Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be surprised the NHS is in trouble…

211 replies

Itmakesnosensetome · 17/02/2023 15:34

We’re on holiday in Tenerife. We’re in a pretty nice hotel, fairly pricey so quite a lot of wealthy retired people . Pretty much every single person is very overweight or obese. I don’t mean a bit of a tum and hips- I’m talking huge, hard bellies on the men and massive women. there has always been overweight people but this feels unbelievable. There are some Spanish, Norwegian and Swedish people and none of them are fat - how can the NHS cope with this problem?

OP posts:
MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 19/02/2023 19:24

TheSnootiestFox · 19/02/2023 19:21

Neither. I'm referring to those up thread saying that if they 'were in charge' obese people would be charged for treatment. In my case and for many women like me, we need treatment because we weren't diagnosed in time by an incompetent NHS. What's unclear?

Nothing now that you've explained.

TheSnootiestFox · 19/02/2023 19:21

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 19/02/2023 19:15

If by 'those in charge' you mean the NHS, are you asking for advice on suing for compensation?

Sorry, your post isn't really clear.

Neither. I'm referring to those up thread saying that if they 'were in charge' obese people would be charged for treatment. In my case and for many women like me, we need treatment because we weren't diagnosed in time by an incompetent NHS. What's unclear?

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 19/02/2023 19:15

TheSnootiestFox · 19/02/2023 17:45

So, out of interest, for those of us who are now technically obese due to 30 odd years of NHS neglect (lipoedema ignored from adolescence and now stage 3 progressed,) will we be receiving compensation from those in charge who are advocating shooting fatties or just expected to crack being abused for something that isn't our fault? Asking for a friend 🙄

If by 'those in charge' you mean the NHS, are you asking for advice on suing for compensation?

Sorry, your post isn't really clear.

TheSnootiestFox · 19/02/2023 17:45

So, out of interest, for those of us who are now technically obese due to 30 odd years of NHS neglect (lipoedema ignored from adolescence and now stage 3 progressed,) will we be receiving compensation from those in charge who are advocating shooting fatties or just expected to crack being abused for something that isn't our fault? Asking for a friend 🙄

User18936572 · 19/02/2023 07:36

I think some people are missing the Covid laws and want to make new ones for other things now

PrincessOfWaiIs · 19/02/2023 06:15

Florenz · 19/02/2023 01:04

I would also tax unhealthy food a lot, like 50%. And use the revenue to subsidise the cost of healthy food. I would also stop supermarkets (and convenience stores etc) selling unhealthy foods and alcohol. They would have to be sold in separate specialist shops.

Jesus Christ.

PrincessOfWaiIs · 19/02/2023 06:14

12 years ago, aged 38, I was a size 10. I walked ten miles a day for exercise, sometimes more. I did yoga and Pilates and ran a few times a week, too. Then I was diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis. Within months I could barely walk, let alone run. I went from being incredibly active to being sedentary. Plus the steroid medication I was put on made me balloon.

I'm now a size 20.

But people like you, OP, judge me all the fucking time. Just this week someone shouter 'fat cunt' at me from a passing car. A man in a supermarket recently told me that I shouldn't bother looking at the hair products as I was doing because until I lost weight I'd still not be attractive. And there is no way I'd ever go on a beach holiday or swimming or anything like that, because I know people like them, and you OP, would laugh at me, judge me and/or be openly hostile.

This thread is the last fucking straw of a really shitty week. I truly hope that you never fall ill and find that you have no control over your body any more, it's the shittest feeling in the world.

Florenz · 19/02/2023 01:04

I would also tax unhealthy food a lot, like 50%. And use the revenue to subsidise the cost of healthy food. I would also stop supermarkets (and convenience stores etc) selling unhealthy foods and alcohol. They would have to be sold in separate specialist shops.

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2023 23:56

VirtualRealitee · 18/02/2023 18:12

If you'd read the post I was quoting and replying to, there'd be no need for the sarky comment 🙄

People keep referencing Spain when it comes to threads about obesity, like they think it's a country full of slender inhabitants who don't have an obesity problem at all.

The shock of horror bit wasn't aimed at you. For some reason MN holds French society as totally aspirational. Children are well behaved. People are beautiful and all well dressed and thin. When it has pockets of obesity and other health issues related to addictions etc.

VirtualRealitee · 18/02/2023 18:12

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2023 17:34

"So why does Spain have such a high obesity rate?"

Across Europe, obesity is linked with poverty. Spain and France, shock horror, have obese people as well.

