Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
AbsolutelyNebulous · 19/02/2023 20:02

Badbadbunny · 19/02/2023 19:48

@swayingpalmtree

Why does their livelihood and ability to cope financially trump my own?

It doesn't, but don't whinge when it's not there for YOUR convenience when you forget to buy something at Tesco and it's too far to drive! It's the hypocracy of some customers that gets me, they don't support local businesses, but then whinge when they're not there for the odd occasion they want to use them!

But who is actually “whinging” about such a scenario? And more importantly who with half a business brain relies on masses of people walking out of Tesco without the ketchup/pot noodles/ toothpaste then coming to their premises to pay 50% more, in order to stay afloat??

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/02/2023 19:59

Also agree. Who on earth would commission having work done without even enquiring how much it might cost them? utterly ridiculous and an appalling attitude towards customers

I agree too. Maybe he has the attitude that the boiler will need fixing (true), so the cost is immaterial; but for many people, they may have to simply sit and freeze and delay the repair until payday or longer.

In that case, it's very reasonable to want to know if you're going to have to pay somebody upfront for coming out to tell you that your boiler will need to be fixed in three months when you can afford it.

swayingpalmtree · 19/02/2023 19:51

Badbadbunny · 19/02/2023 19:48

@swayingpalmtree

Why does their livelihood and ability to cope financially trump my own?

It doesn't, but don't whinge when it's not there for YOUR convenience when you forget to buy something at Tesco and it's too far to drive! It's the hypocracy of some customers that gets me, they don't support local businesses, but then whinge when they're not there for the odd occasion they want to use them!

People keep saying “don’t whinge” but I’m not lol.
I haven’t seen any whining on this thread about the lack of local shops. If my local shops go I won’t miss them as I don’t use them them anyway due to cost. I’ll keep going to the supermarket as I do now.

Badbadbunny · 19/02/2023 19:48

@swayingpalmtree

Why does their livelihood and ability to cope financially trump my own?

It doesn't, but don't whinge when it's not there for YOUR convenience when you forget to buy something at Tesco and it's too far to drive! It's the hypocracy of some customers that gets me, they don't support local businesses, but then whinge when they're not there for the odd occasion they want to use them!

LolaMoon · 19/02/2023 19:32

I don’t mind paying 25-50% more for better product than it’s equivalent in Tesco. So for example I buy local eggs from a farm shop they are £1.20 per 1/2 dozen more than I’d pay in Tesco, ditto cheese meat milk bread etc. But I expect them to be better/fresher/local/sustainable/high animal welfare etc

Same here, but I wouldn’t pay 25-50% extra for the exact same product I can get in the supermarket but cheaper. If I’m paying almost half extra I’d expect it to be much superior quality.

tiredwardsister · 19/02/2023 19:28

AbsolutelyNebulous · 19/02/2023 18:15

In the kind of scenario you describe I’d argue that the shop owner needs a better understanding of his/her customers, not the other way round. Very few people are going to regularly pay 25 to 50% more than supermarket prices for stuff the smaller shop owner, erm, bought in the supermarket!

It doesn’t matter to the customer that the price per unit is more for the small guy than Tesco/Asda etc, or that their overheads are high. A tin of beans is a tin of beans. Faced with those kinds of prices the majority of customers will quite understandably think “I can get this far cheaper” and that’s what they do. It’s just not a viable business unless the little shop is in some food desert because otherwise the supermarket is generally more convenient too in terms of parking, opening times and so on.

I don’t mind paying 25-50% more for better product than it’s equivalent in Tesco. So for example I buy local eggs from a farm shop they are £1.20 per 1/2 dozen more than I’d pay in Tesco, ditto cheese meat milk bread etc. But I expect them to be better/fresher/local/sustainable/high animal welfare etc. I also expect good friendly service, easy parking and a pleasant environment/good presentation. We have a farm shop about 15 miles away they tick all these boxes much of the meat/bread/milk/cakes is actually from the farm or baked on the premises lots of other products are local individual producers are named on meat/honey/jam etc. the prices will be at least 25-50% higher than a big name supermarket. They also sell things that are slightly different although definitely not cheap and and it pays off the place is rammed 6 days a week. A smallish but still significant number of people will pay more they do want to shop locally but I think they have high all round expectations and retailers need to understand this.

swayingpalmtree · 19/02/2023 19:15

Isawyou · 19/02/2023 19:12

Agree. With COL the way it is, it makes sense to find out in advance what something might cost. Her DP sounds awful and insensitive.

Also agree. Who on earth would commission having work done without even enquiring how much it might cost them? utterly ridiculous and an appalling attitude towards customers

Isawyou · 19/02/2023 19:12

Smoothlines · 19/02/2023 15:29

“Fishing for costs”? You think it’s completely unreasonable for someone on a budget to even ask what a job might roughly cost and say they are “fishing for costs”? What a disgusting attitude.

Agree. With COL the way it is, it makes sense to find out in advance what something might cost. Her DP sounds awful and insensitive.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 19/02/2023 19:10

secular39 · 19/02/2023 18:36

🤢 I think I've just became a vegetarian.

You can do pork in few of days, considerably shorter wait time than for beef. We had outdoor pig slaughters in my native country where couple of families bought live pig, butcher shot it, it was processed right there and then and started eating in few days.

secular39 · 19/02/2023 18:51

I find that some of these local shops lack basic customer service and the staff can be so rude. I went to a local health food store and I simply asked the owner if they had non aluminium deodorant's without baking soda (sensitive skin). She asked me why, and I replied that I read it's not good for people with sensitive skin and could explain why I was getting rashes. Well, she then proceeded to laugh and say how foolish I am and that I shouldn't trust what I read on the internet- because of that experience, I refuse to enter that shop again and just pop into Holland and Barret.

secular39 · 19/02/2023 18:36

autumn1610 · 19/02/2023 06:51

“f you buy lamb chops from your local butcher you'll know the animal will have been slaughtered that day and will be fresh”

@Captiancorrellistuba i personally wouldn’t want to be eating meat killer the same day as it’s pretty inedible. Mea Thad to hang to get rid of toxins, rigor morris etc. so they don’t run off down the abattoir to get fresh meat to sell that day. But get your point

🤢 I think I've just became a vegetarian.

swayingpalmtree · 19/02/2023 18:24

AbsolutelyNebulous · 19/02/2023 18:15

In the kind of scenario you describe I’d argue that the shop owner needs a better understanding of his/her customers, not the other way round. Very few people are going to regularly pay 25 to 50% more than supermarket prices for stuff the smaller shop owner, erm, bought in the supermarket!

It doesn’t matter to the customer that the price per unit is more for the small guy than Tesco/Asda etc, or that their overheads are high. A tin of beans is a tin of beans. Faced with those kinds of prices the majority of customers will quite understandably think “I can get this far cheaper” and that’s what they do. It’s just not a viable business unless the little shop is in some food desert because otherwise the supermarket is generally more convenient too in terms of parking, opening times and so on.

Well said! I'm not sure why some people in this thread are acting like we are all walking around with wads of spare cash in our pockets and are just choosing to be "unkind" to local shops out of sheer spite.

Most of us, including me, are having to stick to a strict budget now that everything has gone up. I'm not paying 25-50% more on something that takes me out of my budget just for the sake of a local shop owner. I cant afford to do that.

Why does their livelihood and ability to cope financially trump my own?

AbsolutelyNebulous · 19/02/2023 18:15

taxguru · 19/02/2023 16:54

@Teatime55

I don’t think some businesses understand that there is a playoff between cost/convenience.

They do, but customers don't understand how much extra it costs for the convenience they want. Staffing a shop/cafe for longer doesn't come cheap, nor do the variable overheads such as heating and lighting.

Customers don't understand that the shop pays a hell of a lot more for the products it sells than a supermarket pays, in fact, it's often the case that supermarket selling prices are lower than the shop pays from the suppliers/wholesalers, hence lots of small shops actually buy trolley fulls of goods from Tesco, Morrisons, Aldi, etc - it's cheaper than going to their local Booker wholesaler!

Customers may be "happy" to pay a few per cent more for convenience, but shops can't make a profit on small margins, hence why things can cost a lot more in small places than online or bigger stores, often 25-50% more! That's not all profit for the small shop - they still make less per item than the big store selling at lower prices.

In the kind of scenario you describe I’d argue that the shop owner needs a better understanding of his/her customers, not the other way round. Very few people are going to regularly pay 25 to 50% more than supermarket prices for stuff the smaller shop owner, erm, bought in the supermarket!

It doesn’t matter to the customer that the price per unit is more for the small guy than Tesco/Asda etc, or that their overheads are high. A tin of beans is a tin of beans. Faced with those kinds of prices the majority of customers will quite understandably think “I can get this far cheaper” and that’s what they do. It’s just not a viable business unless the little shop is in some food desert because otherwise the supermarket is generally more convenient too in terms of parking, opening times and so on.

lieselotte · 19/02/2023 17:46

She has meeting rooms too and even they caused drama when lack of clear signage meant people had to ask her where the rooms were. She got so flustered and cross with people. Just make the signs clear and they won't need to bother you

Oh gosh, yes this! I've also had people say "there's a sign". Yes, but it's not clear.

And if you run a cafe please make it clear if it's table service or bar/counter service. So many cafes don't. Why do they expect you to be telepathic?

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 17:45

taxguru · 19/02/2023 17:11

Busy shops with long opening hours also close down! Being busy doesn't mean being profitable. Our village Spar shop closed down last year. It always "appeared" busy, opened 7am to 10pm daily, did all the usual things like off licence, lottery, cash machine, typical Spar range of foods and other goods, etc. Just not enough people using it to buy things that they made enough money on. Far too much of the sales were low profit items so it simply didn't make any profit overall after the ever increasing costs of staffing it for so many hours.

Sure, of course they do- shops close for many different reasons. But I am referring to shops who moan about not having enough trade whilst at the same time barely being open- the two things are often connected as is evidenced in this thread by people saying they are unable to shop locally due to being at work etc

doadeer · 19/02/2023 17:28

miri1985 · 19/02/2023 16:00

My dentists office has an email address on their website which whenever you email it bounces back as that doesn't exist. When I called them I mentioned that the email address listed on their website is sending back an error, the response was we don't use that one, heres this completely different one to contact that is listed nowhere else. 3 years later the incorrect email is still on their website and they haven't done anything to change it.

They have more than enough business that it clearly doesn't matter to them if they aren't accessible by email but I find it so irritating that they can't be arsed to just take the wrong address off the website if they don't want people emailing them rather than having people go to the trouble of emailing and then it bounce back so they have to call.

This is really annoying.

I'm not a dentist but we are constantly updating our website and keeping everything correct.

lieselotte · 19/02/2023 17:27

Not read the full thread but I've never really understood the whole "independent is better" thing. Not always. Not even often, in my view. I'd rather go to an independent cafe because they often (again, not always) have better coffee than the likes of Costa or Starbucks. But I'd rather buy my clothes from a chain (even a small one like Lazy Jack's) because they usually have better more reliable opening hours and refund policies.

People say "well it's better to give your money to local people". Yes but the people who work in the chains are local and spend money locally, even if the profits go elsewhere.

I've also seen the "we don't have wifi, talk to each other" signs in cafes. Guess what - you can look at your phone quickly to check something AND talk to each other!

doadeer · 19/02/2023 17:27

VAT registration is a nightmare. You finally find your feet as a business and start to have better income and then wham! Huge bill. It's awful.

