Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the language of ‘choice’ is not always helpful

157 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 15:48

Of course access to contraception and reproductive health services is a Very Good Thing and is linked in clear and obvious ways to improvements in health and economic outcomes for women globally.

But there is an interesting side effect of the language of ‘choice’ that comes as a result of this access. In previous generations pregnancy and raising children was more or less inevitable for women, but now for a couple of generations we’ve been able to get used to the idea that it is a choice whether or not to try to become pregnant and whether or not to keep a pregnancy and raise a family.

The way we talk about this ‘choice’ effects those women who struggle the most with pregnancy, childbirth and parenting.

When a woman in a stable relationship chooses to try to become pregnant, succeeds in a reasonable timeframe, has a healthy and more or less comfortable pregnancy, survives childbirth with minimal scarring and goes on to raise healthy, able-bodied, neuro-typical children, we celebrate her choice, even though most of those elements are down to luck more than judgement.

When a woman actively chooses not to have children, succeeds in avoiding pregnancy, and continues to feel she made the right choice by the time she is menopausal, we celebrate her choice. This is perhaps more sensible as most of the elements here are at least within the woman’s control!

When a woman chooses to become pregnant outside of a stable relationship, or outside of a very comfortable standard of living, and decides to keep the baby, we question her choice- it may be foolish or naive- and use this as a reason to withhold support.

When a woman suffers illness or injury during pregnancy, such as HG or SPD or gestational diabetes, or is simply too tired and achey and indegestion-y and hormonal to make it through the day, we remind her that pregnancy is a choice she made and so withhold sympathy and support.

When a woman suffers terrible birth injuries we remind her that pregnancy was her choice, and she should have accounted for these possibilities in making her choice.

When a child is not healthy, able-bodied or neuro-typical we remind the mother that no one obliged her to carry her children to term, that it is reasonable to abort if you feel unable to cope with caring for a disabled child (though not everyone has this ‘opportunity’) and that it is highly unfair to expect society to pick up the burden created by one woman’s reproductive choices. We use this as an excuse to withhold support and empathy.

So Aibu to think the language of ‘choice’ is not always helpful to women.

OP posts:
CupidCantAimStraight · 18/02/2023 01:15

When a woman actively chooses not to have children, succeeds in avoiding pregnancy, and continues to feel she made the right choice by the time she is menopausal, we celebrate her choice.

Do we celebrate that choice?

At Christmas I was called, and I quote, a "selfish cow" for choosing not to have children. DP also doesn't want children. We were both independently of that mindset before we got together.

Despite the fact my children would have a 50/50 chance of disability, apparently I'm still selfish for not producing an entire litter of disabled children.

Saw this reel yesterday and it very much resonated
www.instagram.com/reel/Cof7ELmDNZ0/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=

Bottom line is, women can't win.

Busybutbored · 18/02/2023 01:01

SimonRileysGhost · 18/02/2023 00:46

Posters on MN for a start.

Why did you have a child/children with this cock lodger?
Why did you have a child if you're on benefits?
Why did you have another child if your first was such hard work?
All questions asked on here frequently.

I once complained on a thread here about having a hard day with my kids. I was told that I shouldn't have had kids if I didn't want to spend my Saturdays doing home work with primary aged children. As if I could somehow magically push them back into my vagina and make them disappear again.

Those three questions are all legitimate, although fair enough if you didn't know he was a cocklodger to start with.

SimonRileysGhost · 18/02/2023 00:46

MamaCanYouBuyMeABanana · 17/02/2023 16:14

Who is this 'we' who are withholding support for birth injuries, tough pregnancies or having a child with a disability?

I don't recognise most of what you're saying at all.

Posters on MN for a start.

Why did you have a child/children with this cock lodger?
Why did you have a child if you're on benefits?
Why did you have another child if your first was such hard work?
All questions asked on here frequently.

I once complained on a thread here about having a hard day with my kids. I was told that I shouldn't have had kids if I didn't want to spend my Saturdays doing home work with primary aged children. As if I could somehow magically push them back into my vagina and make them disappear again.

ThreeLocusts · 18/02/2023 00:32

Hi OP, I Hinksey you're totally right. The language of 'choice' ignores a lot of context that shapes or precludes choices, and it devolves into victim blaming.

That has nothing to do with not wanting women to have choices. It's about the nature of the choices, and the ease of access to them, being misstated.

Busybutbored · 17/02/2023 23:52

Survey99 · 17/02/2023 16:44

When a woman chooses to become pregnant outside of a stable relationship, or outside of a very comfortable standard of living, and decides to keep the baby, we question her choice- it may be foolish or naive- and use this as a reason to withhold support.

Well, yes, it was a bad choice and people need to be accountable for their choices. But what type of support are you meaning? Most people of course support family/friends where they can, regardless of the validity of their choices. If someone needs a significant amount of extra support beyond what is usual and others feel they can't or don't want to give it, it is not "withholding support", they are simply prioritising their own wellbeing/family which they have the right to do.

The rest of you post is bonkers. I have next experienced anything like that. Of course you will always meet the odd twat, but generally most people are sympathetic to anyone suffering from pregnancy related suffering or outcomes.

This 💯
If you are choosing to have a child in these circumstances, then it is a very selfish choice, and you do have to live with the consequences of that decision

WandaWonder · 17/02/2023 23:26

A pregnancy creates life it is not the same thing as buying a car, house holiday, supporting a team, choosing a political party

When having a baby the parents choices are affecting someone who did not ask to be born, their choices ultimately affect another

So yes people should make careful choices when it comes to having a baby and how they raise any children they have

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 23:25

EatYourVegetables · 17/02/2023 23:21

Affects, not effects.

Also YABU.

Yeah effects has been bugging me. Need an edit function!!

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 23:24

I’m really interested by a common theme from @Yousee @Pineapple9210 and @Languagelanguage

They all three have described how the problem they encountered was unforeseen- I wasn’t disabled when I chose to get pregnant, I had no reason to expect I’d suffer HG, my organs were totally fine before pregnancy.

I think this is a direct consequence of the way we talk about choice. Women feel they have to assert that the problem was utterly unexpected, to prove that their original choice was valid and correct, in order to be heard and to receive sympathy or support.

If there is such pressure around reproductive choice and the way we discuss it, where does this leave the woman who has terrible HG and then chooses a second pregnancy? Or the woman with CP who wants to start a family? If their journey through pregnancy and child rearing is not smooth, do they deserve support?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 23:21

5128gap · 17/02/2023 23:09

But there are some choices that are so common amongst human beings they are viewed differently, in some cases the right to them actually protected by laws ( the right to family life) as such they tend to be viewed differently from the choice to buy a new sofa or go on holiday.
The choice to live as adults with some independence and autonomy, to share our lives with a partner, to live in communities with other people. No one would tell someone struggling with their bills it was their choice to move out of the parental home at 35, or tell someone abused in a relationship it was their choice to live with a partner in the first place. Though those too are choices.
Yet if i understand OPs point correctly, a woman struggling with parenting is told it was her choice, so get on with it in a way that's not applied to comparable choices.

Actually they may well be told that.

Level of incidence does not negate that they are indeed choices. Easy or hard, with or without ‘worthy’ or understandable motivations, they are choices nonetheless. Biological urge is not determinism, as we are not governed solely by instinct but have the capacity to be rational. Individual responsibility for said choices cannot be, and arguably should not be, disavowed.

‘Choice’ may be used as a weapon, but so is the idea that women aren’t in fact capable of choice and are creatures governed by hormones. People who are inclined to attack women will do so anyway, no matter the words they use to do so.

EatYourVegetables · 17/02/2023 23:21

Affects, not effects.

Also YABU.

5128gap · 17/02/2023 23:09

whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 22:33

But is indeed a choice. It’s a human right yes, and a biological urge (rather than purpose, as if it’s by design), but it is still a choice.

But there are some choices that are so common amongst human beings they are viewed differently, in some cases the right to them actually protected by laws ( the right to family life) as such they tend to be viewed differently from the choice to buy a new sofa or go on holiday.
The choice to live as adults with some independence and autonomy, to share our lives with a partner, to live in communities with other people. No one would tell someone struggling with their bills it was their choice to move out of the parental home at 35, or tell someone abused in a relationship it was their choice to live with a partner in the first place. Though those too are choices.
Yet if i understand OPs point correctly, a woman struggling with parenting is told it was her choice, so get on with it in a way that's not applied to comparable choices.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 23:09

@pinkySilver I do agree with you that people are very quick to judge and draw boundaries in life. And common values are useful and important. I also agree that there should be accountability for choices that we make, especially choices that have a negative impact on others such as theft or violence.

Where I disagree is about which things are real, meaningful choices. What we eat, how hard we work, how many kids we have etc are framed as choices but individuals don’t actually have a lot of control a lot of the time. If we hold somebody accountable for a ‘choice’ that wasn’t freely made, or for an unexpected consequence of an earlier choice, we often end up simply being cruel.

