Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
magnifying · 19/02/2023 08:57

We have a family-run farm shop near here but they're only open 10-3pm on Mon-Fri. That might be so that they can fit around school hours (no idea!) but on the rare occasion I've got a day off and have popped in, there's a max of 2 or 3 people in the shop. They recently had to shut down their little cafe as no one was going.

I wanted to suggest they did a trial run of opening say 3-7pm plus Saturday mornings. If it worked, they might actually be able to employ part time staff. As it stands, I'm not sure this business will be viable for much longer. 😬

QuertyGirl · 19/02/2023 08:55

I don't understand why any businesses would be cash only. I never carry cash

Bippetyboppityboob · 19/02/2023 08:55

Kazzyhoward · 19/02/2023 08:53

As has been mentioned by a few posters, the owner/staff may also have to drop their kids off at school, so can't be in two places at once. It's ridiculously hard to find part time staff who are able/willing to work at school drop off/pick up times as most are wanting 10-2 type part time work so they can do the school runs!

But when in many places this would be one of the busiest parts of the day it surely becomes a bit of an issue?

midgemadgemodge · 19/02/2023 08:54

Most people don't do a school drop off each day 😀

What percentage of the adult population work full time 9 to 5 jobs ?

The retired don't work
A lot work shifts like nursing
A lot work part time
A lot work irregular hours like in retail

Bippetyboppityboob · 19/02/2023 08:53

MistressoftheDarkSide · 19/02/2023 08:46

Well this thread is very informative....

I'm a small business owner. My shop has been going since 2016. We opened it when my MIL came to live with us due to dementia so that I could care for her on-site until she was too far gone and went into a care home, because we couldn't afford to be a single income family.

My shop is niche - serves the "alternative" community and is gift / lifestyle oriented.

I have tried every combination of opening hours to suit our customers, and apparently it's never right.

We survived Covid just about, thanks to a council grant, and we moved to cheaper, smaller premises about 18 months ago.

During the years I've been running, I nursed my DM in her last month of life through the cancer she was diagnosed with two weeks after my MIL went into the care home. That was in early first lockdown which of course was a weird blessing in disguise.

One month after our re-opening at the new premises my DP died suddenly after a three week illness - undiagnosed cancer.

In the immediate aftermath my DIL kept the business on life support and did a grand job until I could get my shit together, but it was voluntary as things went a bit hand to mouth without DPs salary.

I now open 6 days a week, 11-6.

I only need to take £200 a day to be comfortable and up until the end of last year was doing ok. Thanks to the cost of living crisis, continuing roadworks on the route into my area, etc etc this has dropped off and some days I'mlucky if I take 50.00. It's my only source of income. There was no life insurance or anything else because my DPs passing was utterly unpredictable.

The customers I do have are great, and love the shop, but they don't need a new crystal every day, so I spend a lot of time whoring myself out on Facebook trying to encourage new customers.

Online is something I need to sort out, but I am one person and there is admin, laundry and sleeping is helpful.

I take cash and card, and will do postal sales generated by Facebook interest.

I try to be upbeat and humorous but I'm still grieving, and our new shop is a huge reminder every day of my DP and our time putting it together.

I can't afford to pay staff. Friends have volunteered to work for free but that involves admin and insurance implications.

I just want to make a living doing something I love without being beholden to the state. I don't want to be a millionaire or build a corporation.

I have had customers complain I am more expensive than a charity shop, well I'm not a charity shop and the pre-loves niche clothing I supply isn't charity shop fodder. I have had people photograph items in my shop to find them cheaper on line and cheerfully tell me they're doing it.

I wouldn't mind if I was over priced, but my price range is 1.00 upwards. And I charge RRP from my wholesalers.

You see, small independent businesses are run by human beings who want to be part of the community sometimes. And as humans, they have lives that are messy and incompatible with the business sometimes.

My DP died at the end of January - his funeral was in March. I had three months to sort everything out and was back in the saddle in April.

I'm putting this out there just as an example of why your local independent business might not be operating to corporate standards.

Oh, and why don't I apply for Universal Credit? That's because yet another level of bureaucracy would see me in a padded cell most likely.

I don't want pity, or charity - I just want to be self-sufficient.

