Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to take this higher - PT workouts injured me.

82 replies

MXVIT · 17/02/2023 11:41

Hi all

I currently have a PT who i go to three times a week. To be brief there is some kind of weakness in my lower back due to an old injury, my PT is obsessed with a certain piece of equipment that if done wrong can put strain on the back.

I have fed this back to my PT that I'm not comfortable using this piece of equipment as I can feel a strain on my lwoer back and my old injury will come back - to which I am frequently told "just see how you go - thats the workout"

Added to this, this piece of equipment is brought out even when my sessions run on consecutive days (due to availability i cant always space them out) - again I raised concerns on this and said I'd be more comfortable if there was a workaround - again i was told "thats the workout - we cant change it - see how you go"

Unsurprisingly, i was using the kit and yesterday my back twinged out, today i can't really move that well and have been popping painkillers like sweets - even when it happened i was told "just carry on with it see how you go"

AIBU to raise this with his superiors? These sessions are not cheap and the business prides themselves on having the best PTs, surely my concrns should have been enough for this guy to look at my workout and formulate workarounds after my concrns rather than just forcing me into a one size fits all workout

I'm very angry that I'm now injured and debating raising this with his superiors as I judge this to be his fault.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
iklboo · 18/02/2023 12:18

It sounds very possible your sacroiliac (SI) joint is in prison.

I know it's an autocorrect but it made me laugh. My SI joint definitely feels like it's in prison when it kicks off 😂

Oblomov23 · 18/02/2023 12:03

You are extremely overdramatic in your use of language. Now. But didn't show any strength of personality before. You say you pushed back. Clearly not hard enough. And then you ask us 'short of walking out'. You missed out the 5 or do middle steps, between those 2. No. I said no. Please arrange another session not including this piece. I don't want to use this bit of equipment, leading up to the almost rude: which part of no didn't you get?
Complain away. In the meantime learn to be more assertive.

GCWorkNightmare · 18/02/2023 11:30

GCWorkNightmare · 18/02/2023 11:26

A friend started raving about her. I decided to give it a go and 9 months on can’t believe what I can do.

I’ve PMed you.

GCWorkNightmare · 18/02/2023 11:26

toddlermom1 · 18/02/2023 10:58

Where did you find your virtual PT if you dont mind. Im trying to find one

A friend started raving about her. I decided to give it a go and 9 months on can’t believe what I can do.

toddlermom1 · 18/02/2023 10:58

GCWorkNightmare · 17/02/2023 11:48

Definitely complain.

I have lower back issues and a virtual PT that has taught me perfect form. 80kg deadlifts and 60kg squats are not an issue because I know how to brace my back for the moves.

Where did you find your virtual PT if you dont mind. Im trying to find one

ThinWomansBrain · 18/02/2023 10:24

PTs aren't necessarily professionals though - some are gym bunnies using their hobby to fund a life style.
If your not happy with the current one - and that includes that he treats you, his client, with respect as well as the actual training element, then find a better one.
If he is part of a larger organisation, make sure they know either why you are moving on or seeking another trainer through them.

Theonlyoneiknow · 18/02/2023 10:14

I find it completely bizarre that a PT wouldn't listen to your concerns and not use that piece of equipment. Surely if it is a PERSONAL trainer they should be making PERSONAL specific workouts for you and not just following a bog standard workout. You should be able to specify that your personal workout doesn't include that piece of equipment.

nonevernotever · 17/02/2023 21:34

thecatsthecats · 17/02/2023 13:47

My PT was so good that he once turned me away from a session because I looked miserable. I didn't even have to say anything, he just knew I'd been under some stress and said, "Look, you're in no state for a workout, let's reschedule".

That's before you come to adaptations he made for injury, for the sake of having fun, or for the sake of covid fatigue.

A good PT makes exercise work for you. Injuries should be rare and accidental.

Yup this. Over the years I've had four different PTs and every single one of them was like @thecatsthecats . You have to be able to trust that they know what they are doing. I can go to my PT session and say actually X is playing up today and he'll rearrange what I'm doing immediately to accommodate that. If something doesn't seem right when I try it he'll suggest something else instead. If I look cold/bored/upset/tired he'll change plans. Which is why I a) come out of every session feeling tired but happy b) can see I'm getting results and c) if he suggests something new I'm happy to try it because I know he knows his stuff.

HundredMilesAnHour · 17/02/2023 21:27

thecatsthecats · 17/02/2023 13:47

My PT was so good that he once turned me away from a session because I looked miserable. I didn't even have to say anything, he just knew I'd been under some stress and said, "Look, you're in no state for a workout, let's reschedule".

That's before you come to adaptations he made for injury, for the sake of having fun, or for the sake of covid fatigue.

A good PT makes exercise work for you. Injuries should be rare and accidental.

Very true. My PT once took me out for lunch instead of training me as he saw immediately that I was in a really bad place and having a terrible time.

The OP's PT sounds like an inexperienced gym instructor who is following a programme that someone else has written for him. But the OP also should have put her foot down and said no.

chopc · 17/02/2023 21:13

I go to a group CrossFit class and have developed a tennis elbow. Even those workouts are adapted for me even though it's a group class. So I don't think your PT knows what he is doing and I think you need to discuss this with him and then take it up with the manager

GingerAle1 · 17/02/2023 21:03

GCWorkNightmare · 17/02/2023 21:00

Yep. She is excellent. Shall I DM you?

Oh sorryI thought you meant an AI thing, not a real person! Ignore me.

GCWorkNightmare · 17/02/2023 21:00

GingerAle1 · 17/02/2023 20:44

A virtual PT helped with this? Sorry to digress, love to hear more.

OP I hope you recover fast. Tbh I think that's very poor service from them.

Yep. She is excellent. Shall I DM you?

RelentlessForwardProgress · 17/02/2023 20:52

I go to Crossfit with a woman who was a competitive horse rider in her youth, she's broken practically everything and has bits of metal stringing things together through various joints. There are virtually no exercises she can do straight , everything has to be adapted/swapped/ modified in some way for her.

We have various different instructors and all of them manage to find suitable alternatives to everything.

The idea that a PT, with only one person to train, is incapable of changing one single exercise at the clients request is just ridiculous! I'd go somewhere else, because the PT isn't capable, but whoever is in charge there should have assessed them and their capabilities, and are as much deficient.

GingerAle1 · 17/02/2023 20:44

GCWorkNightmare · 17/02/2023 11:48

Definitely complain.

I have lower back issues and a virtual PT that has taught me perfect form. 80kg deadlifts and 60kg squats are not an issue because I know how to brace my back for the moves.

A virtual PT helped with this? Sorry to digress, love to hear more.

OP I hope you recover fast. Tbh I think that's very poor service from them.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 17/02/2023 20:38

*spasm, not prison!

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 17/02/2023 20:38

MXVIT · 17/02/2023 12:16

great point, i will do! sciatica would be a good one as the "pop" happened above my bum cheek and now my whole leg is achings so thats likely it.

It sounds very possible your sacroiliac (SI) joint is in prison.

Ice for 20 minutes, not more frequently than 2 hourly, works wonders. Far better than the pain meds.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 17/02/2023 20:35

MXVIT · 17/02/2023 11:41

Hi all

I currently have a PT who i go to three times a week. To be brief there is some kind of weakness in my lower back due to an old injury, my PT is obsessed with a certain piece of equipment that if done wrong can put strain on the back.

I have fed this back to my PT that I'm not comfortable using this piece of equipment as I can feel a strain on my lwoer back and my old injury will come back - to which I am frequently told "just see how you go - thats the workout"

Added to this, this piece of equipment is brought out even when my sessions run on consecutive days (due to availability i cant always space them out) - again I raised concerns on this and said I'd be more comfortable if there was a workaround - again i was told "thats the workout - we cant change it - see how you go"

Unsurprisingly, i was using the kit and yesterday my back twinged out, today i can't really move that well and have been popping painkillers like sweets - even when it happened i was told "just carry on with it see how you go"

AIBU to raise this with his superiors? These sessions are not cheap and the business prides themselves on having the best PTs, surely my concrns should have been enough for this guy to look at my workout and formulate workarounds after my concrns rather than just forcing me into a one size fits all workout

I'm very angry that I'm now injured and debating raising this with his superiors as I judge this to be his fault.

AIBU?

He's a bad PT, and dangerous.

A decent one would not having you working the same body parts two days in a row, you work different muscle groups so the previous ones can recover.

