Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second visit from MIL

167 replies

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 15:51

I posted here a couple of weeks ago after MIL's first visit when she made a few comments about DD's appearance and didn't bring a gift - a lot of posters felt I was BU which in hindsight was fair, and I definitely felt a lot better about things after the immediate post-birth hormone surge had died down but this weekend is MIL's second visit. She's brought along FIL and SIL this time which is nice as they'd not met our 5 week old yet.

SIL arrived last night, stayed with us and had lots of cuddles.

FIL and MIL wanted to get a hotel and stay the whole weekend which is fair enough. They arrived in the car this morning at 11.

MIL held baby for about 20 minutes and at 12 o'clock she announced she was going into town to get her eyebrows done. And was taking SIL as she hasn't been here before, to show her the city.

They're still gone.

Is this weird? Would you travel 3 hours to visit grandchild and then just disappear for hours on end? Or am I again being oversensitive?

I didn't even get chance to suggest we all go - obviously we can't just leave the house on a whim with a newborn but it would have been nice to all go out together?

OP posts:
Ladyofthesea · 19/02/2023 07:38

Languagelanguage · 18/02/2023 18:03

The replies on here are bonkers. I think MN is becoming gransnet and it should be made more clear that must responses are probably from people in the mil's demographic. Who expects to visit for a weekend and then leaves the new mum by herself without even a "You know you're more than welcome to come with"? Really rude and uncompassionate. There is a way to 'give space' that also extends the hand of friendship.

I agree with most posters that MIL was being considerate and I have a 2yo, so hardly a gran! Although technically I could have been a gran if I started very young, but that can be said about anyone over the age of 24!

Mindymomo · 19/02/2023 07:37

Op, I would definitely be annoyed. At least you know for next visit.

BettyOop99 · 19/02/2023 07:27

horriblechristmas2022 · 19/02/2023 06:47

I must admit you seem a little passive aggressive as well, I suspect you have made it quite,quite clear the family aren't welcome, and I actually feel very sorry for the mother in law who can't do right at all

So how you (and lots of PPs) see it:

  • OP is annoyed by something
  • OP sounds annoyed on a few posts
  • Therefore OP has a bad attitude and must have deserved it?

Fantastic Mumsnet logic (that's sarcasm, not passive aggressiveness btw).

Honestly, after speaking to DH (who is usually very forgiving and easy going) we've both concluded that his DM wanted a lovely weekend away in a new city with the added bonus of seeing DGC for a bit in between. Fair enough. Hopefully she will want to spend more time with us when DD is older and more interesting. FIL is quite a bit older than MIL so will probably always just fall asleep on the sofa when he's here. SIL has been very welcome. We might not accept dog, and SIL's 3 cats next time though.

OP posts:
horriblechristmas2022 · 19/02/2023 06:47

I must admit you seem a little passive aggressive as well, I suspect you have made it quite,quite clear the family aren't welcome, and I actually feel very sorry for the mother in law who can't do right at all

Nosleepforthismum · 19/02/2023 05:13

I’m going to actually point the blame at your DH here. I’m not sure if I read your previous thread but it sounds as though you were not particularly welcoming on the first visit (not your fault - also had a c-section and felt rubbish for days after) and your MIL may have picked up on this and planned to do things differently on her next visit. Your DH really should have been handling all this though. You say you are not on the family WhatsApp and so your MIL may well have been asking your DH what the plan was for the weekend and got some half hearted response that forced her to make her own plans.

I have a DB/SIL who live around three hours away and I’m starting to dread going to visit because all we do is sit in the house with no plans to do anything else when we are there and we are just expected to hold the baby and play with the toddler which is lovely but very wearing and frankly boring after a while. Highlighted by having our own slightly younger toddler who is bouncing off the walls after a couple of hours in the same room. This is largely down to my DB who never makes any plans for our visit and ignores or brushes off any attempts to make any. We have recently said that we will make our own plans next time we visit so it’s more enjoyable for us as well. No disrespect to my DB or SIL, they obviously enjoy being in their own home and expect their guests to also enjoy just hanging out there with them.

IndiaDreamer · 19/02/2023 03:32

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 16:00

It could be that - but for context, they live over 3 hours drive away so we never see them. Not sure we'd be reasonable in wanting space from close we never see?

You never see them, but have twice in 5 weeks?

BettyOop99 · 19/02/2023 03:29

UsingChangeofName · 19/02/2023 00:18

Yes I find it rude that MIL left us to dog sit whilst FIL slept on the sofa.

So she didn't leave you to dog sit then, did she ? Her dh (your FiL) was there, should the dog actually need anything in the time she was out.

It's clear you don't like her.
It's clear whatever she does will be wrong in your eyes.
It's clear you only posted on here for people to say "poor you" or "MiL is awful" rather than actually find out if YABU or not.
This is going to be a long journey for you and your in-laws.

OK that bit was unfair. I think she left us to dog and FIL sit to be honest...

I don't think it's clear that I don't like her. I didn't like what she (or FIL) did today. The majority of Mumsnet think I'm being unreasonable. OK. I challenge anyone to feel reasonable when you're expecting a nice family day and end up with a dog who barks every time your 5 week old cries whilst it's owners are absent/unconscious whilst supposedly here to visit their only grandchild.

OP posts:
FredInYourHead · 19/02/2023 03:26

It seems as if you're just nit picking atp.
You said you didn't really make an effort with them pre DC (dh's fault or not), and now you're shocked they're not making a huge effort with you? (Pretty much)

ChildcareIsBroken · 19/02/2023 01:39

OP, you're not unreasonable at all. And before anyone accuses me of bias against MILs, I love mine, she's absolutely great.
Firstly, you didn't need to plan a day out, your baby is 5 weeks, you're busy and tired. Your husband planning lunch and walk is plenty.
Secondly, to come to you all this way and then leaving you for hours to dog sit without agreeing it beforehand is not on. And you could have all gone to town if your MIL suggested it. Newborns are great to take out because they don't need much entertaining at that age and movement will make them sleep.
Your expectations aren't too high. I can't believe you're getting so many harsh replies. You wrote you wish you've done more to build that relationship before baby, but it's never too late and it seems like you're trying but your husband's parents aren't.
And I wouldn't let them bring a dog to my house, so I think you're really accommodating.

bloodyplanes · 19/02/2023 01:21

Spot on @UsingChangeofName

smileladiesplease · 19/02/2023 00:54

Did mil get her eyebrows waxed or threaded?

This is a need to know basis as we need to know what we are dealing with here.

Everyonesinvited · 19/02/2023 00:41

All these in-laws have to do is employ some simple rules for compassionate, thoughtful behavior.

They want to go out? They invite the new mum to come if she wants.

They are here for the weekend? They make it known when they will be in and expecting to be fed, at the very least. At best they will offer to cook certain meals ahead of time and will be offering to hang the washing out/rock a sleeping baby to sleep while you offer hospitality.

They use a decent proportion of the time available with family and baby as that's why they've come. If they go out, they invite the same to come.

They have the courtesy to let the host know when they will be leaving and returning.
They don't arrive so rarely than the holiday home starts to feel like their base, not the focus of the holiday.

They take the time to warmly include their hosts in the special moments of each day because the goal is relationships, not "How little do we have to spend time here before my own needs sound defeafing me.'

PrinceHaz · 19/02/2023 00:26

I think your MIL just fancied a trip away and didn’t care that you were left with sleeping FIL. Now you know how it will go if they come again.

UsingChangeofName · 19/02/2023 00:18

Yes I find it rude that MIL left us to dog sit whilst FIL slept on the sofa.

So she didn't leave you to dog sit then, did she ? Her dh (your FiL) was there, should the dog actually need anything in the time she was out.

