Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 19/02/2023 11:13

borntobequiet · 19/02/2023 10:47

Extending GP opening hours trials a few years ago were unsuccessful.

www.theguardian.com/society/2015/sep/29/almost-half-seven-day-trial-gp-surgeries-cut-hours-after-lack-of-demand

I was surprised to be given an outpatient appointment (dermatology) at a local hospital on a Saturday afternoon a couple of months ago, very soon after a referral from the GP. It was great, I was seen quickly and efficiently and was very happy. But there were only two other patients while I was there. A nurse told me that it was always quiet, people turned down appointments if offered and they’d probably be dropping it. However weekday clinics are very busy with long waiting times.

I remember that trial - the results were mixed rather than unsuccessful and one of the determinants was the lack of publicity given to the scheme in the local area and within the appointments system. Seven years on with even more people forced into the gig economy even more people cant' afford to take time of work to see a doctor or when ill.

All that said, I suspect the model at the practice where I grew up would work as a mid point. They combined with a couple of other practices to offer evening clinics for a lot of routine stuff such as smears with one practice each week offering the late clinic. They also did late surgeries but not every day - just twice a week. On Saturdays there was a half day surgery for urgents. Sunday was call out only.

It doesn't have to be all or nothing, some surgeries still provide this type of model.

Weedoormatnomore · 19/02/2023 11:12

sweeneytoddsrazor · 18/02/2023 23:34

Small independent business probably can't afford the wages to stay open for long hours. Most of them are open 6 days a week, many may be 7 days. Surely you either have a day off in the week or a Saturday where you could pop out to make a purchase

Could they not close one day and have 1 late night closing instead be cheaper on staff hours. I worked 5 days a week and at weekends was either rushing around taking kids to clubs !

RadioactiveWear · 19/02/2023 11:11

I didn't live here for nearly 2 decades and when I came back one of the first things I noticed was that in general, the work ethic here is pretty poor.

People just don't want to work, and then moan when someone else gets something they don't. I worked out that on average, 1/3 of our staff are off sick at any one time and the rest of us have to do their work.

thegrandolddukeofpork · 19/02/2023 11:10

Also don’t get me started on the local chippy that only opens outside of lunch & dinner times and only on very random days every week. The owner shouts at anyone who hasn’t pre-ordered too. We’ve stopped bothering with them.

thegrandolddukeofpork · 19/02/2023 11:08

Couldn’t agree more and it’s something I think about quite a lot as I love to shop local and hate what is happening to our high streets.

We go to the market every Saturday around 0800-0830. The fruit & veg stall have now started taking contactless at any value which is great, we always spend at least a tenner anyway. Their trade always seems to be booming. Their flexibility (and superior product) has increased my loyalty to them.

We like to tie this market visit in with picking up anything we need from the shops, but they’re starting to open later and later now, it used to be standard that shops would open at 9am on a Saturday or weekday, whereas now it’s half an hour up to even 2 hours later than that. And the ones that are open never seem to have in stock anything we go in for (I’m looking at you independent pet shop that only seems to cater for small breeds & independent clothes shop that doesn’t sell clothes for anyone under 5 foot 8), or they don’t take card, or if it’s a cafe they charge a pound extra per item to eat in or don’t sell anything dairy free apart from vegan stuff - my son has suspected CMPA and is EBF. This might all make total business sense to them which is fair enough but they’ve lost my business and I doubt I’m the only one. We go home and order what we need from Amazon or go to a big supermarket.

A local dog trainer recently did a big whiney FB post about how people expect them to be available on weekends and evenings. Alright, don’t be available during those times and see how things work out for you.

It’s not up to the consumer to bend over backwards to meet the needs of businesses.

SerendipityJane · 19/02/2023 11:04

To go with my cake and coffee, I read that Rutland is to become the first county in England without a bank branch.

www.msn.com/en-gb/money/other/now-a-whole-county-will-be-left-without-a-bank/ar-AA17EYdh

A fascinating mix of comments ensue, if you choose to read them. I particularly liked the rather low intelligence suggestion that "boomers" somehow resist change. Who the fuck do you think spent their entire fucking working lives bringing online banking into existence ? Who the fuck has spent 35 fucking years working on digital communications with the vision of working from home as a regular practice ? Well I know it wasn't some twat who thinks someone over 55 is bemused by an "app".

