Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pull away from my close friendship because of her kids

285 replies

abouttimeforu · 19/02/2023 03:56

My close friendship is with my sister. We are extremely close. My child can be very challenging , currently waiting on ASD assessment , attention seeking and has a hard time managing his anger although this has improved greatly .
My child struggles socially and doesn't have many friends.
He is also so kind and loving, very sensitive , thoughtful and funny He is 11.

My sister's two children are by and large, rude and moody. Their mother will often put this down to tiredness and hunger but reality is they are actually just rude and moody, mostly

They will engage with my child when there's no other option but if there are other kids around, they will practically ignore him.
So for example if we were grouping up for an activity, they will purposely say that they want to do x with 'Jen' and completely omit to mention my child's name or include him.
Despite him being the only one left out.
My sister does not intervene or correct them. I would be disgusted if my kids did this and very ashamed tbh.

Her attitude is that they don't have to socialise with people they don't want to socialise with .... until they have no one else and then ask to socialise with my
Child .He has been too available .. my fault.

To me he seems only good enough for them as a stand in but tbh I'm highly sensitive about this issue and biased.
I am very protective of himSo at times I am guilty of overthinking and over reacting when it comes to how I view his interactions with others , when In fact, he is absolutely fine with being on his own sometimes.

My child is always with me when we see my sister and her family. I generally make the effort more as her kids are younger and I have the time.

I think that for my sons self esteem and general happiness, I need to move away from the intensity of the contact , when with my child. He craves their attention and his self worth is so low that he will tolerate being second choice or not a choice at all, as the case may be.
This has only developed recently and I'm
Disgusted if I'm honest but then again , I'm highly sensitive when it comes to him.

My sister has zero insight with her own kids and has never once stepped in and said to her children, for example, to include my child or insist that he be part of a specific group that they were creating. They feel
Very Comfortable leaving him out and she feels very comfortable enabling that .
So, can you advise me here. I really need objectivity thanks.

I will add again that I can be very defensive as he was always labelled the 'troublemaker' which he was mostly, but not always, and always the one that was blamed when there was trouble among them... again, it was mostly him but not always. He has that label now though sadly as it has stuck.
Thanks .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheaBrandt · 20/02/2023 14:21

My Dd and niece who are literally 2 months apart in age friendship ebbs and flows. They were close for a while but have drifted rather through as they have different interests now they are both young teens. No drama and it wouldn’t for a moment affect my relationship with my lovely sister - which is far too strong and precious to be damaged by the whims of 13 year old girls….

LolaSmiles · 20/02/2023 13:54

I wonder if the ND is a red herring. They are pre teens now not little children. The easy days of shoving all the kids together “to play” because the adults get on do come to an end sadly
Agree with this.
The idea that children should be friends just because their parents are friends/they're related is unrealistic.

I like my cousins, always have, we played out as children, and we meet up a couple of times a year as adults with our own children, but they're not my friends and if I had a choice between my cousins or my friends at 11 I'd have picked my friends.

The adults need to separate their relationships from their children's relationship.

MarieRoseMarie · 20/02/2023 12:51

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 12:41

@MarieRoseMarie
Where are you pulling this narrative out of 🤣
Your imaginary stories are getting ridiculous now ....seriously .
I've given you the basic information about how things work with us but you seem intent on misconstruing the facts.
I give up !

I’m genuinely confused that you are so perplexed by this.

she’s an 11 year old girl and your niece.

maybe she is a vile bitchy bully and you are right to agree with all the comments blasting her as a mean evil bitch who’ll get her comeuppance. Or maybe she’s nearly a teenager and there is more going on here.

Either way it seems like staying away from them is the right call.

TheaBrandt · 20/02/2023 12:43

I wonder if the ND is a red herring. They are pre teens now not little children. The easy days of shoving all the kids together “to play” because the adults get on do come to an end sadly. You need to adjust to it - see your sister on your own without kids? Would be a shame to damage your relationship due to this.

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 12:41

@MarieRoseMarie
Where are you pulling this narrative out of 🤣
Your imaginary stories are getting ridiculous now ....seriously .
I've given you the basic information about how things work with us but you seem intent on misconstruing the facts.
I give up !

OP posts:
MarieRoseMarie · 20/02/2023 12:13

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 12:03

So @IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 , your friend Mary pops over for a brew. Uninvited but that's ok.

Then your friend Sally comes over too. You find Sally a lot more interesting. But do you then totally ignore Mary in favour of Sally even though they are both in your house?

Or do you show basic courtesy and talk to them both, making them both feel welcome?

Surely that is what yo y want your dcs to learn,? Courtesy. Learning to manage scenarios with grace and good manners?

