Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
Icanbetherubberband · 19/02/2023 13:31

A lot of businesses have limited business hours because they can't afford to pay for staff for extra hours, so they open for less hours but the hours they get the majority of their custom, so a breakfast cafe opening mornings only (because they get fewer people through later on) or a restaurant only opening in peak evening hours (because they don't get much custom during lunch hours or later on at night). It's not that they aren't adapting to their customers, it's that they have adapted to the bulk of their customers at the expense of losing a handful more. Or that they just cannot get the staff or afford to open on the off chance that that would improve things. This is why big companies have a monopoly, because Costa can afford to stay open until custom picks up in less busy times, or so that they get a reputation for always being open and reliable, whereas small local businesses cannot. The big chains can afford to make a loss some of the time, small businesses cannot. The system is designed to benefit the big chains not the small businesses. They get better deals on things like card machines, product suppliers and company merchandise compared to local businesses, and so end up monopolising the high street

another1bitestheduck · 19/02/2023 13:26

I'm confused why the annoyance seems to be aimed around people wanting shops/GP surgeries etc to be open additional hours, with the implication that we are too stupid to understand this is too expensive for the business, whereas most people instead just want services available at different hours. Nobody expects GPs to be open 9-9 Monday to Sunday but why can't they be open 9-5 M,T,W, 12-8 on Thursday, 9-1pm on Friday and 9-1pm on Saturday? Same amount of hours, just actually gives more working people (i.e. the ones actually funding the NHS) the opportunity to access it, and might even be appreciated by the GPs themselves who presumably also have to do their own shopping etc within business hours!

It also drives me nuts when you can't find, for example, opening hours or a menu for a small business. It is completely free and takes seconds to add opening hours to google, or create a facebook/twitter/insta page with this info. I'm not going to waste my time going somewhere which might not be open when I get there or won't have what I want.

I understand there's a cost to setting up online ordering too but I also don't think older generations understand how much a huge number of people under (approx) 35 would happily pay extra for a service if it means avoiding using a phone!

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 13:25

Heynow3 · 19/02/2023 12:34

Wonderful for your DP. But hardly applicable to a fruit and veg shop.

Businesses make decisions personal to them, so completely applicable to fruit and veg shops (Broadly speaking). Customers often make incorrect assumptions about the reasons why they chose to operate the way they do.
As this thread has shown, customers have an expectation, business owners may have another, and there's the sweet spot where the two parties can form a relationship.
That's where the money is.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 19/02/2023 13:19

Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 04:43

@knitnerd90 "A yarn shop owner will decide she never wants to be open past 5pm because she doesn't want to work evenings... even though if she opened late one night, she could host a knit night and improve her takings as well as build customer loyalty."

I think you'll find that niche hobby/craft shops open with reduced hours because they don't have the footfall after 5.00.pm when customers are getting ready for their evening meal.
Few would want to close at 4.00.pm and then re-open at 7.00p for a "knit & natter" night especially if they don't live on the premises.

Yet I’ve been to yarn shops that do have a knit and natter at night - open later in the day to compensate. They do a roaring trade and often have a waiting list of people who want to join in. So it’s madness that some shops do not explore these trading options. The people who go are those who work m-f 9-5 !! Granted not every marketing trick will work for all small businesses.

leithreas · 19/02/2023 13:09

Teatime55 · 19/02/2023 12:35

I don’t think some businesses understand that there is a playoff between cost/convenience. Often you are willing to pay more if it’s convenient to you.
I used to go to a sewing shop. Not the greatest but nearish with free parking. Could run over and buy something no bother.
They decided they didn’t want a physical shop so went on markets. Problem is they are during the week, often miles away. They grouched on Facebook about ‘not seeing regulars’ but I imagine people don’t want to travel 20 miles for a reduced selection.
They also tried then also selling online, but because of the postage costs they aren’t worth it AND there is loads of other places to go to online instead.

I also worked for a business that was normally on markets but started opening for direct sales on Saturday mornings. Except it wasn’t every week. And they owner would change her mind. She wouldn’t update FB.
She would then be furious when she did open that it wasn’t rammed like the first time she did it. People went and found it closed and wouldn’t go again. Don’t blame them

This is it. It's cost vs convenience, once you lose the convenience of being right there or accepting all payment methods etc then you lose the customer. I was willing to pay more for wool in my local wool shop because I could grab it on my way home from work, I could see the selection in person etc, It never being open past 3pm and on weekends means it isn't convenient anymore.

I have an aldi and an expensive supermarket 5 mins from my house, for most shops I go to aldi but if I just need a loaf of bread and some milk I go to the expensive supermarket and pay a little bit more because I can use the self-service and never have to queue vs aldi where I always have to queue. It's the same principle.

C8H10N4O2 · 19/02/2023 12:55

katepilar · 19/02/2023 12:07

I am amazed how so many people can look at this just from their own perspective. The small business owners are people just like anyone else and their work goes beyond the opening hours, ofter with early mornings if its a vegetable shops etc.

Customers paying with cards costs them money. For small amounts it costs them more then what their own costs are. Often smaller shops only have smaller transactions /compared lets say to a family weekly shop at a supermarket/.
Supporting them goes well beyond your own convenience. In the very wide picture its about the world being in the hands of a few very wealthy people who dont care about anything else then their own power.

People are simply saying why they don't or can't use local businesses. I assume that if a business is difficult for me to access and then making it difficult for me to pay for their services then I'm not a customer they need or want and will go elsewhere.

I don't owe any small local businesses charity. I will use them if they provide good service, something I want and don't put barriers in the way of using them. Some make it clear they want my custom so those are the businesses I'll use.

tiredwardsister · 19/02/2023 12:53

I agree some small independent businesses don’t seem to understand how customers think. I live in a very rural location I never have cash on me and always pay by phone. I’m lucky financially I can afford to support more expensive local shops and I like to buy local food. My nearest small retailer sells a product I use all the time they offered to order it for me on a regular basis (weekly) but 3 times out of 4 “forget” so now I don’t go in there to buy it this means I also don’t buy other stuff in there either. They also didn’t take phone/card tap payments “the machine was broken” for 6 months I never carry my debit card on me anymore and would have to make a special trip to the shop with card to buy things. Combine the two issues together and I’ve stopped shopping in there I feel guilty because I want them to do well. But I have found another small independent shop ok 10 miles further away who are able to do my order and I can pay by pay be phone I go in there weekly and increasingly spending more money in there as I buy more and more of their products. They are more expensive that the big chain supermarket 300 m away but I genuinely want to support local businesses/buy local products and/or ethical sustainable products.
I had a similar problem in our local independent pet food shop who issue a generous loyalty card. I forgot it one day and despite having my details wouldn’t let me put points on it or bring the receipt in the next day and have the points added. Instead of spending the £100 I’d planned to spend I spent £5 and bought the large bag of dog food/new lead in the supermarket. So short sighted.

PegSliderskew · 19/02/2023 12:51

sweeneytoddsrazor · 19/02/2023 10:55

Just wondering how many posters would be happy in this scenario

Hi MN my partner runs a small independent business. He works really hard but has to work every evening and all weekend. I also work part time but due to his hours I am left with all the DC bedtimes , running them to their activities and no family time at weekends. AIBU to be unhappy with this?

MN replies - he needs to change his hours/job

And that would be the right answer. If the hours you need to work to fit around your family's needs are not the same hours at which customers will be available, your small business idea is not viable and you'll need to think again. If you want to run a coffee shop by the station but can't open until 10am because of the school run, you just can't open that business. Or rather you can, but you'd be a fool to yourself because it's certainly going to fail and leave you in debt.

Teatime55 · 19/02/2023 12:35

I don’t think some businesses understand that there is a playoff between cost/convenience. Often you are willing to pay more if it’s convenient to you.
I used to go to a sewing shop. Not the greatest but nearish with free parking. Could run over and buy something no bother.
They decided they didn’t want a physical shop so went on markets. Problem is they are during the week, often miles away. They grouched on Facebook about ‘not seeing regulars’ but I imagine people don’t want to travel 20 miles for a reduced selection.
They also tried then also selling online, but because of the postage costs they aren’t worth it AND there is loads of other places to go to online instead.

I also worked for a business that was normally on markets but started opening for direct sales on Saturday mornings. Except it wasn’t every week. And they owner would change her mind. She wouldn’t update FB.
She would then be furious when she did open that it wasn’t rammed like the first time she did it. People went and found it closed and wouldn’t go again. Don’t blame them

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 19/02/2023 12:35

When my DH and I both WFH, have budgeted the time and the money we like to go out for lunch together.

We kept trying to support local businesses but it was almost impossible to find any open.

We ended up going to a shopping centre near by rather than supporting our local high street.

Heynow3 · 19/02/2023 12:34

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:29

They way up whether the extra is worth it.

Dp does it, is the type of work and the customer worth it?
The customer on the other hand thinks, why does this person not want my money? He had a call on Friday, and this Sunday, how much will it be, do you charge a call-out? In his line of work people asking those questions are either passed on or rejected outright

Wonderful for your DP. But hardly applicable to a fruit and veg shop.