Tangentially feeds into the "only takes cash" side of this thread. Personally I detest cash. Quite aside from it's obvious attraction to scrotey types, is the fact that it doesn't really exist. Try and pay for a car park ticket with the "cash" of a £10 note for a demonstration that holds up in court, where "cash" means an exact assortment of coins. Or try paying for something that's £1 with a £20 note.

Bubblebubblebah · 19/02/2023 11:00

RadioactiveWear · 19/02/2023 10:54

Some people may not agree with my point.

Over Christmas, I tried to book a local restaurant for Christmas Eve or NYE. They told me that they were shut from 22 Dec to 03 Jan for staff holidays. This has been the case for the past 3 years.

Where I work, I only get Christmas Day and NY Day off. All other days are open.

If you are a restaurant, surely your peak trade is Christmas week? Surely you know that when you go into the restaurant business, you are going to work unsociable hours and days?

I went somewhere else instead and TBH found the food great and appreciate them going out of their way to be open at Christmas and would rather spend my money there.

Tbf this solely depends on pre-christmas market. Some places make enough to cover the period and everyone can get off. I am big fan of this. We always closed 24th, 25th and 26th at the very least. I wanted Christmas off so did my staff. Other places aren't fussed so they can get that trade. They closed different times when we were open. Our peak was first 3 weeks of Dec.

C8H10N4O2 · 19/02/2023 10:58

DogInATent · 19/02/2023 10:14

Businesses stuck in the past, will become the past

^ this

You can look on any hobby/special interest forum or social media group and you have constant "use it or lose it" calls from shop owners and regular news of the latest independent retailer supporting the hobby to close. But it's always the same problems:

  • owner retiring with no one to take it on, but they've never considered taking on an apprentice or planning for succession.
  • "we don't do online" and complain that X, Y, or Z is killing the hobby. But X, Y and Z all started as small independent businesses, the difference now is that 80% of their turnover is from online sales.
  • weird opening hours.
  • cliques and/or special offers for regulars, and no time for "timewaster newcomers" perceived as not serious about the hobby/interest.

I agree and people telling me to make sure I do regular trips to cash points just to support a local business in this day and age are wasting their breath. I'm not going to do it.

When I was a child "perishable" shops such as butchers, bakers and green grocers were commonly open by 7:00 at the latest - often open whilst they were unloading to catch the early birds. People would shop before they went to work from a local shop. These shops typically closed earlier in the afternoon, would have maybe one evening a week of late opening and a half day mid week. They also did deliveries to local addresses and usually ran accounts for regular customers deemed credit worthy.

Basically they served the needs of the time. Local shops can't compete with Tesco on the price of a can of beans so they need to offer me something better or unavailable from Tesco in terms service, local provenance, convenience or niche items.

Our local bakers do pretty well and don't have overly extended hours - they make good basic products in interesting variations as well as taking pre orders for filled rolls, sandwiches etc for lunches. They focus on quality and customer service but choose products which enable them to do that without insane pricing.

The bookshop and the games shop also do reasonably well - enthusiastic interested owners with a passion for sharing their interest and a good grasp of their business. I know my local games shop charges a bit more than Amazon for the board game of the moment. I also know that if I go in there and say I'm looking for something new for someone who likes X, Y and Z they give me a good recommendation every time based on personal knowledge of the game. They both also keep customer records (by agreement) to send out info on new items of interest and deliver locally if wanted.

Like every other business they need to adapt and some do it well whilst others will fail. When a shop is open random hours and is cash only I also assume something dodgy is going on and won't use it.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 19/02/2023 10:55

Just wondering how many posters would be happy in this scenario

Hi MN my partner runs a small independent business. He works really hard but has to work every evening and all weekend. I also work part time but due to his hours I am left with all the DC bedtimes , running them to their activities and no family time at weekends. AIBU to be unhappy with this?

MN replies - he needs to change his hours/job

RadioactiveWear · 19/02/2023 10:54

Some people may not agree with my point.

