Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be surprised the NHS is in trouble…

211 replies

Itmakesnosensetome · 17/02/2023 15:34

We’re on holiday in Tenerife. We’re in a pretty nice hotel, fairly pricey so quite a lot of wealthy retired people . Pretty much every single person is very overweight or obese. I don’t mean a bit of a tum and hips- I’m talking huge, hard bellies on the men and massive women. there has always been overweight people but this feels unbelievable. There are some Spanish, Norwegian and Swedish people and none of them are fat - how can the NHS cope with this problem?

OP posts:
EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 16:55

I can be sympathetic to genuine posters; it doesn't render my concern about health services faux @TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl. I am interested in public policy and public health and politics.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:52

Rather than faux concern about health services

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:52

SweetSakura · 18/02/2023 16:50

This thread is really hurting me. I was a size 8-10 till I got sick. Then 5 years of being dismissed by doctors. And now on heavy steroids that have made me balloon to the point I don't recognise myself. Yet is clear that everyone, medical professionals included, is looking at me and judging . Its utterly shit. I'm not particularly vain, I can live with my reflection, but the endless judging is awful.

Not everyone is judging - and the people who are are thick twats.
Flowers
Im embarrassed for people like the OP TBH. I wish they’d just admit they want to bash people they don’t find attractive

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 16:51

No, I don't think the people who are obese but trying very hard to reduce BMI via diet and exercise should be denied treatment. The body is adept at adapting to periods of famine, and adjusts itself accordingly. Apparently, this is why 5:2 regimes work well, because a 24hr fast is not long enough for the metabolism to adapt to compensate. There was something about it in one of the serious papers this morning, which I think came from research arising out of the Zoe Project.

SweetSakura · 18/02/2023 16:50

This thread is really hurting me. I was a size 8-10 till I got sick. Then 5 years of being dismissed by doctors. And now on heavy steroids that have made me balloon to the point I don't recognise myself. Yet is clear that everyone, medical professionals included, is looking at me and judging . Its utterly shit. I'm not particularly vain, I can live with my reflection, but the endless judging is awful.

GenuinelyDone · 18/02/2023 16:38

Swiftbushome · 18/02/2023 09:45

It really is as simple as eating not eating more calories than you burn off. There's always excuses as to why that isn't the case for particular posters - I eat 700 calories a day and walk everywhere but I'm STILL overweight type posts - but honestly that's all there is to it.
I definitely think lots of people need a reality check as to what a normal weight looks like and normal portion size etc.
If everyone around you is big as well then you quite possibly don't notice.

According to every known metric I'm in calorie deficit every single day by hundreds of calories.

I lost weight initially when I started this new lifestyle of exercise and carefully managed food, but have firmly plateaued and stayed that way for 2 years. It's great I reduced my BMI from 43 to 35, but 35 is still too fucking big.

My doctors don't know what to suggest beyond VLC diet, which isn't sustainable or safe with the exercising I do. They prefer that I keep running and walking regularly.

Yes there are lazy/greedy people who are obese, but not all of us are. Should the ones doing their best be denied NHS treatment?

Everyone is purposefully avoiding answering this question.

LaMarschallin · 18/02/2023 16:33

EffortlessDesmond

The New High Protein Diet by a Dr Clark. It's a slightly more veg-oriented version of keto.

That sounds just the ticket. If it is OOP, I'm an inveterate haunter of 2nd hand bookshops, so maybe...Smile

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:20

Oh yay another fatphobic post.

The NHS is in crisis because of the long reigning Tory government and the fact we have far too many people in the country than services can cope with.

The irony is that most people on this forum will likely cost more than many overweight people - do you have any idea how expensive it is for people to have children on the NHS?

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 16:14

Great minds @LaMarschallin ! I've got another one that's better, but it's so old it's bound to be OOP. The New High Protein Diet by a Dr Clark. It's a slightly more veg-oriented version of keto.

LaMarschallin · 18/02/2023 15:09

EffortlessDesmond

Thank you - that's really kind!
And you're right - that's one I've included in my collection after learning a bit about low-carb eating and discovering that diabetes doesn't just mean giving up cakes, biscuits and chocolate. I really miss bagels and pasta and jacket potatoes <sniffle>
And I know I can have some of those things occasionally, but I do miss a big fish and chip supper from the local chipper.

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 15:01

@LaMarschallin Tom Kerridge's book, The Dopamine Diet, is very useful on low carb food. I know you didn't ask for cookbook recommendations, but it walks a sensible line between cheffy and healthy.

QuertyGirl · 18/02/2023 15:01

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/02/2023 10:13

It's a complex issue. Of course there are healthy overweight people but at a population level, it is a massive strain on the NHS (more likely to have health issues, more likely to get complications from other non obesity health issues, longer recovery times, specialist equipment needed, more people to lift etc).

But there are also other significant issues such as chronic underfunding, lack of preventative medicine, an aging population with no functioning care system and a culture of not taking responsibility for personal health. It's strange to pick out just one factor and focus solely on that. Even if everyone was skinny and fit, a health system with not enough funding and a majority of beds taken by elderly people who could be in care homes, would still not function

It's really not complex at all.

We drive everywhere.

People have forgotten what their bodies are for- moving.

LaMarschallin · 18/02/2023 14:56

It's absolutely true that obesity isn't a pure cals in versus cals out problem in everyone.
Some people will, for example, have mental health problems that they "medicate" with over eating; some people will have hypothyroidism etc etc

But for all the people posting on these sorts of threads explaining that they work out every day, eat like a bird, but are still obese, there are people posting on the weight-loss boards saying:
"Ooh, tee hee - don't know what happened, but six biscuits jumped into my mouth this morning! And next week I'm going out so I know I won't have any will power after a few glasses of wine..."

I started looking on the low carb boards for recipe ideas due to having diabetes (not weight related) and was amazed that a lot of people just delude themselves and play at getting the weight off.
Bit like alcoholics who say "Boring old farts who don't drink! I'm here for a good time, not a long time - it's gin o'clock! Haha".

And there are loads of posts suggesting that overweight people be referred to a dietitian - like dietitians will know some magic way of eating exactly what you want while losing weight.
Dietitians will trot out the same "boring" healthy eating ideas that nobody wants to hear.

The reason I was looking for low carb ideas was because I'd been diagnosed with diabetes. I was referred to a dietitian and, 2 years later, I'm still waiting. Good luck with seeing one for just Eating-too-much-itis.

Maybe the best thing to do is eat what you want, snigger at the "teeny-tinies" and tell them to "stuff a biscuit in your gob, love!". But there will be consequences for some and there'll still be a load of fat people for whom posting on the various weight loss boards is their only exercise.

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 11:42

And as yet, there's no good way to treat dementia medically, so the burden on social care is crushing the system as the aged population increases. We shall eventually have to have a social care insurance system that everyone contributes to individually rather than shifting the burden to local authorities via council tax.

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 11:36

@QuertyGirl On the button. There are people on foot, carrying shopping bags, pushing prams, buses and bikes ... but hardly any cars.

@DrinkFeckArseBrick In real (inflation-adjusted) terms, the NHS budget has quadrupled since 1979-80, according to an article I've just read in today's FT by Camilla Cavendish, if you want to read it: I would post a link but it's behind their paywall.

Obviously, lots of that gets soaked up by more sophisticated treatments for a rapidly ageing population living with chronic long-term conditions, the Big Three being diabetes, heart disease and arthritis: together, those three represent two-thirds of NHS spending. Arthritis may not be caused by obesity, but it's often a contributing factor in the other two. SO I agree with what @Swiftbushome wrote above.

Swiftbushome · 18/02/2023 11:04

yet the sad sad fuckers who rushed to agree with them purely to spit their venom about fat people

I dunno. Maybe there are some people who want to spit venom but most of what I can see is just people being honest. Obesity IS a huge problem for the NHS. Other than an aging population it's probably the biggest cost. Since we can't do anything about population aging - it's definitely worth trying to get on top of obesity, which people CAN do something about. People just don't like to hear it.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/02/2023 10:13

It's a complex issue. Of course there are healthy overweight people but at a population level, it is a massive strain on the NHS (more likely to have health issues, more likely to get complications from other non obesity health issues, longer recovery times, specialist equipment needed, more people to lift etc).

But there are also other significant issues such as chronic underfunding, lack of preventative medicine, an aging population with no functioning care system and a culture of not taking responsibility for personal health. It's strange to pick out just one factor and focus solely on that. Even if everyone was skinny and fit, a health system with not enough funding and a majority of beds taken by elderly people who could be in care homes, would still not function

MarshaBradyo · 18/02/2023 10:03

This topic always gets backlash on mn but I hope people are considering this and age related impact as it’s going to get even tougher

jemimapuddlepluck · 18/02/2023 09:59

Obviously OP on wind up, yet the sad sad fuckers who rushed to agree with them purely to spit their venom about fat people 😂always makes me chuckle.

Swiftbushome · 18/02/2023 09:45

It really is as simple as eating not eating more calories than you burn off. There's always excuses as to why that isn't the case for particular posters - I eat 700 calories a day and walk everywhere but I'm STILL overweight type posts - but honestly that's all there is to it.
I definitely think lots of people need a reality check as to what a normal weight looks like and normal portion size etc.
If everyone around you is big as well then you quite possibly don't notice.

ThighMistress · 18/02/2023 09:04

I suppose it’s normalisation. If all your family and friends are overweight, it’s nothing out of the ordinary to be a larger size.

I slob around in old clothes and no make-up; that’s fine round here - absolutely normal. When I lived in Manhattan I’d have stuck out like a sore thumb.

Adverts featuring very fat people and wide availability of vanity-sized clothes - including school uniform - all go to helping people think it’s quite all right to be what is actually a very unhealthy weight.

QuertyGirl · 18/02/2023 07:35

EffortlessDesmond · 17/02/2023 20:52

Anecdata warning! We have late DFIL's and GFIL's cine films of Canterbury daily life in the 1950s and 60s. Just people going about their business. And there is no one who is outside a bit "stout" or slightly tubby. Most of the women, of all ages, would fit into a current 8-12 dress size. There are no chubby children, at all. These are untouched, unedited contemporary amateur footage, and there is not a single person who I would consider overweight.

They didn't drive every

TheaBrandt · 18/02/2023 07:34

If it were up to me there would be a massive education campaign with proper nutrition advice and stats about what obesity can lead to like with smoking, We changed societal attitudes to drink driving / smoking same needs to be done for personal responsibility for your own health.

I would legislate so supermarkets can’t push shit processed food and ensure every teen taught proper nutrition/ health/exercise and easy healthy recipes. Lots of teens and young adults are very into the gym healthy eating lifestyle anyway the boomers and gen x need to take a leaf out if their book…

donttellmehesalive · 18/02/2023 07:27

I'm overweight and agree with you that it's a big problem op.

I don't think any of us can blame the government, the medical professionals, wider society or anyone but ourselves really.

Healthy eating and the importance of exercise is taught throughout fifteen years of compulsory education and calories are printed on everything.

Children are weighed in Year 6 and mn is full of people who are outraged that they've had a letter telling them that their child is overweight, explaining why they aren't and so on.

With the exception of a medical condition that exacerbated weight gain I think it is mostly down to poor impulse and self control, entitlement and denial.

Even knowing that obesity is likely to lead to poor health, lower quality of life and early death doesn't seem to deter us. I don't know what the answer is but it would have to be something radical at this point.

TheaBrandt · 18/02/2023 07:15

The fact it’s so widespread shows there’s a society wide issue though. Our eating / exercise habits that have become “normal” are actually wrong and damaging. Food that should be an occasional treat is eaten daily. Processed food and sedentary lifestyle leads to this. I am approaching 50 and down to 2 meals a day and daily cardio just to stay in a normal bmi.