Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about my sons complete lack of empathy?

86 replies

DreamWaster · 17/02/2023 13:01

He is 10yrs old and has suspected but undiagnosed ASD.

He has never understood empathy and used to watch his class mates when they cried and not feel a need to cheer them up. He pays no attention to his brother if he hurts himself or has hurt him even if hes screaming/crying in pain.

we found a fledgling bird that was in a really bad way and asked to take it home. I was really happy thinking he wanted to make it better so when I gently said that it didn’t look like it would recover he looked at me in confusion and said he knew, he just wanted to keep it as it was ‘cool’ and wanted to keep it with his other things he finds like animal skulls and interesting rocks (we live rurally).

I asked him if he felt sorry for the bird and he said no so I asked if he’d ever want to harm an animal to which he also replied no thank God. Is this worrying behaviour for a 20 year old? He’s a sociable bright boy with friends and is doing ok in school.

I think I’m overly empathetic which may be why it worry’s me more.

OP posts:
anotheragain · 17/02/2023 14:20

MissWings · 17/02/2023 14:12

Doesn’t sound too concerning. Why is he not allowed to find the dead bird cool? I mean it is cool depending on which way you look at it. Particularly if he is into science etc.

It wasn’t dead, it was injured.

Its not caring about the animal suffering, but just seeing it as a collection opportunity that concerned OP.

That would concern me too.

EmptyPlaces · 17/02/2023 14:19

mamabear715 · 17/02/2023 14:14

@EmptyPlaces My youngest (in his 20's) is exactly the same. He's learned to come & awkwardly pat my shoulder if I'm upset, bless him!

My middle child is also Autistic and we do the same Grin if I tried to hug her like I do my other two, it wouldn’t end well 🥴

I love affection from my children; but if anyone else gets too close to me I’ll recoil and step back.

We can’t all be emotional basket cases or nothing would get done, being highly emotional seems to be the new favourite thing amongst virtue signalling dipshits who actually don’t have a clue how the people they claim to relate to feel.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 17/02/2023 14:14

I don't find his behaviour around the bird particularly concerning either. Often I don't feel specific sadness for a dead animal - even with avian flu my feelings are more around despair for the ecological crisis rather than sadness for one particular animal's life (or perceived soul or whatever). Animals and the way they 'work' are fascinating.
I'm not autistic and I've been working in environmental conservation for over 20 years.

mamabear715 · 17/02/2023 14:14

@EmptyPlaces My youngest (in his 20's) is exactly the same. He's learned to come & awkwardly pat my shoulder if I'm upset, bless him!

MissWings · 17/02/2023 14:12

Doesn’t sound too concerning. Why is he not allowed to find the dead bird cool? I mean it is cool depending on which way you look at it. Particularly if he is into science etc.

EmptyPlaces · 17/02/2023 14:12

I’m Autistic.

Crying people make me uncomfortable. I never know what to do or say and when I try I’m always “wrong” somehow.

I’m a Scientist so I’m a logical thinker; an injured bird is just nature being nature. Not something I’d get my knickers in a twist over.

Reugny · 17/02/2023 14:10

ShimmeringShirts · 17/02/2023 14:06

People with ASD do have empathy, we just don’t express it in the same way, or express it at all as it requires us to focus on another person then apply it to ourselves in order to understand the situation. And realistically what’s to be done about another child crying when you’re a child yourself? That’s something for the adults to deal with.

It depends on the situation particularly as adults aren't always right there.

As a PP posted her child has learnt to run over and ask if the other child is ok.

Other children will go and get an adult.

ShimmeringShirts · 17/02/2023 14:06

People with ASD do have empathy, we just don’t express it in the same way, or express it at all as it requires us to focus on another person then apply it to ourselves in order to understand the situation. And realistically what’s to be done about another child crying when you’re a child yourself? That’s something for the adults to deal with.

TheFormidableMrsC · 17/02/2023 13:51

It sounds to me very much as if he has a scientific brain. My son is autistic, he had a dreadful lack of empathy when he was younger (he's 11 now). For sample he'd set out to hurt somebody to "see what happened" and used to stare at them fascinated if they cried. It really limited what we were able to do and where we could go and I had to have eyes in the back of my head.

Fortunately he was diagnosed very early so that has given me a chance to "teach" him how to feel empathy. He is much much better now and will go out of his way to help people or be kind. It may be learned behaviour but it's working. ASD children tend to mimic so I was very careful to ensure he was mixing with nice kids. That sounds absolutely awful when I type it out but it definitely had a positive impact on him. I'm sorry you're in such a long queue for assessment, it's horrendous. I'd consider doing some courses, I found one called "Understanding Autism" very useful. Good luck.

Milky4 · 17/02/2023 13:46

Get him assessed of course and if it turns out he does genuinely lack empathy then please do remember we need people like this in society!

Going to throw in something as food for thought....most surgeons lack empathy or score low on an empathy scale. The people who literally save peoples lives, tend to score pretty low on empathy, why? Because they couldn't do their job if their brain was all filled up and they were getting emotional about cutting into a 6yr old to remove her appendix. Alot of people are OK with blood but still couldn't do that because they'd be shaking, thinking of the family outside crying, worrying about the consequences of losing the child....people who lack empathy don't. They get on with the job. We need that.