Sorry for your losses, can absolutely see how it is ridiculously stressful for small business owners. Your shop sounds amazing and shops such as that which are fuelled by a passion for the products and offer something you're unlikely to find elsewhere (despite rude customers claiming otherwise) I'd happily pay more for and be flexible around opening hours. You offer something unique. If it's a shop though that sells the same as anywhere else then I personally wouldn't bother to work around their ridiculous opening hours or pay double for the same product.

It does sound like your products would do really well online, could some who have volunteered to help do some of that admin and avoid the insurance issue of them being in the shop?

Kazzyhoward · 19/02/2023 08:53

hettiethehare · 19/02/2023 08:47

The not opening until 10am thing mystifies me - between 9 and 10 is when I am most likely to want to go to the shops! It’s post school drop off so now I will be walking home, but when I was in the playgroup days I always wanted something to do between school drop off and either preschool or playgroup starting and ended up wandering round B&Q for want of any better options.

As has been mentioned by a few posters, the owner/staff may also have to drop their kids off at school, so can't be in two places at once. It's ridiculously hard to find part time staff who are able/willing to work at school drop off/pick up times as most are wanting 10-2 type part time work so they can do the school runs!

Kazzyhoward · 19/02/2023 08:51

@FfaCoffi

A lovely fish and chip shop not too far from us is going cash only. There's no cash machine near them. Seems to be an act of self harm to me!

Likely to be them trying to avoid the VAT registration threshold which hasn't increased for years, meaning ever increasing numbers of small businesses are having to register for VAT at a cost of thousands, especially with inflation, resulting in the turnover/sales of some businesses are rising due to higher prices (breaching VAT threshold), but profits are less even before losing thousands in VAT. Siphoning off some cash sales and not declaring them can be the difference between survival and failure!

Some small businesses deliberately open fewer hours to avoid VAT registration if they don't want to go down the "cash" tax evasion route. That's especially the case for small cafes, corner shops, etc., where they'd lose a huge percentage of their profits if they have to register for VAT! One of my clients is a guest house who deliberately "underbook" their rooms as they trade literally just under the VAT threshold. If they breach it by even a few pounds, it will cost them over £10k to the VAT man - as the VAT threshold isn't increasing with inflation, they're having to reduce occupancy levels to stay under it!

hettiethehare · 19/02/2023 08:47

The not opening until 10am thing mystifies me - between 9 and 10 is when I am most likely to want to go to the shops! It’s post school drop off so now I will be walking home, but when I was in the playgroup days I always wanted something to do between school drop off and either preschool or playgroup starting and ended up wandering round B&Q for want of any better options.

DogInATent · 19/02/2023 08:46

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 04:26

Reading comments like this tells me that most people haven't got a clue in Hell of what is involved with running a small local business - especially one that deals with perishables.

Of course it will be more expensive - they don't have the ability to "pile 'em high, sell 'em cheap like Aldi & Lidl as they don't have the turnover to fund that.

Most butchers have to be at the abattoir at 4am at the latest to collect meat (slaughtering usually starts at 1-2. am ) which then has to be butchered before it can be displayed when they open at 8.00.am. That's why many local ones probably shut at 4.00.pm

Fishmongers need to be at the docks at 6.00.am when the auctions for fish landings take place. So they will work similar hours that includes very early travel time.

There is very little profit margin on fruit & veg, which is why most of these shops combine it with floristry.

I'm not sure what is meant by "less convenient". If you buy lamb chops from your local butcher you'll know the animal will have been slaughtered that day and will be fresh.
If you buy from a supermarket the meat will have been refrigerated (or even frozen) for goodness knows how long.

At the end of the day it's customer choice.

Speaking of comments that suggest people don't have a clue, anyone that suggests that meat is being butchered and sold the same day it's slaughtered, or that would suggest the fishmonger attends the fish auction themselves is trying to make a point that doesn't exist and that they don't understand.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 19/02/2023 08:46

Well this thread is very informative....

I'm a small business owner. My shop has been going since 2016. We opened it when my MIL came to live with us due to dementia so that I could care for her on-site until she was too far gone and went into a care home, because we couldn't afford to be a single income family.

My shop is niche - serves the "alternative" community and is gift / lifestyle oriented.

I have tried every combination of opening hours to suit our customers, and apparently it's never right.

We survived Covid just about, thanks to a council grant, and we moved to cheaper, smaller premises about 18 months ago.

During the years I've been running, I nursed my DM in her last month of life through the cancer she was diagnosed with two weeks after my MIL went into the care home. That was in early first lockdown which of course was a weird blessing in disguise.

