Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
MistressoftheDarkSide · 24/02/2023 11:55

@sst1234

Having just wiped the dripping sarcasm in your post from my rhino hide umbrella, I feel compelled to point out that my ranty offering was an attempt to point out the bigger, more complex factors affecting small business.

Some posters get it, some don't - fair enough.

I try and go the extra mile for my customers, within my sometimes limited capabilities. I reserve items for people seen online for weeks because they'll definitely, absolutely, 100% be in for it in the next few days...... after a month, I hoof said items back into stock. I can guarantee, even if I have made gentle contact in this time to ensure they are "desperate for said item" they rock up a few months down the line and are desperately disappointed when I have put them out for other customers to, you know, actually buy. With money.

So someone will no doubt suggest I require a deposit or payment up front..... tried that ...... "I don't get paid till next week".... "I have an unexpected bill...." "I am poor"..... all valid and understandable..... and in order to be community spirited I just smile and nod and cross my fingers....

While I will happily chase trends, keep an eye on the market and accommodate my clientele's desires as far as I can, the points I raised in my previous post are not sheer defeatism but based on as careful analysis of the market as I can muster as a sole trader also occupied with the mundane tasks that go with running a bricks and mortar shop.

No doubt, as evidenced by posts here, there are badly run small businesses, but those that truly are doing their damnedest and still struggling, are at the whim of those fabled market forces, and even global geopolitics..... supply chains, shortages, stuff like that.

The insistence that enough positive energy chanelled into new innovation will always trump outside influence smacks somewhat of the MLM model...... and law of attraction thinking..... believe me, I try to remain upbeat and positive, and I know there is a market for my niche.

But for the small business with tight cash flow, a bad week can make all the difference in terms of re-stocking etc.

I'm sure the next suggestion might be "If it's all so dreadful why don't you pack it in and get a job? After all, you're privileged to run a business and have that independence".

To which I will reply that after 7 years survival, despite everything I wrote in my first post on this thread, everything I have is tied up in and dependent on this business - my entire survival and identity is this business (because I'm supposed to be passionate about it, and I am). I am 54 years old, so far out of the traditional employment loop that I am probably extremely limited in employment prospects.

I am well aware I can't have it all ways, and life isn't always fair, and I work with that.

Another poster mentioned that small business has costs that means that profit, pure disposable profit is rare..... overheads, stock and personal living costs are paid before all else, and helps keep the economy turning, just the same as any form of commerce.

Do we think Tescos are operating from a position of privilege? Well, when they started out, as a PP pointed out, the landscape was very different..... since then more and more rules, fees and taxes have been brought in that have to be adhered to and paid just to operate in order to try and make a living without recourse to state support or dependency.

Ultimately the exchange of currency is a tool that is supposed to help society function. We pay to play the game of life, but we're so fixated on winning or losing we fail to see that what society as a whole needs is more equality of opportunity and less squeezing if the pips by the big cheeses who already have everything they need and more.

So there, got that off my chest.

TLDR : It's complicated. It's ALL complicated.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 24/02/2023 11:46

@LuluBlakey1 I love a local community cafe near us, but it is staffed with volunteers all except the manager, so obviously the staff costs are very low, and the building rent probably negligible. I think it's a great resource, but it's pretty obvious why that's going to be cheaper than a local cafe 100 metres away.

hettiethehare · 24/02/2023 11:43

@taxguru I think you missed my point (or maybe I didn't make it that well) which was that why were Tesco being so insistent on portion control to match the beans with other items, when there are plenty of people who would not want something like beans, so they would have spare bean portions.

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 11:25

This week I took her to our local community ed centre which has a great cafe. We had a fish finger sandwich each with salad and coleslaw (homemade) and Halloumi fries and tea for two. Cost £16.40 for both of us and well worth it.
The prices seem very random.

@LuluBlakey1 it doesn't seem random to me. It suggests that the great cafe in local community ed centre has lower rent and perhaps is subsidised and can therefore run at break-even or a loss which of course the independent cafe cannot do.

You can buy a second hand book much cheaper at a charity shop than a second hand bookshop. I doubt there are second hand bookshops anymore unless they are really niche.

There used to be but they couldn't compete with charity shops who pay a peppercorn rent and pay nothing for their stock and staff costs. Big charities set up shops that are exclusively for books.

It's not the customer's fault and it is of course it's your choice to take your aunt wherever you want. But it should be recognised that Amazon or Oxfam or the local community ed centre funded by local government or charitable grants may be driving independent retailers out of business because of their special advantages.

taxguru · 24/02/2023 11:18

hettiethehare · 24/02/2023 11:11

@taxguru that is so odd as I would always ask for a full breakfast without beans as I don't like them and the sauce tends to contaminate everything else on the plate - I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person who does this either!

Removing an item is very different from asking for something different or adding an item. Removing an item costs them nothing (assuming the price for the full breakfast stays the same).

hettiethehare · 24/02/2023 11:11

@taxguru that is so odd as I would always ask for a full breakfast without beans as I don't like them and the sauce tends to contaminate everything else on the plate - I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person who does this either!

taxguru · 24/02/2023 11:05

OutofEverything · 24/02/2023 10:48

Are you sure the breakfast wasn't a frozen one that was microwaved? Usually the case when places will not swap items.

Or partially pre-cooked and just re-heated when ordered? Or already cooked and being kept warm on a hot-counter or in bain-maries etc? After all, lots of entitled customers seem to expect their cooked food to appear immediately after ordering and complain when it takes 5 or 10 minutes to be served. They seem to forget cooking time, so lots of cafes and takeaways have food "ready to go". They could well have cooked the exact right amount of "matching" ingredients, i.e. 10 slices of fried bread with 20 rashers of bacon, 20 sausages, 10 fried eggs, etc? By that kind of efficiency, they can sell the breakfast at a cheaper price. When you ask for something different, that removes the efficiency, so it's right that there's a charge for the extra time/potentially wasted ingredient that isn't wanted, etc. A charge of a pound for something different from the norm is hardly excessive!

I once went into a Tesco cafe when DS was young and a fussy eater. The only thing he wanted was a portion of baked beans, which were under the heat lamps in a bain marie. We asked for a portion, but the counter assistant refused and said that they could only be served as part of a full breakfast as they'd been portion controlled to match the number of bacon, sausages, eggs, hash browns, etc, so we ended up buying him a full breakfast! (And we ate the other items!).

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 11:04

@ancientgran people make strange decisions all the time like @Isawyou deciding that because a local greengrocer doesn't operate in the hours that suit her and also moans about people he will go out of business. He might or he might not but as long as she can get her carrots elsewhere it's only a problem for him. You and your husband have made the decision to go to a cafe that operates a more flexible bread policy. I think that is wise.

Bubblebubblebah · 24/02/2023 10:54

ancientgran · 24/02/2023 10:51

No it wasn't frozen, you could see into the kitchen area and as I placed my order she was getting sausages out and only stopped when the issue of fried bread came up.

I wonder if they had absolutely no swap policy (even though the bread is ridiculous) because people kept swapping bits?
We had that a lot. "Can I have x instead of y and z instead of a and..." We just made it "here are items, pick what you want" at the end. Some places go the other way with no substitutions at all.

Someone once ordered full english but without sausage and bacon and mushrooms and tomato.... They wanted egg on toast with beans... Which was even an option on a menu!!!😳

ancientgran · 24/02/2023 10:54

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 10:49

How did that work for the cafe where they wouldn't swap a slice of plain bread for the unwanted slice of fried bread?

@ancientgran that's a reason not to go in that particular cafe not a reason not to go in any cafe anywhere ever.

Another place might offer good service and is therefore worth visiting again and again. For instance, a couple of nights ago my friend and I dined at a restaurant offering a free cocktail if you ordered a main course from the a la carte menu.

It was made with grapefruit juice so she declined because she takes statins and they do not mix. The waitress asked if she would like a glass of prosecco either straight or with some peach juice. My friend said yes to both. Incidentally I'm on statins too but forgot you're not supposed to have grapefruit juice. I thought about asking for a prosecco Bellini but decided to chance it because I like both grapefruit juice and living dangerously.

PS she had boeuf bourguignon and I had roast pork belly, both of which we could have cooked at home alone cheaper. But it was just what was needed on a cold night out with a friend in a nice restaurant and very reasonably priced. We didn't even have to do the washing up afterwards.

My point was that I wouldn't use the cafe again, I'm sure they won't understand why they aren't doing well compared to other cafes and we have lots, seaside town and getting a breakfast isn't a problem. They will be another small business failing unless they actually stop and think about customer service.

ancientgran · 24/02/2023 10:51

OutofEverything · 24/02/2023 10:48

Are you sure the breakfast wasn't a frozen one that was microwaved? Usually the case when places will not swap items.

No it wasn't frozen, you could see into the kitchen area and as I placed my order she was getting sausages out and only stopped when the issue of fried bread came up.

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 10:49

How did that work for the cafe where they wouldn't swap a slice of plain bread for the unwanted slice of fried bread?

@ancientgran that's a reason not to go in that particular cafe not a reason not to go in any cafe anywhere ever.

Another place might offer good service and is therefore worth visiting again and again. For instance, a couple of nights ago my friend and I dined at a restaurant offering a free cocktail if you ordered a main course from the a la carte menu.

It was made with grapefruit juice so she declined because she takes statins and they do not mix. The waitress asked if she would like a glass of prosecco either straight or with some peach juice. My friend said yes to both. Incidentally I'm on statins too but forgot you're not supposed to have grapefruit juice. I thought about asking for a prosecco Bellini but decided to chance it because I like both grapefruit juice and living dangerously.

PS she had boeuf bourguignon and I had roast pork belly, both of which we could have cooked at home alone cheaper. But it was just what was needed on a cold night out with a friend in a nice restaurant and very reasonably priced. We didn't even have to do the washing up afterwards.

OutofEverything · 24/02/2023 10:48

Are you sure the breakfast wasn't a frozen one that was microwaved? Usually the case when places will not swap items.

ancientgran · 24/02/2023 10:26

Talia99 · 22/02/2023 17:22

The Thai massage suggestion makes sense - they’ve already paid for the event and staff so any money is better than none.

The suggestion about cutting prices for food doesn’t necessarily. The food has to be bought at a certain price, the electricity for cooking it had to be paid for etc. For some cafes, ‘dropping a quid off the lunch’ when their profit on each lunch is 50p means they are literally paying for the customer to eat it. It’s better to not make any money than it is to actively lose money. With current price hikes, some cafes have their sale prices cut to the bone anyway and that’s without the death spiral mentioned previously where the cafe down the road drops their price £1.10 and the first cafe has to consider matching it.

It’s something Alex Polizzi from the Hotel Inspector bangs on about constantly on the programme when she looks at the subset of hoteliers who are busy but not making any money because they have no idea how much things actually cost.

How did that work for the cafe where they wouldn't swap a slice of plain bread for the unwanted slice of fried bread? It can't cost them more to not fry the bread can it. What happened was instead of selling two breakfasts plus drinks for about £14 we left. The place was empty, I don't mean it wasn't busy I mean that apart from two members of staff we were the only people in there. We weren't asking for a discount but they wanted £1 for the plain bread and to not serve the fried bread.

This was a new business, we often go for a walk (if husband is well) or to sit on the seafront and enjoy the view and then go for something to eat. They have lost the chance of ongoing business because we won't go there again.

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 10:26

Surely it would be the same to you as the pet shop is to me (a non-pet-owner) - somewhere irrelevant that you have no need for and thus simply ignore the existence of.

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll interesting. I am no longer a pet owner but still find pet shops relevant, though increasingly rare. Instead of buying kittens or cat litter I treat them as small zoos with no entry price. As with many aspects of retail, you don't get the same experience online. I feel people are missing this important point and pet shops aside, i suspect we might agree.

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 10:17

Teatime55 · 24/02/2023 09:28

I think that’s a lot for something that wasn’t any good, wasn’t in a nice place, wasn’t even filling.

As I said @Teatime55 I think you should eat at home

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 10:15

We are lucky to have some virtuous among us who don’t care about this so called ‘instant gratification’. Presumably those virtuous ones seek out poor service from badly run small businesses.

@sst1234 buy the things you need and want however you want to do it. No one is saying any different. I buy nearly everything from bricks and mortar stores because it suits me but I don't buy from places where I get poor service. Neither do I class doing my shopping as a humanitarian act but ,maybe you buy different things to me.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/02/2023 10:07

I think that’s a lot for something that wasn’t any good, wasn’t in a nice place, wasn’t even filling.

The vast majority of what you pay doesn't pay for the actual cost of the food and drink. That doesn't mean that they shouldn't work to provide better quality/cooked/prepared/served food and drink - that's what cafes and restaurants live or die by - but was it warm in there? Was the chair comfy? Toilets convenient and clean? Any issues with the provision of the plates, cups/glasses, cutlery? None of those are free, far from it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/02/2023 10:01

A posh tea shop in York that went viral over this. A customer whinging she was charged the price of a cup of tea when she ‘just wanted a cup of hot water’ (plus lemon) and the cafe owner explaining why for a cup of tea, the tea bag and milk were the least of the costs.

Some people are just either entitled and/or stupid. If it's always it's a no-brainer to you to make food and drink at home (or take it out with you), why would you even bother to frequent cafes at all? Surely it would be the same to you as the pet shop is to me (a non-pet-owner) - somewhere irrelevant that you have no need for and thus simply ignore the existence of.

If you are acknowledging the added value that the business can provide, why would you not expect to pay something for it?

It's also interesting how people choose to frame things to justify their own advantage. That awful woman in York was assigning no value at all to the cup (to provide and then wash), the hot water, the staffing, the chair and place at a table, the lighting, the electricity, the heating, the business rates, the lost business from an actual paying customer sitting there etc. etc. She seemed to think that all these significant costs were magically free, but had she wanted a teabag and a splash of milk in her hot drink, that would be the sole costs to the business. Then, if that's her thinking, presumably she sees the price the cafe is charging for a hot drink, compares it with the price of a teabag from a pack of 500, and will mistakenly conclude that they're absolute rip-off cowboys making a solid mint.

It's also baffling how many people seem to think that shops get their stock free and so 100% of the price they get from selling it is profit, and so they can also take as much of it as they want for themselves/friends/entitled CFs completely free of charge. It's like an 'adult' equivalent of expecting to get everything you could possibly want for Christmas, because Santa makes/pays for it all, so cost is utterly irrelevant.

I know it happens a lot, but I still find it hard to understand the nerve of people who will quite cheerfully tell the shop owner that they are looking for details/info/photos about the item they're selling, so that they can order it cheaper online instead. Not even trying to be subtle about it.

Teatime55 · 24/02/2023 09:28

limitedperiodonly · 23/02/2023 20:35

A sandwich and a drink to eat in for under £10? I think you should eat at home.

I think that’s a lot for something that wasn’t any good, wasn’t in a nice place, wasn’t even filling.

WishingMyLifeAway · 24/02/2023 03:01

@RuthW My GP does some late nights and Saturday mornings so it's obviously not impossible.

sst1234 · 24/02/2023 01:22

Badbadbunny · 23/02/2023 14:39

It was a different era and different business landscape back then. For a start there were no huge chains of discounted grocery stores! If someone tried to do the same thing today, they'd not last long!

Same with Alan Sugar who made a killing selling "cheap" hi-fi units, CD radios and personal computers with the "pile it high, sell cheap" philosophy. All that happened is that other manufacturers jumped on the bandwagon, manufactured their own "cheap" copycat versions with their brand name on and pushed him out of the market!

Kwik Save supermarket chain also did the "pile it high, sell it cheap" on branded groceries, i.e. Heinz, Kelloggs, etc., but the likes of Tesco, Asda, etc., just started selling the same items cheaper, pushing Kwik Save out of business.

It's just a race to the bottom now and the pile it high, sell it cheap philosophy just doesn't work anymore.

How awful that customers have benefited from this over the last 50 years, eh? High quality Food and general variety consumer goods had never been so affordable to all - until Covid largesse happened.

LuluBlakey1 · 24/02/2023 01:22

I take my aunt out for a coffee once a week. What used to cost about £5 each - basic toastie and a latte- at a local cafe she likes, now costs £8.50 each.

At the smart patisserie, a cake and a latte is now approx £12.50 each- used to be £16 for both of us and now £25.

We can go to the local cafe- not worth the price though £17 for two very basic toasties (literally two bits of white bread and a bit if average cheese) and a drink. The smart patisserie (which isn't great but she likes it) is out of the question. It's very quiet these days.

This week I took her to our local community ed centre which has a great cafe. We had a fish finger sandwich each with salad and coleslaw (homemade) and Halloumi fries and tea for two. Cost £16.40 for both of us and well worth it.
The prices seem very random.

sst1234 · 24/02/2023 01:17

MistressoftheDarkSide · 19/02/2023 12:09

I think a PP just summed it all up very succinctly - consumers just don't care how they acquire their consumables as long as they get them cheap, quick smart and completely at their own convenience.

If small businesses go under it's not their problem - they can just go elsewhere.

My seas-side town has been hollowed out due to out of town retail parks, there are no department stores. It's all coffee shops, chains, pubs and entertainment. There's a big cinema complex with lots of eateries inside - all corporate. Rates are extortionate so there are huge amounts of empty shops and the place is considered a no go zone for residents. Tourists are disappointed by the lack of vibrancy and diversity.

My shop is in another part of the town on a High Street so people do find their way to the small independent retail outlets in my area but as mentioned in my last whine, there are continuing problems with out of area roadworks that cause drivers to be diverted around the place and which of course is frustrating.

So if traditional shopping is going down the pan and everything goes online, towns are just going to have to rely on entertainment and in person services to survive, and give any sense of vibrancy. Those markets are already at saturation point.

There is also a drive to reduce consumerism for environmental reasons, yet the economy relies on the trading of widgets and services. When any industry collapses, the unemployed as a result don't have the money to support other business bar the essentials. It's a zero sum game.

Technological advances change so quickly that it's hard to keep up.

There's only so much innovation small businesses can incorporate on dwindling capital.

Let's face it - we're heading for a world where the majority do everything online and only venture out for fun occasionally - economically things are going to implode before long, and as for the long term psychological damage being done by it all, well, plenty of evidence of that all around us.

Bottom line, very few people actually care about anything except their own immediate gratification.

How selfish of people to want stuff to be affordable and readily available. And how evil of successful (often large) businesses to provide it.

We are lucky to have some virtuous among us who don’t care about this so called ‘instant gratification’. Presumably those virtuous ones seek out poor service from badly run small businesses.

Bubblebubblebah · 23/02/2023 21:18

Talia99 · 23/02/2023 18:13

A posh tea shop in York that went viral over this. A customer whinging she was charged the price of a cup of tea when she ‘just wanted a cup of hot water’ (plus lemon) and the cafe owner explaining why for a cup of tea, the tea bag and milk were the least of the costs.

www.finedininglovers.com/article/restaurant-owners-fun-response-reviewer-who-complained-about-price-hot-water

We had prople coming in asking for hot water than putting their won tea in. Fine, yeah you like your tea, but 90% got pissy about us charging the hot water. Like am I heating it up and then washing cups for free with my mind or what?

Good on these!