Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull away from my close friendship because of her kids

285 replies

abouttimeforu · 19/02/2023 03:56

My close friendship is with my sister. We are extremely close. My child can be very challenging , currently waiting on ASD assessment , attention seeking and has a hard time managing his anger although this has improved greatly .
My child struggles socially and doesn't have many friends.
He is also so kind and loving, very sensitive , thoughtful and funny He is 11.

My sister's two children are by and large, rude and moody. Their mother will often put this down to tiredness and hunger but reality is they are actually just rude and moody, mostly

They will engage with my child when there's no other option but if there are other kids around, they will practically ignore him.
So for example if we were grouping up for an activity, they will purposely say that they want to do x with 'Jen' and completely omit to mention my child's name or include him.
Despite him being the only one left out.
My sister does not intervene or correct them. I would be disgusted if my kids did this and very ashamed tbh.

Her attitude is that they don't have to socialise with people they don't want to socialise with .... until they have no one else and then ask to socialise with my
Child .He has been too available .. my fault.

To me he seems only good enough for them as a stand in but tbh I'm highly sensitive about this issue and biased.
I am very protective of himSo at times I am guilty of overthinking and over reacting when it comes to how I view his interactions with others , when In fact, he is absolutely fine with being on his own sometimes.

My child is always with me when we see my sister and her family. I generally make the effort more as her kids are younger and I have the time.

I think that for my sons self esteem and general happiness, I need to move away from the intensity of the contact , when with my child. He craves their attention and his self worth is so low that he will tolerate being second choice or not a choice at all, as the case may be.
This has only developed recently and I'm
Disgusted if I'm honest but then again , I'm highly sensitive when it comes to him.

My sister has zero insight with her own kids and has never once stepped in and said to her children, for example, to include my child or insist that he be part of a specific group that they were creating. They feel
Very Comfortable leaving him out and she feels very comfortable enabling that .
So, can you advise me here. I really need objectivity thanks.

I will add again that I can be very defensive as he was always labelled the 'troublemaker' which he was mostly, but not always, and always the one that was blamed when there was trouble among them... again, it was mostly him but not always. He has that label now though sadly as it has stuck.
Thanks .

OP posts:
Milky4 · 19/02/2023 19:33

whumpthereitis · 19/02/2023 15:00

It sounds like the sister is caught between her sister and nephew, and her children. She’s also right in saying she can’t force them to want to be around him - she can’t. Some children can be talked/cajoled/threatened into it (not that they should be, and not necessarily without negative impact in the short, medium, or long term), but others that just won’t work on.

What is she supposed to do? She takes her sister’s pov and risks her children ending up miserable and/or damaging her relationship with them/making all the familial relationships worse, or she respects her children’s wishes and has to deal with the consequences of that. It’s not a great position to be in, but imo she’s doing the right thing in respecting her children.

Feel like you made something up in your head about what I wrote.....

Clymene · 19/02/2023 19:33

@NumberTheory I am not saying that any child should be taught to accept that aggressive and controlling is fine and dandy. Parents need to supervise closely. There need to be open and honest conversations.

This poster you quoted wasn't saying that. A lot of posters aren't saying that. The overwhelming POV seems to be that 'well your kid isn't fun for my kids to be around and he's not even got a diagnosis anyway'.

Autistic children are much, much more likely to be victims of bullying than NT children. Excluding a child for being disabled is a form of bullying.

NumberTheory · 19/02/2023 18:42

Clymene · 19/02/2023 11:05

It is really really offensive to suggest that teaching children to be inclusive of differently abled children means they will have poor boundaries and be prey to abusers as adults.

Fucking hell, I thought I'd read some revolting shit in my time on here about autistic people but that one is right up there.

It might be more effective if you explained how children can be shown to be inclusive of kids with aggressive and controlling behaviour without it making them more likely to accept aggressive and controlling behaviour in adulthood (or childhood).

Because for most parents you will seem to be saying they should do the opposite of what they’ve probably been doing to protect their kids - tell them not to tolerate it, to walk away and not engage with someone who does it.

Simply calling that concern offensive is likely to entrench the attitudes of parents who might otherwise be open to learning new ways of teaching their children. They are always going to be more concerned about their own children than they are about how offended you are.