@BlastedPimples The analogy doesn’t hold because when someone pops over uninvited you still have the option of telling them that now is not a good time! You still have the ability to uninvite them. These cousins never have that ability. They are not inviting their cousin and have no ability to say “not today”.

It’s more like if you invite your friend Sally over but before she arrives your other friend Mary who you didn’t invite over arrived like she does every other day uninvited. She has a key and comes and goes whenever she likes. You are never allowed to uninvite her. She comes over regardless and you have no say in the matter. Every week she comes over.

Are you an evil meanie if sometimes you just want to play with Sally not Mary?

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 12:03

So @IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 , your friend Mary pops over for a brew. Uninvited but that's ok.

Then your friend Sally comes over too. You find Sally a lot more interesting. But do you then totally ignore Mary in favour of Sally even though they are both in your house?

Or do you show basic courtesy and talk to them both, making them both feel welcome?

Surely that is what yo y want your dcs to learn,? Courtesy. Learning to manage scenarios with grace and good manners?

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 12:00

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

We are talking about kids who normally happily play together. Kids who dump someone else in favour of someone 'better'

Basic, very very basic, good manners.

I would expect better manners from my children in this scenario, yes. You do not exclude people because it's hurtful and unnecessary.

You want to see people by themselves then by all means tell me and I will help you arrange that too.

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 11:58

Well that took a weird turn.

She's being rude and her behaviour mean because a ' better option' has come along so she dumps him, while we are visiting and nobody bats an eyelid at this behaviour. That's my point.

They have great chats and fun until then.

She simply dumps him.

At no stage did I say he's not invited over or he's there all the time 
I said that we often do spend free time together. At each other's homes and holiday together.

Sometimes the simplest explanation is the truth@MarieRoseMarie .

OP posts:
MarieRoseMarie · 20/02/2023 11:41

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 11:25

Sorry @MarieRoseMarie ... where are you going with 15 year old niece example And inappropriate.
Are you being deliberately confusing?
In my example, the cousins had visited, a friend arrived and how I would deal with it, described.
Not the other way round where the niece is 15.
Now that IS weird ...

What do mean where am I going?

I’m pointing out that you are visiting your niece and her friend who is a girl is coming over to play. She may have started her periods. She may want to talk about things that are awkward to talk about in front of a boy.

I was pointing out that you and other posters keep saying that it’s rude to exclude a guest. I was saying that your DS drops over all the time and they are not inviting him. At what age is it acceptable to understand that a young girl may want time alone with a girl friend away from a boy? 15? 14?

it’s not sexually inappropriate, it’s just age inappropriate. She may be trying to exclude him because she wants time alone with her friend!

aSofaNearYou · 20/02/2023 11:39

Butchyrestingface · 20/02/2023 09:31

You've said that your sister is very defensive about her kids and you admit to being very defensive about your kids.

I can't see any conversation about the issue going well.

I agree with this. It sounds like you are both very defensive of your kids and there is bad behaviour on both sides that is being dismissed by the respective parents.

I think you are right to stop forcing the kids together, but wrong to think that these kids should want to be close to someone that for years was aggressive and bossy towards them, regardless of whether he is ND.

They are young teens anyway, they won't need to be playing soon, they can just interact with the adults.

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 11:25

Sorry @MarieRoseMarie ... where are you going with 15 year old niece example And inappropriate.
Are you being deliberately confusing?
In my example, the cousins had visited, a friend arrived and how I would deal with it, described.
Not the other way round where the niece is 15.
Now that IS weird ...

OP posts:
MarieRoseMarie · 20/02/2023 11:13

This would all make sense to me if they were 7 and 9. They are basically teenagers!

MarieRoseMarie · 20/02/2023 11:12

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 11:06

It has become more obvious in this thread that we all have different ideas about manners, friendship and what's acceptable socially .
So for example, in my home , if the cousins called as they do very regularly and a friend of my kids dropped in, there would be no tolerance of dumping the cousins who visited , to go off and play with the friend who called.
In my world, that's rude and Ill mannered.

They'd all be encouraged to get in with it.
@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 thank you for clearing up your context.

Even at 11 and 13? They’re not babies and they are not inviting your cousin, you are. They have no choice in the matter.

At what point does this end? I’m not being facetious. I’m genuinely interested in where you draw the line on politeness. Your now 15 year old niece has two female friends over for a sleepover and your DS drops over, is she still obligated to include him? 14? 13?

This all just feels weird and inappropriate. Not sexually at all. Just that maybe your son is socially a bit younger than his age. But an 11 year old girl wanting to hang out with other girls is not bullying.

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 11:06

It has become more obvious in this thread that we all have different ideas about manners, friendship and what's acceptable socially .
So for example, in my home , if the cousins called as they do very regularly and a friend of my kids dropped in, there would be no tolerance of dumping the cousins who visited , to go off and play with the friend who called.
In my world, that's rude and Ill mannered.

They'd all be encouraged to get in with it.
@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 thank you for clearing up your context.

OP posts:
TiaI · 20/02/2023 11:06

They are cousins, of course they will hang out occasionally but might not be close. That’s fine

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 20/02/2023 11:02

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 11:00

Yes it is a bad thing if you exclude people.

Really? So you're honestly saying you must associate with everyone, even if you don't want to?

Is that what you truly, honestly are saying?

Do you associate with everyone even if you don't want to? Or are you like 99.99999% of people who choose who they associate with?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 20/02/2023 11:01

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 10:45

@MarieRoseMarie and yet until someone else turns up, they are perfectly happy to play with their cousin.

Once someone better crops up, he's dumped. Not included. Dumped.

We don't know that they are 'perfectly happy' to play with their cousin. He's the default, but not their choice. I really don't see what the problem is. They didn't invite their cousin over.

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 11:00

Yes it is a bad thing if you exclude people.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 20/02/2023 10:59

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 10:11

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 really?

You just dump friends when someone 'better' comes along? You sound nice.

You wouldn't encourage inclusion, courtesy, politeness and overall, decency?

Personally, I'm of the view that if someone comes to visit or there an arrangement, then you don't drop the person if someone else crops up.

Appallingly bad mannered.

If my cousins were at my house, and my best friend came over, yes, I would choose to go and play with my best friend.

Is that really such a bad thing?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 20/02/2023 10:58

OP, I've been thinking about this over the last hour while watching tv. Something you said resonated with me. But first, I think if you had mentioned in your OP that your niece was whispering to her friend about your son and being mean to him, my response to you would have been 180 degrees different. Whether your son was mean before, is not really relevant now. What you are describing is mean-spirited teasing and bullying by your niece. Not wanting to play with your son, and teasing him are two entirely different things.

When I was at school I was..... very different from others. Intensely shy and quiet, and preferred to be on my own living in my own head in my own fantasy world. I had a few close friends as a child, but I was always very, very different. I remember whenever new kids came to our school, the school bullies would get to them first, they'd whisper about me and encourage the new kids not to be my friends and to join in the bullying. That is what your post about your niece reminded me of.

What I'm saying is I don't think your niece's bullying of your son is related to his past behaviour. She sounds like a mean-spirited bully and I think she would be like this with other kids too, whether they're NT or not. I know you've made up your mind about the future, but I am wondering if you have spoken to your sister about your niece's behaviour? And if so and if that did nothing, is it possible for you to speak to your niece, personally? I don't mean be aggressive but just have a quiet chat to her, explain how hurtful her behaviour is. That it's ok if she doesn't want to play with your son, but bullying him and whispering and being nasty is not ok and it's hurtful and how would she like it if someone did it to her? It may help her change, because I can guarantee she probably does it to others at school too.

Beautiful3 · 20/02/2023 10:51

They are all that age now, where you cannot tell them who to play with. I'm sorry I know it's hurtful, but they're not going to want to play with an angry 11 year old. Both my siblings were similar to yours, and were told to play with me. No thanks, I'd rather go to my room and read, or go for a walk then face meltdowns/angry outbursts. You cannot make kids over 11, play together.

BlastedPimples · 20/02/2023 10:45

@MarieRoseMarie and yet until someone else turns up, they are perfectly happy to play with their cousin.

Once someone better crops up, he's dumped. Not included. Dumped.

CatSpeakForDummies · 20/02/2023 10:35

I can see both sides as I have an autistic DC (shuts down rather than lashes out though) but I have also been the parent who has had to negotiate with her gentle children about them spending time with a friends child who lashes out. The child I know has no additional needs, but has had a few life changes they are acting out on, so I've drilled it into my kids to be kind to them.

In that situation my kids appear moody and quiet to my friend. I can see they are actually nervous and walking on eggshells around tricky DC. I'd probably blame it on tiredness and hunger to try and be kind to my friend.

Adding other kids to the mix would be difficult and too much for DCs to manage - should they still be kind if another child is being shouted at unfairly, or hit, for example. It's a situation that not many 11 or 12 yos could navigate easily without someone getting hurt or offended.

Luckily I have the option of only seeing her as an adult, the cousin situation is a lot more difficult. I think your sister is trying to be kind, is stuck between her DCs and you and loves you all.

abouttimeforu · 20/02/2023 10:32

Yes@Stomacharmeleon I did because we often talk about his progress with his psychologist and school as it has been so significant. He is self aware and this is all part of his regulation work with them.

OP posts: