Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have said this at the riding school?

269 replies

TigeToo · 18/02/2023 15:41

I’ve been doing horse riding lessons for around 6 months now (after on and off lessons when I was younger). I was paired up with a lovely but very sedate cob called Frank. It’s a mission to get Frank to do anything other than a very slow half hearted trot. It was ok at first as I needed a slow steady horse to build my confidence up but now it’s just frustrating. I’m meant to be learning how to canter but I can’t get Frank to canter. The instructor shouts “give him a kick” which I do but he doesn’t give a shit. The instructor will then laugh and call him a lazy bones or something. Occasionally she’ll run up behind him doing a weird noise which might make him canter for 3 steps but then he’ll stop again.
Last week I arrived at the stables and was told “Frank isn’t available so I’ve got Toby out for you, he’s a bit more forward, are you ok with that?”

Well Toby was amazing! Still slow and steady but up for a slow canter when requested. He was perfect!! I had an amazing lesson and finally felt like I was getting somewhere (with lots of cantering!!)

At the end of the lesson I asked if I could have Toby again on my next lesson. She said that was fine and wrote his name next to mine in the booking book.

So imagine my horror when I turn up today and see Frank stood waiting for me. I said “I’m meant to be on Toby today” and she said “oh, sorry he’s not available this week”. So I said “As lovely as Frank is I really want to learn to canter now, is there any other horse available?” And she got pissed off and said “no, I’ve got Frank ready now”.

So I took Frank into the school. Absolutely pointless, walking around so slow that he literally stopped a few times. Managed a slow trot, no chance I was getting anything else out of him.

So when it came to booking next weeks lesson I said “can you put me down for a horse I can learn to canter with” and she said “I can try but Frank is the best horse for you really due to your height, weight and ability” (I’m 5ft 10in, 10.7stone). They have a massive yard full of horses. I have another friend who goes and has said she won’t ride Frank or Toby as they’re too difficult to work with.

I didn’t book at the time but after speaking to friend I rang them just now and asked if I could book in with Blaze, Pepsi or Toby next week. They said “yes, I’ll put them on as well as Frank”. I said “No, not Frank”. She got very defensive and said there were no guarantees that it won’t be Frank if he’s the only one available so I said I won’t bother then.

The lessons are expensive and I feel like the’re taking the piss out of me.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 19:31

Judgyjudgy · 18/02/2023 19:26

Totally this. Tell them you go elsewhere

Hmm, the thing I would say about this is, is OP may not actually know specific horses well enough to know that they are a level up from Frank, So she unfortunately needs to trust the RS/Instructor - and that trust is not there understandably. THEY should be telling HER about the next horse for her, other than Frank (poor Frank). She needs an ally at the School, who knows her, and the available/suitable horses for her to be able to gain confidence and ability. In some cases, one that is a bit push-button. This is what should happen in a decent RS that is wanting to appeal to all abilities, and for the novices to improve, and enjoy and get something for their money!

Judgyjudgy · 18/02/2023 19:26

Dacadactyl · 18/02/2023 15:47

I don't know anything about horses, but from what you've said YANBU. You're paying for a service and they should accommodate you. I'd have said "if I can't have x, y or z horse then I will find another riding school. Are any of them available next week or the week after?" If the answer is no then find somewhere else. I think they're taking the mick really.

Totally this. Tell them you go elsewhere

Ultraninja · 18/02/2023 19:24

thewinterqueen · 18/02/2023 19:13

You should be able to make a horse canter if you can ride. I'm sorry to say it. You need to learn to use a stronger leg, or increase your strength. Sadly, most riding school horses can become a little numbed to aids, so perhaps ride with a whip. Just holding a whip can be enough to make some horses more forwards. Either way, you are going to have to strengthen your use of the leg to get him to canter. Part of learning to canter is about holding the canter too.

Op doesn't need us to teach her to ride the canter via the internet. She's paying £60 per lesson for the riding school staff to teach her.

I'm glad that at least a few of the horse people on here understand the value of a rider learning on a school master before being expected to ride on a horse that is more challenging. Challenging for whatever reason, being unwilling to work counts as challenging.

menopausalbloat · 18/02/2023 19:21

So you're basically exercising Frank for them? And paying for the privilege.
Bollocks to that.

Theskyoutsideisblue · 18/02/2023 19:19

If I was a riding school pony I’d be frank and do fuckall

ifIwerenotanandroid · 18/02/2023 19:16

When I was about 8yo I was desperate to ride & my parents eventually gave in & booked me just two lessons. I think they were hoping I'd hate it & then shut up about it.

I got a Frank. I forget his name but I can still see his lovely black & white face, but OMG he was a nightmare. He really didn't want to go out. We were led in a line along a grass verge next to the road through the village, & my horse was so lazy he kept stopping & putting his head down to eat the grass! I was told to pull his head up & get him moving, & it was sooooo hard to do. Then we crossed the road (few cars in those days) into a field, & my horse deviated under a tree & swiped me off backwards using a low branch. I didn't care, I was just so thrilled to be around horses. I got back on & we rode about a bit before heading back the way we came. My 'Frank' certainly speeded up to get back to his stable & presumably a bit of shut-eye - everyone predicted & commented on it!

Sadly, although I couldn't think of anything I wanted more than to ride every week of my life, my parents declared they'd given me what I wanted & there would be no more of it. Gits.

thewinterqueen · 18/02/2023 19:13

You should be able to make a horse canter if you can ride. I'm sorry to say it. You need to learn to use a stronger leg, or increase your strength. Sadly, most riding school horses can become a little numbed to aids, so perhaps ride with a whip. Just holding a whip can be enough to make some horses more forwards. Either way, you are going to have to strengthen your use of the leg to get him to canter. Part of learning to canter is about holding the canter too.

Leftbutcameback · 18/02/2023 19:11

Fairly typical experience that many of us have been through - but hate to think how much you’re paying for private lessons as my group ones are now £50 p/h. We’ve all got stuck on a Frank before but it isn’t really on for it to be every week. I would ask to speak to the owner and explain that you won’t be coming back unless they can provide you with a better service. You’re not that tall or heavy, and from your posts there are a few other horses which suit.

Otherwise worth trying a new school.

Its pretty much always the case that you can request but are not guaranteed a horse but that doesn’t mean you should get stuck on the same one every week.

Might also be worth asking if another lesson time would help - if your lesson clashes with a group one for example for older kids then some the horses may be required for that. Good luck and don’t let it put you off.

LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 19:10

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 19:09

The bottom line is that while Frank is clearly very safe and forgiving, he is not a first ridden for moving up the gears. If they wish to use him as such, they need to be schooling him outside lesson hours instead of running at him. A good school would understand that Toby was right for you now and make the effort to organise it. Although with the spring grass coming in you might find Toby overly forward for the foreseeable and even Frank might have a spring in his step.

The other thing you could do is ask to speak to the yard manager. If they want your business they will accommodate you. It sounds like they're taking money to let you plod around and are happy to continue to do so. At this price for a private lesson they're having a laugh.

That's assuming they get out on some grass though..... I wonder....

hourbyhour101 · 18/02/2023 19:10

Ultraninja · 18/02/2023 18:33

Good schools put riders on a "schoolmaster" that really knows their job. A horse that will do what the rider wants - if the rider asks in the right way. Then the rider learns the correct aids, and gets used to the horse's moves and gaits. Then they progress to horses that aren't quite so easy, with the confidence that they are asking correctly, and they learn about how good riders teach the horse while they ride.

I feel sorry for the Franks of this horse world. Mentally or physically not up to the job. An easy horse for the instructors to use because they know they won't cause the students any problems. Frank has either been ridden so badly for so long that he's forgotten what the correct aids are and what they mean, or he's never learned them. Ribs sore from constant kicking and I'm sure regularly given a smack to make him "behave". Used and his good nature abused.

This all of this in spades.

That said some schools are notoriously bitchy. The hands would work their favourite horses and leave the franks of this world be worked by others or for lessons. Some will be privately owned of course.

Someone mentioned working with the horse in the stables first. I had a frank (ex race horse) that his owner said would be better shot as wouldnt make him any money now, so I took him on. He is a little bugger and totally knows when he can get away with being lazy. But he can move fast if he's in the mood for it (like humans I suppose)

He doesn't mess around with me esp if I bring him a treat before hand, but once I had forgotten them and my god he kept slowing and turning to give me the evil eye. Horses are iMO v smart.

The franks are perfect for newbies but op your in that transition state of you need a more forward horse to enable you to go forward.

Yes experienced riders can get franks moving but that's true of any horse if your experienced. It also doesn't mean that there's something wrong with the horse or op just currently your needs don't match.

Gagaandgag · 18/02/2023 19:09

I hate the fact that horses can be whipped and kicked. When you really think about it - It’s awful. Poor Frank

LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 19:09

The biggest RS near me has an upper weight limit of 14st I think.
I don't think 10st should be a limiting factor, and height might also affect the way she can apply leg and so on, so needs to be big enough height wise.
She might be on the cob because he has a broader back for her height (I imagine him to be 15hh max. and I at 5'7" would not feel great on that), but none of that makes up for the fact that he needs a rocket (which I still think is not fair).

Sparemyblushesplease · 18/02/2023 19:09

The bottom line is that while Frank is clearly very safe and forgiving, he is not a first ridden for moving up the gears. If they wish to use him as such, they need to be schooling him outside lesson hours instead of running at him. A good school would understand that Toby was right for you now and make the effort to organise it. Although with the spring grass coming in you might find Toby overly forward for the foreseeable and even Frank might have a spring in his step.

The other thing you could do is ask to speak to the yard manager. If they want your business they will accommodate you. It sounds like they're taking money to let you plod around and are happy to continue to do so. At this price for a private lesson they're having a laugh.

Everyonehasavoice · 18/02/2023 19:04

Sounds like your height and weight are an excuse, (I do know they are a factor as I ride )
If you can’t insist on not having Frank, and that is unusual
If you turn up and you’re told you have Frank, refuse to pay. There’s no point if you’re not learning anything. Especially as lessons are not cheap
Just tell them if you’re learning to canter you need a horse that will canter

Ultimately I’d find another stables

Poor Frank, he’s clearly fed up, sounds like he needs to be retired

ComfortablyDazed · 18/02/2023 18:54

DottieUncBab · 18/02/2023 18:09

This, when I first started riding I used to have a horse like a Frank, once I got more confident with my riding I could make any horse canter, I could make any horse ride on the bit, I could make any horse do what I wanted. I don’t think it’s the horse it’s the rider.

Right, but …. the OP is learning to ride?

That’s why she’s there, literally having lessons.

To learn to ride.

Why are some on this thread expecting her to be experienced enough to be able to get a recalcitrant horse to canter?

If she was easily able to do that, she wouldn’t need to be there doing what she’s doing. Having lessons to learn to ride.

OP - YANBU.

powershowerforanhour · 18/02/2023 18:47

perhaps be asking them to teach you more trotting work (collected & extended)"

If Frank is willing and able to do anything recognisable as a collected and extended trot- especially when ridden by an advanced beginner- I'll eat my hat. And the cover. A couple of lunge lessons aren't a bad idea but expecting a beginner to learn to canter on Frank is like trying to teach a learner driver to do a 3 point turn in a really
heavy vehicle with no power steering.

LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 18:45

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 18/02/2023 18:41

I used to have horse riding lessons and always ended up on a particular pony who used to buck and misbehave. Another girl always used to get the nicer ponies. She was popular with the yard staff and the riding instructor whereas I was shy and quiet. I’m sure there was an element of favouritism. There was a lot of bitchiness but I put up with it because I loved horses. In hindsight I’d wish I hadn’t bothered, it would have saved my mum and dad a fortune.

Ah, I feel sorry for the younger you (and can probably relate). It is SUCH a bitchy world.

If it makes you feel better, my nickname (I was 12 ish), was Spare Face!

LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 18:43

I don't think learning to canter on the lunge is as nice as doing it freely in the school. So much more rewarding to think you have achieved it yourself, intentionally that is. And it really should be possible on a riding school horse that is kept nicely schooled (which I don't think Frank is, otherwise he would obey the rider).
I would always feel that the circle is a little small, even actually when lungeing without anyone on board.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 18/02/2023 18:41

I used to have horse riding lessons and always ended up on a particular pony who used to buck and misbehave. Another girl always used to get the nicer ponies. She was popular with the yard staff and the riding instructor whereas I was shy and quiet. I’m sure there was an element of favouritism. There was a lot of bitchiness but I put up with it because I loved horses. In hindsight I’d wish I hadn’t bothered, it would have saved my mum and dad a fortune.

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 18/02/2023 18:40

Shannith · 18/02/2023 18:14

Is definitely switch schools. There is a difference between learning to canter and learning to canter though if that makes sense.

There is learning what canter feels like, getting used to the motion and getting confident in your balance and used to the relative speed.

The Franks of this world are great for that - because they are not going to do anything unexpected - just canter sedately round.

If you do persevere then maybe Framk on a lunge with the instructor dictating the pace and direction while you can sort yourself out on top.

Then you can learn to ride the canter - ask correctly and ride the pace, be able to do transitions up and down smoothly, turn, circle, do some lateral movements. For this you need a more forward but still safe horse. Toby or similar.

A lot of schools have a kind of unwritten rule that you need to be able to get the beginner horse going nicely in all 3 paces before you move up. Ask them for a very honest appraisal of where you are in your riding journey.

At the very small school where I keep my mare they have a Frank - Goldie. You could "put your dead grandmother on her" - she's a great introduction to riding as she's rock solid. But she won't do a tap more than she has to if she can get away with it.

With me or the instructor on her she'll jump an small course and do a half decent prelim test (slowly).

There is nothing worse than being over horsed - you want to be totally safe for now.

So if I were you I'd change schools and find one where they can give you a clear plan for how you progress.

So canter on lunge for 3 lessons, canter safe horse 3 lessons, move up to a more forward horse, working on transitions, poles, lateral moves in all 3 paces.

Do you have a goal in mind? A timeline? You should share this and have an instructor who can give you a realistic and honest feedback on how you get there.

Good instructors do take it slower than you might think. It's so important to establish the basics properly before going to the next stage. If like most of us horses are a long term life choice the then getting really established in walk and trot on a forward horse is even more important than cantering. So being able to really ride inside leg to outside rein, to control tempo within the pace, to do effective lateral work all this needs to be established in walk and trot first. Because it will make cantering so much more fun.

Hope that makes sense.

The Franks at the riding school where I learned would not "canter sedately around" - they would not stay in canter for a full circuit of the school without constant leg. OP's Frank sounds like that. There were others that would indeed canter sedately around (and some that had to be held back to stop them cantering). Each type is right for learning different things. Frank is not right for learning what OP needs to learn at the moment.

LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 18:39

Ah Thelwell 😍

To have said this at the riding school?
Thindog · 18/02/2023 18:38

After six months of lessons I would expect to be learning to canter. As others have said cantering on the lunge would allow you to concentrate on balance and developing a secure seat. I'd look for another school, B.H.S. approved if possible, or see if you can find someone with a friendly cob who might teach you, in return for help with looking after their horse.

LoveMyPiano · 18/02/2023 18:34

Ultraninja · 18/02/2023 18:33

Good schools put riders on a "schoolmaster" that really knows their job. A horse that will do what the rider wants - if the rider asks in the right way. Then the rider learns the correct aids, and gets used to the horse's moves and gaits. Then they progress to horses that aren't quite so easy, with the confidence that they are asking correctly, and they learn about how good riders teach the horse while they ride.

I feel sorry for the Franks of this horse world. Mentally or physically not up to the job. An easy horse for the instructors to use because they know they won't cause the students any problems. Frank has either been ridden so badly for so long that he's forgotten what the correct aids are and what they mean, or he's never learned them. Ribs sore from constant kicking and I'm sure regularly given a smack to make him "behave". Used and his good nature abused.

I agree with you 100%

PaperDoves · 18/02/2023 18:34

Matilda1981 · 18/02/2023 15:52

To be honest if you could ride you would be able to get Frank to canter so I’m on the side of the riding school here!!

I agree that a good rider would be able to get the Franks of the world going, but I completely disagree with the average riding school ethos that you have to master the Franks to graduate to the better horses. People need to learn to ride on safe, easy horses. That might be Frank while you're mastering walk and maybe trot, but when you're ready to canter you need a safe, easy horse that doesn't take five days at the gym to get into canter!

YANBU, OP. It's your money, you have the right to say you never want to ride Frank again, and if he's the one ready and waiting for you, you won't be having a lesson. (But they really can't promise you a specific horse, for many reasons -- there's a certain aspect of luck of the draw with lessons, although given the number of horses they can surely give you "not Frank").

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 18/02/2023 18:34

"horseback riding" is what Americans call it.

It makes perfect sense- we talk about being "on horseback".

American also use use "riding" more than British people do, think "riding the railroad", "riding on the bus" "she gave me a ride to school" etc so it makes sense that they would tend to add clarification when talking about equestrian activities.

I believe that "riding" is equivalent to "shagging" in Ireland too...