Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be surprised the NHS is in trouble…

211 replies

Itmakesnosensetome · 17/02/2023 15:34

We’re on holiday in Tenerife. We’re in a pretty nice hotel, fairly pricey so quite a lot of wealthy retired people . Pretty much every single person is very overweight or obese. I don’t mean a bit of a tum and hips- I’m talking huge, hard bellies on the men and massive women. there has always been overweight people but this feels unbelievable. There are some Spanish, Norwegian and Swedish people and none of them are fat - how can the NHS cope with this problem?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSnootiestFox · 21/02/2023 21:49

JenniferBooth · 21/02/2023 19:06

Tax Botox and fillers (more if they arent taxed already) If these treatments go wrong and people need treatment on the NHS to put them right they can pay for it

I can play this game too.

Oh yes, and what about all those dodgy breast implants done privately that were then removed by the NHS? Didn't see anyone going on about lifestyle choices then! 🙄

JenniferBooth · 21/02/2023 19:06

Tax Botox and fillers (more if they arent taxed already) If these treatments go wrong and people need treatment on the NHS to put them right they can pay for it

I can play this game too.

Florenz · 21/02/2023 18:51

Tax junk food and stop selling it in supermarkets. If people want to eat junk food they should have to go a specialist shop to buy it. And it should not be allowed to be advertised or packaged attractively.

DiddyHeck · 21/02/2023 18:33

I certainly don't see obesity as a "lifestyle choice" - I have never met anyone yet who went deliberately eating to excess to put on weight!!

Of the 64% of UK adults who are overweight/obese, there will be plenty who choose to do nothing about it and for some of them, the reason will be because they just don't want to give up or cut back on treats, junk food and alcohol.

So for some, it's very much a lifestyle choice at the moment anyway.

letthemalldoone · 21/02/2023 14:41

JudgeJ · 20/02/2023 22:32

However, if we are saying that obesity is a lifestyle choice and people should be charged for treatment, can we also include other lifestyle choices, drugs, alcohol, smoking related diseases and say those people should also be charged for their care? More and more lifestyle problems are now being 'diagnosed' as illnesses that let people off the hook, even being a slob nd not keeping your home clean and tidy is now a 'MH' condition. Let the NHS deal with illnesses, not never ending inventions.

What a ridiculous, nasty, supercilious post!!

I certainly don't see obesity as a "lifestyle choice" - I have never met anyone yet who went deliberately eating to excess to put on weight!!

So what do you do that "lets you off the hook"??? Practically perfect are we?

JenniferBooth · 21/02/2023 12:36

What absolute ignorance @JudgeJ If you are university educated as most of the middle classes on here claim to be it was a waste of money. i want to say brains and common sense are two different things but you dont seem to have either.

TheSnootiestFox · 21/02/2023 07:55

JudgeJ · 20/02/2023 22:32

However, if we are saying that obesity is a lifestyle choice and people should be charged for treatment, can we also include other lifestyle choices, drugs, alcohol, smoking related diseases and say those people should also be charged for their care? More and more lifestyle problems are now being 'diagnosed' as illnesses that let people off the hook, even being a slob nd not keeping your home clean and tidy is now a 'MH' condition. Let the NHS deal with illnesses, not never ending inventions.

A progressive genetic disease where non metabolic fat builds up on arms and legs eventually causing disfigurement and disability is not a lifestyle choice and I most certainly don't want to be 'let off the hook'. How fucking dare you??!

JudgeJ · 20/02/2023 22:32

TheSnootiestFox · 19/02/2023 19:21

Neither. I'm referring to those up thread saying that if they 'were in charge' obese people would be charged for treatment. In my case and for many women like me, we need treatment because we weren't diagnosed in time by an incompetent NHS. What's unclear?

However, if we are saying that obesity is a lifestyle choice and people should be charged for treatment, can we also include other lifestyle choices, drugs, alcohol, smoking related diseases and say those people should also be charged for their care? More and more lifestyle problems are now being 'diagnosed' as illnesses that let people off the hook, even being a slob nd not keeping your home clean and tidy is now a 'MH' condition. Let the NHS deal with illnesses, not never ending inventions.

