to, but I bet anything you don’t. Or do you find that on one occasion you have hardly spoken to Bob but on another occasion you speak quite a lot to him. That is not using someone.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:07

Clymene · 19/02/2023 11:05

It is really really offensive to suggest that teaching children to be inclusive of differently abled children means they will have poor boundaries and be prey to abusers as adults.

Fucking hell, I thought I'd read some revolting shit in my time on here about autistic people but that one is right up there.

Yeah, you've put this much better than me tbh. No wonder so many autistic adults struggle so badly.

JMSA · 19/02/2023 11:06

But if your sister's children were taught to pander to your son, then it would only lead to resentment from them anyway. Also, it wouldn't reflect how children are going to treat him in real life.
I understand that it's hard and that you are overprotective of your son, but I'm not sure if you'll be doing him any favours if you withdraw from this relationship. He needs real life social interactions that don't just come from his mother.
Instead of putting all the onus on your sister - which I can imagine is quite a pressure on her - couldn't you speak to your niece and nephew directly, encouraging them to include your son when you feel they're being unfair?

OnaBegonia · 19/02/2023 11:06

my child had angry outbursts and would shout and generally be aggressive and bossy
I think it's obvious why they don't want to socialise with him. You're being very irrational and blinkered to assume everyone should like your son the way you do.

Clymene · 19/02/2023 11:05

It is really really offensive to suggest that teaching children to be inclusive of differently abled children means they will have poor boundaries and be prey to abusers as adults.

Fucking hell, I thought I'd read some revolting shit in my time on here about autistic people but that one is right up there.

N27 · 19/02/2023 11:05

Sorry if I’ve missed this, but how long has he been “greatly improved”?

years of being challenging, aggressive and loud are not going to be completely forgotten about in a few months? Relationships take time, trust needs to be earned.

BadNomad · 19/02/2023 11:03

Pinkdelight3 · 19/02/2023 10:58

That's not what's happening though. They're choosing to play with him sometimes and leaving him out at other times because it suits them. That is using someone.

So as per a previous comment - would you rather they ignored him all the time for consistency? Because the playing with him all the time is not going to happen.

Yes. Be consistent. Either be his friend or don't be. Look how many threads there are on MN about one person being treated differently within their friendship group and being hurt by it. Invited to some things, then ignored for others. They're rightly told they are being used and should ditch those friends.

In this case they're not even friends. They're just playing with him when it's convenient to them. They don't give a toss about him. I would not keep taking my child to people who treat him like that.