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 12:31

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:29

They way up whether the extra is worth it.

Dp does it, is the type of work and the customer worth it?
The customer on the other hand thinks, why does this person not want my money? He had a call on Friday, and this Sunday, how much will it be, do you charge a call-out? In his line of work people asking those questions are either passed on or rejected outright

I agree. But I’m referring to businesses who do this then moan they can’t make ends meet.

You can’t have it both ways I’m afraid.

Heynow3 · 19/02/2023 12:30

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:21

Quite obviously they've taken the decision not to expand.
These reasons will be personal to the owner/owners.
Businesses can make decisions based on how they want to run, not on what, you, think is the correct way to operate.

Of course. I’m not expecting them to operate the way I want them too.

They just need to stop whinging that the customers are going elsewhere. Customers are voting with their feet. They want to shop after 3.45pm.

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:29

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 12:23

Businesses can make decisions based on how they want to run, not on what, you, think is the correct way to operate

Absolutely they can. But then they have to be prepared for the financial consequences too which may involve losing money.

They way up whether the extra is worth it.

Dp does it, is the type of work and the customer worth it?
The customer on the other hand thinks, why does this person not want my money? He had a call on Friday, and this Sunday, how much will it be, do you charge a call-out? In his line of work people asking those questions are either passed on or rejected outright

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/02/2023 12:25

I wonder why we don't see more automated takeaway coffee premises, really. Obviously not going to attract the 'purists', but as instant Costa machines are A Thing, why not just have little high street lobbies open 24/7 (or maybe closing for a few hours overnight, where vandalism could be an issue).

There would need to be security and safety measures, of course, but I'm sure these could be thought out and implemented.

I don't know whether they still do the same thing now, but when I lived in Europe 20+ years ago, they had 24/7 glass bottle-return machines in the walls of shops (that would issue you with a ticket in return of your deposit); they also had people come out early in the morning at weekends and put the newspapers in bags on lamp-posts, for you to help yourself and put money in the box.

I'm thinking that there may be some middle-ways whereby an actual person needs to attend at some point, but doesn't need to stay there permanently. I guess that's one of the big attractions of having online stores, allowing people to order whenever they like and you only having to check in periodically when it suits you to process the orders and dispatch the goods.

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 12:23

Businesses can make decisions based on how they want to run, not on what, you, think is the correct way to operate

Absolutely they can. But then they have to be prepared for the financial consequences too which may involve losing money.

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:21

Heynow3 · 19/02/2023 12:11

It is not saturated with other businesses. It is just the other main competitor is willing to adapt to what the customers want. They have expanded three times now so the demand is clearly there.

Meanwhile the early closing place complains about lack of customers…

Quite obviously they've taken the decision not to expand.
These reasons will be personal to the owner/owners.
Businesses can make decisions based on how they want to run, not on what, you, think is the correct way to operate.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/02/2023 12:15

Most people don’t complain. Heh just get on with their lives, shopping where it suits them. This kind of huffy attitude towards customers is never going to preserve a business.

Yes, I agree with this. They aren't bothered when something that never worked for them in the first place is no longer there to still not work for them.

You'll always get the drama llamas who cry about small businesses closing, but who never used them themselves. Of course, nobody can take them seriously if they genuinely think that a little local shop can continue to exist as a pretty ornament without anybody ever using it.

Heynow3 · 19/02/2023 12:11

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:07

The demand isn't there if the market for those goods and services is saturated with other businesses.
Of course, if they chose to close or they go out of business, then a small amount of demand will go to the remaining business. Often these decisions will be made in-house by the owners. It could be a restocking issue, could be a lifestyle choice.
Money is made by being niche, not by competing over hrs and cost. Leave that to the supermarkets or bigger businesses.

It is not saturated with other businesses. It is just the other main competitor is willing to adapt to what the customers want. They have expanded three times now so the demand is clearly there.

Meanwhile the early closing place complains about lack of customers…

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 19/02/2023 12:10

katepilar · 19/02/2023 12:07

I am amazed how so many people can look at this just from their own perspective. The small business owners are people just like anyone else and their work goes beyond the opening hours, ofter with early mornings if its a vegetable shops etc.

Customers paying with cards costs them money. For small amounts it costs them more then what their own costs are. Often smaller shops only have smaller transactions /compared lets say to a family weekly shop at a supermarket/.
Supporting them goes well beyond your own convenience. In the very wide picture its about the world being in the hands of a few very wealthy people who dont care about anything else then their own power.

Bit fundamentally if people work Monday-Friday then they cannot use the local shop if it is only open m-f 9-5.