One month after our re-opening at the new premises my DP died suddenly after a three week illness - undiagnosed cancer.

In the immediate aftermath my DIL kept the business on life support and did a grand job until I could get my shit together, but it was voluntary as things went a bit hand to mouth without DPs salary.

I now open 6 days a week, 11-6.

I only need to take £200 a day to be comfortable and up until the end of last year was doing ok. Thanks to the cost of living crisis, continuing roadworks on the route into my area, etc etc this has dropped off and some days I'mlucky if I take 50.00. It's my only source of income. There was no life insurance or anything else because my DPs passing was utterly unpredictable.

The customers I do have are great, and love the shop, but they don't need a new crystal every day, so I spend a lot of time whoring myself out on Facebook trying to encourage new customers.

Online is something I need to sort out, but I am one person and there is admin, laundry and sleeping is helpful.

I take cash and card, and will do postal sales generated by Facebook interest.

I try to be upbeat and humorous but I'm still grieving, and our new shop is a huge reminder every day of my DP and our time putting it together.

I can't afford to pay staff. Friends have volunteered to work for free but that involves admin and insurance implications.

I just want to make a living doing something I love without being beholden to the state. I don't want to be a millionaire or build a corporation.

I have had customers complain I am more expensive than a charity shop, well I'm not a charity shop and the pre-loves niche clothing I supply isn't charity shop fodder. I have had people photograph items in my shop to find them cheaper on line and cheerfully tell me they're doing it.

I wouldn't mind if I was over priced, but my price range is 1.00 upwards. And I charge RRP from my wholesalers.

You see, small independent businesses are run by human beings who want to be part of the community sometimes. And as humans, they have lives that are messy and incompatible with the business sometimes.

My DP died at the end of January - his funeral was in March. I had three months to sort everything out and was back in the saddle in April.

I'm putting this out there just as an example of why your local independent business might not be operating to corporate standards.

Oh, and why don't I apply for Universal Credit? That's because yet another level of bureaucracy would see me in a padded cell most likely.

I don't want pity, or charity - I just want to be self-sufficient.

Bippetyboppityboob · 19/02/2023 08:45

Tekkentime · 19/02/2023 08:40

Councils really do go out of their way to destroy businesses. They shouldn't have that level of power.

It depends who owns the land the car park is on though. Although councils invariably handle the charges they usually pay the owner and so the charges cover that (plus a bit left over depending how busy it is), it's not the case that they actually own most car parks. Here for example the owner has always been clear that they will make the land private if they don't recieve their 'rent'. During covid the council paid for this out of our council tax so parking was free at point of use but had already been paid for. Of course not wildly popular with people who don't drive who are paying for it but not much choice.

FfaCoffi · 19/02/2023 08:44

We have a lovely cafe near us, but it's often closed early afternoon, and not always at the same times.

I've given up trying to go there as I'm fed up with finding it closed.

A lovely fish and chip shop not too far from us is going cash only. There's no cash machine near them. Seems to be an act of self harm to me! Even our PTA has card machines these days.

ClimbingRoseBush · 19/02/2023 08:42

my town has a few really nice independent bakers. But when I get back from work (before 5, to collect from ASC) and need bread, the only place open is Greggs. So I go to Greggs.

Bubblebubblebah · 19/02/2023 08:42

Tekkentime · 19/02/2023 08:40

Councils really do go out of their way to destroy businesses. They shouldn't have that level of power.

Anything to cover the accounting blackholes from bad projects and ... Yes, fucking tunneling and downright open stealing and corruption

Tekkentime · 19/02/2023 08:40

Councils really do go out of their way to destroy businesses. They shouldn't have that level of power.

gettingolderandgrumpier · 19/02/2023 08:40

I find the shops that don’t have set opening hours seem to fail . There is a cafe near me not that long took over and in all honesty I’ve never seen it open , I never see it open at weekends when it’s right near a busy retail park . I get that if it’s quiet you shut but how are customers to know when you are open ? . Surprise surprise I believe it’s now permanently shutting .

Bippetyboppityboob · 19/02/2023 08:39

Susanw1985 · 19/02/2023 08:29

It’s so they can have a life. I work in a similar profession and chose it so I wouldn’t have to work nights or weekends. My husband works shifts so between us we can manage childcare.

