Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My MILs partner smacked our 3 year old

284 replies

BubblingRage · 18/02/2023 12:46

Sorry for this being very long winded!
A bit of background first. MIL moved her new partner into her house after talking to each other for a month during the first lockdown. Everything was very quick and he seemingly arrived at her house with nothing. No furniture, towels, tv… literally just a handful of clothes. I always found him a bit “iffy” and refused to let my then 2 year old round to his nanny’s without me or my husband being there. (Once lockdown lifted obviously). Fast forward nearly 2 years and I’ve warmed to him, so I finally agree for my MIL to have our 3 and 1 year old overnight near Christmas so we could go out a celebrate my birthday. For a couple of weeks afterwards my 3 year old didn’t want “nanny” and (I shall refer to him as) “R” to come round our house. He also started not wanting to go round to nanny’s house either. This was very unusual as he usually dotes on his nan. Alarm bells starting ringing.
They came round to ours on Boxing Day as their surrogate Christmas Day. I noticed that R was often rolling his eyes and shaking his head at our DS. He wasn’t doing anything wrong, he was just an excited 3 year old at Christmas!
DS didn’t mention anything for a couple of weeks so I assumed he’d forgotten all about whatever was bugging him. Every so often he would drop into conversation or just randomly say that he doesn’t like “R”. I lightly questioned him about it but never really got a proper answer out of him. My DH asked MIL if anything had happened. She said R told DS off for throwing a dice. So we assumed that was what was wrong!
This morning DS randomly said again that he doesn’t like R. I sat him down and said that I will always help him. I always believe him and will never be angry or sad if he tells me what is bothering him and that I will always help him. But that I can’t help him if he doesn’t tell me what’s wrong. He then said that “R” smacked him round the head when he had a sleepover at nanny’s. Nanny had gone to get him a drink, DS was playing with a dice and R smacked him. He didn’t tell him off or shout, just smacked him.
I am beyond livid and although he’s only 3, I believe my son implicitly.
I don’t know what to do. We’re going to mention it to MIL and not let DS round to their house. But I feel like that’s not enough!
im just absolutely gutted for my son. And I’m so annoyed that I didn’t listen to my own instinct.
What would you do in this situation?!

OP posts:
MadamArcati99 · 18/02/2023 19:44

and i am sorry but 'gut feelings' are very over-rated, you do not have to look far on MN to see the endless procession of MNers whose 'gut feeling' has let them down badly in their choice of life partner!

MadamArcati99 · 18/02/2023 19:41

DotAndCarryOne2 · 18/02/2023 18:17

This is terrible advice. The OP has no idea what happened but has a gut feeling, as we all have with our children. If MIL witnessed the assault (that’s what it is), she won’t admit it because she knows the implications, which is why she’s only admitting to hearing a telling off. If the child was hit and MIL witnessed it and backed up her partner, this explains why the child doesn’t want to see either of them, and his behaviour in the months prior to telling what happened, bears out that something happened to traumatise him.

This man appeared out of nowhere, moved in with MIL after a month of ‘talking’ and turned up with no belongings. That’s a huge red flag - he probably isn’t the axe murderer some are making him out to be, but something isn’t right. The family know nothing about him and MIL has taken him at face value - OP doesn’t say whether she was recently widowed or divorced prior to this, but possibly circumstances around loneliness during lockdown played a part. So at the end of the day who do you trust ? A man you know nothing about and don’t particularly like/trust, or your DC ?

And by the way - an instance of accusing the OP of pinching him when she got hold of his arm awkwardly doesn’t give him a ‘track record’ of lying. It depends on perspective. The OP had a gut feeling about this man and her DS hasn’t wanted to see his GM despite previously doting on her. The OP has witnessed for herself a degree of intolerance of her DS on the part of this man. I would err on the side of caution and get a background check on this man so they know what they’re dealing with, and then make a decision based on that. We’re talking about the wellbeing/safety of a child here. Red flags everywhere.

I said she should be wary, but tehre is far, far from any concrete evidence .

It really boils down to who is the most likely to be lying, the MIL of the 3 year old?

I do not necessarily agree that most women would side with a relatively new partner who abused their grandchild over their own son and his toddler. I mean , would you?

I think it is absolutely plausible that the child didn t want to see them because they had both told him off for being naughty. He is used to her doting on him and this must have come as a shock. I doubt he would be against nanny unless she had done something to him .

None of us on here know any of the characters involved and this may have happened ,and you should certainly be very cautious going forward, but the fact is we do know for sure that one of the people involved has form for lying

ehb102 · 18/02/2023 19:21

CRB and DBS checks are not any kind of gold standard. Many abusers go uncharged.

Amazing how many people think the fact they feel safe having sex with someone means that person is a fit person to take care of children. I wouldn't blame you if you didn't let your child go to MIL without you ever again.

BubblingRage · 18/02/2023 19:12

MySugarBabyLove · 18/02/2023 19:05

I think the fact that people here don’t seem to know the difference between Clare’s law and Sarah’s law means that nobody can possibly tell the OP what she can or can’t find out.

Claire’s law is for adults to be able to do a background check on a partner to see whether they have previous convictions against a partner. Nothing to do with child abuse and only a partner can request one.

Sarahs law is to check whether someone has a history of child abuse, someone can request one if their child is in that person’s presence, but the information from it very much varies from area to area.

I do also agree with @Nimbostratus100 · that the three year old’s wording sounds indicative of something else.

There’s no way a three year old is going to be able to tell someone word for word exactly what happened several months ago and be accurate about it. That doesn’t necessarily mean that he’s lying, he’s at the very least heard the wording from somewhere, but “hit around the head” isn’t three year old language.

OP does he go to nursery? Could he have heard this wording from another child who has heard it from a parent or older sibling?

How did the conversation emerge when he told you all this? Did you lead him in any way?

I’m not saying that this R is innocent, nobody knows. But talk of offering ultimatums and threatening the MIL that if she doesn’t break up with him she’ll never see the child again is over dramatic. It’s possible to minimise the child’s interaction with this man without having to go in all guns blazing based on an account of a three year old three months down the line using language which is not a child’s language.

I would be more concerned that this has happened somewhere else tbh or that he’s overheard someone telling someone that it’s happened to them.

I’ve been very careful not to lead him in my questioning and to not ask him too many times so he thinks I’m not getting the answer I’m looking for and then tells me what he thinks I want to hear.
It’s so difficult because I want to ask more questions but don’t want to make it a bigger deal than he thinks it is? I mean, to me it’s a massive deal and to him, he obviously knows it’s wrong and it’s playing on his mind. I just don’t want him to form it as a memory if I keep asking him about it, if that makes any sense at all?!
I also don’t want him to think he’s being punished by not being able to go round to his nans house now that he’s told me.

OP posts:
MySugarBabyLove · 18/02/2023 19:05

I think the fact that people here don’t seem to know the difference between Clare’s law and Sarah’s law means that nobody can possibly tell the OP what she can or can’t find out.

Claire’s law is for adults to be able to do a background check on a partner to see whether they have previous convictions against a partner. Nothing to do with child abuse and only a partner can request one.

Sarahs law is to check whether someone has a history of child abuse, someone can request one if their child is in that person’s presence, but the information from it very much varies from area to area.

I do also agree with @Nimbostratus100 · that the three year old’s wording sounds indicative of something else.

There’s no way a three year old is going to be able to tell someone word for word exactly what happened several months ago and be accurate about it. That doesn’t necessarily mean that he’s lying, he’s at the very least heard the wording from somewhere, but “hit around the head” isn’t three year old language.

OP does he go to nursery? Could he have heard this wording from another child who has heard it from a parent or older sibling?

How did the conversation emerge when he told you all this? Did you lead him in any way?

I’m not saying that this R is innocent, nobody knows. But talk of offering ultimatums and threatening the MIL that if she doesn’t break up with him she’ll never see the child again is over dramatic. It’s possible to minimise the child’s interaction with this man without having to go in all guns blazing based on an account of a three year old three months down the line using language which is not a child’s language.

I would be more concerned that this has happened somewhere else tbh or that he’s overheard someone telling someone that it’s happened to them.

BubblingRage · 18/02/2023 18:51

So a bit more background on my MIL. She had an affair and left my husbands dad for another man who had a terminal illness (they were childhood sweethearts) she married him shortly before he died. My DH had a bit of trouble wrapping his head round all of it (understandably) and she truly believed I was manipulating him against her… I wasn’t.
We then built a better relationship between her and myself when I was pregnant with DS1. DH has said that she never laid a hand on him when he was younger and that smacking was definitely not a thing in their household.
In lockdown 1, when they introduced bubbles for single households, we asked her if she wanted to form one. She turned us down as she was planning on moving in with R.
He has 2 grown children from a previous relationship who he sees a few times a year. No mention of their mum.
The only thing I can find online about him is his linked in page and a CV which has a 20 month gap in it.
She recently bought a house on her own and he pays her rent as he couldn’t go in on the mortgage due to having some debt, which he has told my husband he’s now paid off. Another red flag. Where has he got the money to pay it off?
He works for the local council so I’m assuming they’d crb check him?

DS has over exaggerated things in the past but I definitely wouldn’t say he’s a liar! He’s got the memory of an elephant so is very reliable in that respect.

