Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second visit from MIL

167 replies

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 15:51

I posted here a couple of weeks ago after MIL's first visit when she made a few comments about DD's appearance and didn't bring a gift - a lot of posters felt I was BU which in hindsight was fair, and I definitely felt a lot better about things after the immediate post-birth hormone surge had died down but this weekend is MIL's second visit. She's brought along FIL and SIL this time which is nice as they'd not met our 5 week old yet.

SIL arrived last night, stayed with us and had lots of cuddles.

FIL and MIL wanted to get a hotel and stay the whole weekend which is fair enough. They arrived in the car this morning at 11.

MIL held baby for about 20 minutes and at 12 o'clock she announced she was going into town to get her eyebrows done. And was taking SIL as she hasn't been here before, to show her the city.

They're still gone.

Is this weird? Would you travel 3 hours to visit grandchild and then just disappear for hours on end? Or am I again being oversensitive?

I didn't even get chance to suggest we all go - obviously we can't just leave the house on a whim with a newborn but it would have been nice to all go out together?

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · 18/02/2023 21:55

@Eyerollcentral
I’ve thought that OP provided them entertainment - she gave birth to their grandchild whom they came to see. They didn’t come because of local architecture, did they ?

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:53

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:38

Again, I agree that I should have said something or asked to come too, or even better, arranged something beforehand - but DH arranged everything (I'm not on the family WA) and I said previously I can't be spontaneous and just up and leave baby as she is breastfed, so she would have to come too. And also - getting brows done isn't a family activity, so not sure we would have been welcome anyway?

I haven't been spiky or unwelcoming to them though, at least never intentionally. FIL was happy enough to snooze anyway.

But you could have taken the baby and gotten your own brows done, had a look round the shops, had a bite to eat all three of you. It’s just really about spending time together isn’t it? Or are you saying you only wanted them to stay at home all day. You do have a five week old baby so it would be completely understandable if you did. Do you not contact your mil or SIL yourself at all? Not sure saying FIL was happy enough to spend afternoon snoozing on my couch is the best comparison to show your friendliness OP, the man was unconscious! It doesn’t sound like you are particularly close with your in laws to begin with. Saying I have not intentionally been rude or cold to them is not the same as saying I extended the same warm welcome to my home as I do to all visitors. Some people just don’t like to be stuck at home all day, I have family members like that, is that the kind of personality your MIL has? It can be annoying but I think lack of communication is the biggest problem here, not deliberate snubs. As others have said they may have thought she doesn’t want us sitting looking at her all day expecting food and entertainment. Newborn babies are of course beautiful but twenty mins at a time probably max for anyone bar the parents to gaze at a likely sleeping baby.

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:52

Eastereggsboxedupready · 18/02/2023 21:46

Who is sorting the evening meal tonight op? Did mil bring cakes back? A gift? Flowers? Seems her visit is a box ticking trip to tell people she came..

MIL and SIL brought some bits back for dinner and DH went out for the rest. I'll be sure to be eternally grateful!

OP posts:
pizzaHeart · 18/02/2023 21:51

I’ve read a few pages and can’t understand why you’re getting such a hard time here. Of course you expect your in-laws to come and see you, their son and their GDC. There is a perfect medium between trying to take baby away from her parents and just looking at her for a few minutes. Your MIL could chat with you, take baby for a walk, watch her sleep, cook you a special dish or whatever. It looked like she just needed to get rid of FiL and their dog for a day to do shopping with her daughter. PPs were saying that your MIL couldn’t win, well she could, simply by behaving like a normal grandma without any sort of extremities.

NosieRosie · 18/02/2023 21:50

YANBU

What grandparent travels to meet their gc and then spends most of their time in town without the gc or the parent? It beggars belief!

The only people your dc can count on is their parents OP. Anyone else will visit to suit their own agenda

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 21:46

And eye roll, you sound super spikey!

Eastereggsboxedupready · 18/02/2023 21:46

Who is sorting the evening meal tonight op? Did mil bring cakes back? A gift? Flowers? Seems her visit is a box ticking trip to tell people she came..

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 21:45

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:22

Were you welcoming when they arrived this weekend? I mean obvs No one expects you to roll out the red carpet when you have just had a c section and that kind of disingenuous reply does somewhat give the impression you may be spiky in real life. If you haven’t organised or discussed what people wanted to do over the weekend I don’t think you can be very surprised if they make their own arrangements, I know you have a very young baby but two seconds sends a WhatsApp in the family group saying looking forward to seeing you at weekend, what does everyone fancy doing Saturday (baby dependant of course!)? Or even better asking your partner to raise it with them before they arrived. Also unless your mil is the flash she wasn’t gone and out the door in ten seconds or less. All you had to say was shall I come too? Give me ten minutes to get ready or ok we’ll how about I meet you both in an hour or two and we can have a walk or grab a coffee?

WTF was disingenuous about that?

This is just bullying.

She doesn't have to be an events manager just because her in-laws are coming over.

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:45

Thanks @Googlelafy

This is exactly what I think, unfortunately. They bought lots of nice things in town and she's going back tomorrow. When they came back, SIL (who did buy a gift) wanted baby back but MIL was only interested in having dinner. It does sting but maybe she's just not a baby person. Not every grandparent is - I'll just have to get over it.

OP posts:
Jdjdntbhh · 18/02/2023 21:44

Giving you space to have a snooze and not overwhelm you?

Googlelafy · 18/02/2023 21:39

I cannot get over that your mother in law did not buy a gift for her grand daughter. She clearly came for a shopping trip but surely could have spent more than 20 minutes with her grandchild. I feel the same as you. You are NOT unreasonable.

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:38

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:22

Were you welcoming when they arrived this weekend? I mean obvs No one expects you to roll out the red carpet when you have just had a c section and that kind of disingenuous reply does somewhat give the impression you may be spiky in real life. If you haven’t organised or discussed what people wanted to do over the weekend I don’t think you can be very surprised if they make their own arrangements, I know you have a very young baby but two seconds sends a WhatsApp in the family group saying looking forward to seeing you at weekend, what does everyone fancy doing Saturday (baby dependant of course!)? Or even better asking your partner to raise it with them before they arrived. Also unless your mil is the flash she wasn’t gone and out the door in ten seconds or less. All you had to say was shall I come too? Give me ten minutes to get ready or ok we’ll how about I meet you both in an hour or two and we can have a walk or grab a coffee?

Again, I agree that I should have said something or asked to come too, or even better, arranged something beforehand - but DH arranged everything (I'm not on the family WA) and I said previously I can't be spontaneous and just up and leave baby as she is breastfed, so she would have to come too. And also - getting brows done isn't a family activity, so not sure we would have been welcome anyway?

I haven't been spiky or unwelcoming to them though, at least never intentionally. FIL was happy enough to snooze anyway.

OP posts:
jannier · 18/02/2023 21:37

Maybe she's on here and read the numerous anti mil and nobody can visit posts so is trying to follow advice.

StarsSand · 18/02/2023 21:29

Oh my goodness.

I would have given ANYTHING for my MIL to have held the baby for 20 minutes before politely fucking off to give me some space.

I had PIL parked on my sofa making my life a misery on a daily basis and it contributed to me developing PND.

It's good manners to keep visits short with a newborn.

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:22

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:07

@Eyerollcentral

Thanks for your comments. Maybe I'm not the most warm and enthusiastic person ever but we got on well before baby arrived. MIL has met her twice now - the first time she was just a few days old and I was absolutely wrecked by the C-section and lack of sleep. If I came across cold on that occasion, I didn't mean to. But she held baby lots (I'm not precious of that) and seemed happy enough. Not sure I had time to come across sulky today before she left.

And I conceded I should have arranged for us all to do something beforehand. But it all happened so fast - literally she handed me back the baby, got her shoes on and was out the door. Honestly! FIL didn't even know she was going to get her brows done and missed her saying so, it happened so fast.

Were you welcoming when they arrived this weekend? I mean obvs No one expects you to roll out the red carpet when you have just had a c section and that kind of disingenuous reply does somewhat give the impression you may be spiky in real life. If you haven’t organised or discussed what people wanted to do over the weekend I don’t think you can be very surprised if they make their own arrangements, I know you have a very young baby but two seconds sends a WhatsApp in the family group saying looking forward to seeing you at weekend, what does everyone fancy doing Saturday (baby dependant of course!)? Or even better asking your partner to raise it with them before they arrived. Also unless your mil is the flash she wasn’t gone and out the door in ten seconds or less. All you had to say was shall I come too? Give me ten minutes to get ready or ok we’ll how about I meet you both in an hour or two and we can have a walk or grab a coffee?

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 21:21

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 20:58

And again OP why didn’t you say oh I thought we’d do something together today instead of immediately taking offence and going off on an online strop? A lot of passive aggressive behaviour, which a lot of people just cba with

That's so unfair. She's a new mother. No one could have predicted such oddness let alone how to manage it.

smileladiesplease · 18/02/2023 21:15

I think you have too high expectations of you and others. Chill. You can't change people but you can accept both yourself and others.

