Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That some small businesses are failing because they don’t adapt to the needs of their customers?

783 replies

Isawyou · 18/02/2023 23:02

I try to shop local. Fortunately I do have some great independent places nearby.

What I am finding frustrating is for example the fruit and veg shop closes at 4.30pm. They start packing up at 3.45pm and it is really difficult to buy things from there where they are stacking all the stands with the produce inside. They also look unhappy at customers coming to buy at packing up time. It is easier to go to the Tesco express that stays open until midnight.

Other shops do not open until 10am and close early. So I can’t get there before work or after work.

They complain their businesses are not doing well and people do not shop local but they are not exactly facilitating it for the customers either.

OP posts:
DaughterofZion · 21/02/2023 10:43

Florenz · 20/02/2023 18:09

GPs should be open far longer than they are. 6am-10pm or suchlike. Doctors need to wake up and smell the coffee. They take a Hippocratic Oath and they are breaking it by not opening more hours.

Don’t be daft.
this is is Hippocratic oath.
what part of this says doctors should work to their bones? The oath clearly says doctors should look after their own health and nothing about sacrificing their lives or health for selfish patients

Hippocratic Oath
Declaration of a New Doctor
As a new doctor, and a member of the medical profession:
I solemnly pledge that I will do my best to serve humanity – caring for the sick, promoting good health and alleviating pain and suffering.
I will care for all patients equally and not allow prejudice to influence my practice.
I will respect the autonomy and dignity of my patients, and will uphold their confidentiality.
I will acknowledge my patients’ physical, psychological, and social needs and assist them to make informed decisions that reflect their own values and beliefs.
I will respect, support and give gratitude to my teachers, colleagues and all those who sustain the NHS.
I will reflect on my practice and recognise my limits.
I will seek to increase my understanding and skills, and promote the advancement of medicine as both a teacher and a learner.
I will work towards a fairer distribution of health resources and oppose policies in breach of human rights.
I will look after my own physical, mental and emotional well-being in my personal and professional life.
I shall never intentionally cause harm to my patients, and will have the utmost respect for human life.
I will practice medicine with integrity, humility, honesty and compassion.
I recognise that the practice of medicine is a privilege with which comes considerable responsibility and I will not abuse my position.
I make this declaration sincerely, freely and upon my honour.

Thelnebriati · 21/02/2023 10:37

So the problem with running a business when you have kids or are disabled and claim tax credits is that you can't earn too much or you lose all of the benefits but still have all of the expenses and be no better off.
Earning just above the threshold is risky, it leaves you a lot more vulnerable to a situation tipping you over the edge into bankruptcy. That risk is greater for poor people who have no safety net.

Then some snarky person will deride you for running an 'artificial' business.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 21/02/2023 10:23

Option 4 is an artificial business to prove they're "working" enough hours for their tax credits claim! All they need to do is break even, i.e. open long enough and sell enough to cover the costs (i.e. rent, utilities, stock, etc), and it opens the doors for tax credits, free prescriptions, housing allowances, etc. Just open a few hours per day and ker-ching!

Wow, that sounds like a whole load of faff. I always think when you see stories of rogue traders on consumer programmes, who use amazing skill and go to such effort and hard work to run their shoddy outfit; baffles me why they don't just put the same time and effort into running a legitimate business and never have to be looking over their shoulder for the police (or Matt Allwright)!

Badbadbunny · 21/02/2023 10:15

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/02/2023 10:00

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll dragons den - omg, yes! I don’t know how those dragons manage to keep themselves from either laughing or shouting at some of the totally delusional ‘entrepreneurs’.
Maybe some of these small shops etc really are just financed by other family members to keep someone occupied/happy? The only other options that come to mind are 1)wasting an inheritance on a passion. 2) money laundering. 3) drug front.

Option 4 is an artificial business to prove they're "working" enough hours for their tax credits claim! All they need to do is break even, i.e. open long enough and sell enough to cover the costs (i.e. rent, utilities, stock, etc), and it opens the doors for tax credits, free prescriptions, housing allowances, etc. Just open a few hours per day and ker-ching!

Not so much these days due to new applicants being on UC instead and existing tax credit claimants being transitioned over from TC to UC, but it was endemic 10-15 years ago for people wanting to claim tax credits but not wanting to "work" in proper employment.

I'm an accountant and had lots of clients doing it, mostly market stalls (due to cheaper more flexible rents), but lots also rented run-down cheap rental shops, spent the minimum on buying stock (often second hand shops selling cheap tat, or sweet shops selling cheap non branded sweets easy to get at wholesalers, etc!). Even now, I have a bed and breakfast client who only lets out rooms a few times per year just to earn enough to pay the overheads, so always breaks even, and lives on tax credits.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/02/2023 10:00

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll dragons den - omg, yes! I don’t know how those dragons manage to keep themselves from either laughing or shouting at some of the totally delusional ‘entrepreneurs’.
Maybe some of these small shops etc really are just financed by other family members to keep someone occupied/happy? The only other options that come to mind are 1)wasting an inheritance on a passion. 2) money laundering. 3) drug front.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 21/02/2023 09:34

Actually I’ve often thought that about a fair number of little shops which keep hours that just don’t seem compatible with the needs of the customer - like the sweet shop upthread that doesn’t open for school children!

As on the other current thread about the woman who delivers meals from London in Essex, I think a lot of people just never really sit down and properly look at the figures, to realise that they clearly don't add up, however much you want them to, and how much you enjoy your work and work hard at it.

Just look at Dragons' Den to see how many business owners end up working for nothing, risking their homes and ploughing all their savings into an unsustainable, unviable business - all the while clearly convinced that they have a great, profitable firm. They think that passion and a yearning are all they need for success.

CatJumperTwat · 21/02/2023 09:33

The new fruit and veg that opened near me offer free kids for apples

I bet that's popular with the local parents.

DollyPartonsBeard · 21/02/2023 09:24

This happened to me last week. I needed a particular sewing/ craft item and visited all four craft/ sewing/ art shops (all independent) in my local town. None of them had the item, and in one shop the assistant cross examined me about the item and was then very dismissive - "I've never heard of one of those" / "Are you sure that's what it's called?" - despite it being made by a massive and well known brand whose other items they stocked.

Another got her phone out and googled it and then confirmed they didn't have one. There was no offer to order one in at any of the shops, so yes, I ordered one from Amazon and it came the next day.

Bezos 1 - local independent stores nil

purplehair1 · 21/02/2023 09:07

I love our local greengrocers. But I work full time long hours and I’m only able to buy from them at weekends. Plus they are cash only which seems antiquated these days and I never have cash on me any more. Another greengrocer has opened up a few doors down in an old cafe and takes cards plus seems to be open really late. I wonder how the original shop is doing with this competition.

mustgetoffmn · 21/02/2023 09:07

Tessabelle74 · 20/02/2023 17:38

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 righty oh. A GP I know has 4 cars, a full time nanny despite all her kids being secondary school age and has a house that must be worth nearly a million quid, and she's just one partner in the practice. Can't afford to open more hours, that's hilarious 🤣

Are you in US? Very very different to UK

mustgetoffmn · 21/02/2023 09:03

mustgetoffmn · 21/02/2023 08:59

Too many retail outlets only operate 9.00 to 5.00. So closing exactly at the point they would pick up most trade. I understand it’s a hard lifestyle but we no longer have woman indoors dealing with housekeeping and shopping during the day

Re GPS that’s different. Really work places should and if decent do allow time off for medical appointments. Also a big infrastructure of support around these services which don’t operate outside hours

mustgetoffmn · 21/02/2023 08:59

Cheeriochoc · 18/02/2023 23:12

It’s not just shops I feel like my GP practice is totally out of touch. Why do they close at the weekend? Surely people need to see a doctor 24/7 so why can’t they open on Saturday and Sundays too? Totally get there’s a shortage of doctors right now so wouldn’t want to make it worse but I’ve never understood why GP practices think they should open 9-5 Monday- Friday type hours!

Too many retail outlets only operate 9.00 to 5.00. So closing exactly at the point they would pick up most trade. I understand it’s a hard lifestyle but we no longer have woman indoors dealing with housekeeping and shopping during the day

DaughterofZion · 21/02/2023 06:58

Cheeriochoc · 18/02/2023 23:12

It’s not just shops I feel like my GP practice is totally out of touch. Why do they close at the weekend? Surely people need to see a doctor 24/7 so why can’t they open on Saturday and Sundays too? Totally get there’s a shortage of doctors right now so wouldn’t want to make it worse but I’ve never understood why GP practices think they should open 9-5 Monday- Friday type hours!

Because the GP is not an emergency service. If you need a GP for something that cannot wait through the weekend, that counts as urgent / emergency and you need 111 or the emergency department. Surely, that’s not hard to understand?
PS. A lot of GP surgeries offer extended access on weekdays from 6.30 pm to 8.30pm and also Saturdays 9am to 1pm. But I remember a lot of patients did not attend those appointments because they forgot, had something better to do, or simply decided that rash could wait till the normal working hours on a weekday. .

ashitghost · 21/02/2023 01:51

YANBU we’ve got a great butchers but shuts at 2pm.

LuluBlakey1 · 21/02/2023 01:43

Our local village - long shopping street- is a mix of fruit and veg/chemists/ordinary bakers/ charity shops/butcher/wool shop, haberdashery shop/ book shop and then on one stretch the trendy bakers and desert shops, deli, trendy cafes/'lifestyle' shops/florist.

I don't know how lots of them in the 'on-trend' stretch make a living. One cafe is always empty and so unwelcoming and expensive. One of the bakers opens at 10am and closes at 2pm and charges £3.50 for a muffin and £4.50 for a loaf of bread. The desert shop is so up itself it's funny- tiny, unwelcoming and extortionate £4.50 -£5.50 per slice of cake/torte (to take home because it's only big enough to have a counter for 2 people and the staff look as if you are a nuisance), opens 3 or 4 days a week at 10am and closes at 2pm. The wool shop seems as if it is never open. The 'lifestyle' shops sell one off things like art prints, room diffusers, attractive small tins etc that cost a fortune and I never see anyone buying- you feel uncomfortable going in because there's never anyone else in. None of the many cafes are anything much although they think they are. There's a 'cool' clothes shop for women and the prices are astonishing and it's always empty. There's one for men too and that's the same.
I've come to the conclusion the 'on-trend' ones must be run by people who run them as additional income and are not bothered about how much profit they make.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/02/2023 01:29

@wellstopdoingitthen you’d think it was. Actually I’ve often thought that about a fair number of little shops which keep hours that just don’t seem compatible with the needs of the customer - like the sweet shop upthread that doesn’t open for school children!
the wool shop in question is run by a much older lady, who probably thinks the calendar still says 1958….

wellstopdoingitthen · 21/02/2023 01:22

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 19/02/2023 00:11

We have a wool shop, but you aren’t allowed to browse the wool or touch it. You must stand one at a time at the counter and ask for the wool you want - you aren’t allowed to touch it, must be paid for first… but you can ask you wipeable items to be brought up on the counter to touch such as knitting needles. only open 10-2 on days only the owner knows. Due to covid.

Never seen anyone shop there!

Is it a front for a drug baron? Confused

MrsMikeDrop · 21/02/2023 01:16

Not quite the same, but when I was a student I worked in retail and leading up to Xmas the shops were open until midnight. Sure a few people came in, but not many so they'd be better off opening until say 9 or 10pm, it's not like they would make more sales and it would cost having all the staff for that many extra hours. This was a long time ago, before online shopping as well. If say that's probably what happens with smaller businesses too, the extra hours mean less time with family and it's probably not worth the small amount of business?

OutofEverything · 21/02/2023 01:09

20% of small businesses fold within the first year and 60% within 3 years.
Running a small business is hard because there are so many variables.
People on this thread are talking about small shops and opening hours. But there are other issues such as where your shop is located, who your main customers are, getting trustworthy staff, etc. You can't open long hours and staff a shop totally by yourself so you need to be able to have staff you can trust who will not rip you off. If your customers are mainly retired people, then there may be no point having longer opening hours as it may lead to only a tiny increase in customers.

I really miss a 24 hour shop that used to be open near me. But when recruiting low paid staff became difficult they kept posting notices they were shutting at 10om because of a lack of staff. Eventually they just changed the opening hours and now i9t closes at 10pm every night.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/02/2023 23:51

I know it's seriously frustrating when people say it would be great if you opened earlier or later, but they don't actually mean that they would come in regularly then and spend money with you. People who don't want to use your business have no right in interfering and telling you how you should run it.

However, like the shopkeeper upthread who clearly got so many people asking to buy batteries that they felt the need to put up a 'WE DO NOT SELL BATTERIES!" sign rather than do the obvious thing and start stocking batteries, I think it can also be easy for the business owner to assume they know what customers do/would want - and to declare that 'there's no call for it' when they have no real way of knowing.

Wouldn't it make sense to try out new hours/schemes for a limited time and then see how it goes - just how you would with new products that you don't know might or might not be popular? If people come and put their money where their mouths are, keep it going if you can; if they don't, lesson learned and bonus easy answer to know-it-all non-customers with their useless 'advice'.

Isawyou · 20/02/2023 23:45

majothomy · 20/02/2023 23:42

It's a difficult one.. Costumers vote with their feet, good, attentive, personable service, good quality or unique products at reasonable prices will make people come back. Inconvenient opening times won't stop people. One can usually work around it, I don't think it's absurd, small businesses haven't got the money or staff to be open all the hours under the sun that people seem to be suggesting.. If it's just you on your own, you're quite entitled to have a lunch hour for example.. My reason for shopping at supermarkets is sadly just down to cost especially of late..!

Nobody is suggesting that small businesses open all hours under the sun but if they want to pack up at 3.45 then it’s no surprise that customers go elsewhere.

OP posts:
majothomy · 20/02/2023 23:42

It's a difficult one.. Costumers vote with their feet, good, attentive, personable service, good quality or unique products at reasonable prices will make people come back. Inconvenient opening times won't stop people. One can usually work around it, I don't think it's absurd, small businesses haven't got the money or staff to be open all the hours under the sun that people seem to be suggesting.. If it's just you on your own, you're quite entitled to have a lunch hour for example.. My reason for shopping at supermarkets is sadly just down to cost especially of late..!

Isawyou · 20/02/2023 23:38

Cottagewitch · 20/02/2023 23:31

I think that's part of the problem though. I ask people what they want, get a lot of responses, adapt accordingly and still not a soul comes in for those later hours or that specific type of product everyone wanted to see. People seem to want you to adapt to their needs so that you're there for them at, say six o'clock, for that once every six months when they decide they need something. Not that I blame people really, it's not their fault. There's more convenient and cheaper options about than local and it's understandable in this climate that people go elsewhere.

Then if asking the people isn’t working, then adapt again and try a different method.

Look at the trends, what is popular, what is up and coming, can you offer something that no one else is offering. You know the market you are in.

You sound quite defeated.

OP posts:
Cottagewitch · 20/02/2023 23:31

Isawyou · 20/02/2023 22:45

Extending opening hours is just one issue. It may not be the answer for you and for other businesses. Nobody is saying it is the answer to a booming business.

For a business to succeed you need to keep making changes and adapting to what people need otherwise people simply go elsewhere.

I think that's part of the problem though. I ask people what they want, get a lot of responses, adapt accordingly and still not a soul comes in for those later hours or that specific type of product everyone wanted to see. People seem to want you to adapt to their needs so that you're there for them at, say six o'clock, for that once every six months when they decide they need something. Not that I blame people really, it's not their fault. There's more convenient and cheaper options about than local and it's understandable in this climate that people go elsewhere.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/02/2023 23:25

The new fruit and veg that opened near me offer free kids for apples

That sounds a bit too much going above and beyond, mind! Grin