You work niugini a clients physiology and capabilities ALWAYS, including allowing for injuries/strains/disability etc.

"That's the workout" is bollocks. I trained as a sports therapist before becoming disabled, and with that attitude I'd have been kicked out of both my degree and professional body.

Certainly don't go back, and he needs reporting to prevent injury to other clients.

flabbygoldfish · 17/02/2023 17:43

My PT keeps asking if I can feel anything in my back after every exercise & then corrects my firm if I do.

LakieLady · 17/02/2023 16:38

ChChChChangeName · 17/02/2023 12:22

YANBU. What's all that nonsense about not being able to change the work out? The whole point of a PT is that your training is personalised.

Some PTs are great but there are some absolute cowboys as well and I wonder whether you've found one of them. I'd look elsewhere.

I see a physio for back problems occasionally. She has a real bee in her bonnet about the lack of proper accreditation for PTs, and told me that she sees a lot of people with injuries caused by incompetent PTs.

She's firmly of the opinion that some of them are downright dangerous.

FinallyHere · 17/02/2023 16:30

It's about finding someone who knows what they are doing, so you build up trust between you. Ten years after my first session, I know that even if my mind thinks a suggested exercise will hurt, it won't really. Even to the extend of changing an exercise, getting me to focus on say my hands or my breath so that I'm not tensing up the area that will be loaded.

Human bodies are very complicated mechanisms. For example, pain is often felt at the 'other end' of a muscle than the site of potential damage, called referred pain. It takes a lot to know how to successfully adapt exercises, working around the physical and the mental limitations. If your mind thinks something is going to hurt, it will hurt.

A great therapist will be able to put together programmes which really get the best out of your whole body.

I hope you find a good 'un.

FinallyHere · 17/02/2023 16:14

For so, so long any exercise I understood ended up with back pain. I had all the tests going so knew that it was purely postural.

Finally (sic) found a PT with an interest in posture and good (perfect) alignment. It still took a few months of exercising with an eye on using the right muscles and posture to make my core muscles able to support me.

In your shoes, I'd find a different PT. So many just have always had great core strength so really don't understand the issue. Find someone with an interest in this area.

Transformational.

fishonabicycle · 17/02/2023 15:52

Er just say no! You are paying for a service - a PT should do a workout to suit you, not 'one size fits all'! I saw a PT for ages and he would do whatever was necessary on the day - IE if my shoulder hurt we would do a bit of gentle rehab on it and harder work on other parts. Your PT sounds useless.

Ivyy · 17/02/2023 15:48

Op if you don't have one already I recommend getting a heat pad for when your back flares up. When I'm in pain and struggling to move much, I'll lie on the bed with it under my back and do various stretches. A good one for sciatica is lying with both knees bent, bring one leg up and cross the ankle over the knee of the opposite leg. Then gently push the inside of the crossed leg at the knee down til you feel the stretch in your thigh and up to your glutes. It probably has a name I don't know but my physio taught it to me years ago and it always helps that whole area. It's nice and gentle when you're in pain and feeling fragile but need to stretch that area out.

I'd complain straight away to this guy's superior, write an email while you're feeling like this and it's all fresh in your mind. It's totally unprofessional and he'll likely cause more injuries to others. I'd have completely lost trust now and not be able to go back to him again. Sorry you've had such a rubbish experience and really hope your pain starts to ease asap, it's the worst Flowers

SettingPrecedents · 17/02/2023 15:36

Oh come on people, stop having a go at the OP. It’s hard to stand up to someone who has knowledge or power or experience over you. That’s how people get injured, harassed, in to situations they’re not comfortable with, piled on with work they can’t do, assaulted etc etc. It’s all part of a spectrum. A personal trainer should make a personal plan for their client, it’s not the client’s fault for not being confident in standing up to them (and OP was clear that she did in fact try to stand up to him).

Yes, OP, you should absolutely complain. You told him of your injury, you asked not to use the equipment, he refused to tailor the workout and put you in a position where you felt forced in to an exercise you didn’t want to do, and you were injured as a result.

Thinkbiglittleone · 17/02/2023 15:23

Yes raise the issue.
You do need to learn to advocate for yourself though. I personally would have just said,
"I'm not using that, choose something else for me"
PT says "just see how you go"
I reply "Again,I'm not using that, choose something else for me"