Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the language of ‘choice’ is not always helpful

157 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 15:48

Of course access to contraception and reproductive health services is a Very Good Thing and is linked in clear and obvious ways to improvements in health and economic outcomes for women globally.

But there is an interesting side effect of the language of ‘choice’ that comes as a result of this access. In previous generations pregnancy and raising children was more or less inevitable for women, but now for a couple of generations we’ve been able to get used to the idea that it is a choice whether or not to try to become pregnant and whether or not to keep a pregnancy and raise a family.

The way we talk about this ‘choice’ effects those women who struggle the most with pregnancy, childbirth and parenting.

When a woman in a stable relationship chooses to try to become pregnant, succeeds in a reasonable timeframe, has a healthy and more or less comfortable pregnancy, survives childbirth with minimal scarring and goes on to raise healthy, able-bodied, neuro-typical children, we celebrate her choice, even though most of those elements are down to luck more than judgement.

When a woman actively chooses not to have children, succeeds in avoiding pregnancy, and continues to feel she made the right choice by the time she is menopausal, we celebrate her choice. This is perhaps more sensible as most of the elements here are at least within the woman’s control!

When a woman chooses to become pregnant outside of a stable relationship, or outside of a very comfortable standard of living, and decides to keep the baby, we question her choice- it may be foolish or naive- and use this as a reason to withhold support.

When a woman suffers illness or injury during pregnancy, such as HG or SPD or gestational diabetes, or is simply too tired and achey and indegestion-y and hormonal to make it through the day, we remind her that pregnancy is a choice she made and so withhold sympathy and support.

When a woman suffers terrible birth injuries we remind her that pregnancy was her choice, and she should have accounted for these possibilities in making her choice.

When a child is not healthy, able-bodied or neuro-typical we remind the mother that no one obliged her to carry her children to term, that it is reasonable to abort if you feel unable to cope with caring for a disabled child (though not everyone has this ‘opportunity’) and that it is highly unfair to expect society to pick up the burden created by one woman’s reproductive choices. We use this as an excuse to withhold support and empathy.

So Aibu to think the language of ‘choice’ is not always helpful to women.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 16:37

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 16:30

Oh sure, there are examples all over mumsnet.

”She doesn’t deserve a seat on the bus more than anyone else, she’s just a little bit pregnant and any way that’s a lifestyle choice she made” being one frequent if trivial example.

“I wouldn’t pick up someone else’s DCfrom school/drop them off at football with mine/look after them while their DM goes to an antenatal scan- that’s what DPs are for and anyway why is she having another DC if she can’t sort childcare for the first” is another frequent and less trivial example.

What has that got to do with choice? People are free to make those same judgement calls regardless of whether a woman gets to choose to keep a pregnancy or not.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 16:37

@takealettermsjones I am not suggesting removing options from women, I am saying that the language we use about ‘choosing’ puts an unhelpful emphasis on individual agency in situations where so much is outside of an individual’s control.

Its kind of a bait and switch at a societal level - as if to say “of course you can make reproductive choices, just know that we, society, will now hold you to account for all aspects relating to those choices. If you want independence in these matters you’ll be completely on your own if you run into difficulty.”

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 16:36

Women always had a choice though, except it was between giving birth or having an unsafe (not always illegal) abortion.

No one said that all the consequences of having choice would be positive ones, and nor do they need to be in order for choice to be a wonderful and vital freedom to have.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 16:30

Oh sure, there are examples all over mumsnet.

”She doesn’t deserve a seat on the bus more than anyone else, she’s just a little bit pregnant and any way that’s a lifestyle choice she made” being one frequent if trivial example.

“I wouldn’t pick up someone else’s DCfrom school/drop them off at football with mine/look after them while their DM goes to an antenatal scan- that’s what DPs are for and anyway why is she having another DC if she can’t sort childcare for the first” is another frequent and less trivial example.

OP posts:
Snaketime · 17/02/2023 16:26

MamaCanYouBuyMeABanana · 17/02/2023 16:14

Who is this 'we' who are withholding support for birth injuries, tough pregnancies or having a child with a disability?

I don't recognise most of what you're saying at all.

As a woman who had terrible sickness while pregnant to the extent that I lost weight during pregnancy and was thinner after childbirth than before, having to work even though unable to keep food down, was unable to be hospitalised because I could keep warm lemonade down, I remember being sat behind the till at work and a Male customer asked for something I had to get up to get and he said 'oh come on your pregnant not ill' literally no sympathy at all because it was my choice and women do it all the time.

MamaCanYouBuyMeABanana · 17/02/2023 16:14

Who is this 'we' who are withholding support for birth injuries, tough pregnancies or having a child with a disability?

I don't recognise most of what you're saying at all.

takealettermsjones · 17/02/2023 16:09

When you talk about support, what do you mean? Do you have examples of support (such as healthcare, financial support etc) being withheld from women in the circumstances you describe?

If you mean that society can judge women harshly for their choices, that's not new. But I don't think that's a reason not to have choices.