Which is fine, but can't really moan when their businesses fail as they aren't open when the majority are not in work and can actually get to the shops, no?

Charminginjohnlewis · 19/02/2023 08:39

@GoChasingWaterfalls
“honestly don't get it. I'm convinced it's a money laundering operation hiding under the veneer of white straight legged trousers”
😂😂😂

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/02/2023 08:39

I have the same experience - there are local shops and cafés that look interesting but I have never set foot inside them because I never see them open. Cafés that don't open until 10am (and unpredictably not then), and seemingly close mid afternoon. Shops that only open for a few hours in the middle of the day, and not on the weekend.

I notice they are often "passion projects", where someone has dreamed of opening a book cafe or a "mothers' hub", and I don't think the owners are financially reliant on making a profit.

Greensleevevssnotnose · 19/02/2023 08:38

Mine is open every other Saturday

Goatinthegarden · 19/02/2023 08:37

thehorsehasnowbolted · 19/02/2023 07:39

After the pandemic, you will find that a lot of these types of items are cheaper on the high street (in the shops that survived, that is)

Many large on-line platforms took advantage of Covid and started to charge extortionate prices for almost everything. They are no longer what they used to be, now that they have a captive market

But I’m actively not finding this to be the case. I often look online at products/prices before I try real brick and mortar stores. Yesterday I want a cleaning product for my bike. I looked online and it was £7.99 from several online stores.

I like to support my local bike shop, so I cycled down to pick up the same product. It was £10. I bought it because I wanted it there and then and I want to keep them in business. But times are hard for everyone and it’s not that sustainable.

Bubblebubblebah · 19/02/2023 08:36

thesnailandthewhale · 19/02/2023 08:26

For me it's more to do with the local council - parking in my nearest town is £2 for an hour, constant roadworks mean traffic getting there is horrific - both these reasons mean if I just need one or two items I won't make the journey into town, nothing to do with opening hours of the businesses.

There was not so long ago an idea from one council that they will abolish free parking after 6 or 6:30 and move it to 11pm. Every idiot understood it would kill of the independent restaurant we all love in the city because the larking would be extortionate. Well everyone except the council! There was a consultation and I don't think it went well for them. The businesses saying it will kill them were not just simple mum and pop cafes, but everyone including michelin star place.
There is no park and ride as far as I know. Councils are not bloody helping

GoChasingWaterfalls · 19/02/2023 08:34

On the other hand, we have an independent clothes store that sells clothes that are ridiculously expensive in a small market town in the North West. It's not a massively deprived area, but it's not flooded with wealth either. Fairly average I would say.

They sell the kind of clothes that you might expect an aging female politician to wear. I.e., smart but not glamorous. Not "on trend".

The shop has survived two floods, Covid, and now the current economic crisis.

I honestly don't get it. I'm convinced it's a money laundering operation hiding under the veneer of white straight legged trousers.

HolibobsinApril · 19/02/2023 08:32

The cash only nonsense is annoying. Even the local PTA use an app on phone to pay £1 for ice creams on Sunny Fridays!

Saschka · 19/02/2023 08:32

deveronvalley · 19/02/2023 08:01

I live in a town with a dying town centre. A new little ‘occasions’ shop opened very recently, cards, balloons, small gifts and trinkets. They closed Thurs-Wednesday for the schools midterm break to go on holiday (I’m in Scotland) which included the 5 days leading up to Valentines Day 🤷‍♀️

I think some businesses are literal hobby businesses, and the owner has enough money from elsewhere that they don’t actually need to turn a profit. Others are a front for money laundering and not making a profit is the whole point.

We have a yarn shop locally which opens between 1-3 daily, but not every day. A cafe next to the station which opens at 9:30 (thereby missing the commuter and school mum rush, the owner literally told me he “didn’t want to get up that early”), shuts at 2pm, doesn’t serve food so not targeting the lunch trade, and is randomly closed whenever the owner has better things to do. The owner is a coffee obsessive and is just using the cafe as an excuse to be more involved in the coffee trade. There are pictures of his trips to various Guatemalan roasteries on the walls. May also be laundering money, but to be honest he seems too clueless for that, so I assume he has a trust fund or something.

And finally we have more than one beauty/hair salon with no posted opening times, website or phone number, which seems to consist of the owner and her friends sitting drinking Prosecco, who won’t take bookings or give you a price list if you walk in and inquire. Clearly not a genuine business.