It's that simple.

I WFH, I can finish at 5pm and go to the shop or I can go before work. On the days that I go into the office, I can stop on my way so before 9 or on my way home so after 5.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 19/02/2023 12:09

I think a PP just summed it all up very succinctly - consumers just don't care how they acquire their consumables as long as they get them cheap, quick smart and completely at their own convenience.

If small businesses go under it's not their problem - they can just go elsewhere.

My seas-side town has been hollowed out due to out of town retail parks, there are no department stores. It's all coffee shops, chains, pubs and entertainment. There's a big cinema complex with lots of eateries inside - all corporate. Rates are extortionate so there are huge amounts of empty shops and the place is considered a no go zone for residents. Tourists are disappointed by the lack of vibrancy and diversity.

My shop is in another part of the town on a High Street so people do find their way to the small independent retail outlets in my area but as mentioned in my last whine, there are continuing problems with out of area roadworks that cause drivers to be diverted around the place and which of course is frustrating.

So if traditional shopping is going down the pan and everything goes online, towns are just going to have to rely on entertainment and in person services to survive, and give any sense of vibrancy. Those markets are already at saturation point.

There is also a drive to reduce consumerism for environmental reasons, yet the economy relies on the trading of widgets and services. When any industry collapses, the unemployed as a result don't have the money to support other business bar the essentials. It's a zero sum game.

Technological advances change so quickly that it's hard to keep up.

There's only so much innovation small businesses can incorporate on dwindling capital.

Let's face it - we're heading for a world where the majority do everything online and only venture out for fun occasionally - economically things are going to implode before long, and as for the long term psychological damage being done by it all, well, plenty of evidence of that all around us.

Bottom line, very few people actually care about anything except their own immediate gratification.

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 12:08

taxguru · 19/02/2023 11:55

Fair enough, but don't complain when all the small shops have closed down.

Our village had 3 pubs, and two have now closed. Lots of villagers whingeing about how sad it is and how inconvenient and they don't like the one that's stayed open because it's turned into more of a family restaurant than a pub. But they should have damn well used the other two pubs more if they wanted them! They only closed because of lack of custom!

Oh I’m not- frankly I don’t care if they go out of business because they’ve made it impossible for me to shop there anyway so I can’t really miss something I never use in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

PrincessConstance · 19/02/2023 12:08

Hospitality, in particular, has been over-saturated in recent yrs, they need a refresh and some will decide to close and do something else.

TeamPineapple · 19/02/2023 12:07

I do think that shopkeepers' and business owners' personalities and demeanors can make or break a business if there's competition in the vicinity - which these days is nearly always, either physically or online.

Totally @Hooklander
There's a local gallery and cafe near me which I now avoid due to the owner's inability to cope if more than one person is in the queue waiting for a coffee. She goes into meltdown, almost shouting at customers that she "can't do more than one thing at a time", despite the customers quietly and patiently waiting 😮

I know of 2 groups that avoid it too because of this. The owner actually agreed and arranged for one group to hold their meetings in her cafe, but when they did she would get agitated because there were too many people wanting drinks. They were incredibly patient with her, didn't mind waiting, never put pressure on her, yet she'd get so agitated she'd cry. Some of the group would even help her out. Eventually the group felt so uncomfortable that they asked the organiser to find another venue, and when the organiser told the cafe owner that they'd no longer visit she got so angry that they were taking our custom elsewhere!

She also got funny with me when I phoned and asked what her opening hours are, telling me "they're on the door!" Yes, but I wasn't outside the cafe, I was at home, and her website didn't have opening hours listed 🙄Even her FB page doesn't list them (all I found was a long post from months ago where it mentions "open from 9am to 4pm Tuesday to Friday, 2pm on Saturday"), and the times mentioned on Google and FB differ.

She has meeting rooms too and even they caused drama when lack of clear signage meant people had to ask her where the rooms were. She got so flustered and cross with people. Just make the signs clear and they won't need to bother you! 😠

I noticed how there used to be another group held there which has relocated. I wonder why 🤔

katepilar · 19/02/2023 12:07

I am amazed how so many people can look at this just from their own perspective. The small business owners are people just like anyone else and their work goes beyond the opening hours, ofter with early mornings if its a vegetable shops etc.

Customers paying with cards costs them money. For small amounts it costs them more then what their own costs are. Often smaller shops only have smaller transactions /compared lets say to a family weekly shop at a supermarket/.
Supporting them goes well beyond your own convenience. In the very wide picture its about the world being in the hands of a few very wealthy people who dont care about anything else then their own power.