Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
HelicopterHeights · 19/02/2023 05:59

I don't get all this "shop local" stuff. I am not a charity, I am not going to pay more or get worse service just so some local person can make a profit. No one in my town is concerned about my livelihood so why am I meant to pretend I care about their's? Seems so weird to me. If they want my custom they need to run a better business. Simple as that really.

knitnerd90 · 19/02/2023 05:56

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 04:43

@knitnerd90 "A yarn shop owner will decide she never wants to be open past 5pm because she doesn't want to work evenings... even though if she opened late one night, she could host a knit night and improve her takings as well as build customer loyalty."

I think you'll find that niche hobby/craft shops open with reduced hours because they don't have the footfall after 5.00.pm when customers are getting ready for their evening meal.
Few would want to close at 4.00.pm and then re-open at 7.00p for a "knit & natter" night especially if they don't live on the premises.

that absolutely can be true, but I'm talking specific cases where I know they would have gotten a crowd, and there was demand, and they didn't want to. And I agree that the footfall rarely justifies regular late opening, but many successful craft shops have one late evening, especially in larger towns or cities. That's just one example. And what's more, the owners who run their stores this way wind up having to close. I've personally seen shops close because the owner ran it like a hobby instead of a business. Running your business as a hobby isn't just about things like unfriendly hours; it's about how you treat your customers. I've been a knitter for over 20 years and have been to a lot of shops. It really is a niche that's known for dreamy hobbyists.

(opposite case: My friend's grandmother ran a craft-related shop for decades. She began closing early as she got older (she didn't retire until well into her 80s), and till the day she closed, her shop was cash-only. Newcomers might be baffled, but longtime customers didn't mind.)

Tinseltangle · 19/02/2023 05:41

I run a deli and after 1.30pm its tumbleweed, maybe 2 customers until we close at 4pm. We tried opening until 6.30, still dead. We are now considering opening 7 x 3 everyday as it works better for baking. If anyone has any suggestions how to improve afternoon/evening footfall im all ears.

Username24680 · 19/02/2023 05:34

As a manager in a small local independent (clothing store in my case) - regardless of what you do, there’s always going to be someone unhappy with it 😬😅

We open Mon-Sat 10-5 in winter, 9-5.30 in summer and Sunday 12-4 in winter and 11-5 in summer.
Every week I’ll have someone moan at me because we open too late (we don’t, we usually serve our first customer around 11am!) or about how ridiculous it is that we don’t do late night shopping (it’s not ridiculous - we rarely see a customer during the last 30-45 mins of trading). For us to open the shop earlier and stay open later just on the off chance that one of these people decided to shop would just not make financial sense to the business at all!
As it goes, the ones we get moaning about the times are usually the same ones to ask for a discount every time they come into the shop too.

daisychain01 · 19/02/2023 05:32

Exactly that @Caspianberg and there isn't a big margin in fruit and veg either! Personally I'd give my business to them any day over the bloody supermarkets. Loose produce is fab and none of that shrinkflation- you know what you're getting and it's always lovely and fresh.

Caspianberg · 19/02/2023 05:24

Most fruit and veg places I know are up in London at midnight getting produce from the markets. Then drive a couple of hours back, sleep 2 hrs, unload everything ready to sell. No wonder they close at 4pm

daisychain01 · 19/02/2023 05:15

I doubt the fruit and veg shop will close down, they are always very busy. Have they actually told you they aren't doing well, OP? What time do they open up? I expect they have to be down at the wholesaler at the crack of dawn to collect all the produce so open earlier. By 4.30pm they're probably done for the day. Personally I value those local businesses, because I like my fruit and veg loose rather than packed in all that single use plastic that the supermarkets need to get rid of.

WandaWonder · 19/02/2023 05:14

They have to pay costs so would need to make up those costs for it to make it worth their while to open differently or even just want to have a life themselves? They can't exactly work from home and have flexibility life some employees can have

I can't imagine them thinking 'wow we will be better off if we stay open longer never thought of that'

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 05:07

teezletangler · 19/02/2023 04:52

I'm amazed at all these cash-only businesses. How do they justify it when everything moved to card in the pandemic? Where I live even veg- and preserve-sellers with roadside stalls accept cards. Anyone can get one of those little readers now that hooks up to your phone so there's really no excuse.

Do you know the supplier takes at least 1.7% on every transaction? That is without rental of the unit.
That is a cost to the business that has to be factored in to the pricing structure.

In addition they don't work properly in areas where internet access is poor.

Oopswediditagain2023 · 19/02/2023 05:06

Yes! It really winds me up in my town. As a business owner myself, I'm always trying to adapt etc, and I find some just look at things so dogmatically and then blame others when their business model doesn't work.

Lostacorn · 19/02/2023 04:58

A few local shops near me still close for lunch. Then they complain they loose business to larger stores. One is across the road from my work, they close for an hour. I would go in regularly on my lunch break if they were open.

My local post office opens at 10am and closes at 12.30 and closed at the weekend.

teezletangler · 19/02/2023 04:52

I'm amazed at all these cash-only businesses. How do they justify it when everything moved to card in the pandemic? Where I live even veg- and preserve-sellers with roadside stalls accept cards. Anyone can get one of those little readers now that hooks up to your phone so there's really no excuse.

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 04:43

@knitnerd90 "A yarn shop owner will decide she never wants to be open past 5pm because she doesn't want to work evenings... even though if she opened late one night, she could host a knit night and improve her takings as well as build customer loyalty."

I think you'll find that niche hobby/craft shops open with reduced hours because they don't have the footfall after 5.00.pm when customers are getting ready for their evening meal.
Few would want to close at 4.00.pm and then re-open at 7.00p for a "knit & natter" night especially if they don't live on the premises.

knitnerd90 · 19/02/2023 04:30

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 19/02/2023 00:11

We have a wool shop, but you aren’t allowed to browse the wool or touch it. You must stand one at a time at the counter and ask for the wool you want - you aren’t allowed to touch it, must be paid for first… but you can ask you wipeable items to be brought up on the counter to touch such as knitting needles. only open 10-2 on days only the owner knows. Due to covid.

Never seen anyone shop there!

Yarn shops are notorious and not just in the UK - people run them almost as a hobby because they love to knit/crochet themselves. Many can't justify long opening hours, given their turnover, but in all my years of knitting and living in multiple places, I have met some really difficult owners. I've been to some pretty eccentric bookshops, but on the whole, bookshop owners seem to understand they are running a business. A yarn shop owner will decide she never wants to be open past 5pm because she doesn't want to work evenings... even though if she opened late one night, she could host a knit night and improve her takings as well as build customer loyalty.

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 04:26

Sleeptightnightlight · 19/02/2023 00:25

People wouldn't need haranguing into 'shopping local' if shopping local wasn't generally worse (more expensive, less convenient) than the alternatives.

Reading comments like this tells me that most people haven't got a clue in Hell of what is involved with running a small local business - especially one that deals with perishables.

Of course it will be more expensive - they don't have the ability to "pile 'em high, sell 'em cheap like Aldi & Lidl as they don't have the turnover to fund that.

Most butchers have to be at the abattoir at 4am at the latest to collect meat (slaughtering usually starts at 1-2. am ) which then has to be butchered before it can be displayed when they open at 8.00.am. That's why many local ones probably shut at 4.00.pm

Fishmongers need to be at the docks at 6.00.am when the auctions for fish landings take place. So they will work similar hours that includes very early travel time.

There is very little profit margin on fruit & veg, which is why most of these shops combine it with floristry.

I'm not sure what is meant by "less convenient". If you buy lamb chops from your local butcher you'll know the animal will have been slaughtered that day and will be fresh.
If you buy from a supermarket the meat will have been refrigerated (or even frozen) for goodness knows how long.

At the end of the day it's customer choice.

Sashimiandhisthunderpaws · 19/02/2023 04:00

@Florenz really!

Tesco was founded over 100 years ago in a very different retail landscape. Realistically small independent retailers can't compete with Tesco. Economies of scale, the power to dictate the terms with their smaller scale suppliers like farmers, i.e. 3 months credit, purchase price of milk, its easy enough for them to employ staff 24/7 that are easily replaceable. They'll have an estates department/outsource to a real estate specialist that will manage all aspects of there sites, getting favourable terms on there leases etc. That's just the start.

CjCreggs · 19/02/2023 03:54

I agree with all this. It's really sad tbh. I live in a cheshire village near the national trust property where pride and prejudice was filmed (Colin fifth in the lake) it's a beautiful village. We get a lot of tourists which is perfect frankly.