OP posts:
pinkySilver · 17/02/2023 22:52

I think you're making something from nothing. But I don't expect you or many to agree. People will always judge - as you are now. It's normal. What's good, what's bad, what do we a society approve and what do we not. Otherwise how can we have a society, (which is a group held together by common values?) They / we judge everything - not just having kids. And it;s how we evolve.

And I also think we should be accountable for our choices. What we eat, how hard we work, what we spend, how we partner up, how many kids we have, how much we drink, whether we decide to break the law or not... Our choice. But there should also be compassion and support for those who have rough luck or for whom things don't work out.

Overall I don't think support is deliberately withheld though - and the woman who has two kids in a stable relationship with both partners working gets far less from the state than the mother with no home, no funds, no partner.

So I think you are making something out of nothing. But I don't expect anyone to agree.

JaneJeffer · 17/02/2023 22:50

What a load of rubbish.

enweto · 17/02/2023 22:48

I think you might be overthinking it tbh.

I get what you’re saying, but that’s language for you. No real alternative is there?

whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 22:40

SarahAndQuack · 17/02/2023 22:36

Of course they haven't always had that choice. What utter bullshit.

Not always legally, not always with social approval and not always without, but abortion techniques have been utilized for millennia. Even today, roughly half of all worldwide abortions occur in countries where it is illegal.

That is why ‘pro life’ laws don’t work, because they don’t stop abortions, they just put women in danger.

SarahAndQuack · 17/02/2023 22:36

whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 16:36

Women always had a choice though, except it was between giving birth or having an unsafe (not always illegal) abortion.

No one said that all the consequences of having choice would be positive ones, and nor do they need to be in order for choice to be a wonderful and vital freedom to have.

Of course they haven't always had that choice. What utter bullshit.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 22:34

LlynTegid · 17/02/2023 21:50

OP I agree with you. Not just because there is an element of luck and good fortune, but because we don't know individual circumstances of most people. Choice may be a valid word in some limited way (such as when talking about the options for an unplanned pregnancy) but not in the wider context and all the situations you describe.

Thanks @LlynTegid you put that really well

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 17/02/2023 22:33

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 22:28

No @5128gap I think you articulated that really nicely!

But is indeed a choice. It’s a human right yes, and a biological urge (rather than purpose, as if it’s by design), but it is still a choice.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 22:28

No @5128gap I think you articulated that really nicely!

OP posts:
5128gap · 17/02/2023 22:13

It is that by framing this fundamental human right/biological purpose as a lifestyle choice, we are reducing it to some sort of luxury that is gatekept for those who can afford it, are sensible enough to do it 'properly', and have only themselves to blame if it goes wrong? Or have I misunderstood?

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 22:09

Thelnebriati · 17/02/2023 22:03

The only people I've seen pushing 'pregnancy as a choice' in a derogatory way
(ie 'you chose to get pregnant so suck it up') are men who twist the word 'equality' to mean 'identical treatment'.

I’ve definitely seen that happen and it is Not Nice. Somehow though I find it more upsetting when other women do it.

OP posts:
AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 22:06

Languagelanguage · 17/02/2023 19:48

You're right. I was disabled by pregnancy and quickly learned to tell people otherwise the hostility I faced for being disabled with a baby (aka bad choice) was really depressing.

It also gives men a dirty out (they pretend it's a contraceptive choice open to the woman after the fact when it may not be for her).

@Languagelanguage I’m so sorry you went through that. And how terrible to then have to be defensively telling people all about private, sensitive information for fear of further judgement.

You’re right about the out for men too… so depressing

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 17/02/2023 22:03

The only people I've seen pushing 'pregnancy as a choice' in a derogatory way
(ie 'you chose to get pregnant so suck it up') are men who twist the word 'equality' to mean 'identical treatment'.

Snaketime · 17/02/2023 21:54

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 17/02/2023 21:10

@Snaketime Im sorry you had such a rough pregnancy, but having had HG myself I know exactly what you’re describing with that customer. I hope your experience of motherhood has been much more pleasant since your DC was born.

Thank you. It has been a mix as I had PND with my first who had since been diagnosed with hyper mobility syndrome, DCD, ADHD, potential IBS and is borderline for autism. My second potentially has ADHD too.

HG sucks, I hope your experience of motherhood has been a much better experience too.