Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to borrow £££ to

82 replies

cherry2727 · 18/02/2023 20:09

Extend our house ? We bought a small 2 bed 1930s semi less than 10 years ago and haven't done much to it since .
Dh and I now in a comfortable position financially after years of struggling . We have circa £2k of disposable income after bills . Not life changing but it's a lot to us as I've worked hard to get to a very good place in my career .

We have about £200k equity in the house and I suggested that we could borrow £100k with a repayment of £800 over 15 years to extend the property . It's quite small ( open plan) and doesn't work well for entertaining and downstairs space . He nearly hit the roof! We ended up arguing and him saying that I was trying to drag us into financial ruin! I work so hard and I just feel like we are stuck in this small house and I have little prospects of having a more comfortable home or even buying a bigger house.For background he is very laid back and I'm a lot more ambitious if that helps .

I honestly don't want to put us into financial ruin but I just assumed that this was the natural progression as we couldn't afford to move house . Isn't that what most people in our position do? I'm really curious whether I'm asking for too much? How do people afford extensions without saving for a decade ? Am I really in the wrong to suggest such? I am new to all of this and just assumed that everyone borrowed more to invest into their property. He isn't speaking to me and doesn't want to discuss it further . I feel soo deflated but also open to whether I am being unreasonable. Thank you

OP posts:
cherry2727 · 18/02/2023 22:04

Sounds like I might have to apologise to dh for coming up with a stupid suggestion - I feel soo ashamed . I do feel a bit angry at him as I was only suggesting something to help out our family life so my motive was in the right place even though clearly wasn't the best idea. He made me feel like I was deliberately dragging us into unnecessary debt when that wasn't my motive at all.

OP posts:
cherry2727 · 18/02/2023 22:01

@Starseeking thank you for breaking it down like this - I stupidly just assumed that borrowing more would be more viable than moving house . We were lucky to be tied into our last mortgage deal prior to the interest rate rises so I wouldn't want to lose such a deal . I will contact our broker who we used years ago to explore our options .

@Iknownononono I think I misunderstood the term equity and so worked it out incorrectly- thank you for the clarification. I earn 70k and dh earns 28k so jointly it's over 65k. We were looking at a rear extension with kitchen . Building costs are soo expensive post Brexit- we couldn't also get a loft conversion with this money , sadly . I do agree that's it's all relative and specific to everyone's situation. I will make contact with our old broker on Monday and hope for the best . If not , we will have to save for a few years like a poster suggested .

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 18/02/2023 21:54

There is always a danger that a large extension may mean that your investment is beyond the limit for the street, would you not be better moving into a larger house?

QuietlyConfident · 18/02/2023 21:53

Building work is a nightmare at the moment. Unless a close friend or family member is a good builder and prepared to prioritise your work, moving to a bigger house would be less expensive and stressful (and even if your best mate did run a building firm materials would still be hugely expensive, and unpredictable over the course of the project).

If you add the state of interest rates at the moment I can see why your DH thinks it's a terrible idea.

hettie · 18/02/2023 21:50

Would spending that much on that property mean that it was at least worth 100k more? Before we did the when on our current pace we had it valued and asked the two estate agents who valued it what it would be worth if we did xyz work on it.

Iknownononono · 18/02/2023 21:49

Ok, work the numbers.

You bought for £250,000 and it's now worth £430,000 - that's £180,000 increase. Surely you paid more than £20,000 over the last ten years (including your initial deposit) towards the equity of the property? You should have significantly more than £200,000 in equity.

You want to spend £100,000 on an extension - presumably you'll get an extra bedroom for that but potentially not given that you've not mentioned the upstairs in your OP and (frankly) building prices are mad right now. So, if 3 bedroom properties are selling for £500,000 in your area then you've spent £144,000 (when you factor in the interest on the loan) on an extension that only increased your property value by £70,000. Spending £144,000 to get £70,000 is patently a terrible idea.

If you can afford to pay £1800 to a lender and you have (probably in excess of) £200,000 equity, why can't you afford to move to a £500,000 3-bedroom property? On a standard 4.5x multiplier, you'd need an annual income of just below £67,000 (plus enough for stamp duty and fees etc) but it should definitely be feasible. If your income is less than that then, frankly, you absolutely should not be repaying £1800 to your lender. If you cannot afford to move then you cannot afford to extend.