It's clear you don't like her.
It's clear whatever she does will be wrong in your eyes.
It's clear you only posted on here for people to say "poor you" or "MiL is awful" rather than actually find out if YABU or not.
This is going to be a long journey for you and your in-laws.

Undermyumberellaellaella · 19/02/2023 00:03

Good god. Yes I remember the last post where you were being unreasonable and here you are again.. being unreasonable. She can't win either way.

pizzaHeart · 18/02/2023 23:16

@Eyerollcentral
I wasn’t attempting to be obtuse, I was sarcastic. My point was that they came to spend some time with their grandchild, not for something else, at least it’s what they said.

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 22:29

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 22:20

Very disingenuous. You indeed imply all of that. Nasty.

I don’t at all. You seem to be projecting a lot.

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 22:20

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 22:08

I haven’t said anything like that. The OP is upset because her MIL went out. I have asked if they have a good relationship, if she was welcoming to them (as it didn’t really come across that she gets on with them particularly or that she was pleased about the visit), that newborns spend a lot of time asleep and that maybe the in laws thought gosh it’s a lot to expect dil to have to look after us all day as well as the baby. Not sure how you’ve gotten what you said from my posts but 🤷‍♀️

Very disingenuous. You indeed imply all of that. Nasty.

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 22:17

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 22:08

You're right - I'm not particularly close to them. DH hasn't done much to promote the relationship, and has naturally gravitated towards my family who he is very close to. I do regret this and feel guilty about it - which is why I was keen that they should feel welcome to visit any time here and see the baby.

I imagined they would come here and spend some time with us at the house (DH had planned something nice for lunch) and then if every one got cabin fever we would have suggested going out for a walk or something all together.

I think my only crimes are not making an effort in the years before baby (led by DH) and not making a full plan for the day today. Although I do think MIL had a shopping trip in mind and anything else would have been a disappointment.

I don’t think you need to feel guilty about anything, you are a new mother at the end of the day. It’s clear though there is a communication problem and your husband really should have made sure everyone was aware he was going to make a special lunch and maybe all go for a walk later. I don’t think it’s uncommon for some men to gravitate towards the wife’s family because tbh I think often it’s easier and they have to do less planning, talking to and keeping in touch as their wife will naturally do that with their own family. It really is for your husband to lay the groundwork there on that. If his mother and sister feel he hasn’t made the effort to make them feel part of your family then it’s really down to him to start making more of an effort. If they don’t know you really well it could just be as simple as not being entirely relaxed in your home - though obvs your fil had no problem conking out! I’m sure as they see the baby more your relationship will naturally develop as you see more of them. In the first instance though defo get your husband to add you to the family WhatsApp group and then you can send pics, etc. Or if that’s strictly nuclear family only set up your own group w his mum, dad and sil and start with baby spam. I know in my own family it really does help silly as it sounds to build that rapport especially where family members are separated by distance.

Tourmalines · 18/02/2023 22:17

This
yes , it’s like a breeding ground for bashing MILs . One day the DILs will be MILs , tables always turn

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 22:08

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:53

But you could have taken the baby and gotten your own brows done, had a look round the shops, had a bite to eat all three of you. It’s just really about spending time together isn’t it? Or are you saying you only wanted them to stay at home all day. You do have a five week old baby so it would be completely understandable if you did. Do you not contact your mil or SIL yourself at all? Not sure saying FIL was happy enough to spend afternoon snoozing on my couch is the best comparison to show your friendliness OP, the man was unconscious! It doesn’t sound like you are particularly close with your in laws to begin with. Saying I have not intentionally been rude or cold to them is not the same as saying I extended the same warm welcome to my home as I do to all visitors. Some people just don’t like to be stuck at home all day, I have family members like that, is that the kind of personality your MIL has? It can be annoying but I think lack of communication is the biggest problem here, not deliberate snubs. As others have said they may have thought she doesn’t want us sitting looking at her all day expecting food and entertainment. Newborn babies are of course beautiful but twenty mins at a time probably max for anyone bar the parents to gaze at a likely sleeping baby.

You're right - I'm not particularly close to them. DH hasn't done much to promote the relationship, and has naturally gravitated towards my family who he is very close to. I do regret this and feel guilty about it - which is why I was keen that they should feel welcome to visit any time here and see the baby.

I imagined they would come here and spend some time with us at the house (DH had planned something nice for lunch) and then if every one got cabin fever we would have suggested going out for a walk or something all together.

I think my only crimes are not making an effort in the years before baby (led by DH) and not making a full plan for the day today. Although I do think MIL had a shopping trip in mind and anything else would have been a disappointment.

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 22:08

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 21:59

Gosh you sound so selfish and entitled eyeroll. Thinking the op should be welcoming yet mindful that people may not want to spend over 20 minutes with her, be quick to invite herself but never expect an invitation, make her home available for guests to sleep in without ever expecting a gift or compassionate word.... I'm so glad you're not my mil.

I haven’t said anything like that. The OP is upset because her MIL went out. I have asked if they have a good relationship, if she was welcoming to them (as it didn’t really come across that she gets on with them particularly or that she was pleased about the visit), that newborns spend a lot of time asleep and that maybe the in laws thought gosh it’s a lot to expect dil to have to look after us all day as well as the baby. Not sure how you’ve gotten what you said from my posts but 🤷‍♀️

BettyOop99 · 18/02/2023 22:00

pizzaHeart · 18/02/2023 21:51

I’ve read a few pages and can’t understand why you’re getting such a hard time here. Of course you expect your in-laws to come and see you, their son and their GDC. There is a perfect medium between trying to take baby away from her parents and just looking at her for a few minutes. Your MIL could chat with you, take baby for a walk, watch her sleep, cook you a special dish or whatever. It looked like she just needed to get rid of FiL and their dog for a day to do shopping with her daughter. PPs were saying that your MIL couldn’t win, well she could, simply by behaving like a normal grandma without any sort of extremities.

Thanks @pizzaHeart - this is what I expected, but it's clear I don't know my in-laws very well, or I would have known better. At least expectations have been set early on and I will try to not be disappointed in future. Luckily my own family are amazing and DH is close to all of them

OP posts:
Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 21:59

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:53

But you could have taken the baby and gotten your own brows done, had a look round the shops, had a bite to eat all three of you. It’s just really about spending time together isn’t it? Or are you saying you only wanted them to stay at home all day. You do have a five week old baby so it would be completely understandable if you did. Do you not contact your mil or SIL yourself at all? Not sure saying FIL was happy enough to spend afternoon snoozing on my couch is the best comparison to show your friendliness OP, the man was unconscious! It doesn’t sound like you are particularly close with your in laws to begin with. Saying I have not intentionally been rude or cold to them is not the same as saying I extended the same warm welcome to my home as I do to all visitors. Some people just don’t like to be stuck at home all day, I have family members like that, is that the kind of personality your MIL has? It can be annoying but I think lack of communication is the biggest problem here, not deliberate snubs. As others have said they may have thought she doesn’t want us sitting looking at her all day expecting food and entertainment. Newborn babies are of course beautiful but twenty mins at a time probably max for anyone bar the parents to gaze at a likely sleeping baby.

Gosh you sound so selfish and entitled eyeroll. Thinking the op should be welcoming yet mindful that people may not want to spend over 20 minutes with her, be quick to invite herself but never expect an invitation, make her home available for guests to sleep in without ever expecting a gift or compassionate word.... I'm so glad you're not my mil.

Eyerollcentral · 18/02/2023 21:58

pizzaHeart · 18/02/2023 21:55

@Eyerollcentral
I’ve thought that OP provided them entertainment - she gave birth to their grandchild whom they came to see. They didn’t come because of local architecture, did they ?

I don’t see a baby as entertainment but ok… let me explain it to you another way as you are attempting to be obtuse, maybe the in laws didn’t want her to feel that in addition to caring for a newborn she also had to entertain them all day meaning feed, hydrate and stimulate.