Over Christmas, I tried to book a local restaurant for Christmas Eve or NYE. They told me that they were shut from 22 Dec to 03 Jan for staff holidays. This has been the case for the past 3 years.

Where I work, I only get Christmas Day and NY Day off. All other days are open.

If you are a restaurant, surely your peak trade is Christmas week? Surely you know that when you go into the restaurant business, you are going to work unsociable hours and days?

I went somewhere else instead and TBH found the food great and appreciate them going out of their way to be open at Christmas and would rather spend my money there.

Chowtime · 19/02/2023 10:52

I think most small business owners work for themselves because they WANT to set the hours that are convenient for them. I set my own working hours and people have to fit in with that. It means that I get a great work/life balance and have evenings and week-ends off to socialise and spend time with family. I've never been happier - sod having more money and working more!

borntobequiet · 19/02/2023 10:47

Extending GP opening hours trials a few years ago were unsuccessful.

www.theguardian.com/society/2015/sep/29/almost-half-seven-day-trial-gp-surgeries-cut-hours-after-lack-of-demand

I was surprised to be given an outpatient appointment (dermatology) at a local hospital on a Saturday afternoon a couple of months ago, very soon after a referral from the GP. It was great, I was seen quickly and efficiently and was very happy. But there were only two other patients while I was there. A nurse told me that it was always quiet, people turned down appointments if offered and they’d probably be dropping it. However weekday clinics are very busy with long waiting times.

DogInATent · 19/02/2023 10:45

Schleep · 19/02/2023 10:40

As a small business owner, I've tried things like Sunday and evening opening hours only to find the ones who suggest it come in once or twice and then never do it again.
Same with stocking certain products - someone will come in making a big fuss about how we should stock X, Y, Z and then come in and buy one once and we're left with stacks of unsellable items.

Can't speak for all small businesses (or all customers) of course, but it's amazing how many customers with no experience or in depth understanding of the industry think they can run the place better, but never make an attempt to do open something themselves to solve the problem themselves.

What's the demographic of your customers? And is there a difference between the demographics of your actual customers vs. your ideal customers?

Echobelly · 19/02/2023 10:43

Some local shops do seem to act like it's the 1950s and there are housewives at home all day. I still see some that open 10-4 or 5 during the week, and are shut on Sunday and/or close at lunchtime on Saturday. Honestly they'd do better to shut, on, say Monday instead, and open 12-8 on weekdays (I notice this is a more common thing in the US) so they can get business after people get back from work and more people on weekends.

That said, in neighbourhoods like mine more people are working at home so shops might be doing OK from that. And I do appreciate the difficulty of getting staff for outside 9-5 hours, although that might be a good way to give evening jobs to local young people by having evening shifts.

I think it also is in part as they are more likely to be family businesses, and the family doesn't want to work all week, which is understandable.

MadeOfSteel · 19/02/2023 10:42

These small businesses are likely to be sole traders, or have only help from family. With something like a greengrocer, he or she might have to be up at 03:00 to get to the nearest wholesale market so they get the freshest produce. I imagine that's why they can't stay open till 20:00.

Alternatively, they probably just can't afford to pay for the staff they'd need to operate 12 hour opening or longer.

They also won't have the buying power of the supermarkets so their stock costs will be considerably higher.

Sadly, they're just being squeezed and pushed out of the marketplace by consumers' changing lifestyles and demands.

Schleep · 19/02/2023 10:40

As a small business owner, I've tried things like Sunday and evening opening hours only to find the ones who suggest it come in once or twice and then never do it again.
Same with stocking certain products - someone will come in making a big fuss about how we should stock X, Y, Z and then come in and buy one once and we're left with stacks of unsellable items.

Can't speak for all small businesses (or all customers) of course, but it's amazing how many customers with no experience or in depth understanding of the industry think they can run the place better, but never make an attempt to do open something themselves to solve the problem themselves.

Tabitha005 · 19/02/2023 10:39

I agree with lots of things being said on this thread. Our local high street has everything, including a DiY store - that closes at midday on a Saturday and is always closed whenever I drive past on my way home from work at just gone 5pm, too. Same for the cafe/bakery, butchers, greengrocer and pet store. I think any of these stores that could open even half an hour later would get a lot of custom - as the high street is generally always pretty busy with traffic on the way home from work.