You also see it across other professions - Traders, Soldiers, lawyers, and high positions of power e.g CEO's are a few. But we need these people. Society would break down if everyone sat around worrying about people's feelings. There would be little progress.

If he does lack empathy, no doubt he will need support and help with EQ but it doesn't mean he's flawed in some way. It can actually be a huge advantage.

bikiniisland · 17/02/2023 13:46

I am autistic and suffer from hyper empathy.

What I don't possess are the communication or social skills to be able to transfer that to a real life 'my friend is upset, I should comfort them' situation.

WinterFoxes · 17/02/2023 13:44

Bit bloody tired of saying this on MN but being autistic does not mean lacking in empathy. My autistic son is one of the most empathetic people I know.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 17/02/2023 13:42

I think you can very assured by the fact he doesn't want to actually hurt anyone. He may experience empathy but just not outwardly and not in the same way you do. Just keep chatting to him very simply about how and why others are feeling a certain way. 'Oh look brother is feeling very sad we should do X to cheer him up. That bird is hurt, poor bird. Remember how much you disliked it when you hurt your arm.' Etc. Sounds like he has many positive qualities.

MuggleMe · 17/02/2023 13:42

Sounds a lot like my asd 8yo DD. I've had to teach her the appropriate way to respond when friends fall over etc, before she used to complain her sister was too noisy when she cried, now she can run over and say are you ok? But only because I've taught her.

MandeeMore · 17/02/2023 13:41

Sorry, but I do think you should be concerned. ASD does not equal 'no empathy.' Struggling to understand other's perspectives is not the same as simply not caring when somebody is in pain or upset.

I have 2 DC with ASD. One who is extremely caring, who struggles to understand alternate opinions: but does appreciate their validity.
The other is manipulative, gaslighty and more than likely has a co-morbid personality disorder. He also understands others perfectly well, he just doesn't give a shit about anything other than himself, sadly.
It's not the same.

If your son falls into the second camp: understands but doesn't care, I would seek medical assessment urgently. The teen years come around quickly and are hell on earth. I don't know how I'm still alive.

RemoteControlDoobry · 17/02/2023 13:37

It’s alexithymia that causes lack of empathy in autistics.

many autistics are extremely empathetic

AllOfThemWitches · 17/02/2023 13:30

I don't have advice but I do have a (severely) autistic child who finds it hilarious when people hurt themselves, if it's any consolation.

Conkersinautumn · 17/02/2023 13:28

My autistic daughter is very sensitive to others in pain, in that she will spot quite small clues that someone has a headache, injury or is acting differently. BUT she doesn't really try to 'do' something about that information. So whilst she is aware and thus able to be sensitive to others she won't appear to 'react'. If she has a headache she will generally be overwhelmed, and withdraw. She works on the basis that someone will say 'no I can't because of headache' rather than making allowances, so I would be trying to keep noise down for eg.

pppppppp · 17/02/2023 13:24

@DreamWaster My 15DD has ASD, diagnosed when she was 13 (it took 3 years to get the diagnosis).

She doesn't have any empathy at all but she doesn't hurt people/animals or go out of her way to be mean/rude. I genuinely think she just doesn't understand how other people are feeling. She can't really read social cues or people's expressions either.

Last year I really hurt my toe when I was on the landing, blood everywhere, DD got up from her bed and closed her door rather than see if I was ok as I was making too much noise!

She's a very literal thinker, and also really in to science. She's brilliant at biology!

I really wouldn't worry too much. It took me a long time to get used to the way she acts - for example ignoring her younger brother if he's crying. She's not doing any harm and I now completely understand it's just how her brain works!

DreamWaster · 17/02/2023 13:19

Thanks, this is all very reassuring.

OP posts:
Upsidedownagain · 17/02/2023 13:18

Having autism (if it turns out he does) doesn't necessarily mean not being empathetic.

Not comforting a friend or sibling doesn't necessarily ring alarm bells for me. I work with 10 and 11 year olds. The boys often display a macho, tough front. They're more likely to tease another child who is upset than to support them, though some do, obviously. If he is keen to be part of the dominant group in the class, he may well see a lot of this in the others and see it as the way to be.

He doesn't hurt others or do anything destructive so try not to worry too much. Once you get a diagnosis, if you do, things may become clearer.

ItsaStupidSillyThing · 17/02/2023 13:14

cues* not queues 😊

ItsaStupidSillyThing · 17/02/2023 13:14

My 5 year old ----has autism. Dc does have some empathy, but not in the same way as others. Dc will miss facial queues though and only notice more dramatic emotions. Dc will comfort other children at school, but struggles to think how other will feel and can be inconsiderate alot.

TooSmallForTheMembrane · 17/02/2023 13:13

romdowa · 17/02/2023 13:08

He probably does have empathy but maybe not as you experience it. I'm autistic and I have lots of empathy but I know lots of autistic people don't experience it in the same way.
His classmates crying , realistically what could he have done? Would a hug have solved their issue? Probably not. Same for his crying sibling. So he probably just doesn't see the point. He's probably a very logical / black and white thinker.

I’m waiting for an adult autism assessment and agree with it. Not caring and not responding typically are different.

DreamWaster · 17/02/2023 13:11

@Languagelanguage yes he is scientific and loves the natural world/biology so that would make sense.

OP posts: