Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up on heels?

232 replies

Mimmi78 · 17/02/2023 17:41

I have had a life long love affair with heels, tall, shiny, colours, kittens, courts and sky highs.
Roll forward to working from home since 2020 and now spend one day a week in my Central London office.
I have recently found a whole day in them excruciating and painful. just can't wear heels all day anymore! I have been lugging them about in a bag and do the train to office in trainers and any other walking!
Aibu - just keep lugging them about like the rest of us!
Yanbu- Join the revolution and here are some fabulous feel good but not horrid alternatives!

OP posts:
latticeleaf · 19/02/2023 12:36

I agree they are very dated and I am very pleased about this because:

  1. They are really bad for our feet and can cause bunions and permanently shorten the Achilles tendon. Women have far more foot surgeries than men in the UK.
  2. Some women claim they need them to 'power dress' Not seen any working men choosing to use them to feel powerful or look professional.
  3. Many women wearing them end up walking bare foot after a night out because they are in so much pain but I've never seen men 'choose' to wear them to a club and walk home bare foot.
  4. They are very difficult to run in, contrary to a couple of posters claims on this thread that they can run better in heels. Never seen an athlete choose to wear heels to run a race in for speed and comfort.
  5. Many women have to load a spare pair of shoes in their bag just so they can get from A to B because they can't when they wear heels. Not seen many (any) men do this.
  6. Thinking you like something through free choice is often actually down to social norms and aesthetic expectations. Men generally don't choose to wear heel because it is not the social norm or expectation. They also don't have social imagery and expectations of beauty around them being long and slender.

I am out quite a bit and I have seen so many women with very cute flats and boots with dresses. Definitely not seen any women under 45 in heels.

jays · 19/02/2023 11:39

Cinecitta · 19/02/2023 09:14

Nobody “grooms” women to wear anything. They do it willingly.
They do it for men’s attention. If anyone dismisses it, they are lying. Of course women wear high heels for attention. What else would they wear them? For their own amusement?
The idea behind high heels is that they elongate the legs and jot out the arse and tits. It’s about sexual titillation, a signal for men.
Oh my, I sound like Germaine Greer! 😆

I’ll tell you why I wear high heel. I’m really short. I’m slim but I have really chunky calves, my mum did too, it’s just genetic. I feel so dumpy and dislike the way my legs look in a dress unless I have heels on. I need a bit of a slight platform, don’t suit ankle straps and I don’t suit a thin stiletto heel, I need to balance out my calves. I would love to wear ballet pumps but I don’t suit them. Id love to wear biker boots with a dress, that’s my dream look. But I don’t suit that. I can’t help what I suit and what makes me feel like I’m dressing for my body shape. It’s really disheartening to hear the judgment from some of the women in this thread that they’d look at me and think I’m old, unfavourable, stupid, not to be taken seriously. I don’t shout flat shoes with a dress. Just like some people don’t suit skinny jeans. It really is that simple. I would love to suit flat shoes but I don’t. Doesn’t mean in stupid, trying to disable myself, can’t do my job properly or am desperate for male attention. I just want to wear what suits me.

Busybutbored · 19/02/2023 10:42

Nimbostratus100 · 19/02/2023 09:09

well, I do enjoy a good proper difference of opinions on Mumsnet, but normally just blank out anyone saying silly things like "unhinged" as it normally just indicates lack of content in their posting

but I do need to come back to this

because of the flippant, throwaway "no one is being forced to" etc.

because I dont think its true

Those 80 year olds you are talking about probably were forced to

and these days, in the uk, it would not be legal to put it in writing in a dress code, but the expectation can still be there, social and professional

And outside the UK... well you only have to look at some of the awful ads for various airlines and see what ALL their stewardesses are wearing, to know it is still being enforced.

The more you post, you reinforce the 'unhinged' comments ... did someone in heels hurt you as a child?
Maybe the 80yo just liked to look nice, and I'm sure they did. The 90+ Queen wore heels, did you hate her and were you also disgusted at her too? She seemed pretty able to me.

Topseyt123 · 19/02/2023 10:34

I ditched stiletto and other forms of heels when I was in my mid twenties. I'm 56 now.

I've not worn them since and now have no clue how I ever managed to walk around in them. I kind of admire women who can and do, but to me the heels just look scary.

For comfort and security I would only ever wear trainers or flat loafers. I don't care what anyone thinks of my choices and I certainly wouldn't put stilettos/ high heels in a bag to lug around. Just why bother?

Cinecitta · 19/02/2023 09:14

VestaTilley · 19/02/2023 08:54

YANBU. Ditch them. Awful that women are groomed to wear them - bad for our backs and knees.

Nobody “grooms” women to wear anything. They do it willingly.
They do it for men’s attention. If anyone dismisses it, they are lying. Of course women wear high heels for attention. What else would they wear them? For their own amusement?
The idea behind high heels is that they elongate the legs and jot out the arse and tits. It’s about sexual titillation, a signal for men.
Oh my, I sound like Germaine Greer! 😆

rothbury · 19/02/2023 09:12

I don’t find heels uncomfortable and can easily run in them.

However, they’re just so dated and old fashioned. I got rid of mine.