Flatly, the numbers do not add up to anywhere near a sensible decision. You'd be throwing away thousands and thousands of pounds, not to mention the risk that you default on the payments if cost of living gets too much or something impacts either of your incomes. Plenty of people are commenting that they did it but that's entirely irrelevant - they aren't you, they aren't living in your house, they don't have your income. It's a bit like asking "should I lose 10kg" and overweight people might say "I lost 10kg and I feel way better" but if you're significantly underweight then losing 10kg is an awful idea. Based on what you've said here, you absolutely should not do this.

Starseeking · 18/02/2023 21:42

@cherry2727 If you purchased a new property for £550k, you would only pay a mortgage on £270k, assuming that you rolled all your current £280k equity into it.

Your new total mortgage repayment on current rates would be about £1,400 per month. It would be worth you speaking to a (free) broker to get actuals based on your income and expenditure as those are just rough figures I calculated based on the thread information.

You'd need to consider whether your DH would be prepared to move house for more space, given he doesn't currently want to do work to the house.

Babyroobs · 18/02/2023 21:14

We extended when dh inherited some money so was able to pay outright but I don't think we would have borrowed extra to do it as we are just too cautious. It depends on your situation though and if you have 2k a month 'spare' then it sounds like you could afford it as long as your job is secure etc. Having extra space is life changing and does improve quality of life no end.

cherry2727 · 18/02/2023 21:11

@Starseeking - Hmmm do you think it's work spending to a broker on this? I've plugged the figures unto a mortgage calculator and repayments are roughly £1900 a month on a £550,000 mortgage over 20 years .

We currently owe 150k on our mortgage
House worth 430k with 15 years left on mortgage . It's a battle field for me - I just don't have a clue what is the best option and mr brain box isn't helping at all by sulking!

@HazardaGuest we have one ds who is 7. Our garden is currently 80 feet long and we looked into a 6 x3m rear extension so we would still have a decent size of garden left - well enough to stick a garden table and dreaded trampoline ! Lol

OP posts:
HazardaGuest · 18/02/2023 20:50

Do you have children yet, because you could really regret losing the garden space when they come along.

Starseeking · 18/02/2023 20:48

With those figures, you could easily buy a 3 bedroom place for say £550k, with a mortgage of 65% LTV, given your significant equity.

Granted mortgage interest rates aren't great at the moment, but that would give you a larger, better laid out footprint downstairs, than extending the 2 bedroom house, which is more likely to be a long thin property.

cherry2727 · 18/02/2023 20:40

Ah that's lovely to hear @Soonenough . I'm pleased it worked out well for you.

Sadly we don't have any grand savings just a few months worth. My dh is definitely one who is comfortable- he says he likes the idea of us paying £1k a month towards our mortgage and our overheads are low and wants to keep it that way. We do have a 13 years gap so perhaps he just wants to settle down and coast to retirement whereas I feel like life has just begun. I feel a bit deflated but I guess it's a dose of reality

OP posts:
Soonenough · 18/02/2023 20:32

I did this and have never regretted it . Total mortgage payment of £1800 is not too bad . Disposable income would be £1200 which is quite good. It would have to be adding more value on property , give you more living space that would still be relevant in next 10 years or so. Do you have any other funds in case of ML or unemployment?

My EXDH was reluctant as he was content with the house, as I think a lot of men are . It works OK for them . However , the extension brought such pleasure for many years . I still love it and hope my son or daughter will buy it when I am ready to leave it.

cherry2727 · 18/02/2023 20:32

Interesting perspectives- thank you

We bought the house for 250k and it's now worth circa 430k so we didn't buy anything fancy. We can't afford to move as an extra bedroom where we live is roughly 500k and upwards . We would have to stay here for a very long time so I just assumed that if we extend for less than we would need a bigger mortgage for we could be a bit more comfortable.

Building costs are dire - we are being quoted 3k per sqm for a permitted extension- it's unbelievable!

@Iknownononono I didn't consider the cost in interest per year - I just looked at affordability. I will have to now take this into consideration.

@MojoMoon yes I totally agree - our communication is really bad - mainly from his side . He shuts down whenever we don't agree - happens all the time. I'm not one who shouts or throws abusive or swear words around but he finds it quiet difficult to express himself when we don't agree . I
Don't know what to suggest to make him better - I guess some adults are raised with this skill and some aren't .

OP posts:
Blinkingheckythump · 18/02/2023 20:24

HazardaGuest · 18/02/2023 20:19

I don’t understand why you can afford this but can’t afford to move?

I'm glad I'm not the only one thinking this

Candleabra · 18/02/2023 20:23

Building costs are so expensive at the moment. It’s double, even treble what it was even a few years ago. If you’re looking to release that amount of equity I would honestly look into moving first.

Tohaveandtohold · 18/02/2023 20:21

I wouldn’t do it personally. Spending almost half of what you now have as your disposable income on the extension surely requires so much thought so I don’t think your DH is being unreasonable as he’s just cautious.
Also you need to see if what you do on the house will provide as much returns as well.

DashboardConfessional · 18/02/2023 20:20

I mean if you are looking at paying a lender £1800 per month, then surely you could take your 200k deposit and buy something bigger? Unless you mean you paid £500k somewhere posh for this 2 bed!

AlwaysLatte · 18/02/2023 20:20

Given those figures I wouldn't. It's not a financially smart move at all so I'm with your DH on this one. Could you consider a garden office or loft extension instead?

HazardaGuest · 18/02/2023 20:19

I don’t understand why you can afford this but can’t afford to move?

MojoMoon · 18/02/2023 20:19

It would be sensible to understand how much value you would realistically add to the house by doing so.

But really the main problem here is the communication between you.

Regardless of whether it is a good idea or not, the possibility of extending the house is something a couple should be able to have a respectful and civilised discussion about. Not have him "hit the roof" and then have a massive sulk.

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2023 20:19

It's a perfectly usual thing to do. My DD has remortgaged, as the value and her wages went up. She's taken down walls and extended the kitchen. She's put as much value on as she's spent. A lot of people buy with a view to improving by remortgaging later on. Do you have seperate savings? What's his plan with his?

Fuckthebucket · 18/02/2023 20:18

You are not being unreasonable. We’ve extended recently and added £80k onto the mortgage to afford to do it. Plus we also saved for the new kitchen, bathroom etc.

I understand your DH’s reticence though; I did feel twitchy at the thought of adding so much to our mortgage when it was comparatively low.

Building work is not cheap now, ours began before the price of materials started to rise and it would be prohibitively more expensive now. So if you do borrow against your mortgage, I’d recommend you check and then double check that it’s worth it eg. You’d made the money back or you’d be staying in the house for long enough that it makes your time there significantly better.

pawz · 18/02/2023 20:17

£800 a month to repay for the next 15 years is a huge huge extra burden to take on, on top of your mortgage. If you have 2k at the moment a month surplus, putting almost half of that surplus into a debt repayment is not something I would personally see as a good financial choice.

That's assuming for the next 15 years your earnings won't drop, a huge recession won't hit, COL won't impact other payments etc. If you're now in a comfortable place after years of struggling I wouldn't be rushing to take on another 100k+ of debt.

Personally I think you could save for eight years and then be able to do it out of savings - if eight years of saving for it doesn't seem worth it - then 15 years of replacements isn't worth it - that's how I look at things when deciding what to risk!

Iknownononono · 18/02/2023 20:17

I agree with him - I think you're nuts.

  1. Interest rates are very high - it's a terrible, terrible time to borrow.
  2. Releasing £100,000 for a small 2-bedroom property is awful from a financial perspective. You'll almost certainly never make that back because of the street cap and plot size etc.
  3. You'd only leave yourselves £300 per week after bills, that's very risky.
  4. If you can't afford to move then why on earth do you think you can afford this?
  5. Have you realised that this plan is costing you £3000 per year just in interest? Think how many venues you could rent for hosting people for £3000 per year.

Your idea is, frankly, so bad that if my DH insisted on it then I'd seriously consider divorce. Many people borrow to invest in their property, in fact, property is one of the safest and most certain ways to invest - but not like you've suggested.

Swipe left for the next trending thread