Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be surprised the NHS is in trouble…

211 replies

Itmakesnosensetome · 17/02/2023 15:34

We’re on holiday in Tenerife. We’re in a pretty nice hotel, fairly pricey so quite a lot of wealthy retired people . Pretty much every single person is very overweight or obese. I don’t mean a bit of a tum and hips- I’m talking huge, hard bellies on the men and massive women. there has always been overweight people but this feels unbelievable. There are some Spanish, Norwegian and Swedish people and none of them are fat - how can the NHS cope with this problem?

OP posts:
rwalker · 18/02/2023 07:11

letthemalldoone · 17/02/2023 23:17

So what's your master plan for turning this around then @Itmakesnosensetome ?

I think the idea is for people to be more aware and responsible for there OWN health

in this day and age should we really have to have our arsed wiped and be told be the government to look after our health

Catscatsandfourcats · 18/02/2023 03:25

@Itmakesnosensetome I completely agree. I'm currently in Thailand and it's obvious who the Brits are round the pool. It's really made me think about my own weight and lifestyle. I've put on a huge amount of weight over the last 2 years. I comfort eat, do little exercise and my mental health is suffering. This has been quite an active holiday but my body is aching, probably because of inflammation and I have poor circulation. I'm now opting for healthy food and doing gentle yoga in the morning. I don't need a doctor to tell me I'm overweight or what I should be doing about it. I already know but it's interesting to note how the Thai people eat. Their portions are smaller and they seem much more aware of how much food is enough. It's really brought home to me how bad the obesity epidemic is in the UK.

letthemalldoone · 17/02/2023 23:17

So what's your master plan for turning this around then @Itmakesnosensetome ?

Itmakesnosensetome · 17/02/2023 21:18

Sorry to seem like I posted and ran - haven’t checked phone as we’ve been doing stuff on holiday.

i see I’ve been accused of being ignorant/not understanding the true problems of the NHS and yes, from my original post I understand why this might be the case! I had been observing for a few days round the pool and the obesity problem was just so clear. I totally understand the NHS has so many issues, mainly to do with under investment and funding. I also get that dementia, which is not caused by any lifestyle choices we know about, is the number 1 killer in the UK. However, IN GENERAL (I get there are exceptions) obesity is caused by overeating and inactive lifestyle. It is IN GENERAL a person’s lifestyle choices that make them obese. I’m not a martyr - I eat pizza, drink wine etc but I also eat heartily most of the time (no, not lettuce leaves from buffets 🙄🙄🙄) and exercise regularly. So I just maintain a reasonable lifestyle.

to the person who was apparently the 15th person to point out that tits cheaper to holiday in February than the summer, this resort is expensive year round and many of the older people here are owner/members so the outlay is pretty huge. I was trying to point out that this isn’t a class issue, it’s epidemic.

thanks to those that highlighted that being severely overweight (again, I’m not talking about people who are carrying a little excess - I’m not body shaming and no, I haven’t felt that the men have hard bellies but you can see it) can cause cancers, are responsible for many hip and knee replacements, heart attacks, as well as by-pass surgery.

OP posts:
EffortlessDesmond · 17/02/2023 20:57

@htdef2 I sympathise with you and understand how difficult it must be to find a sensible balance of eating well, healthily and to find and maintain a balance after a life of yo-yo eating/dieting.

EffortlessDesmond · 17/02/2023 20:52

Anecdata warning! We have late DFIL's and GFIL's cine films of Canterbury daily life in the 1950s and 60s. Just people going about their business. And there is no one who is outside a bit "stout" or slightly tubby. Most of the women, of all ages, would fit into a current 8-12 dress size. There are no chubby children, at all. These are untouched, unedited contemporary amateur footage, and there is not a single person who I would consider overweight.

JenniferBooth · 17/02/2023 19:32

Friend of mine who has always had manual physical jobs can no longer excersise while waiting for the NHS to pull their finger out and do his knee replacement

htdef2 · 17/02/2023 19:21

YANBU

I am obese, it isn't good and I need to sort it out.