I think we’re going to sit MIL down in person and ask her about it and tell her that DS will not be spending time at her house if he is there.
I don’t want to give her an ultimatum as what she does with her own personal life is her business. She can see DS but it has to be at our house and supervised.
Im also going to apply for background through Sarah’s law.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 18/02/2023 18:40

DotAndCarryOne2 · 18/02/2023 18:27

FFS !!!!

what is that supposed to mean?

How many 3 year olds talk about "being smacked around the head"? Where has this language come from? That is a worry - is he hearing threats?

How many 3 year old are going to be harping on about a simple smack after 2 months? Honestly, if you think this is likely, you have never spent any time trying to get a three year old to divulge what happened 2 weeks ago.....

A man is in the room with his partner and her grandchild, she leaves, he gets up, hits the grandchild, and sits back down again???

If someone has hit or threatened this child, then I dont think this account, and these circumstances are the truth of the matter.

and based on the language the child is using, it sounds like he has heard threats, in some situation or other, habitually

DotAndCarryOne2 · 18/02/2023 18:30

MaireadMcSweeney · 18/02/2023 13:54

OP cannot do a police check
she can't do a Clare's law
only the partner can have a disclosure. She could request it on MIL's behalf but they would only disclose to MIL.

YES SHE CAN !!! Anyone can request a background check if they have reason to believe the partner of a friend or relative may pose a risk. And they can request it as a parent of a child in contact with the person in question. The police will also disclose anything of concern even without the parents requesting a check, if they report it.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 18/02/2023 18:27

Nimbostratus100 · 18/02/2023 15:28

this just doesnt ring true at all, where has a 3 year old got that sort of language from? Children who have been smacked dont respond like this - otherwise it would be as easy as this to uncover abuse, wouldnt it?

I dont know what to suggest, but it all sounds very weird and worrying, and sorry, I dont know what to say - I wouldnt take it as a full and frank diclosure of anything though

FFS !!!!

Nottodaysausage · 18/02/2023 18:25

What a prick. Have you googled this man's name? You'd be suprised by what Google throws up if you Google their name and towns /counties you know that they've lived in

DotAndCarryOne2 · 18/02/2023 18:22

FeetupTvon · 18/02/2023 17:05

If your ds had lied about you pinching his arm… is there any possibility he could be exaggerating?

Would you really want to take the chance ?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 18/02/2023 18:17

MadamArcati99 · 18/02/2023 16:46

Going against the grain but think your implicit belief in the allegations of your 3 year old ( who is known for lying) is misplaced

  1. By your admission he has form for lying ' I’ve held onto his arm and got down to his level to explain something. He’s accused me of pinching him'
    So when you tell him off and he says you are pinching him its a lie, but when R tells him off and DS says he is smacking him about the head , it's true?

  2. At the other side of serving hatch your MIL could definitely hear the difference between a smack arounf the head and the ensuing yelp of pain , and a telling off.

  3. DS didnt want his nanny to coem to the house either.f they both told him off this makes sense, if only R hit him , it doesn't
    4 He didnt mention it for 3 months, and only mentioned it when you told him you would believe anything that came out of his mouth

You are right to be cautious around this man, but expecting your MIL to break up with him, or bringing charges of assault on the word of a 3 year old with a track record of lying, is for the birds

This is terrible advice. The OP has no idea what happened but has a gut feeling, as we all have with our children. If MIL witnessed the assault (that’s what it is), she won’t admit it because she knows the implications, which is why she’s only admitting to hearing a telling off. If the child was hit and MIL witnessed it and backed up her partner, this explains why the child doesn’t want to see either of them, and his behaviour in the months prior to telling what happened, bears out that something happened to traumatise him.

This man appeared out of nowhere, moved in with MIL after a month of ‘talking’ and turned up with no belongings. That’s a huge red flag - he probably isn’t the axe murderer some are making him out to be, but something isn’t right. The family know nothing about him and MIL has taken him at face value - OP doesn’t say whether she was recently widowed or divorced prior to this, but possibly circumstances around loneliness during lockdown played a part. So at the end of the day who do you trust ? A man you know nothing about and don’t particularly like/trust, or your DC ?

And by the way - an instance of accusing the OP of pinching him when she got hold of his arm awkwardly doesn’t give him a ‘track record’ of lying. It depends on perspective. The OP had a gut feeling about this man and her DS hasn’t wanted to see his GM despite previously doting on her. The OP has witnessed for herself a degree of intolerance of her DS on the part of this man. I would err on the side of caution and get a background check on this man so they know what they’re dealing with, and then make a decision based on that. We’re talking about the wellbeing/safety of a child here. Red flags everywhere.

MojoDaysxx · 18/02/2023 18:01

Follow your gut instict.

TicketBoo23 · 18/02/2023 17:59

MIL moved her new partner into her house after talking to each other for a month during the first lockdown. Everything was very quick and he seemingly arrived at her house with nothing.

Even before this happened, it's clear that your mil has "issues".

This behaviour does not speak of a well adjusted, wise, person who is reliable for hosting your child full stop. You clearly can't rely upon her judgement or decision making.

I think they - note they - are going to say your Ds is lying, exaggerating or misconstruing and this man is going nowhere..

Someone that desperate for a partner is not going to give them up easily.

CatherineCawoodRetired · 18/02/2023 17:58

@Rodneyisaplonker you are wrong. The leaving a mark mantra is an absolute myth. The law is around 'reasonable chastisement' and marks or otherwise don't come into it.
If a parent dragged their 15 year old 6' son off a younger sibling in a fight and left bruises on the 15 year olds wrist as a result of protecting the other sibling they would not face prosecution.

SchoolTripDrama · 18/02/2023 17:55

@BubblingRage What is your plan, OP? I think we're all a little bit heartbroken for your DS and are itching to see justice served at least slightly

CatherineCawoodRetired · 18/02/2023 17:55

Comedycook · 18/02/2023 13:46

I'd report him to the police without hesitation

What I said but far more succinct!

CatherineCawoodRetired · 18/02/2023 17:54

I would absolutely report this to the police. Firstly, it's assault and falls out with the English law on 'reasonable chastisement', secondly, reporting it may actually trigger checks on other intelligence of his behaviour that hasn't been joined up yet. The fact he landed from elsewhere with minimal possessions is dodgy and he may have had to leave where he came from so your MIL was a quick and easy getaway.
As others have said, it's unlikely he will be prosecuted but it is possible he will be invited in for voluntary interview and even if he denies the incident and it's NFA'd it's a footprint against him should he behave violently again. He could move in to another relationship and do the same again.
Your MIL should consider a Clare's Law disclosure but even if that yields nothing he has still assaulted her grandchild and she should make informed decisions based on this fact. But if there is information on him historically it may help her with her decision making if she's struggling.
You absolutely can not allow this man near your child supervised or not.
Any repeat incident and you haven't reported the first time will not reflect well on you as parents as well as the obvious exposing your vulnerable child to further harm.
I'd be wary if a big show down though, he's got a propensity to violence and it may isolate MIL - she could well be treading in egg shells around him already. Don't isolate her unless she denies or refuses to accept what happened and the consequences.
Report, accept some professional enquiries will be made which may be uncomfortable but will have your sons best interests at heart and safeguard him from this point.
You must feel dreadful but your communication with your son has allowed him to share the incident with you and you can now show him how you can protect him from this man from now on.

ReneBumsWombats · 18/02/2023 17:50

What would you do in this situation?!

Suppress the urge to smack him oops upside the head myself, ban him from ever seeing me or my kids and consider my relationship with my mother if she didn't fuck him off too.

marymay62 · 18/02/2023 17:34

Your DS isn’t safe with this man - whether R actually hit your DS ( and I would believe him) or DS imagines or feels that he did or might do - he doesn’t feel safe so he isn’t . It’s possible your MIL isn’t safe either, with this man. Do you ever see her without him? Just wondering about how much control he has. Get him checked out and keep him out of your lives. One hit is one too many.

Thesharkradar · 18/02/2023 17:23

What would you do in this situation?!
smack 'R' round the head with a baseball bat

whattodo22222 · 18/02/2023 17:23

ArcticSkewer · 18/02/2023 12:49

That's awful!

I'm sure there are lots of things you can do but I actually would start by asking the police to do a background check on him using the Sarah's Law/Claire's law.

This!

Instinct is powerful and he's proven you right

billy1966 · 18/02/2023 17:21

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2023 17:09

You should be pulling him up on him rolling his eyes and shaking his head. You need to find out this man's background and not leave your children there until this is all sort out.

I agree.

Rolling your eyes at a child in front of the parents is a very aggressive action.

I would be very wary of the arrogance of someone doing that.

It is the sort of thing you do to someone who irritates and annoys you.

TheShellBeach · 18/02/2023 17:21

I do wonder if the OP's mother's partner is also violent to her? To the OP's mother, I mean.

It wouldn't surprise me.

TheShellBeach · 18/02/2023 17:20

This is awful, OP.

I am put out that some posters have suggested that people who had babies in the 1980s (and were children in the 1960s) would see smacking as acceptable.

I was born in 1956. My parents did not smack me and I remember my mother and father telling us that they had made a pact never to hit any of us. They told us that when an adult hits a child, they have shown the child that the adult is not to be trusted, and that the adult has lost the respect of the child.

My children were born in the 1980s and I did not hit them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread