Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kissing newborns on the face

106 replies

AWholeNewWorls · 17/02/2023 20:52

Is it wrong to think only mum and dad should be allowed to kiss newborns? I was advised in one of my NCT classes that visitors should refrain from kissing baby on the face and should wash their hands before holding baby.

I told my mum this and she scoffed and said I shouldn't be "one of those mums" and it will make the baby weird if I mollycoddle like that. She said she raised me and my siblings without any of us catching anything bad etc. and we were all visited by lots of visitors (I have a fairly large and close knit extended family). I am expecting my first DC in about 4 weeks now and nervous about how to politely assert myself when it comes to conflicting views with my mum/MIL.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 19/02/2023 13:44

MrsBunnyEars · 17/02/2023 21:04

a baby doesn’t need kisses.

That’s one of the saddest things I’ve read.

I wouldn’t let a random kids my baby, but grandparents - absolutely. Clearly there’s a tiny chance of something bad happening, but in my view it’s outweighed by the massive importance of showing love fr those close to us.

This.

AutumnScream · 19/02/2023 13:43

What a fucked up thread saying babies shouldn't be kissed at all. Ffs. Great then they develop weak immune systems as well.

My first is due in 2 weeks and you can bet your bottom dollar shes getting millions of kisses a day when shes here.

5128gap · 19/02/2023 13:39

Oh, I expect you're right. Every week I read on here about something new that grandparents shouldn't be allowed to do. Might as well add kisses to the list.
For what it's worth, I've never been prevented from kissing my DGC, nor did I prevent it for my own DC, and they are all in excellent health. I'm not aware of any special germs that GPs carry that parents don't, so unless I banned kisses altogether, it would seem a bit illogical.

23NameChange · 19/02/2023 13:28

I think some of this might be to do with an increase in awareness and information as well. My DD contracted group b strep sepsis during her birth and was very poorly (NICU) for several weeks. Since then i understand that there is currently a big trial going on to see if testing pregnant women for group b strep reduces the number of cases of group b strep sepsis + meningitis, and there is a strep b vaccine trial going on. So perhaps its bringing it all a bit more attention and a very good thing if it stops another family suffering like we did.

Calphurnia88 · 19/02/2023 13:24

Katypp · 19/02/2023 12:51

I don't kiss babies on their faces so I don't have to justify anything. I just think the angst is completely out of proportion to the actual risk involved. But then it's a great opportunity to dictate to the inlaws and threaten to stop contact if they don't comply, so what's not to like?

It's a great opportunity to dictate to the inlaws and threaten to stop contact if they don't comply

Now who's being hysterical? 😁

✌🏻

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 13:19

UserNameSameGame · 19/02/2023 13:00

Not kissing babies is a relatively new thing. The last 5 years or so. As such, most people who aren’t actively involved in having a newborn now, or during that period, won’t have heard of it.

However it’s natural for you to feel that, because you have just learned it, everyone must know, because surely everyone knows everything about babies, particularly if they have been their themselves.

I do think that parenting classes should put it more in context - that the advice they are giving bring “the latest advice” also means it is relatively new advice and that maybe you should go a bit gently with those who are not in the loop. I think failing to set that context least to a big division between the generations. I read something on here last week where a poster declaimed she would never trust her PIL to look after her child because they didn’t know blueberries should be crushed before being given to a toddler.

I remember being quite snippy with my parents 15 years ago because they didn’t know that you shouldn’t give strawberries or honey before 18 months old, how important BLW and finger foods were, not to leave baby in a car seat longer than 30 minutes etc. With hindsight I wish I had recognised that they were all relatively new bits of guidance at the time.

All that is not to say the latest guidance is wrong, but just that it might need to be explained gently to others.

Well my eldest is 50 and I knew it then so it isn't that recent.

JenniferBarkley · 19/02/2023 13:05

And many of us have young children and were never told this, so it's clearly not widespread.

UserNameSameGame · 19/02/2023 13:00

Not kissing babies is a relatively new thing. The last 5 years or so. As such, most people who aren’t actively involved in having a newborn now, or during that period, won’t have heard of it.

However it’s natural for you to feel that, because you have just learned it, everyone must know, because surely everyone knows everything about babies, particularly if they have been their themselves.

I do think that parenting classes should put it more in context - that the advice they are giving bring “the latest advice” also means it is relatively new advice and that maybe you should go a bit gently with those who are not in the loop. I think failing to set that context least to a big division between the generations. I read something on here last week where a poster declaimed she would never trust her PIL to look after her child because they didn’t know blueberries should be crushed before being given to a toddler.

I remember being quite snippy with my parents 15 years ago because they didn’t know that you shouldn’t give strawberries or honey before 18 months old, how important BLW and finger foods were, not to leave baby in a car seat longer than 30 minutes etc. With hindsight I wish I had recognised that they were all relatively new bits of guidance at the time.

All that is not to say the latest guidance is wrong, but just that it might need to be explained gently to others.

Katypp · 19/02/2023 12:51

I don't kiss babies on their faces so I don't have to justify anything. I just think the angst is completely out of proportion to the actual risk involved. But then it's a great opportunity to dictate to the inlaws and threaten to stop contact if they don't comply, so what's not to like?

Calphurnia88 · 19/02/2023 12:49

Katypp · 19/02/2023 12:40

I am sorry, but it is hysterical.
Lots of things you do with a baby carry risks such as using a car, not sterilising bottles properly, choking while weaning etc etc etc but no one suggests these should be banned. But give MN mums something they can exercise control over others with, especially in laws, and they are all ears.

It isn't hysterical and those examples are not comparable. At all.

Travel is essential, car seats exist.
Milk is essential (and not all mothers can BF), sterilisation tools and equipment exist.
Weaning is essential, there is guidance on when babies are ready for weaning and how to prepare food to avoid choking, as well as what to do if your child does choke.

Kissing a newborn is not essential, it carries risk and cuddles exist.

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:49

Kalasbyxor · 19/02/2023 12:40

ancientgran, I'm sorry Flowers
My colleague's daughter got herpes which infected her cornea when she was just a year old. It led to severe discomfort, the need for strong medication in such a little body, and ultimately, some scarring. They're pretty sure it came from SiL.
It's not posturing to take sensible precautions, especially when there is no conflict in terms of babies' actual needs.

Thank you. I feel so sorry that someone caused that harm to an innocent baby. I hope it hasn't permanently damaged her sight.

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:47

Katypp · 19/02/2023 12:40

I am sorry, but it is hysterical.
Lots of things you do with a baby carry risks such as using a car, not sterilising bottles properly, choking while weaning etc etc etc but no one suggests these should be banned. But give MN mums something they can exercise control over others with, especially in laws, and they are all ears.

Travelling in a car you are legally obliged to mitigate the risk by using a safe car seat. You should sterilise bottles properly, no excuse not to. Choking when weaning? Are you serious, you can't leave babies on a milk diet for ever, at some stage you have to carefully start to introduce other food.

None of that excuses an adult selfishly putting a child's health at risk. Kiss the on the top of the head, the tummy etc. You don't have any justification for choosing to kiss a baby on the face.

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:44

Reclaimtheoutdoors · 19/02/2023 12:41

That’s awful, note to self - don’t kiss baby when I have one.

and I’d never dream of kissing others peoples babies anyway, I can’t believe that’s even a thing.

and I’m that aunty who loves all my friends kids, comes to their birthday parties and give them cuddles.

I am happy if I have passed that information on. Somethings people have quoted we have to do, I mean the risk of choking when they go on to solid food doesn't compare does it, I mean they need food they don't need to be kissed on the face. A kiss on the top of the head, blowing a raspberry on a bare tummy are all great, risking their health, maybe their life and doing it purely selfishly as an adult just isn't acceptable.

Reclaimtheoutdoors · 19/02/2023 12:41

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:29

I was kissed as a toddler, got herpes (cold sores) I get them badly and as a teenager would get an outbreak at least once a month. I didn't get the nice neat little cold sore on the lip, I got huge ones and they have scarred. So a kiss on the face and 67 years of misery. It wasn't worth it but hey the adult did what they wanted.

That’s awful, note to self - don’t kiss baby when I have one.

and I’d never dream of kissing others peoples babies anyway, I can’t believe that’s even a thing.

and I’m that aunty who loves all my friends kids, comes to their birthday parties and give them cuddles.

Kalasbyxor · 19/02/2023 12:40

ancientgran, I'm sorry Flowers
My colleague's daughter got herpes which infected her cornea when she was just a year old. It led to severe discomfort, the need for strong medication in such a little body, and ultimately, some scarring. They're pretty sure it came from SiL.
It's not posturing to take sensible precautions, especially when there is no conflict in terms of babies' actual needs.

Katypp · 19/02/2023 12:40

Calphurnia88 · 19/02/2023 12:30

No one is posturing.

Current guidance (as many of us have said) is to avoid kissing newborns to avoid risk of serious illness.

No matter how small the risk may be, you are still putting your baby at risk by ignoring the guidance but that is the choice you make as a parent.

It's not hysterical.

I am sorry, but it is hysterical.
Lots of things you do with a baby carry risks such as using a car, not sterilising bottles properly, choking while weaning etc etc etc but no one suggests these should be banned. But give MN mums something they can exercise control over others with, especially in laws, and they are all ears.

DancingDaughter50 · 19/02/2023 12:36

@ancientgran
I can't understand how people can be so selfish.

At least back then they could claim ignorance.

Not now.

Unfortunately great grandma chasing dd around for a kiss terfifed her and I was too stupid and naive to say no.
We had to avoid her because she wouldn't listen.

namechange143 · 19/02/2023 12:32

We had this issue too. I was so scared of the cold sore problem but also other bugs too.

Our DS was born in lockdown so it was easier then.

I still don't kiss our toddler on the lips, I often wonder if that's a bit mean

Calphurnia88 · 19/02/2023 12:30

Katypp · 19/02/2023 11:57

So much angst, so much hysteria, so much posturing about your rules, so much showing who's boss for a risk that is surely so small it's not worth worrying about.

No one is posturing.

Current guidance (as many of us have said) is to avoid kissing newborns to avoid risk of serious illness.

No matter how small the risk may be, you are still putting your baby at risk by ignoring the guidance but that is the choice you make as a parent.

It's not hysterical.

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:29

Katypp · 19/02/2023 11:57

So much angst, so much hysteria, so much posturing about your rules, so much showing who's boss for a risk that is surely so small it's not worth worrying about.

I was kissed as a toddler, got herpes (cold sores) I get them badly and as a teenager would get an outbreak at least once a month. I didn't get the nice neat little cold sore on the lip, I got huge ones and they have scarred. So a kiss on the face and 67 years of misery. It wasn't worth it but hey the adult did what they wanted.

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:26

JenniferBarkley · 18/02/2023 09:20

My youngest is only 2 and was born in summer 2020 and we were never told this.

Honestly can't remember who missed who and where but no problem with it here. The idea of not kissing your own baby on the face is so sad.

Not as sad as giving them herpes.

ancientgran · 19/02/2023 12:07

BashfulClam · 17/02/2023 20:59

I’m not sure but people with cold sores even if they have no active sore shouldn’t as they can still be infectious for herpes before a sore develops.

Even people who have never had an outbreak can be carrying the herpes virus and can pass it on. Some people have an immune system that means they don't get the sores but still shed virus so no one should be kissing a baby near the eyes, the mouth or any sore/broken skin. Far safer to say no kissing the face. Kiss somewhere with thicker unbroken skin and keep them safe.

Inspirationpending · 19/02/2023 12:00

There is a recent campaign from the Kit Tarka foundation explaining the risks around neonatal herpes and why newborns shouldn’t be kissed on the face.
Its rare but can be fatal

Katypp · 19/02/2023 11:57

So much angst, so much hysteria, so much posturing about your rules, so much showing who's boss for a risk that is surely so small it's not worth worrying about.