Before lockdown we had a cafe open and honestly it was ridiculous, because we have this preconceived idea that people who live here are either very rich or extremely posh which is a joke because it's literally a village near Stockport! They moved in and the prices were frankly offensive let's say £12.95 for a plain jacket potato! They were also only open for 3 hours a day.. The communities response was 'Ha fuck that!' And they went out of business so fast'.

There are 2 places that do very well in the village for lunches and that's because they focus on 2 different things. 1 does all manner of sandwiches and salad boxes but you know they pre cook the bacon and they're quick so if you ask for a bacon, sausage Sandwich you're gonna get one in about 2 mins because it was all cooked before they opened and the micro wave just heats it all up. They're really expensive but builders love them because they can pre order and it's always rammed

The second place is entirely self made, a bit more expensive, but they make all the cakes themselves, the sandwiches etc are made
To order, lovely staff etc, it's more ££ but you get what you pay for and actually they moved with the times because they used to be cash only but then lock down happened and people were anxious about using cash/ the co op closed their cash machine and the post office was really funny about cash as well. I was surprised they did it Because they were very much into the cash only business and then suddenly they accepted card and now they make so much more than the other shop because the other one is worse but they always historically accepted card so if the atm in the village was down you couldn't go to the second place whereas you can now :)

brightare · 19/02/2023 03:52

Goatinthegarden · 19/02/2023 03:27

My issue with local businesses, rightly or wrongly, is that I can get the same product cheaper online. I saw a book I wanted on Amazon recently, decided to go out and buy it in a local bookstore. It was £6.99 on Amazon and £22 in the bookstore, so unfortunately I went home and bought it online. I will occasionally spend a few more £ to support a local business, but I couldn’t justify that difference.

I recently wanted a certain pair of trail running shoes, not one running store in my large city stocked them. I got them online, next day delivery. I do want to shop local, but there is just so much more choice, competitive pricing and availability online. Even large high street stores often don’t have the same choice in store that they have online.

Exactly. I would always prefer to support local but just can't afford to anymore.

YDBear · 19/02/2023 03:41

Went into a tea shop for an afternoon tea the other day at 3:50pm. “Sorry, “I was told, “we close at 4.” “Seriously?” said I. “A tea shop that closed at 4? Next you’ll be telling me you’re open for breakfasts, but only after 11.”

Goatinthegarden · 19/02/2023 03:27

My issue with local businesses, rightly or wrongly, is that I can get the same product cheaper online. I saw a book I wanted on Amazon recently, decided to go out and buy it in a local bookstore. It was £6.99 on Amazon and £22 in the bookstore, so unfortunately I went home and bought it online. I will occasionally spend a few more £ to support a local business, but I couldn’t justify that difference.

I recently wanted a certain pair of trail running shoes, not one running store in my large city stocked them. I got them online, next day delivery. I do want to shop local, but there is just so much more choice, competitive pricing and availability online. Even large high street stores often don’t have the same choice in store that they have online.

LoisLane66 · 19/02/2023 03:12

Many independent greengrocers shut early as they have to get up at 04.00 to get goods from the markets and back to their premises, unload and get the shelves filled.

ShippingNews · 19/02/2023 03:09

My SIL has a "pie and sandwich" van which she drives around the local industrial areas every day from 10am until 2pm. All the factory and industrial workers pour out of their workplaces to buy her food. Win-win !

LoisLane66 · 19/02/2023 03:06

An independent hair salon in my town only takes cash and their price for a cut and blow dry on my short hair (mid ear level) was £60. I was shocked as even Toni & Guy only charge £55 and have much more up to date premises and look more professional and not dressed in sloppy clothes. I was shocked at the price as they don't have prices or a 'menu' advertised on their small website.

ohlalalalalalalalala · 19/02/2023 02:38

@boilingstormyseas out of interest does the pizza van seem to do well?

BaroldFromEastenders · 19/02/2023 02:32

There’s a DIY shop in my small town who are open all week but always closed on a Sunday. Most people are doing their DIY on a weekend and this shop has the monopoly in this area - the nearest big DIY store is 40 minutes away. Absolutely missing a trick not being open - just close on another day during the week!