If you'd read the post I was quoting and replying to, there'd be no need for the sarky comment 🙄

People keep referencing Spain when it comes to threads about obesity, like they think it's a country full of slender inhabitants who don't have an obesity problem at all.

Ericaequites · 18/02/2023 17:52

@Iwantmyoldnameback Queen Victoria was 4’11”. In her later years, she had a fifty-two inch waist and symptoms indicative of sleep apnea. Her Majesty could only sleep propped up on bran pillows with down pillows over them. It’s amazing she did not have a stroke or heart attack earlier. Her blood pressure would have been very high. I revere and respect the Royal Family, but they had some terrible health habits.

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2023 17:34

"So why does Spain have such a high obesity rate?"

Across Europe, obesity is linked with poverty. Spain and France, shock horror, have obese people as well.

Ponoka7 · 18/02/2023 17:32

Florenz · 18/02/2023 16:57

There should be different rates of national insurance just like there are every other type of insurance. People who eat healthily and do a lot of exercise should pay half rate, people who who eat fairly healthily and do some exercise should pay standard rate, and people who eat unhealthily, smoke/drink alcohol, take drugs and do little to no exercise should pay double rate. That way there would be a clear financial incentive for people to invest time and effort in improving their health and fitness.

How would you get out of work addicts to pay? What about really fit drug users? Then we have the prison population. It costs society a fortune from a person being charged to the end of their incarceration. Those who have children under SS. Many groups could never pay enough into the system for what they use. According to many MNers, fat people are below child rapists and killers. We could do a individual spending system. I could use mine on being fat because in our family we have home births without even needing stitches. We are all very healthy, then drop dead. How the hell would it be policed?

VirtualRealitee · 18/02/2023 17:09

TheFrozenCanal · 17/02/2023 18:21

There is a difference between countries like Spain and France, and the UK, and I've lived in all three.

The two former have easier access to a very wide variety of fruit and vegetables. Their lettuces are varied and enormous, for example. The best we have is thr comparatively unappetising little gem. The side salad we would get next to a sandwich in this country is generally seen as a garnish, but abroad its very much part of the meal. In short, our relationship with vegetables is not what it should be, and we have easy access to beige, processed foods that make us lazy chefs.

There is another problem of course, and I think it comes down to housing costs. Houses in the UK are so costly that both partners have to work, where traditionally one partner couls stay at home and prepare healthy meals. This is a very difficult one to unpick, after all, who wants to sell their house for less so that the buyers can work less? Housing in france is much cheaper and pricing is less volatile.

In terms of beer bellies, it is true that beer here usually comes in pints, but in france and Spain a portion is smaller. You do see beer bellies in germany, and they have big glasses there too.

Lastly, as English speakers, we are strongly influenced by American culture, which includes their food, and that's not quite the case in france and Spain.

I am overweight: the cause - my cravings for chocolate bars in pregnancy, and the ease to buy them, though again, the kind of 50g portion snack product isn't really available over there. They do have them, but it's usually a multi pack of four so a bit less of an impulse buy at the newsagents. Their newsagents are also mostly news and mags, rather than chocolate. The range of magazines available in the average town in france is mind boggling, so much more than you could find in the spar here. They are as such exposed to much more inspiration for hobbies. Further, there is massive funding at a local level for grass roots sports of all kinds, think stuff like archery, which is sometimes seen as a bit niche here and is underfunded (I am an archer)

So why does Spain have such a high obesity rate?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 17:05

SweetSakura · 18/02/2023 17:04

Exactly, also those who do adrenaline sports (or maybe all sports - my son has broken his arm twice playing football.... Half the kids in a&e were there in football kit...)...

What about those who get a respiratory disease... They could have shielded instead. Or those who get food poisoning, maybe shouldn't have eaten at that restaurant ..

Funnily enough the OP herself is a very keen skier! Why should she get healthcare when she participates in a sport by which she could do serious and permanent damage to her health?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 17:04

Yes @Florenz adding to my question - what about disabled people who are healthy but can’t exercise? Do they get marked down?

What if a healthy person has a car accident and is in intensive care for 6 weeks - does their NI contribution go up? Who is managing and adminning all of this? It’s an awful lot of work!

It’s almost like people should think it through before they spout absolutely ridiculous unachievable drivel.

SweetSakura · 18/02/2023 17:04

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:57

OK I’ve just tear your posts.