Badbadbunny · 19/02/2023 17:16

percypal · 19/02/2023 17:01

The VAT thing is absolutely correct. The owners of several Italian chip shops round here disappear back to Italy for weeks at a time and it’s as much about staying under the VAT threshold as it is seeing their family. Obviously they probably still do a roaring cash trade too that they don’t declare😆

Yep, VAT is absolutely killing small businesses and stopping them from expanding. VAT registration threshold hasn't changed since 2017 and won't chance until at least 2024. At a time of high inflation, that's disgraceful. Of course it helps bigger businesses by reducing competition!

taxguru · 19/02/2023 17:11

Thighlengthboots · 19/02/2023 13:42

But the entire point is- many businesses aren’t hitting the sweet spot which is exactly why so many are going under. In my town there is a permanently rotating change of ownership of such shops where they last for a year or two and then they’re gone, another takes over and the same thing happens all over again. If they were truly hitting a sweet spot then hardly any retail businesses would close. But many, many are and it’s because they aren’t willing to adapt to the very customers that keep them alive.

Busy shops with long opening hours also close down! Being busy doesn't mean being profitable. Our village Spar shop closed down last year. It always "appeared" busy, opened 7am to 10pm daily, did all the usual things like off licence, lottery, cash machine, typical Spar range of foods and other goods, etc. Just not enough people using it to buy things that they made enough money on. Far too much of the sales were low profit items so it simply didn't make any profit overall after the ever increasing costs of staffing it for so many hours.

percypal · 19/02/2023 17:01

The VAT thing is absolutely correct. The owners of several Italian chip shops round here disappear back to Italy for weeks at a time and it’s as much about staying under the VAT threshold as it is seeing their family. Obviously they probably still do a roaring cash trade too that they don’t declare😆

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/02/2023 16:55

How can they give you a cost if the business doesn't know what the problem is.
Broken boilers are unpredictable and have multiple faults.

So surely asking if there’s a call out charge to look at the boiler and establish what the problem is, and to provide a cost for the repair once it’s known would be a reasonable ask.

taxguru · 19/02/2023 16:54

@Teatime55

I don’t think some businesses understand that there is a playoff between cost/convenience.

They do, but customers don't understand how much extra it costs for the convenience they want. Staffing a shop/cafe for longer doesn't come cheap, nor do the variable overheads such as heating and lighting.

Customers don't understand that the shop pays a hell of a lot more for the products it sells than a supermarket pays, in fact, it's often the case that supermarket selling prices are lower than the shop pays from the suppliers/wholesalers, hence lots of small shops actually buy trolley fulls of goods from Tesco, Morrisons, Aldi, etc - it's cheaper than going to their local Booker wholesaler!

Customers may be "happy" to pay a few per cent more for convenience, but shops can't make a profit on small margins, hence why things can cost a lot more in small places than online or bigger stores, often 25-50% more! That's not all profit for the small shop - they still make less per item than the big store selling at lower prices.

DogInATent · 19/02/2023 16:49

Saschka · 19/02/2023 15:41

GPs DO provide Saturday and evening appointments - usually via a central hub, because takeup is actually very low (most people GPs see are retired patients will multiple chronic health conditions, not working-age people with acute self-limiting illnesses), and it is pretty wasteful to have every single GP practice open but only seeing a couple of patients each.

But you can indeed get a saturday appointment if you want one.

Our practice does not offer extended hours for anything other than a 'routine' appointment, and does not offer any weekend appointments. Diagnostic out patient services may be available at weekends, but not provided by the GP.

miri1985 · 19/02/2023 16:00

My dentists office has an email address on their website which whenever you email it bounces back as that doesn't exist. When I called them I mentioned that the email address listed on their website is sending back an error, the response was we don't use that one, heres this completely different one to contact that is listed nowhere else. 3 years later the incorrect email is still on their website and they haven't done anything to change it.

They have more than enough business that it clearly doesn't matter to them if they aren't accessible by email but I find it so irritating that they can't be arsed to just take the wrong address off the website if they don't want people emailing them rather than having people go to the trouble of emailing and then it bounce back so they have to call.

Swipe left for the next trending thread