Nimbostratus100 · 19/02/2023 09:09

magicthree · 19/02/2023 08:28

@Nimbostratus100 - oh, do give up. I have known women who have worn heels into their 80s without it 'disabling' them. No-one is being forced to wear them. You sound unhinged.

well, I do enjoy a good proper difference of opinions on Mumsnet, but normally just blank out anyone saying silly things like "unhinged" as it normally just indicates lack of content in their posting

but I do need to come back to this

because of the flippant, throwaway "no one is being forced to" etc.

because I dont think its true

Those 80 year olds you are talking about probably were forced to

and these days, in the uk, it would not be legal to put it in writing in a dress code, but the expectation can still be there, social and professional

And outside the UK... well you only have to look at some of the awful ads for various airlines and see what ALL their stewardesses are wearing, to know it is still being enforced.

VestaTilley · 19/02/2023 08:54

YANBU. Ditch them. Awful that women are groomed to wear them - bad for our backs and knees.

Calphurnia88 · 19/02/2023 08:51

Forestfire12345 · 19/02/2023 08:45

Let's not be too self righteous on the ballet flats there! It's a patriarchal plot 🤣

This is a good point.

Ballet flats will be my new heels at work... As in travel to work in trainers, then swap to ballet flats when I get to the office.

HelloBunny · 19/02/2023 08:50

Ballet flats can be very uncomfortable. It’s all of the cheap ones out there. I have some leather ones with a proper sole. No plastic shoes is one of my rules in life! (wore plenty of plastic shoes, years ago too).

Forestfire12345 · 19/02/2023 08:45

Let's not be too self righteous on the ballet flats there! It's a patriarchal plot 🤣

To give up on heels?
WandaWonder · 19/02/2023 08:45

Oblomov23 · 19/02/2023 08:24

I still love heels but only wear them very occasionally. I don't get the hatred, if others find them uncomfortable don't wear them, I don't find them uncomfortable and enjoy occasionally wearing them.

If they are comfortable why not wear them more?

Wonderwoman333 · 19/02/2023 08:44

They look dated, I never see younger women wearing them.
I don't understand why people wear them, why would you wear shoes that you need to take another pair with you to change into as they are so uncomfortable?
They force your feet into unnatural positions too.

ScarlettSunset · 19/02/2023 08:44

KangarooKenny · 19/02/2023 08:38

Ive not worn heels since I had plantar fasciitis. When you’ve known that pain, you know it’s not worth it.

It was flat shoes that caused this in my case. But I definitely wouldn't want to be wearing very high stilettos or similar these days either.

Forestfire12345 · 19/02/2023 08:41

I love heels. I could literally stare at some of them them as a thing of beauty. 😍(Ihave)
Unfortunately, can't wear them anymore. Not gonna lie, my life is sadder in flats. Actually sadder. A wee chance at a heel and I've got the buzz back. Feel fecking fantastic ✨️🙌

Herroyal · 19/02/2023 08:40

‘"an item of clothing designed to disable women for the viewing pleasure of men!"’

sums them up for me! As a gay women a rarely wore them when I was younger - the odd wedding maybe or work do - but now wouldn’t dream of it.
wearing shoes that hurt to walk in, and can damage your feet and toes, are hopefully not something my daughter will have to entertain when she’s older.

Greenfairydust · 19/02/2023 08:40

I think high heels in the workplace look a bit naff and dated anyway.

Wear flat shoes at work and keep your heels for night outs/big events.

KangarooKenny · 19/02/2023 08:38

Ive not worn heels since I had plantar fasciitis. When you’ve known that pain, you know it’s not worth it.

Squamata · 19/02/2023 08:38

If a person did to you what heels do to you, you'd sue and win a lot of money.

Herroyal · 19/02/2023 08:37

‘Corsets were actually very practical and comfortable.’

as of course! corsets famously comfortable, which is why women fainted all the time wearing them…

HelloBunny · 19/02/2023 08:35

I don’t consider heels to be “disabling” any more than the other things I used to wear back then... (when young). Skin tight jeans (no elastane), thongs, Wonder Bra, handkerchief tops, no coat on a night out. None of which I would do now. But I’m sure that girls all over the world are doing!

Smoothlines · 19/02/2023 08:35

I can’t wear any sort of heels -even two inches is too high for me. It somehow seems to catch the joint and creates awful pain, even at that low height.

Squamata · 19/02/2023 08:35

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 23:22

Corsets were actually very practical and comfortable. They had same function as our bras- support for being active. It was tight-lacing which was a fad and the replacement of whale bone with steel bone that was uncomfortable and caused the health issues.

Bullshit, why didn't men wear them if they were practical and comfortable?

Calphurnia88 · 19/02/2023 08:34

After a pandemic (lots of WFH), pregnancy, mat leave and soon returning to work I have decided to ditch the heels.

I'm keeping the ones I already own for special occasions (might eBay some) but not buying any new ones and I intend to wear flat boots and ballet flats to work. I love The Row Mary Jane ballet flats and luckily there are some good dupes at Zara, Cos, etc.

Oblomov23 · 19/02/2023 08:34

How do you know that disables then whilst? Or after? Not everyone finds wearing them uncomfortable.