Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Describe the imaginary political party you would want to vote for

108 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/02/2023 22:28

For those of us fed up of the sad selection on offer!

The left are toxic, the right are toxic. I want a pragmatic ‘centre’ party. A bit like the early days of New Labour. A focus on average working people and families, long-term plans for the environment, healthcare and cost of living/housing. No identity politics twattery, no TWAW, no taking the knee type gestures. Straight talking people who can be honest with the public about what is and isn’t possible rather than offering the moon on a stick then failing to deliver it. Standards and transparency and an oath to resign the moment they’re caught lying about their tax affairs. A leader with gravitas that doesn’t look like he or she is about to burst into tears at any moment Kier or have a constant lame grin like they can’t really believe they’ve been made Head Boy and are enjoying wearing the badge Rishi. Maybe a sort of British Barack Obama?

What about you?

OP posts:
Whammyyammy · 19/02/2023 11:28

A party where the members are in touch with reality, and not all wealthy ex Eton types.
A party that tells the truth.
A party where members don't act for personal gain

Doubt will ever see those traits in a politician

Cuppsoupmonster · 19/02/2023 11:28

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 10:18

Identity politics are why we have equal pay and paid maternity leave.

No it isn’t.

DancingDaughter50 · 19/02/2023 11:25

Oh yes immediate laws and axcess to dignified end of life care eg choosing when to go.

It's not hard other countries mange it.

I can get doctors certifying me now to say I'm of sound mind and say at what stages I'd like to go..
The when I get to those stages another's doctor would assess and that is it.

It's my bloody life its undignified that I can't choose.

Cuppsoupmonster · 19/02/2023 10:51

@ACynicalDad actually I did as well now I think about it. Things felt quite stable for a bit, Cameron was a bit of a posh Tory boy but I think quite intelligent and he didn’t brush his hair with a balloon or try to be a ‘personality’.

Lwsimoo · 19/02/2023 10:27

Universal Basic Income, proportional representation, green investment bank, a new arm of HMRC that would be properly funded and independent from govt to investigate tax avoidance and evasion. A 90 % tax on the top 1% of earners. Re write the agriculture bill so it's more conservation based, fund a just transition from current practice to a more sustainable practice. End buy to let mortgages. Put a heavy tax on any second homes as Wales has done. Strip back intermediate management tiers of NHS, redirect funds into patient care. Rejoin the EU. or- Celtic Alliance - independent Wales, Scotland and Ireland - Westminster can go it alone if they want to be little England. A strong new bill for environmental and animal rights protection which would encompasses water quality, and huge huge fines for transgressions. New criminal legislation against environmental harm. An actual ban on fox hunting and any kind of blood sports.

squashyhat · 19/02/2023 10:24

Artisticpaint · 18/02/2023 23:19

Every MP should have to work out side of politics for three years, preferably in retail or manufacturing.
women’s rights would have to be key.

Or front-line health or social services. National Service for politicians.

DisappearingGirl · 19/02/2023 10:19

I'd vote for your party OP! I think New Labour (before the Iraq war) had it about right.

Also agree with PP that we won't get any of this without proportional representation where every vote counts.

Also the PP who said they are quite conservative in their politics but hate this Tory party ... I consider myself centre left but agreed with everything you said, which I found interesting.

Also sorry to mention the trans issue as don't want to derail the thread, but I'd love to see a party who dare to openly discuss this with the aim of pragmatic steps that support both trans people and female people. A big push for gender neutral spaces (in addition to single sex ones) would be the most obvious gain to me - this would also be useful for dads taking their daughters out (or mums with sons).

Sososocold · 19/02/2023 10:19

I'd too like to see a sensible party. There needs to be a very frank and honest conversation with us all about realistically can be provided.

I'd like to see a party who are willing to face the fact the NHS in its current form is not working and is willing to completely overhaul it in a sensible manner. There is too much waste, too many pen pushers and not enough boots on the ground. There needs to be a real look at boots on the ground staffing and ensuring there is enough of it all the time and not relying on current staff doing overtime. We really need to be honest with ourselves and realise that we are going to have to contribute to some of our healthcare. This needs to be done on a sliding scale or in bands like the (absolute gold dust) NHS dentist system.

I'd like a party who are going to face the elderly care crisis. We are only at the beginning, we have a large aging population. We need to be bringing back convalescent homes and step down care to help the hospital back log. This needs to be done on a large scale in most towns and all cities. All these over 50s developments been built should instead be warden flats or community care flats. So independent living with a warden who patrols for anyone who can live independently but susceptible to falls or just needs a bit of help all the way to independent living flats with a care team on site who visit every few hours to help with meds/ dressing/ toileting etc as home carers would but would actually only work on that site. This would be a halfway house between living independently in their own home and going into a residential care home. It allows carers to be on site so not travelling and if there are buzzers in the flats then help can be asked for quickly rather than carers discovering people laid on floors.

It would be nice to have a party committed to children's education and early years care. Look carefully at the funding of early years places to ensure providers are not short changed. Address class sizes (20 children max). Fund education so it can provide nurture provision/ learning mentors/ TAs in every class/ small booster groups/ reading recovery teachers. Schools should not be scrambling around trying to afford basic equipment like glue sticks and pencils. They should not be having to cut creative subjects purely to be able to buy new reading books. Scrap SATs - there are better ways to measure progress and performance that don't destroy child mental health. Education needs to stop been a hot political potato, get rid of all the wasteful think-tanks, put educators in charge of education and let the educators get on with it.

In regards to SEN, we need a government committed to building SEN schools and provision. SEN schools that cater for academic children with SEN. Schools that cater for children with mental health difficulties. Education provision that doesn't look like traditional school (forest school/ farm school/ community school). More choice than just schools that offer provision for moderate or severe learning needs or behaviour needs. We also need a government willing to get rid of this attendance pressure where SEN is a factor. SEN parents generally want their children to attend an education setting, getting into school is difficult for some children - they need support to do so and laddering where they may only attend 1 or 2 sessions a week and a planned slow integration to school life. Sending threatening letters about attendance helps no-one.

We are in dire need of residential places to offer respite services and holiday care for children. This requires a skilled and valued workforce. Plus funding for more that just 1-1 care to be provided.

I'd also like to see a commitment to energy and food security.

Looks like an impossible ask tbh.

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 10:18

Identity politics are why we have equal pay and paid maternity leave.

Cuppsoupmonster · 19/02/2023 10:11

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 10:08

Nice name change. Did you mistype when you went to change back?

No, I was going to start a thread about my housing woes but started typing and couldn’t be bothered!

ACynicalDad · 19/02/2023 10:10

I quite liked where the coalition were, that may make me unique. I wasn’t a fan of Blair/Brown they spent too much, but there was good there too. I don’t want a link to trade unions nor vested interests able to give £100k+. I don’t like state funding of political parties but think it might be the bests option. Dislike ERG types but also Corbyn types. If the Lib Dem’s did what it said on the tin then I’d be quite happy if they came through the middle but they are pretty bonkers these days. I liked Clegg, Alexander Laws - the Orange Bookers.

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 10:08

Nice name change. Did you mistype when you went to change back?

Cuppsoupmonster · 19/02/2023 10:04

Plus I’m on maternity…

And a remainer.

I’d make a rubbish Farage, wouldn’t I?

Its almost like the idea that somebody has mixed views and doesn’t 100% align to the right or the left really confuses people.

Cuppsoupmonster · 19/02/2023 10:03

I wish I earned enough to employ an accountant for tax avoidance purposes 😆

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 10:02

People who talk about ‘straight talking’ and ‘average working people’ are usually neither. Those who talk about ‘identity politics’ being divisive are often the kind of people that make identity politics a necessity. There’s a definite intersection of those who shout the loudest about people on benefits wanting something for nothing and those who have accountants to assist their tax avoidance and regard paid maternity leave as a step too far.

lljkk · 19/02/2023 09:40

If the main focus of your imaginary parties is women's right issues then they won't be parties for most people, not me either. So they won't get in power. But good luck with that. You all should start your ideal party & see how you get on. Prove me wrong.

Cuppsoupmonster · 19/02/2023 09:27

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 09:16

Sorry, not you, the OP.

No ‘identity politics’, ‘Straight talking people’, ‘average working people and families’

I can’t say I was surprised to see them go on to say

‘This is exactly how I feel. Life is not ‘free’ yet there seem to be an awful lot of people who expect it to be,’

’Nobody should be out of work because they’re ‘depressed’ or similar. I can see the need for being signed off on a reasonably short term basis through depression but not a life of doing nothing and being on benefits.’

Which part of that is either wrong or like Nigel Farage?

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 19/02/2023 09:25

I would like religion to be removed from party politics. I live in Northern Ireland and while politics here is meant to be secular it really bloody isn't. I am utterly fed up with the tribalism.
I'd also like to be able to vote for the same parties that actually rule in Westminster and not feel like some sort of parochial backwater (which NI currently is).
I absolutely love where I live but I bloody hate the factionalism that festers here.

Tandora · 19/02/2023 09:20

I knew some nastiness about trans people would be headlining there somewhere. What is it with people at the moment 😡🤯

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 09:16

Sorry, not you, the OP.

No ‘identity politics’, ‘Straight talking people’, ‘average working people and families’

I can’t say I was surprised to see them go on to say

‘This is exactly how I feel. Life is not ‘free’ yet there seem to be an awful lot of people who expect it to be,’

’Nobody should be out of work because they’re ‘depressed’ or similar. I can see the need for being signed off on a reasonably short term basis through depression but not a life of doing nothing and being on benefits.’

DancingDaughter50 · 19/02/2023 09:12

The party that recognises its own limits and gets experts in for big decisions like NHS and schools.

As well as asking the lowest down people in an organisation for their feedback.

A party which categorically understand women rights and safeguards my dd future.

One that is balanced and understands we need more schools not less.

We need far more primary schools and smaller classes with proper steps to identity children with sen and get them proper support. That's where children's educational inequality lies not with grammar. Make sure every child can actually read before they leave primary and use a range of methods if phonics isn't working, drop it.

We need a party that understands rose Smith is not able to suddenly head up education because she's got no experience of it.. We must have experts and I don't mean politically driven tribal political ones.

Wheredowelive · 19/02/2023 09:08

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 09:06

You sound like Nigel Farage.

How?

Aurorabored · 19/02/2023 09:06

You sound like Nigel Farage.

Wheredowelive · 19/02/2023 09:05

FindingMeno · 19/02/2023 09:00

Something so refreshing and new that it turns society as we know it upside down.
Redistribution of wealth and power from the billionaires and corporations.
Make wealth beyond your needs something to be ashamed of, not aspire to.
I don't know how it would happen, but it's the society I'd like to see.

See this is very much ‘the mumsnet view’ but how on Earth would you attract investment with that??

magnifying · 19/02/2023 09:04

I'd like a party that canvassed the people across the U.K. and developed policies where there was areas of consensus. Often it feels like policies are determined by lobbyists or people stuck in a Westminster bubble.