Nevermind31 · 19/02/2023 17:42

Some things are not quite clear here - it seems OP and sister are good friends, and she spends a LOT of time around there.
she says she is available.
it is not clear if nephews are asking for cousin to come round because no one else is available,
it seems more like if they have friends round they don’t want to play with cousin. They might not want to see their cousin at all, not their choice to have him around again. They might resend to constantly having their space invaded, by someone they don’t particularly get on with, making them moody and grumpy.
i also don’t think they will like the Don more if he is less available- they will just happily go about their lives.
OP - please do what is best for your son, but stop blaming the cousins

whumpthereitis · 19/02/2023 15:00

Milky4 · 19/02/2023 13:25

You sound like someone who reflects deeply and is aware of your own biases and flaws. For that reason, I'm quite sure your sister is in the wrong - as this is the most balanced AIBU I've read.

The relationship is clearly hurting you, even if it isn't your son - as quite rightly you'd expect a close sister to be caring for her nephew in a similar protective manner as you.

You can't force children to play together - your child will pick up on the half heart approach anyway. But it's reasonable to expect his Auntie to be sensitive to it, not wish him to be left out and to respond to you and him with kindness.

Step back from the relationship. Seek other friendships. You don't have to go NC or anything that drastic but you can be unavailable next time she wants to meet up and slowly distance yourself to where you are able to see her and feel positive.

It sounds like the sister is caught between her sister and nephew, and her children. She’s also right in saying she can’t force them to want to be around him - she can’t. Some children can be talked/cajoled/threatened into it (not that they should be, and not necessarily without negative impact in the short, medium, or long term), but others that just won’t work on.

What is she supposed to do? She takes her sister’s pov and risks her children ending up miserable and/or damaging her relationship with them/making all the familial relationships worse, or she respects her children’s wishes and has to deal with the consequences of that. It’s not a great position to be in, but imo she’s doing the right thing in respecting her children.

Everyonehasavoice · 19/02/2023 14:25

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 19/02/2023 12:23

It doesn’t change the other kids’ experience, and after interacting for so many years, I would find it very hard to believe the possibility of special needs has not been suggested to them by their mother many many times.

My mother always went out of her way to be inclusive whatever it took: we saw our toys destroyed, were hit with rocks (I kid you not)and on occasion, when I was 12, I was repeatedly pestered by a kid a year older than me trying to kiss me and touch my breasts. They all had special needs but, I wish my mother had not forced us to be so bloody “understanding”, it was hell every single time.

I have a child with a disability now, he is a handful at times but it has also been my view that if he is to have friends, real friends, he has to reign over his own behaviour to ensure other kids enjoy spending time with him.

When he was younger, the best thing I could do was to watch him as a hawk and intervene if he was unpleasant to other kids or simply keep play dates short enough. I obviously expected good behaviour from the other kids towards my son as well, but never expected them to put up with misbehaviour because he has a disability. Interestingly, this has taught him that friendship goes both ways, respect is paid back with respect.

DS has grown up into a considerate young man, has plenty of friends and is able to maintain his own friendships. I don’t think this would have happened if I had not insisted on him learning how to interact with people. I won’t say it was easy, I was bloody exhausted most of the time and walking on eggshells but it has paid off at the end (for now).

Confused
I didn’t say it changed anyones experience,
nor did I say anything about children having to play with someone they don’t want to,
i was simply pointing out that PPs comments were related to childrens outlook

Milky4 · 19/02/2023 13:25

You sound like someone who reflects deeply and is aware of your own biases and flaws. For that reason, I'm quite sure your sister is in the wrong - as this is the most balanced AIBU I've read.

The relationship is clearly hurting you, even if it isn't your son - as quite rightly you'd expect a close sister to be caring for her nephew in a similar protective manner as you.

You can't force children to play together - your child will pick up on the half heart approach anyway. But it's reasonable to expect his Auntie to be sensitive to it, not wish him to be left out and to respond to you and him with kindness.

Step back from the relationship. Seek other friendships. You don't have to go NC or anything that drastic but you can be unavailable next time she wants to meet up and slowly distance yourself to where you are able to see her and feel positive.

TrashyPanda · 19/02/2023 13:00

It is not unreasonable that your sisters’ DC have friends they actively chose to spend time and that they prefer the company of these friends to that of their cousin. That’s because you have a different relationship with your friends - one you have actively chosen due to shared interests etc - than with someone you happen to be related to. It isn’t exclusionary behaviour to prefer to spend time with people you like.

you describe your son as challenging, controlling and angry. Maybe his cousins are scared of him?

Does your son have many friends? Maybe you could bring one along next time you meet up?

whumpthereitis · 19/02/2023 12:40

The reasons for a someone’s behavior don’t necessarily change the impact of the behavior on those around them. They may be able to understand why he acts as he does, but that doesn’t change the fact that they don’t enjoy his company.

I’m not of the view that you have go get on with family by virtue of sharing DNA. I’m related to some great people, and I’m also related to some arseholes. I don’t consider myself obliged to interact with the arseholes because they’re related to me. That’s never struck me as a healthy value to have.

She’s right that she can’t force them to be close to him or include him. It sounds like they do try when it’s just the three of them, but they’d rather be with their friends if they have the option to. That sounds pretty normal tbh. I’m sure most if not all of us have people we get along with superficially because we have to be around each other, but that doesn’t mean we choose to socialize with them outside of that.

Bigbadfish · 19/02/2023 12:28

They're cousins. So wouldn't choose to be friends and are only mashed together due to you and their mum.

Of course the socialise when there's no other option! Even adults do this. Eg work events.

You don't paint a picture of a child easy to get on with and so at their age they are going to have criteria that means they filter out people they want to willingly be with.

You just need to find his people and accept that family events are for family but otherwise they aren't friends.

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 19/02/2023 12:23

Everyonehasavoice · 19/02/2023 05:31

@Clymene
I think OP mentioned her son was being assessed for ASD so as yet not classed as having a disability.
reading the PPs they are looking at the situation from a child’s perspective and mentioning it as such in explaining reasons why the cousins do not want to play with Ds.

OP I suggest you talk to your sister, ask her if she’s talked to her children about your Ds behaviour and try to see if there’s a way forward possibly by just seeing them without others around.

It doesn’t change the other kids’ experience, and after interacting for so many years, I would find it very hard to believe the possibility of special needs has not been suggested to them by their mother many many times.

My mother always went out of her way to be inclusive whatever it took: we saw our toys destroyed, were hit with rocks (I kid you not)and on occasion, when I was 12, I was repeatedly pestered by a kid a year older than me trying to kiss me and touch my breasts. They all had special needs but, I wish my mother had not forced us to be so bloody “understanding”, it was hell every single time.

I have a child with a disability now, he is a handful at times but it has also been my view that if he is to have friends, real friends, he has to reign over his own behaviour to ensure other kids enjoy spending time with him.

When he was younger, the best thing I could do was to watch him as a hawk and intervene if he was unpleasant to other kids or simply keep play dates short enough. I obviously expected good behaviour from the other kids towards my son as well, but never expected them to put up with misbehaviour because he has a disability. Interestingly, this has taught him that friendship goes both ways, respect is paid back with respect.

DS has grown up into a considerate young man, has plenty of friends and is able to maintain his own friendships. I don’t think this would have happened if I had not insisted on him learning how to interact with people. I won’t say it was easy, I was bloody exhausted most of the time and walking on eggshells but it has paid off at the end (for now).

XelaM · 19/02/2023 12:21

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:27

Some of the attitudes on here are unrealistic. While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out. As a teacher, I've found it so challenging and heartbreaking over the years to see the loneliness of neurodiverse children whose behaviour pushes other children away, but there really is only so much you can ask of other children in terms of kindness, patience and understanding before their own needs need to come first.

Yes, like the majority on the thread, you feel that NT children are more important. Thank fuck there are people who are committed to focusing on and improving life for disabled individuals. They're just not on this thread. 😆

Ho did you get THAT from what the poster said?!

MonkeyMindAllOverAround · 19/02/2023 12:00

Op, I think you just need to keep your distances. It is obvious the kids do not enjoy the company of each other and you really can’t force a friendship, much less so when the kids are entering teenage.

This doesn’t mean you need to cut your sister off, especially if you are close, just meet with her without kids.

Cocobutt · 19/02/2023 11:59

These threads always get hijacked by posters trying to find things to be offended about.

