It's absolutely true that obesity isn't a pure cals in versus cals out problem in everyone.
Some people will, for example, have mental health problems that they "medicate" with over eating; some people will have hypothyroidism etc etc
But for all the people posting on these sorts of threads explaining that they work out every day, eat like a bird, but are still obese, there are people posting on the weight-loss boards saying:
"Ooh, tee hee - don't know what happened, but six biscuits jumped into my mouth this morning! And next week I'm going out so I know I won't have any will power after a few glasses of wine..."
I started looking on the low carb boards for recipe ideas due to having diabetes (not weight related) and was amazed that a lot of people just delude themselves and play at getting the weight off.
Bit like alcoholics who say "Boring old farts who don't drink! I'm here for a good time, not a long time - it's gin o'clock! Haha".
And there are loads of posts suggesting that overweight people be referred to a dietitian - like dietitians will know some magic way of eating exactly what you want while losing weight.
Dietitians will trot out the same "boring" healthy eating ideas that nobody wants to hear.
The reason I was looking for low carb ideas was because I'd been diagnosed with diabetes. I was referred to a dietitian and, 2 years later, I'm still waiting. Good luck with seeing one for just Eating-too-much-itis.
Maybe the best thing to do is eat what you want, snigger at the "teeny-tinies" and tell them to "stuff a biscuit in your gob, love!". But there will be consequences for some and there'll still be a load of fat people for whom posting on the various weight loss boards is their only exercise.