That being said, the support isn't there for people who are struggling with food issues. I have a cyclical eating disorder and go through phases of severe restriction (I've received help for this), binge/purging (I've received help for this) and just binging (where I am now) and there is zero help if you are a binge eater. Getting help for the other two issues with my eating was hard, but it is not there for binge eaters at all. I have been in contact with doctors for around a year trying to get help, but there is none - absolutely none!

I'm not a weak willed person, I've given up smoking in the past and have maintained 200 calorie per day diets whilst exercising for four hours per day. I need some help, I can't seem to fix this on my own, I fail over and over again. I approach every day with a plan on how to improve my diet, but fail, it isn't a will or discipline thing, it is a mental health issue.

It can be more complex than just being greedy and lazy. I don't even enjoy the food I eat, I actively dislike the feeling of eating and the tastes involved, I would describe it more as a form of slow self-harm.

RedRiverShore3 · 17/02/2023 18:29

With some people it isn't how much you eat though, it can't be as I sometimes eat a load of crap but my weight is always the same, about 21.5 BMI, some fat people probably don't eat as much as me and are still fat, I also sit on my arse a lot so it not all the exercise I do. I think some are just naturally fat like some are very naturally thin and its genetic

Sugarplumfairy65 · 17/02/2023 18:28

I've cost the nhs nearly £1 million over the last 8 years with the treatment I've had so far. None of it related to obesity, smoking or drinking though. I was always as fit as a fiddle until one day I wasn't. I'm thankful every day for our nhs

TheFrozenCanal · 17/02/2023 18:21

There is a difference between countries like Spain and France, and the UK, and I've lived in all three.

The two former have easier access to a very wide variety of fruit and vegetables. Their lettuces are varied and enormous, for example. The best we have is thr comparatively unappetising little gem. The side salad we would get next to a sandwich in this country is generally seen as a garnish, but abroad its very much part of the meal. In short, our relationship with vegetables is not what it should be, and we have easy access to beige, processed foods that make us lazy chefs.

There is another problem of course, and I think it comes down to housing costs. Houses in the UK are so costly that both partners have to work, where traditionally one partner couls stay at home and prepare healthy meals. This is a very difficult one to unpick, after all, who wants to sell their house for less so that the buyers can work less? Housing in france is much cheaper and pricing is less volatile.

In terms of beer bellies, it is true that beer here usually comes in pints, but in france and Spain a portion is smaller. You do see beer bellies in germany, and they have big glasses there too.

Lastly, as English speakers, we are strongly influenced by American culture, which includes their food, and that's not quite the case in france and Spain.

I am overweight: the cause - my cravings for chocolate bars in pregnancy, and the ease to buy them, though again, the kind of 50g portion snack product isn't really available over there. They do have them, but it's usually a multi pack of four so a bit less of an impulse buy at the newsagents. Their newsagents are also mostly news and mags, rather than chocolate. The range of magazines available in the average town in france is mind boggling, so much more than you could find in the spar here. They are as such exposed to much more inspiration for hobbies. Further, there is massive funding at a local level for grass roots sports of all kinds, think stuff like archery, which is sometimes seen as a bit niche here and is underfunded (I am an archer)

SweetSakura · 17/02/2023 18:15

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/02/2023 17:56

I actually don't disagree that obesity is a huge (haha) problem - it is.

But it isn't being addressed correctly - shouting at people and shaming them to eat less, well if that worked, we wouldn't have a problem!

People are being misdiagnosed, denied access to treatment etc because the stigma attached to 'fat' or 'obese' is so fucking entrenched even within the medical profession, that we're thought of as BAD people who brought this upon themselves due to their inherent idle greediness and lack of willpower.

My DCM was dx after TWO YEARS of pushing and pushing for help. Thats two years of wheezing, struggling to sleep, coughing if I lay down, an enlarged heart on xray, swollen ankles - despite weight loss and exercise (my first indicator that something was wrong was my decreasing ability to exercise. I went from skiing, climbing, horse riding, hillwalking, walking my dogs miles each day to struggling with my own stairs) - before someone referred me to a rheumatologist and treated my hypothyroidism... and then the rheumatologist discovered my heart defect literally by accident whilst trying to figure out why treating the thyroid wasn't fixing the issues.