Parenting is a marathon not a sprint so enjoy it.

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:12

ensayers · 18/02/2023 21:02

Maybe mil or sil can only tolerate you or DH or kids for short periods of time?
If you didn't live so far away maybe they would of just popped round for a couple of hours instead of whole weekend, but because they came so far it doesn't feel right to stay 2 hours then drive home.

The reason I've never been to my brother's house, which is 3 hours away, is because after the first hour there would be a lot of silence and I'd be trying to think of excuses to leave, but it's so far away that a one hour stay feels wrong.

Not sure that's the reason - they were all keen to come and stay with us at Christmas, but we had to cancel (with a month's notice) due to complications with my pregnancy and baby was born early. We hosted them for Christmas 2021 all day though.

OP posts:
BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 21:07

@Eyerollcentral

Thanks for your comments. Maybe I'm not the most warm and enthusiastic person ever but we got on well before baby arrived. MIL has met her twice now - the first time she was just a few days old and I was absolutely wrecked by the C-section and lack of sleep. If I came across cold on that occasion, I didn't mean to. But she held baby lots (I'm not precious of that) and seemed happy enough. Not sure I had time to come across sulky today before she left.

And I conceded I should have arranged for us all to do something beforehand. But it all happened so fast - literally she handed me back the baby, got her shoes on and was out the door. Honestly! FIL didn't even know she was going to get her brows done and missed her saying so, it happened so fast.

OP posts:
soraya · 18/02/2023 21:06

What I think is unreasonable is that a family member wants to stay with you when you have a 5 week old. also good that they went out so that you don't have to cook them lunch when you have enough to do and probably getting up feeding during the night. If this was their plan then they should have mentioned it to you so that you didn't rush around buying food etc.

ensayers · 18/02/2023 21:02

Maybe mil or sil can only tolerate you or DH or kids for short periods of time?
If you didn't live so far away maybe they would of just popped round for a couple of hours instead of whole weekend, but because they came so far it doesn't feel right to stay 2 hours then drive home.

The reason I've never been to my brother's house, which is 3 hours away, is because after the first hour there would be a lot of silence and I'd be trying to think of excuses to leave, but it's so far away that a one hour stay feels wrong.

tobeornottobe1 · 18/02/2023 20:59

OP I wouldn't comment just yet, as you've got all day tomorrow to get through as well? After tomorrow maybe today won't seem so bad 😬

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 20:58

And again OP why didn’t you say oh I thought we’d do something together today instead of immediately taking offence and going off on an online strop? A lot of passive aggressive behaviour, which a lot of people just cba with

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 20:56

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 20:49

You sound lovely.

Yes I find it weird that MIL came to see GC and disappeared an hour into the visit to go to town for a lovely day out. Thought we'd spend the day as a family, but I was wrong.

Yes I find it rude that MIL left us to dog sit whilst FIL slept on the sofa.

Yes I thought people would agree that it was all a bit nuts - I was wrong on that front.

Yes I know things could be worse.

I find it easier to post here than to talk to my family/friends as I don't want to colour their views on my in-laws and treat them any differently.

But I've learnt my lesson. In future I won't post as it only seems to get me more annoyed.

Do you like your in laws? It doesn’t seem like you do. People can pick up on that you know. Maybe you are very warm and welcoming in real life but you really aren’t giving out those vibes here. Is it possible your MIL felt you didn’t want her there? Are you quite prescriptive in terms of how people interact with the baby? Just feels like there are a lot of gaps. If I had driven 3 hours and didn’t feel like my presence was anything more than just tolerated tbh I would probably go out and get my eyebrows done too rather than stay and risk a row with the mother of a new born who didn’t seem to want me there.

M08my · 18/02/2023 20:55

FWIW I am of the 30% that says yanbu.

It is frankly bizarre that your mil came the first time without a present (I didn't read the first thread). People can say I'm entitled but it's just true, the majority of grandmothers I know would have been shopping before baby was born and be so excited for the baby to try on the (possibly impractical) mittens they'd bought, or alternatively some precious handmedown blanket or whatever. They're behaving more like acquaintances eg neighbours. But even my neighbours had a baby cardigan to give my dd when they first met her.

I couldn't get worked up about them leaving you alone with the baby after 20 mins, because guests are hard work, but it is strange that they'd be so gleeful about eyebrows instead of the baby.