BigMandysBookClub · 20/02/2023 17:55

I think the issue is that many of us work long hours and have caring responsibilities and a sedentary job. I barely get any free time between my job, chores and caring. I have a gym membership and try to run, but don't manage to do much because of time constraints and kids bringing bugs home all of the time. I eat fairly healthily and am not over weight, but I could do a lot better if I had time to make more effort. Modern life needs to be more conducive to being healthy and active.

SweetSakura · 20/02/2023 17:52

DonnaBanana · 20/02/2023 17:38

It's all about mental health I think. Mentally healthy people aren't running to the kitchen cupboards for a snack non stop. We have drained funding out of MH for years now and so much of a healthy lifestyle starts with it. Fix the nation's mental health and mood and they will want to eat better, exercise, walk more, etc.

Mental health services- absolutely.

Also easy access to healthy food (I lived in a very deprived area for a year, without a car, and was determinedly healthy but it involved carrying all my bags of fresh fruit and veg up a huge hill, with busy traffic and past drug dealers and prostitutes. I could see why lots of people just got take out /snacks from the convenience store)- it's easy to criticise people but they may be battling in all sorts of practical ways

An investment in research into conditions like lipodema and into better medications for autoimmune conditions than the steroids that come with side effects like weight gain/water retention/diabetes risk. Also research into the causes of the autoimmune diseases.

DonnaBanana · 20/02/2023 17:38

It's all about mental health I think. Mentally healthy people aren't running to the kitchen cupboards for a snack non stop. We have drained funding out of MH for years now and so much of a healthy lifestyle starts with it. Fix the nation's mental health and mood and they will want to eat better, exercise, walk more, etc.

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 17:18

@Swiftbushome, the remark I quoted was a response to this:

There's no disputing that obesity is a massive issue, but smoking/drinking/drugs/and yes, food, are all addictions that usually carry various emotional baggage. Do you expect people to be able to stop just because you said so? If only it was that simple! Mental health issues need to be better supported.

And I found it a bloody idiotic response. These things are obviously symptoms of psychological/emotional distress. And if we seriously wanted to tackle them, we'd be massively increasing the provision of quality MH support.

Swiftbushome · 20/02/2023 17:11

GarlicGrace · Today 17:08

All this "it's mental health" stuff is going too far.

Yes, you're so right! People make perfectly sane choices to smoke, be fat, be inactive, abuse drugs and alcohol, experience stress-related illnesses ... because it's so good for them? Being psychologically healthy and emotionally balanced, they look in the mirror and go "I'm really glad I'm a fat, stinky, broke addict!"

Twit.

So what's the solution? We just give up and accept that people will all eventually become obese and the NHS will implode?

Swiftbushome · 20/02/2023 17:10

Any sane person would still treat obese people too. But as a society we are putting much more strain on the NHS through obesity than anorexia. We really do need to address that on a societal level. There's no point in people taking offence, it's just a fact. And anyway there is a long way between overweight and underweight. Nobody as far as I can tell is suggesting the solution would be for people to starve themselves. That's ridiculous. We need people to aim for a HEALTHY weight.

GarlicGrace · 20/02/2023 17:08

All this "it's mental health" stuff is going too far.

Yes, you're so right! People make perfectly sane choices to smoke, be fat, be inactive, abuse drugs and alcohol, experience stress-related illnesses ... because it's so good for them? Being psychologically healthy and emotionally balanced, they look in the mirror and go "I'm really glad I'm a fat, stinky, broke addict!"

Twit.

SweetSakura · 20/02/2023 16:54

Presumably people would still treat anorexics, even though the "simple solution" would be for them to just eat more calories than they burn?

SweetSakura · 20/02/2023 16:52

My friend also overexercised and starved herself throughout her teenage years and twenties before finally being diagnosed with lipodema. Again, the unfair judgement she has faced has been horrendous.

And like others say, even if someone does overeat due to disordered eating, why is that faced with so much more moral judgement than undereating? When both are the some kind of psychological response. I was anorexic for a long time and even at the time remember being shocked at the people who would congratulate me on my figure. Compare that with the disdain for my ' swollen with steroids' figure now. Yet I am the same person. The same person who gives so much to society through volunteering and public service . The loyal funny friend. And yet some people would take one look at me and think the NHS shouldnt treat me.

Swiftbushome · 20/02/2023 16:12

Fair enough. I'm not judging either of you for your size anyway. My point was that it wouldn't make sense to "sue the NHS' for not treating the lipodema when it was stage 1 when the NHS website says the treatment would have been diet and exercise anyway. But if you're telling me the NHS website is wrong then OK.
I still stand by the fact that the obesity crisis is putting a huge strain on the health service (along with aging population which we can't do anything.about) and for MOST people even though they don't want to hear it, the solution is just stop taking in more calories than you burn off.
But actually you DID lose 10 stone so even if you didn't lose it where you wanted to - which is shit for you, I'm sorry- you've still made a massive improvement to you heath, surely?

JenniferBooth · 20/02/2023 15:23

@Swiftbushome I have it on my legs which stayed the same despite LOSING TEN STONE. And before you start i had it before the weight gain. My Gran had it Its hereditary in my case.

@TheSnootiestFox Flowers

TheSnootiestFox · 20/02/2023 09:55

Swiftbushome · 20/02/2023 06:36

Well I have never suggested that obese people should have to pay for their treatment, so I don't think your post was aimed at me anyway but I don't think the lipodema example makes a huge amount of sense tbh. The NHS website says the treatment would have been diet and exercise, maybe CBT and talking therapies to help you cope. Doesn't seem like in the early stages you'd have needed anything different to anyone else who wanted to lose weight. It says in severe cases liposuction may be needed and may not be available on the NHS but I guess in early stages it wasn't yet severe? Sorry to her it's progressed btw.

Dp you have lipoedema? FYI lipoedema fat is non metabolic so can't just be dieted or exercised off. The NHS website is about the worst place to look for information about it tbh as they won't acknowledge its a disease because then they'd have to treat it. Most UK women go abroad for treatment, I'm due in Germany again in April for my 3rd of 3 very expensive and painful operations.

But early diagnosis and conservative treatment could have helped, and that was exactly my point. Had I been diagnosed at the age of 14 when I could have worn compression and eaten low carb, it would not have progressed in the same way as it has due to me being told its all my own fault, I need to eat less and move more and being directed to slimming world to then spend 2 decades eating the wrong things for my disease, because every NHS medical professional I met said it was the right thing to do.

Then, I might not have got past a stage one, would not have spent the ages of 11 to 32 either starving myself or making myself sick and over excercising and certainly wouldn't have had to spend my house deposit on liposuction like I did last year. So, actually no, it's a perfect example! But I'll just carry on being judged by everyone who just sees the fat hanging off my arms and legs, and have actually no idea that not everyone has control over their weight no matter what they do. So, for me, the NHS is the cause of my problems and and I'm in trouble now because of it and not the other way around!

MyrtIe · 20/02/2023 07:43

Obesity can be the result of disordered eating in exactly the same way as being very thin can.

Do you make such sweeping statements about very thin people, too, OP? Do you attack and judge those with MH issues only if they're obese? Is being thin the acceptable face of eating disorders for you?

Quirrelsotherface · 20/02/2023 07:09

You are right but you won't get the right answers on here. In some quarters of Mumsnet you aren't allowed to mention overweight people even though there are so, so many more in UK (and America) than anywhere else...

Swiftbushome · 20/02/2023 06:36

Well I have never suggested that obese people should have to pay for their treatment, so I don't think your post was aimed at me anyway but I don't think the lipodema example makes a huge amount of sense tbh. The NHS website says the treatment would have been diet and exercise, maybe CBT and talking therapies to help you cope. Doesn't seem like in the early stages you'd have needed anything different to anyone else who wanted to lose weight. It says in severe cases liposuction may be needed and may not be available on the NHS but I guess in early stages it wasn't yet severe? Sorry to her it's progressed btw.