Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/02/2023 08:56

Bubblebubblebah · 20/02/2023 08:54

Chrrently it could be availability. Hospitality has had big issues hiring.
But if you have someone cover mid day, you can do split shift yourself. There are ways, lots are not easy but it's usually temporary solution while you are sorting things.

Yeah maybe. I just don't think there's a great number of people crying out to work weekends at the moment, are there?

Bubblebubblebah · 20/02/2023 08:54

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/02/2023 08:52

I wonder how much of it is not affording the staff and how much of it is them simply not being available.

Chrrently it could be availability. Hospitality has had big issues hiring.
But if you have someone cover mid day, you can do split shift yourself. There are ways, lots are not easy but it's usually temporary solution while you are sorting things.

LondonJax · 20/02/2023 08:53

Sadlifter · 20/02/2023 08:30

Oh, and my greengrocer gets up at 4am every day to stock the shop. I don't begrudge him shutting at 3. I go on my day off.

Well my local greengrocer is the one in the market I mentioned. 9am to 1pm on a Friday. Now, I do use them in the school holidays but only if I remember. He's not locked in my brain as I don't see him for at least 6 weeks between the holidays. So I get into the habit of using the supermarkets. I'm fine with that, I assume he's fine with that.

The stall owner I have a mild problem with is the one who won't work weekends as she wants to spend it with the family (fine - so do I) but then complains that she's not getting enough traffic. Well she won't will she?

Those businesses who don't want to work on Sundays, fine. Want to shut at 3pm, fine. But don't complain that you're not getting customers. If you, as a business owner, want to shut at 3pm you have to understand that some potential customers will never use you and be OK with that and get on with your chosen business model.

However our high street owners regularly complain that no-one comes to their shop - then shut early! We do come to their shops - it's just not open as we wander past it after we finish OUR working day!

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/02/2023 08:52

Bubblebubblebah · 20/02/2023 08:49

If you are missing on busy shopping times because you can't afford staff, you either do that hours yourself (like most of us did) until you have it confirmed that it will make enough for staff or you concede to not having that income and don't moan about people not supporting.

We trialed evenings which meant 8am-10pm for few weekends to see if it's viable. Hard as fuck, but it gave us clear answer whether it was or wasn't worth it in the location (after customers were mentioning they would like evenings). It was not😂

I wonder how much of it is not affording the staff and how much of it is them simply not being available.

DilemmaADay · 20/02/2023 08:50

Yes, I like meeting friends for coffee sometimes after work, all the really nice independent places seem to close at 4pm, so we end up at Nero or Costa which opens till 7.
I understand that independent businesses might not have the resources to open late, but it's the faux suprise and anger that people aren't going there when they insist on only opening when most people are at work.

Bubblebubblebah · 20/02/2023 08:49

Sadlifter · 20/02/2023 08:28

They can't afford the staff. You shop at the supermarkets if you want, I'll make the effort to use my local greengrocer who is perfectly entitled to have a day off on Sunday 🤷‍♀️

If you are missing on busy shopping times because you can't afford staff, you either do that hours yourself (like most of us did) until you have it confirmed that it will make enough for staff or you concede to not having that income and don't moan about people not supporting.

We trialed evenings which meant 8am-10pm for few weekends to see if it's viable. Hard as fuck, but it gave us clear answer whether it was or wasn't worth it in the location (after customers were mentioning they would like evenings). It was not😂

Bubblebubblebah · 20/02/2023 08:43

"what's the harm in you staying open a bit if I come in as your closing".

People LOVE this in hospitality
Clear signage at what time kitchen closes, still 15 min after"oh come on, the staff is still theeeeere. You don't want our money or what?"
Keep the money and use them to learn read time.
I had people look at signs on the door, look inside where lights were dimmed and chair were on top of table and floor was being cleaned, walk in and ask for table for 4🤦

Can't make everyone happy, but can try with majority. If enough people are happy, all is fine and bills are paid.

Doyoumind · 20/02/2023 08:40

Totally agree with this. The fruit and veg shop near me was open short hours and eventually closed. There's a nice little coffee shop but it isn't open before or after office hours. I would go and get a coffee in the morning when I'm working from but it doesn't open until after 9 and it closes mid afternoon. It's on a route that's much busier before and after work than during the day. They are missing out on a lot of potential custom.

Jellycatspyjamas · 20/02/2023 08:39

Asking for a cost breakdown over the phone without a previous visual mitigated assessment is impossible.

But asking on the phone if there’s a call out charge to undertake the visual inspection is reasonable - many tradesmen do and I want to know before he arrives so I can pay him, or decide the call out charge is unaffordable for me at that moment in time. Unless he advertises that he’ll do an initial call out free of charge how would I know what it would cost me?

lieselotte · 20/02/2023 08:35

The pp with the husband who is a heating engineer/plumber but thinks it's beneath them to give a price should learn from a local kitchen supplier near me. Obviously kitchen prices vary enormously, but they have a few photos of kitchens they've done recently with the cost. So you at least get an idea of what a kitchen of the same size and type of unit would cost.

A heating engineer can set out their call out charge on their website, and give example problems and what they typically cost to fix, eg a broken valve, or a new pump, or a new circuit board for a boiler, or a new radiator. It's really not that difficult.

Isawyou · 20/02/2023 08:33

Sadlifter · 20/02/2023 08:30

Oh, and my greengrocer gets up at 4am every day to stock the shop. I don't begrudge him shutting at 3. I go on my day off.

That is fine. But that doesn’t suit most people. My grocer that packs up early often misses the after school crowd too. Yet is complaining that people do not shop local.

I don’t begrudge him shutting early. I just shop at the other better grocer that has introduced later hours a couple of evenings a week. They are doing a roaring trade and deservedly so.

OP posts:
Thighlengthboots · 20/02/2023 08:33

Bearing this in mind, I do wonder, If many on here think that a lot of these businesses are run poorly, how many of you would take the financial risk and stress to go and show us how it should be done...........just try it, you might end up eating your words as well intended as they are

I run my own business so I am well aware of the pressures and stress it involves. I went into it with my eyes open and I knew how hard it would be. I started up just before Covid hit so have that to deal with plus the fall out too. However, I am also aware that listening to your customers is the key to being successful. Business that cannot adapt will fail so being able to adapt is the most important issue for me. Obviously businesses fail for many reasons but if I were only to open 10-4 I know I would fail because it wouldnt suit my customers and there would be financial consequences. I have taken a huge financial risk to start up which makes it very important to listen to feedback from the people who pay my bills.

Isawyou · 20/02/2023 08:31

doingitforyorkshire · 20/02/2023 08:27

Ex - small business owner here, garage/petrol station. Ran it for 12 years after building it up from nothing, very stressful, had £20000 grand of my money invested and my house on the line.
You do learn and adapt to customers but the stress of losing everything is immense, the fear factor drives you.

However, I couldn't keep all customers happy, I couldn't accommodate them all, a good few complained that I would go bust if I didn't do this or do that. Many complained, "what's the harm in you staying open a bit if I come in as your closing". All common complaints. On the other hand, 80-90% of our customers were happy, they were repeat business, they were the ones I focused on and despite the others thinking the business was being run badly, the 80-90% of them allowed the business to flourish.

Did I ever think of accommodating the other 10-20%, no, I found the whole process so stressful that on the odd occasion, I tried the uptake on the changes was low, not profitable and just was not financially viable for the business.

That was just my business, all others are different, being run for different reasons, some to expand and grow, others want to make money, and some small businesses are run by owners as a means to an end to pay their overheads and make a small amount for them to live on and that's all they want.

I heard one employee of another small business complain about how it was run, when the owners were moving on, I suggested they step in and run it the way they thought it should be, strangle they refused flat out. The owners in this instance had once been in his shoes but did take it over and tried it but realised it wasn't for them. Many people only see it from the outside and are never in a position to experience running a small business, I know two others who tried and they wrapped it too as they found it too hard going on their own.

Bearing this in mind, I do wonder, If many on here think that a lot of these businesses are run poorly, how many of you would take the financial risk and stress to go and show us how it should be done...........just try it, you might end up eating your words as well intended as they are!

It is not about accommodating everybody. That is impossible. But if a businesses takings are seriously down and they are not adapting to what the majority of the customers needs, then that is an issue.

My locals business complain people don’t shop local and still don’t change their hours to actually make it accessible for people.

OP posts:
Sadlifter · 20/02/2023 08:30

Oh, and my greengrocer gets up at 4am every day to stock the shop. I don't begrudge him shutting at 3. I go on my day off.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 20/02/2023 08:29

user1497787065 · 20/02/2023 07:08

So everyone on MN who supports the public sector strikes thinks that small business owners should be open before 8am until after 6pm preferably six or even seven days a week.

No, we think that if you only open when the majority of your customers are working that you will limit your sales.

I'm never going to take time off work to visit a local shop, it isn't happening. I don't have enough leave to cover the school holidays as it is so i'm not wasting it.

Sadlifter · 20/02/2023 08:28

They can't afford the staff. You shop at the supermarkets if you want, I'll make the effort to use my local greengrocer who is perfectly entitled to have a day off on Sunday 🤷‍♀️

Isawyou · 20/02/2023 08:28

Blip · 20/02/2023 08:01

There are two sides to this.
As a customer I want businesses to be open the hours that suit me and a friendly person to help me.

But the business owners are looking for a lifestyle that works for them and to make as much money as they need. So small businesses often don't open every day and open the hours that suit them the best.

I think if the business wants to operate on their own choice of hours and what suits them best that is fine but it is the businesses who have reduced hours who are then complaining the customers are going elsewhere and not shopping local. Like the fruit and veg I mentioned in my first post. They start packing up at 3.45. It is no surprise that people ignore their shop altogether.

OP posts:
doingitforyorkshire · 20/02/2023 08:27

Ex - small business owner here, garage/petrol station. Ran it for 12 years after building it up from nothing, very stressful, had £20000 grand of my money invested and my house on the line.
You do learn and adapt to customers but the stress of losing everything is immense, the fear factor drives you.

However, I couldn't keep all customers happy, I couldn't accommodate them all, a good few complained that I would go bust if I didn't do this or do that. Many complained, "what's the harm in you staying open a bit if I come in as your closing". All common complaints. On the other hand, 80-90% of our customers were happy, they were repeat business, they were the ones I focused on and despite the others thinking the business was being run badly, the 80-90% of them allowed the business to flourish.

Did I ever think of accommodating the other 10-20%, no, I found the whole process so stressful that on the odd occasion, I tried the uptake on the changes was low, not profitable and just was not financially viable for the business.

That was just my business, all others are different, being run for different reasons, some to expand and grow, others want to make money, and some small businesses are run by owners as a means to an end to pay their overheads and make a small amount for them to live on and that's all they want.

I heard one employee of another small business complain about how it was run, when the owners were moving on, I suggested they step in and run it the way they thought it should be, strangle they refused flat out. The owners in this instance had once been in his shoes but did take it over and tried it but realised it wasn't for them. Many people only see it from the outside and are never in a position to experience running a small business, I know two others who tried and they wrapped it too as they found it too hard going on their own.

Bearing this in mind, I do wonder, If many on here think that a lot of these businesses are run poorly, how many of you would take the financial risk and stress to go and show us how it should be done...........just try it, you might end up eating your words as well intended as they are!

LondonJax · 20/02/2023 08:26

Cirice · 19/02/2023 23:16

I nipped in to my towns Victorian indoor market yesterday. The market bosses are always in the local papers complaining about footfall and how the council charges too much for stalls and they are struggling etc etc.
3pm, Saturday afternoon and 90% of the stalls were closed. No butchers open, veg man had pulled the shutters as had the sweet stall. If I wanted underwear or. Second hand book I’d have been ok, but nothing else was open.
in the end I went to the large Tesco opposite and bought what I’d needed.

Id have preferred to support the market, but they don’t seem to help themselves

At least yours is open (ish) on Saturdays.

Ours deemed it sensible to run a market from 9am - 1pm on Fridays...which means most people can only use it on a day off! And yes, they then moan that they're having falling footfall.

OK then, I'll just ask the boss if I can nip out at 10am to buy a pound of potatoes and a few onions shall I? Or should I just pop into the nearest supermarket when I finish work at 4pm on Fridays? Umm...let's think about that one?

And yes, those of us who actually do make the effort to use the market on a Friday when we have that precious day off, have asked if they can move it to a Saturday. A few do other, more profitable, markets then and one stall owners doesn't work weekends as she wants to spend it with her family. Fair enough, but people who work can't buy from her most of the year. Her problem, her solution.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 20/02/2023 08:25

Hooklander · 19/02/2023 21:04

OTOH some proprietors are so rude they're comedy gold - hence the background to Fawlty Towers.

A local independent café on our seafront has a manager of this ilk. We think of it as 'performance art' and enjoy the view while she tells customers to fuck off under her breath.

I kind of want to go there now...

LondonJax · 20/02/2023 08:20

user1497787065 · 20/02/2023 07:08

So everyone on MN who supports the public sector strikes thinks that small business owners should be open before 8am until after 6pm preferably six or even seven days a week.

No. But if start work at 8am and work through until 4.00pm (school) plus have to be in school at lunch time, how can I support a local business that is only open from 8am until 4pm Monday to Friday? It is physically impossible.

But then we get our local shop owners complaining that 'no-one uses the high street - use it or lose it'. Which we would if they opened their doors at the weekend! Small businesses either open when customers are around or make a life style decision to be open when it suits the business owners lifestyle. Either is fine but a business can't have both. I have an on line business as well as working full time. My decision. I don't moan if a customer orders something on a Sunday for urgent despatch - if I don't want to do it, I shut the on line shop at the weekend. I can't have it both ways and I don't expect to be asked to do that by high street shops. Small businesses need to make up their minds what they want, provide it or don't and have the consequences. It's pure economics.

Thighlengthboots · 20/02/2023 08:04

user1497787065 · 20/02/2023 07:08

So everyone on MN who supports the public sector strikes thinks that small business owners should be open before 8am until after 6pm preferably six or even seven days a week.

I used to work in the public sector and regularly worked weekends, started at 7am, shift work, occasionally night work. So whats the issue here? If you start your own business you need to consider what hours your customers will require you to be open. If you want to only open 10-4 then thats entirely your choice but you cant then moan that you lack trade.

Blip · 20/02/2023 08:01

There are two sides to this.
As a customer I want businesses to be open the hours that suit me and a friendly person to help me.

But the business owners are looking for a lifestyle that works for them and to make as much money as they need. So small businesses often don't open every day and open the hours that suit them the best.

Bubblebubblebah · 20/02/2023 07:33

user1497787065 · 20/02/2023 07:08

So everyone on MN who supports the public sector strikes thinks that small business owners should be open before 8am until after 6pm preferably six or even seven days a week.

Civil service does you know w hat? 7-7 window usually. Dpending on business needs people can do their hours between 7am-7pm.
So one day you can do 7-3, then day when it's needed or you need it you can do 11-7.
Business should, and some do,employ similar thinking but not on ad hoc basis, of course.

Many restaurants already have irregular opening hours for example with some day starting earlier, some day closing later. That is what their market required.

I don't see why someone couldn't do 2 days early open-close and 2 days late open close for example. Some businesses do themselves no favour by being rigid and then moan no one wants to support them.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/02/2023 07:25

So everyone on MN who supports the public sector strikes thinks that small business owners should be open before 8am until after 6pm preferably six or even seven days a week.

I don't think people are saying that; but it's often a case of knowing your market and picking a good time when the custom is there. Be open when people are around before work/school or after they get home, if not both. If you specialise in selling breakfast butties to workers, you can probably be finished and on your way home for the day by 11am or earlier; but you do need to be open and serving before 8:30am.

It just seems a bit silly to not open before most people are at work and then close before they finish work.

Similarly with the days, as long as you make your opening days clear and stick to them, you'd be much better to have a day or two off but then open longer hours on the other days. Much easier for people working 'traditional' hours to be able to give you custom if you're only open 8-6 on Wednesdays and Fridays rather than 10-3 five days a week.

My parents ran their own retail business long ago and would have preferred not to have to work on Saturdays, but realised that it was (then at least) the busiest day for custom, so they opened Tuesday-Saturday and had Sunday and Monday as their weekend. Yes, some people would grumble that they weren't open on Mondays, but virtually nobody was unable to get there at all during the week when they were open if they wanted to.