My sister has the same heart problem, it is in fact genetic. She was dx in 2 weeks from first onset of symptoms. She is not fat.

If we could ditch the idea that all weight issues are soley down to people being lazy greedy fuckers, update the science (which is REALLY out of date, and/or involves studies on tiny groups) we could change so much and save the NHS a huge amount of money.

I whole heartedly agree and I note that people aren't engaging with my post or yours because they don't fit with their prejudices

SweetSakura · 17/02/2023 18:15

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/02/2023 17:56

I actually don't disagree that obesity is a huge (haha) problem - it is.

But it isn't being addressed correctly - shouting at people and shaming them to eat less, well if that worked, we wouldn't have a problem!

People are being misdiagnosed, denied access to treatment etc because the stigma attached to 'fat' or 'obese' is so fucking entrenched even within the medical profession, that we're thought of as BAD people who brought this upon themselves due to their inherent idle greediness and lack of willpower.

My DCM was dx after TWO YEARS of pushing and pushing for help. Thats two years of wheezing, struggling to sleep, coughing if I lay down, an enlarged heart on xray, swollen ankles - despite weight loss and exercise (my first indicator that something was wrong was my decreasing ability to exercise. I went from skiing, climbing, horse riding, hillwalking, walking my dogs miles each day to struggling with my own stairs) - before someone referred me to a rheumatologist and treated my hypothyroidism... and then the rheumatologist discovered my heart defect literally by accident whilst trying to figure out why treating the thyroid wasn't fixing the issues.

My sister has the same heart problem, it is in fact genetic. She was dx in 2 weeks from first onset of symptoms. She is not fat.

If we could ditch the idea that all weight issues are soley down to people being lazy greedy fuckers, update the science (which is REALLY out of date, and/or involves studies on tiny groups) we could change so much and save the NHS a huge amount of money.

I whole heartedly agree and I note that people aren't engaging with my post or yours because they don't fit with their prejudices

Dacadactyl · 17/02/2023 18:13

cptartapp · 17/02/2023 17:40

Dacadactyl unworkable. Most of the COPD patients I see for example are smokers. They simply wouldn't pay for their inhalers, BP meds, anticoagulants, ulcer dressings etc etc, and would land up in hospital in days with serious complications. In their thousands.
And that's just one group.

My idea would be that they don't get treated in hospital then either. And then they'd die. But i think people would change their ways if these measures were rolled out wholesale.

Of course though, this would cause moral and ethical issues for doctors and the medical profession may not get behind such draconian measures.

TheKeatingFive · 17/02/2023 18:06

The culture of taking no responsibility for one's health is not sustainable. You're not wrong OP.

letthemalldoone · 17/02/2023 17:59

@CarPoor "Do you desire to be fat?
How many times do you look at yourself in the mirror and go "god I wish I had more cellulite", give me a spare tire, bingo wings yes!"

^This!!

I don't know any overweight or obese people who actually want to be big. I think a lot of them struggle with being villified for their size, and that does nothing for their motivation. There has to be some underlying reason why someone is unable to help themselves with their weight? I don't think it's at all the case that people don't care?

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/02/2023 17:56

I actually don't disagree that obesity is a huge (haha) problem - it is.

But it isn't being addressed correctly - shouting at people and shaming them to eat less, well if that worked, we wouldn't have a problem!

People are being misdiagnosed, denied access to treatment etc because the stigma attached to 'fat' or 'obese' is so fucking entrenched even within the medical profession, that we're thought of as BAD people who brought this upon themselves due to their inherent idle greediness and lack of willpower.

My DCM was dx after TWO YEARS of pushing and pushing for help. Thats two years of wheezing, struggling to sleep, coughing if I lay down, an enlarged heart on xray, swollen ankles - despite weight loss and exercise (my first indicator that something was wrong was my decreasing ability to exercise. I went from skiing, climbing, horse riding, hillwalking, walking my dogs miles each day to struggling with my own stairs) - before someone referred me to a rheumatologist and treated my hypothyroidism... and then the rheumatologist discovered my heart defect literally by accident whilst trying to figure out why treating the thyroid wasn't fixing the issues.

My sister has the same heart problem, it is in fact genetic. She was dx in 2 weeks from first onset of symptoms. She is not fat.

If we could ditch the idea that all weight issues are soley down to people being lazy greedy fuckers, update the science (which is REALLY out of date, and/or involves studies on tiny groups) we could change so much and save the NHS a huge amount of money.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 17/02/2023 17:55

HoboHotel · 17/02/2023 17:53

It's the fat around your organs and the inflammation which is harmful. You can't suck that out.

Celebrate the English Pear.

letthemalldoone · 17/02/2023 17:54

HoboHotel, I had overweight family members, and as I said I could list plenty of obese people from childhood! There were obese children too - granted, probably a lot fewer than now - but I recall one girl whom the teacher called a barrel and laughed at her.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 17/02/2023 17:53

Queen Victoria was rather a chunk I believe.

I have a dodgy knee from aerobics, one of my friends needed a hip because of damage done by dancing. Obviously I know some weight related ones too but as with most things there are more than one answer.
I think people living longer is a reason for increased worn out joints as well.

HoboHotel · 17/02/2023 17:53

Seasonofthewitch83 · 17/02/2023 17:16

Oh please, not this bollocks again.

If actual adipose fat was so dangerous, why is liposuction not offered as a treatment?

It's the fat around your organs and the inflammation which is harmful. You can't suck that out.

MarshaBradyo · 17/02/2023 17:53

ImNotHereToMakeFriends · 17/02/2023 17:47

100% correct, my fiancé is a hip and knee surgeon, people are not willing to change their lifestyle but expect surgeons to perform miracles with a new hip or knee replacement.

The stats in hip replacements show how much the NHS has changed what it offers since created too.

How many of us will expect a new hip or knee in next few decades

on googling it’s pretty high

The statistics make it clear. In 2017, the number of primary hip and knee replacement surgeries in England, Wales and Northern Ireland totalled 91,698 and 102,177 respectively, based on numbers submitted to the National Joint Registry.

According to projected figures from a 2015 study published in the Osteoarthritis and Cartilage journal, the NHS will need to perform an estimated 439,097 hip replacements and 1.2 million knee replacements by 2035 to keep the population in England and Wales mobile and pain free.

ImNotHereToMakeFriends · 17/02/2023 17:51

NeedToChangeName · 17/02/2023 17:50

@ImNotHereToMakeFriends is obesity one of the main reasons for hip / knee replacement? I've sometimes wondered about that. it makes sense that carrying extra weight puts pressure on joints

Yes sorry I didn’t mention the link, but that is exactly it! The pressure on the joints.

HoboHotel · 17/02/2023 17:50

letthemalldoone · 17/02/2023 17:35

Of course there was obesity back then - I could reel off a list of friends/family/acquaintances/neighbours were obese in say the 70s/80s/90s.

I'd need a time machine to compare then and now, but tbh to say there was NO obesity, is simply untrue. There was more homebaking ergo lots of sugar consumption. People actually ate sugar sandwiches - that was a thing (ick). There were huge home-cooked dinners and sumptuous puddings, and plenty of fried food.

Fat people probably did die younger. Everyone knows that people eat more than they need to - the issue surely is why, and how can you help people to make more healthy choices - because in spite of all that is being done, it ain't working!

Of course a heavier person reading a pompous thread like this is going to exchange that bar of chocolate they were about to eat, and seek out a lettuce leaf....

Of course there was obesity back then - I could reel off a list of friends/family/acquaintances/neighbours were obese in say the 70s/80s/90s.

really? Thinking as hard as I can back to my childhood in the 80s, I can think of two obese people in my parents' generation, none in my grandparents ', and I don't think I ever met a really fat child.

NeedToChangeName · 17/02/2023 17:50

ImNotHereToMakeFriends · 17/02/2023 17:47

100% correct, my fiancé is a hip and knee surgeon, people are not willing to change their lifestyle but expect surgeons to perform miracles with a new hip or knee replacement.

@ImNotHereToMakeFriends is obesity one of the main reasons for hip / knee replacement? I've sometimes wondered about that. it makes sense that carrying extra weight puts pressure on joints