Walkaround · 19/02/2023 11:56

As this behaviour from the children has only happened recently and their mother, despite being extremely close to her sister, is apparently oblivious, I have a sneaking suspicion that the reality is that she is not remotely oblivious and the children, now they are old enough to start thinking that they shouldn’t always have to go along with their parents’ social arrangements, have started expressing behind the scenes to their mother their upset that they have to see quite so much of their aunt and cousin. This is an arrangement that is down to the close relationship of the sisters, not of the cousins, after all. It is not easy to say to your sister that your children are being rude and moody because they are upset that they are having to spend so much time in your company and are resentful their feelings are not being respected, so she pretends they are just tired and hungry and always behave like this, because she doesn’t want to see less of her sister, but knows that telling her children off publicly will just result in things she does not want aired publicly being expressed in openly unkind ways. Behind the scenes she probably is telling her children to be kinder and more thoughtful, because they do love their cousin and can play nicely together when they get together in smaller doses, but what they want is less time spent making that effort and if this sentiment continues to be ignored, the OP is right that it will be harmful to everyone. It would be such a shame if relationships are ruined in the long term when the only real problem is that everyone is just seeing a bit too much of each other.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:54

Anyway, at this point I can't say anything without a certain couple of posters jumping on and twisting it so I'm out. I maintain that teaching your kids to be aware of disabilities and differences from a young age benefits everyone.

VirtualRealitee · 19/02/2023 11:53

It's a shame this thread has been derailed by one person.

Any chance of getting it back on track? I'm sure the OP doesn't want to read pages of bickering and squabbling when they get back.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:44

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 11:42

@AllOfThemWitches yes you have. You have responded to @EnidSpyton directly saying Yes, like the majority on the thread, you feel that NT children are more important. Thank fuck there are people who are committed to focusing on and improving life for disabled individuals. They're just not on this thread. 😆

you feel like.

(Sorry Enid for the tag!)

Yes, that's how her post comes across. She's far from the only one. Mumsnet is known for its intolerance of people with disabilities.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:43

Pinkdelight3 · 19/02/2023 11:41

I'm not even really talking about what children should or shouldn't do, I'm talking about adults' attitudes. Stop pretending there isn't a whole lot of ableist shit on this thread.

Well most people are talking about what children should or shouldn't do. You're talking about what preoccupies you and see everything through that lens. That makes sense now, but doesn't mean people here should be the target for your anger. Ironic really. When we're talking about putting up with people having to tolerate someone else's angry outbursts or not.

Anger? Jesus wept.

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 11:42

@AllOfThemWitches yes you have. You have responded to @EnidSpyton directly saying Yes, like the majority on the thread, you feel that NT children are more important. Thank fuck there are people who are committed to focusing on and improving life for disabled individuals. They're just not on this thread. 😆

you feel like.

(Sorry Enid for the tag!)

Pinkdelight3 · 19/02/2023 11:41

I'm not even really talking about what children should or shouldn't do, I'm talking about adults' attitudes. Stop pretending there isn't a whole lot of ableist shit on this thread.

Well most people are talking about what children should or shouldn't do. You're talking about what preoccupies you and see everything through that lens. That makes sense now, but doesn't mean people here should be the target for your anger. Ironic really. When we're talking about putting up with people having to tolerate someone else's angry outbursts or not.

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:41

'Aggression and swearing' 😆 do you mean where I said 'thank fuck?' I love this place

AllOfThemWitches · 19/02/2023 11:40

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 11:39

Why is this ableist? As this is the post you are saying is.
While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out.
The aggression and swearing isn't making your point clear.

Wrong again. I have not singled out one particular post.

5128gap · 19/02/2023 11:39

I think these children need to be kept apart. There is no natural friendship between them and trying to force it especially at their ages is not going to work. The best that will happen is his cousins will tolerate your DS when the adults are around. They won't like him any more than they currently do, and he will no doubt be aware of that.
Whether you make this about you and your sister is up to you. You could keep the children apart and continue a relationship with her outside of that, even if only by message or phone. This is just a stage of your life long relationship with her and there will be many years ahead after your children are grown up where you might be glad you didn't let this destroy your friendship.

MichelleScarn · 19/02/2023 11:39

Why is this ableist? As this is the post you are saying is.
While it's awful that so many neurodiverse children struggle socially, it's totally unreasonable to ask and expect other children and parents to put themselves/their children in harm's way so that a neurodiverse child doesn't feel left out.
The aggression and swearing isn't making your point clear.

Swipe left for the next trending thread