I know I'm lucky to have these things on my doorstep, but there are plenty of local people who work between 'normal' working hours who will never be able to use these stores as they're never open when we need them. Thus, we instead use the local Sainsbury's. The only convenience stores which stay open later are the Spar and Premier - where costs are typically much higher than the supermarket.

The chemist closes for lunch - every day - which baffles me. Plus, they're forever having issues for which they constantly blame the local GP surgeries, but which is clearly always to do with their own ineptitude. They've got SO bad that I'll drive to a different chemist in the next village rather than use the one a three-minute walk from my front door.

Elphame · 19/02/2023 10:39

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 04:43

@knitnerd90 "A yarn shop owner will decide she never wants to be open past 5pm because she doesn't want to work evenings... even though if she opened late one night, she could host a knit night and improve her takings as well as build customer loyalty."

I think you'll find that niche hobby/craft shops open with reduced hours because they don't have the footfall after 5.00.pm when customers are getting ready for their evening meal.
Few would want to close at 4.00.pm and then re-open at 7.00p for a "knit & natter" night especially if they don't live on the premises.

5pm? Luxury!

I went down to my local craft shop the other day only to find it now closes at 3pm. Hopeless.

I went home and ordered from Amazon and had what I wanted delivered the next day.

Teatime55 · 19/02/2023 10:29

My friend lived in a Hamlet. It had one shop and one pub.
The shop closed at 4pm and was only open a few hours on a Saturday morning. During the week everyone was out working, friend said they would be busy at the weekends, as it forced everyone to drive to town for milk and bread.
The pub closed on Sundays, again when they would be really busy.

I know someone who runs a bookshop. They did very well in lockdown but it’s actually harder now. They will do anything for you though. Keep books for you, drop them off at your house for free, do events evenings and weekends. If there are local events they will open Sundays/long hours.
On the flip side if they know it’s going to be quiet they just close. They now close for the whole of Christmas/new year holiday as they sell so little (they will drop a book off for you if you live near them though).

My local council has just scrapped 2 hour free parking. Will be a disaster.

GiantPandaAttacks · 19/02/2023 10:27

I’ve given up on our local high street entirely. It caters solely to the retired or SAHPs who can work around insane opening hours like the greengrocer who sells on the high street for two/three hours a day. I’d love to be able to buy fresher stuff from him but sainsburys is open when I finish work, and he’s long gone. There also seems to be an abundance of trinket shops as well - I don’t want these in my home, and they aren’t present in my friends’ homes either. I can’t see how they’ll exist long term. I think changing tastes are not factored in.

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 10:26

I'm an accountant and have dozens of small business clients who would like to grow, but can't because of the VAT, so artificially restrict their business, through shorter opening hours or days/weeks off, to keep turnover under the threshold

This is interesting and never occurred to me. I'd say this strategy is not working though as these businesses dont last- every year or so another shop takes their place so it clearly cant be working that well.

chevvyroo · 19/02/2023 10:25

Valentina12 · 19/02/2023 01:41

I work from home a lot. But I’m not allowed to work from cafes because data protection / insecure connections etc. am I the only one??

Don't you use a VPN?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/02/2023 10:23

I'm an accountant and have dozens of small business clients who would like to grow, but can't because of the VAT, so artificially restrict their business, through shorter opening hours or days/weeks off, to keep turnover under the threshold.

That's really interesting, I wonder if that explains some of the businesses I've been wondering about.

What would the threshold be though?

Patienceisntvirtuous · 19/02/2023 10:23

I've experienced this recently too. Went to the market on my lunch hour to pick up some bread and fruit, bread stall was already packed away. . 130pm! Fruit stall owner was packing up too.

It's sad because it's only a little market and I would hate to see it not there any more, but cater properly for your customers!

SpringDaffy · 19/02/2023 10:20

These businesses going down the "card only" route lose my custom. They also mostly open 10-4.
I use cash mostly.
They use the sign like a badge of honour, when quite frankly, they are losing customers and will upload sad posts for sympathy all over Facebook, blaming Covid, when they go bump.

Swipe left for the next trending thread