And I don’t have time for the people with the school of thought that a health service should go “Got yourself into this problem? Get yourself out of it” Does the same apply to childbirth emergencies, COVID, flu, people who crash their car and need intensive care etc?

Or just fat people?

Exactly, also those who do adrenaline sports (or maybe all sports - my son has broken his arm twice playing football.... Half the kids in a&e were there in football kit...)...

What about those who get a respiratory disease... They could have shielded instead. Or those who get food poisoning, maybe shouldn't have eaten at that restaurant ..

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 17:03

@SweetSakura, there's no need to go off at me with quite such vitriol. I am sorry your illness and the treatment for it has caused your weight gain and certain that you'd prefer a cure.

I also understand that "healthy" food generally means more expensive and that anyone who is poor in time or money may struggle to follow the well-known advice. I don't know the answers but am trying to keep pace with informed opinion.

SweetSakura · 18/02/2023 17:01

Florenz · 18/02/2023 16:57

There should be different rates of national insurance just like there are every other type of insurance. People who eat healthily and do a lot of exercise should pay half rate, people who who eat fairly healthily and do some exercise should pay standard rate, and people who eat unhealthily, smoke/drink alcohol, take drugs and do little to no exercise should pay double rate. That way there would be a clear financial incentive for people to invest time and effort in improving their health and fitness.

And what about all the people like me , who are unable to exercise for years because doctors dismiss their symptoms only to eventually find out they were seriously ill? Because with my condition (myasthenia gravis) for instance, it is not unusual to go many many years before a diagnosis. Most of us loved exercise and grieve for the hobbies we have had to give up. But you would have the undiagnosed pay more NI ? I went back and forth to GPs for years being told there was nothing wrong before an optician thankfully spotted my ptosis and asked the doctor to refer me to neurology.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:58

Florenz · 18/02/2023 16:57

There should be different rates of national insurance just like there are every other type of insurance. People who eat healthily and do a lot of exercise should pay half rate, people who who eat fairly healthily and do some exercise should pay standard rate, and people who eat unhealthily, smoke/drink alcohol, take drugs and do little to no exercise should pay double rate. That way there would be a clear financial incentive for people to invest time and effort in improving their health and fitness.

OK genius so on an operational level, how does that work? And who pays for the man power it will take to police that, check for fraud, bring cases against rule breakers, etc? That’s A LOT of admin. It will we just trust people to self declare?

Od genuinely like to know your answer.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 18/02/2023 16:57

Years ago when fat was demonised it should have been sugar, can't think why that decision was made. It's why it's easier to lose weight on LC diets than LF. And those fats should be natural like butter or olive oils not plastic margarine crap.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:57

OK I’ve just tear your posts.

And I don’t have time for the people with the school of thought that a health service should go “Got yourself into this problem? Get yourself out of it” Does the same apply to childbirth emergencies, COVID, flu, people who crash their car and need intensive care etc?

Or just fat people?

Florenz · 18/02/2023 16:57

There should be different rates of national insurance just like there are every other type of insurance. People who eat healthily and do a lot of exercise should pay half rate, people who who eat fairly healthily and do some exercise should pay standard rate, and people who eat unhealthily, smoke/drink alcohol, take drugs and do little to no exercise should pay double rate. That way there would be a clear financial incentive for people to invest time and effort in improving their health and fitness.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/02/2023 16:56

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 16:55

I can be sympathetic to genuine posters; it doesn't render my concern about health services faux @TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl. I am interested in public policy and public health and politics.

I was talking about the OP, I hadn’t actually read your posts!

SweetSakura · 18/02/2023 16:56

EffortlessDesmond · 18/02/2023 16:51

No, I don't think the people who are obese but trying very hard to reduce BMI via diet and exercise should be denied treatment. The body is adept at adapting to periods of famine, and adjusts itself accordingly. Apparently, this is why 5:2 regimes work well, because a 24hr fast is not long enough for the metabolism to adapt to compensate. There was something about it in one of the serious papers this morning, which I think came from research arising out of the Zoe Project.

Only those "working very hard via diet and exercise" ?
Fuck off.

Medicines caused my weight gain. And they still haven't got my symptoms stable enough to enable me to exercise regularly. I bloody love exercise! I used to run to the pool then swim a couple of miles and run home. I used to paddle board or kayak or cycle for hours. Now I can only walk a few hundred metres before I lose the ability to send signals to my muscles. I have to rest several times when brushing my hair because I start losing the ability to send signals to my muscles. Are you saying I don't deserve NHS treatment?