Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not wanting SD to stay in house while we are away

145 replies

guiling · 18/02/2023 20:42

DH and I have 2 under 5s, he has a DD from when he was a teenager, she is now 33.

She lives just over an hour away in a well known beautiful city where she has a great job she loves. However she is quite negative about the city and very anxious about not being in a relationship and maybe not having children. As a result she very often stays with us at weekends, and we have always told her she is welcome to come as much as she wants to. We have a good relationship.

I genuinely want her to be happy and to feel she has a home to come to when needed (her mother lives 3 hours away so we are easier to come to). I overlook niggles when she is here for this reason - such as:

  • she rarely cleans up / tidies up after herself
  • she often leaves lots of lights on eg bathroom or her bedroom after she has left the house,
  • on two occasions there have been several big obvious bloodstains on the sheets which she hasn't attempted to clean.
  • she always "forgets" to take her shoes off to go upstairs which is a house rule
  • she very often forgets or leaves her keys behind so we have made numerous copies for her / lent her ours (which she has sometimes lost!)

We live in London and while partly she wants to see us, a large factor is also going out to parties etc. She will often come back at 4-5am and then sleep all day. So barely sees us often.

The dilemma - soon we will be away for 4 weeks in the UK. Partly a holiday but partly helping an aunt with something (and we will be working from there at times).

I know that we will be asked if she can house sit and I'm just not comfortable with it mainly for the reasons above. I'm happy to welcome her to her father's home to visit, but not for it to be used as a party base while we are away.

AIBU if I say no?

OP posts:
2013isback · 18/02/2023 23:54

Where does your husband stand on the issues you've been having when she stays while the whole family's home - e.g., losing the keys, leaving the lights on, etc? Is he as bothered as you are? Is he also reminding her each time she "forgets"? Is he doing his share of cleaning up after her, or all of it? If so, he may be in agreement with you that she shouldn't stay.

If not, it's awkward. If you're worried that she'll ask her dad if she can stay and he'll say yes without talking with you first, I think you do have to preempt it, even though it might be uncomfortable to bring it up with him if she hasn't asked. You're not unreasonable to say no if you know you'd be miserable during your trip worrying about what's happening at home. The keys thing alone would worry me, but over a month all kinds of things could come up that she'll deal with badly if she's not able to remember basic common sense things like keys or treat the house or her family with respect and common sense.

I suppose you could install a combo lockbox, put all of the house lights on a timer or motion sensor, and put wipeable runners on the most traffic'd parts of the floors and plastic covers on her bed - but it's annoying to have to toddler-proof the house for a 33yo when you haven't had to do it for the actual toddlers.

FingerPuppet · 18/02/2023 23:52

I don't know. I can't imagine not being welcome in my parents home, even if they weren't there at the time.

She is quite clearly welcome at her father’s home, though.

Would your parents be okay with you treating their home the way the SD is treating the OP’s home?

Mine wouldn’t tolerate it at all, not that I would be that disrespectful in the first place.

frazzledasarock · 18/02/2023 23:51

Oh please. I would not want any adult who behaved like a pig living in my home whilst I wasn’t there.

sounds like she’ll trash the house and lose the keys anyway leaving it more likely to be broken into than if you locked it up and turned the alarm on when you leave.

And yes leaving bodily fluids for someone else to clean up is disgusting. And I’ve never had a period leak and not noticed it, and I’ve never ever left my period stains to be cleaned up by someone else.

if you treat someone’s home like a shithole they’re not going to trust you to live there in their absence.

and this is not her parents home it’s not her childhood home. It’s her father and step mothers home and she’s a guest when she goes over.

My DH has a step mum and a similar age gap between his half siblings. No way would he treat his dads home the way this grown ass woman treats her fathers.

HanSB · 18/02/2023 23:47

There can't be much of an age difference between you both if you have under 5s? There is a huge difference in your personalities and where you are in your lives and I expect she just doesn't realise the things that annoy other people if she's usually messy and lives alone. You need to have a good talk with her about expectations as a guest in your home, whether she stays for one night or for longer and that it is upsetting and disrespectful to be used as hotel whilst not considering your family and feelings.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/02/2023 23:46

SchoolTripDrama · 18/02/2023 22:35

@IDontWantToBeAPie Yeah? I'm 28 and go to parties all the time. My friends are 25 to 39 all without kids and parties are common. They're 33 not 83.

That's quite sad. In fact it's very sad 😔

Lol.

How on earth is it sad to see friends, listen to music, dance, play games, have fun? Would you rather we sat at home and watched TV?

We all live in London, don't have kids yet and have free time we enjoy spending together.

Parties doesn't just mean teenagers vomiting cider behind the park... we are all professionals earning £35-150k, we own our homes or rent beautiful spaces, we go to museums and art galleries and restaurants and yes.. party together 😂

Thinking it's sad to be a 33yo having friends and enjoying parties is frankly Victorian.

Upsidedownagain · 18/02/2023 23:46

Surely she won't be staying for the whole month if she has a place to live and a job an hour away? Just weekends?

As a member of the family, I feel you should let her but I would make it very clear that you expect her to tidy up after herself. And if she loses her key, that is her problem.

OldFan · 18/02/2023 23:45

@SchoolTripDrama I'd say going to parties is the opposite of sad (though I'd disapprove if there were drugs involved.) 33 isn't old.

@guiling Could there be a cleaner if she does stay? She could pay for them and a bit towards the electric bill. That might be enough to put her off coming, anyway.

katepilar · 18/02/2023 23:44

OP, I cant blame you that you dont want her to stay, I wouldnt either. She clearly have issues, but they are not yours to solve.

Fedupfatandfrumpy · 18/02/2023 23:42

YANBU - I am a stepdaughter and younger than your SD. I wouldn't dream of behaving the way she does. You're right to have concerns OP. It's your home not a hotel.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/02/2023 23:42

@katepilar some of my high thread count sheets can't be put in the e washing machine or soaked with certain things. It affects the thread count. They're dry clean.

Cotton or poly etc obviously can be soaked with salt and then washed.

Some of my linen that were expensive won't get blood out until I take them to a specialist cleaner.

Obviously.

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/02/2023 23:41

SchoolTripDrama · 18/02/2023 22:35

@IDontWantToBeAPie Yeah? I'm 28 and go to parties all the time. My friends are 25 to 39 all without kids and parties are common. They're 33 not 83.

That's quite sad. In fact it's very sad 😔

Why is going to parties sad?!

katepilar · 18/02/2023 23:40

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/02/2023 22:14

I'd let her stay. It's good to have the lights/boiler/ heating used when you're away.

Nothing you've said is massive. She'll have to clean up if she's h to r only one there. Period mishaps happen... she probably didn't know what type of sheets you have.

type of sheets? what do you mean by that?

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/02/2023 23:40

Well you are entitled to say no, but it’s not very friendly given it’s her Dad’s house.

What I would do is say you are welcome to stay, but while we’re on the topic these are the house rules, you don’t follow them, you need to start following them. She needs some boundaries as she is stuck in an extended adolescence.

Namechange44000 · 18/02/2023 23:35

My SD is just like this. Also early 30s. It’s amazing she can hold
down a job to be honest. I always thought she’d improve as she matured but she hasn’t. She’s a complete nightmare for being considerate and the way she treats our place. I actually thought she was a one off but sounds like she may have been separated from her twin at birth. I wouldn’t leave my SD alone in my house for a few hours let alone a few weeks.

NatashaDancing · 18/02/2023 23:34

Isahlo · 18/02/2023 21:20

How would having an adult child sleep in your house invalidate home insurance- just spent a minute going through and can’t see why,

It wouldn't. I'd be more worried about having no one there for 4 weeks.

Whataretheodds · 18/02/2023 23:33

SchoolTripDrama · 18/02/2023 22:35

@IDontWantToBeAPie Yeah? I'm 28 and go to parties all the time. My friends are 25 to 39 all without kids and parties are common. They're 33 not 83.

That's quite sad. In fact it's very sad 😔

Sad? How so? What should we be doing instead? Staying in every evening?

OP, I don't see the appeal in a 'housesitter' that leaves the place messy/dirty.

Has your husband spoken to her about having respect for your home? If not does he know how you feel about it?

marchella · 18/02/2023 23:29

Geepee71 · 18/02/2023 20:45

Won't it invalidate your home insurance if she stays?

I've seen a few people say similar things. Why would it invalidate your insurance? How do people go away/do house swaps? I've never heard of it except for here.
OP - I don't think your reasons are great but I understand not wanting someone living in your house. I'm not a big fan of it ( though have done it for holidays/ petsitting etc.

AnneLovesGilbert · 18/02/2023 23:26

Not sure why people are focussing on the period leak. Though all that required was to notice the sheets as she made her bed, strip it instead and stick a wash on or at least tell OP or her dad.

She leaves lights on, rolls in at 4 or 5 am, sometimes without her keys, sleeps half the day, and thinks she’s too important to tidy up after herself.

She can be lazy and have poor standards in her own home but it’s not okay in someone else’s.

The only reason anyone is defending this is that OP is this woman’s stepmum. Turns out being from a broken home is a get out of jail card well into your thirties - I really missed a trick there as a poor step child, how silly of me. Wasted opportunity to act like a teenager under someone else’s roof and expect to get away with it.

Aldith · 18/02/2023 23:24

OP I’m a Xennial (1984) and would not treat a house like that. I cannot say I would be innocent of doing that at 18 but 20 years later and things change.

Your SD is showing a complete lack of disrespect for your house rules which does make things awkward. As a stepmother myself I know how difficult that line is to tread. I would probably let her stay but have her dad read the rules of what you expect in your home and how you expect it to look when you get back. If she fails then she does not get to stay alone again. You have to give her some responsibility though or she will forever act like a teenager.

Inertia · 18/02/2023 23:22

She’s got a lot of form for losing keys. That would make it too much of a security risk for me. Ordinarily it would be better to have an adult there than leave the house unoccupied, but not if she’s losing keys/ not locking up properly/ not switching things off before leaving. The anxiety of potentially having to check all that ever day would make me say no.

FingerPuppet · 18/02/2023 23:22

She's a millennial, the ones in our family are still treated like teenagers despite being in their early thirties. I'm sure not all millennials are like this, but the ones I have dealings with, in our family and through work etc, are a bit like your SC.

No. She is a grown woman.

I’m 34 and I couldn’t imagine living like this. No one I know that’s my age lives like this.

I can’t wrap my head around the fact that she left her blood soaked bed sheets for you to clean. Or that she cannot take her shoes off to go upstairs. Or clean up after herself. I find all this quite shocking, actually.

I have two children under 5 too OP, and I would not tolerate another adult in our home who was regularly coming home drunk at 4am/5am, regardless of their relationship to me.

None of this is okay.

I think you need to rethink your offer of her coming to stay with you guys whenever she likes. Will she still be coming to sleepover at weekends when she is in her 40s?

She needs to build her own life, and you need to be a little less available.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 18/02/2023 23:16

She’s 33. does she lose the keys to her own home or is it just your keys she doesn’t care enough about? Certainly old enough to have an adult conversation.

Susan-we need to talk. We love having you visit and we are really glad you see our home as your home. However, there are some issues cropping up that we need to talk about so that they don’t become massive problems and I don’t want us to fall out. We would like you to be more considerate when here; you are a grown woman and should behave as such. You need to turn lights off when you leave rooms, stop losing your house keys, clean up after yourself, strip your bed and put a load of washing on. Plus whatever non negotiables there are; and have the conversation with her dad there so she sees a united front.

Wearingatshirt · 18/02/2023 23:09

From the point where she's lost sets of keys then I'd be inclined to say no as a security risk and unreliable.

DulcetTones · 18/02/2023 23:08

Not cleaning the sheets is gross. Acting like a teenager in your parent's home at the age of 33 is annoying. (Can't be bothered to help with the cleaning? Disregards house rules? Sleeps all day after partying all night, etc. Yes, that's annoying in a house guest, even if she is your husband's adult child.)

I'd be worried she wouldn't treat your home and belongings with respect, but the bigger concerns are the higher bills and the security of the house, if she can't be trusted to not lose her keys. She honestly sounds incredibly immature for 33, and I wouldn't want her in my house when I was away.

However, telling her she can't stay probably will cause some awkwardness and bad feeling. Even saying that she'd have to pay the bills while you're away might be uncomfortable. Considering that she behaves like a teenager, I'm assuming that none of you have the type of relationship where you can comfortably tell her what to do/how to behave. And to be honest, when the adult child is 33, that ship may have sailed!

SunburstsOrMarbleHalls · 18/02/2023 23:02

DSD should definitely be more respectful of house rules. I can completely understand how this must frustrate you especially if this is repeated behaviour.

It sounds like she is switching off and reverting to a teenager when she visits.

I know a lot of people think the blood stains on the sheets are grim but she may genuinely be embarrassed and not know how to bring the topic up with you or her dad. Has a specific conversation about blood stained sheets taken place? along the lines of accidents happen but if she can give them a clean that would be really appreciated?

Fast forward a few decades, would you allow your own children to visit/stay in your house if they behaved the same? If the answer is no then stick to your guns with your DH.

My DD is like this re electric usage, keys and tidying but had ADD. She has a great job so all her mental focus is spent in work and not in her personal down time. It can be frustrating but it is what it is. I offset the inconvenience of tidying up when I get home with the fact she is doing me a favour house sitting and I would rather have someone present in the house for security.

Although frustrating nothing you have said is majorly awful so I would try again a discussion about house rules.

She most definitely is capitalising on the convenience of her dad living in London, she may think this is fine if not told any different. As long as her partying ended before she returned to the house and she was not routinely waking the household up on her return that wouldn't bother me.