Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the definition of a fussy eater?

59 replies

chronictonic · 17/02/2023 09:01

What's your definition of a "fussy" eater?

Always been interested in this as my 10 yr old could be labelled, and is labelled, a "fussy" eater.
But after 10 years of parenting, I've come to the conclusion that every child I've know is one (or could be labelled one) in some shape or form.

My child hates pizza, lasagne, spag bol and lots of other things that most children love.
But she will gladly polish off a huge plate of steamed vegetables and a steak/fish etc. And is quite adventurous in some ways (loves all smoked fish etc) but she would only eat pasta plain for example and would be alarmed by a speck of pepper! But give her a still moo-ing steak and she's in heaven.

Her best friend on the other hand enthusiatically eats lots of the usual kid's favourites: pizza, pasta, chips, a roast, without fuss, and with great gusto.
But she'll always leave the green beans & broccoli etc. And look truly disgusted by them 😂 The other day she was appalled by the idea of having rice... but her mother describes her as unfussy.

Would it be fair to call either of them a "fussy" eater? Or both of them?

What makes a child NOT a "fussy" eater?
If it means they eat EVERYTHING I am yet to meet one!

Even the most adventurous and 'foodie' child I know refuses simple green veg. Will gladly polish off a seafood curry, risotto, dumplings, sushi, ramen, pies, falafel etc. though! (Not all at once!)

So are all kids basically "fussy" eaters these days or shall we just abandon the term and just call them Kids?

Side note:
I do know some children with very limited & therefore problematic diets due to sensory food aversion & I don't think it's fair to label them "fussy" as it's so much more complex than that.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blondeshavemorefun · 09/05/2023 12:26

I think it's far better to say what they eat rather than what they won't

That helps people if cooking /feeding them

Fussy is probably not finding anything on an average menu in a restaurant or at a friends house where given various options and say no

Dd6 will eat most things - loves for example chicken mince lamb sausages veg fruit roasts omelette pasta whether plain spag bol lasagne pesto , jackets , beans on toast

Prefers fish in breadcrumbs /batter rather than plain

Not a huge fan is mash but loves sausages and mash at school 😂

But will eat a jacket scraped out with cheese /butter. Which is basically mash

Supersimkin2 · 09/05/2023 12:14

Anyone who makes their preferences my problem. Sigh.

Anoisagusaris · 09/05/2023 12:12

You say no kids eat green veg - well mine wouldn’t be spectacularly adventurous and all 3 love broccoli and green beans.

KarmaStar · 09/05/2023 11:58

The terms picky and fussy are unwarranted in regards to this subject.
there are many more people who have intolerance to the bigger selection of ingredients available now.ditto more dislikes as more options.Then there is the consideration of vegan food,eating organic food and being aware of what eating certain goods is doing to the climate due to flying them around the wor

lljkk · 17/02/2023 17:25

Sometimes MNers mention their fussy eater, then describe a huge long list of foods the child eats: I get shirty about this, I would have been delighted if DS ate half on their list.

What makes a child NOT a "fussy" eater?

I would say, NOT fussy = if they generally eat or will at least try (no instant refusal or protests) many items (don't mean every item, but a wide range), especially from these groups:

meats, vegetables, fruit, foods with sauces, cheeses, crisps, icecream.

to give examples of my Fussiest eater:
... vegetables: for a long time only brocoli, than only carrots (until he was almost 7yo); now really only eats 4 types of veg
... fruit ... only fruit leathers & Schloer
.... sauces, only ketchup; no gravy or custard of course.
... crisps: I actually danced a jig when he tried Wotsits, that was so novel
... dairy: only cheese on pizza, no other time
... ice cream: he will now eat some besides Magnums

Weirdly, unlike rest of my kids, he quite likes white fish and has even tried a prawn Shock

He's now 15 (years, not months) & will actually eat (mildly protesting) a pizza with a range of toppings on it, like olives, ham ,peppers. This only happened in last 9m. I'm still reeling from it. He got a 7 in GCSE catering last year, cooking quinoa lasagna. Not like he ever tried a bite of it AFAIK. We had to do all the taste-testing for him.

DS still organises food on his plate, doesn't like mixing.

No SN. Some people just get stuck in their ways.

IloveRickyGervaisAndHisTeeth · 17/02/2023 17:06

Mine -

doesn't like fish, minced beef (so shepherd's pie, lasagne, chilli con carne), anything with cheese (even pizza), shellfish, pasta, anything with lemon or lime flavouring it, offal (I can't blame him for that).

A fusy child? No, my 64 year old husband!

Cuwins · 17/02/2023 16:56

For me a fussy eater would be someone who doesn't eat a whole food group or the majority of it- so no veg or only carrots for instance.

HeartInDrive · 17/02/2023 15:36

I think the term fussy is really unhelpful and mostly quite judgemental. Look at some of the posts on here. Some people feel very superior if their kids eat ‘everything’, like they’ve done something ‘right’.

Lots if kids that are called ‘fussy’ have sensory issues with food and/or ASD for example. For those children, e posing them to ‘everything’ at a young age, won’t necessarily help. Lots of kids with autism regress with good. If they can explain their issues and you actually listen, it’s not fussiness. One of my kids has autism, might be unhelpfully classed as fussy by others but her diet is actually very good overall.

I’ve been called ‘fussy’ because I’m vegan. I’m not fussy, I just choose to not eat animal products.

We don’t make issues about food, no one gets called names due their preferences.

DoubleChocolateBrownies · 17/02/2023 15:30

I was a fussy eater as a child. I would eat only “green dinner“ (pesto pasta) or “Red dinner” (tomato pasta), fish fingers, chips, pizza (no “real” tomatoes or toppings)… That was it for savoury. Huge rows at the dinner table over my refusal to eat any veg.

As an adult I’m not fussy but it took until university - when I consistently cooked for myself and ate out with friends - for that to happen. I think where it wrong as a child is partly that it made my mum so angry I didn’t want to give her the satisfaction of changing my mind.

Huh, I’ve only just figured that out. I must remember that as my baby grows up…

AlmostaMamma · 17/02/2023 15:13

Ponoka7 · 17/02/2023 15:03

I knew of a child from Punjab who didn't like spicy food. His GM was saying how 'such' children used to die because there was no sustainable alternatives. In the UK we would call it a failure to thrive. Children across Africa are fed Pap (under other names) children who were then on the spectrum often didn't do well when it was time to move to other foods, so didn't the 'fussy easters' but rice/Noddles are beige foods. Every culture has a equivalent of white bread. It depends on how traditional the parents are if fussy eating is allowed, or catered for. I know of many people who are from other countries who are reluctant try any food that they haven't been brought up on.

People say this sort of thing on threads like this. However, it certainly hasn’t been my experience. Do you have any resources/studies on any of this that you can link?

Ponoka7 · 17/02/2023 15:03

AlmostaMamma · 17/02/2023 14:12

I think fussy eating is very western/Anglo. It’s not something I was even aware of as a concept until I moved to the U.K. It’s still bizarre to me, tbh. Kids being fed beige food, people of all ages ‘not liking veg’, the weird hang ups around seafood.

You guys have a LOT of food issues.

I knew of a child from Punjab who didn't like spicy food. His GM was saying how 'such' children used to die because there was no sustainable alternatives. In the UK we would call it a failure to thrive. Children across Africa are fed Pap (under other names) children who were then on the spectrum often didn't do well when it was time to move to other foods, so didn't the 'fussy easters' but rice/Noddles are beige foods. Every culture has a equivalent of white bread. It depends on how traditional the parents are if fussy eating is allowed, or catered for. I know of many people who are from other countries who are reluctant try any food that they haven't been brought up on.

AtleastitsnotMonday · 17/02/2023 14:55

This thread demonstrates perfectly how the term 'fussy eater' is of very little use, because everyone interprets it differently. Fussy can cover a whole spectrum of preferences and those using the term fussy eater often consider themselves to have some sort of moral high ground. I wonder if this is linked to the health implications for those with limited diets. E.g children who's diets are limited to 'beige' foods etc.

I think the more severe end of fussy selective eating would be tolerating (not necessarily liking but tolerating enough to be able to manage at a dinner party for example) foods in one format but not another eg. eating roast potato but not wedges, or one shape of pasta but not another. Or not eating at least 2 or 3 items from each food group ie carbs, proteins, dairy and fats, fruit and veg.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 17/02/2023 14:46

Sirzy · 17/02/2023 09:26

I think often “fussy” is linked to not having the same tastes as parents more than anything else. What you have described is them having personal preference not being fussy.

I agree with iam4eels. Ds has arfid so has a very very limited diet orally. He isn’t fussy he physically can’t bring himself to eat the wrong things

Exactly this for me. My parents moaned for years that I was a fussy eater, but they eat a very limited selection of foods/meals and if I didn't like one of them, there was no alternative. I eat basically everything - I'm not not a fan of boiled or steamed veg or stew. I can go into any restaurant and happily find something to eat on the menu.

I was convinced for years I hated carrots...turns out I just don't like boiled carrots. I could put away a whole tray of roasted carrots quite happily. See also cauliflower, leeks, brussels sprouts, cabbage etc.

Still hate broccoli, aubergines and courgettes though...

AlmostaMamma · 17/02/2023 14:12

I think fussy eating is very western/Anglo. It’s not something I was even aware of as a concept until I moved to the U.K. It’s still bizarre to me, tbh. Kids being fed beige food, people of all ages ‘not liking veg’, the weird hang ups around seafood.

You guys have a LOT of food issues.

AlmostaMamma · 17/02/2023 14:09

MRex · 17/02/2023 13:54

Ok, but even with Indian food there are still options. Saag paneer with chapati for example; zero spices would usually be added to either. Lots of restaurants might be willing to cook up something else plain. Chinese, Japanese, Korean and Vietnamese all have plainer options too, especially if you ask. There are billions of people living in Asia, honestly you can find plainer food options to suit all palates.

What sort of saag paneer have you encountered that contains zero spices?!

Theelephantinthecastle · 17/02/2023 14:00

Fwiw I don't think fussy eating is a moral failing or anything, I totally get that it's more annoying and frustrating for the person themselves than it is for me. But I don't think you can say that only eating plain food with zero spice is totally normal and not at all limited.

I would be happy to use a different term if there is a better one than fussy. I have a good friend who is a fussy eater and she describes herself that way (she won't eat spices, mushrooms, pulses, tomatoes, "wet" food and is also vegetarian)

Theelephantinthecastle · 17/02/2023 13:56

MRex · 17/02/2023 13:54

Ok, but even with Indian food there are still options. Saag paneer with chapati for example; zero spices would usually be added to either. Lots of restaurants might be willing to cook up something else plain. Chinese, Japanese, Korean and Vietnamese all have plainer options too, especially if you ask. There are billions of people living in Asia, honestly you can find plainer food options to suit all palates.

You must have had some very badly made saag paneer! It would usually have spice..

MRex · 17/02/2023 13:54

Singularity82 · 17/02/2023 11:55

@MRex tbe thing is though, “not spicy” varies wildly. Some peoples definition of spicy is anything with flavour (not saying that’s the case for anyone on this thread, just my experience in general). I love spicy food, my partner has no tolerance for it whatsoever. He once made a chilli that literally tasted like tomatoes and minced beef to me. He thought it was a bit spicy, to be it just had a hint of paprika in it. So not spicy isn’t always helpful to people who have a very low tolerance to it.

Ok, but even with Indian food there are still options. Saag paneer with chapati for example; zero spices would usually be added to either. Lots of restaurants might be willing to cook up something else plain. Chinese, Japanese, Korean and Vietnamese all have plainer options too, especially if you ask. There are billions of people living in Asia, honestly you can find plainer food options to suit all palates.

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/02/2023 13:49

Fussy eater = someone whose food preferences, allergies, sensitivities, physical or psychological food issues pisses someone else off as it's not convenient for them.

For those of us who have the above issues, please know, it's actually not convenient for us either, actually it's a fucking nightmare to live with and I've never heard the label 'fussy eater' be applied by anyone with the actual ability to be helpful.

takealettermsjones · 17/02/2023 13:36

Dacadactyl · 17/02/2023 13:27

I honestly can't think of a food I wouldn't eat if it was put in front of me. Also just asked DH if he can think of a food I wouldnt eat, he said no. Maybe that is unusual, I'm not sure.

I also think your difficult relationship with said parent goes deeper than being made to eat a soup you didn't like.

I think @Theelephantinthecastle has a good take on what fussiness around food is.

It's unusual to not dislike anything at all. Look around this thread. Ask your friends. Google it. Very unusual! Great for you, though, of course.

I also think your difficult relationship with said parent goes deeper than being made to eat a soup you didn't like.

Of course it does. It's just an example. But it highlights an inflexible attitude that, in my experience anyway, can permeate out to many other areas than just food, and that attitude as a whole is the cause of many a difficult parent-child relationship when the child gets older.

Dacadactyl · 17/02/2023 13:27

takealettermsjones · 17/02/2023 13:01

Okay, but your belief that anyone who has a food dislike is "fussy" just because you don't personally have any at all is very odd. You're very unusual if it's true that you don't dislike anything at all.

My parents had the same attitude towards me, by the way. I was a very good eater as a child but didn't like two things. I was made to sit there, gagging and struggling, while I forced myself to eat a soup made almost solely of one of the things they knew I didn't like.

Funnily enough I still don't like the food now, and I don't like the parent much either. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I honestly can't think of a food I wouldn't eat if it was put in front of me. Also just asked DH if he can think of a food I wouldnt eat, he said no. Maybe that is unusual, I'm not sure.

I also think your difficult relationship with said parent goes deeper than being made to eat a soup you didn't like.

I think @Theelephantinthecastle has a good take on what fussiness around food is.

Theelephantinthecastle · 17/02/2023 13:11

I think not eating pizza, pasta, or anything with pepper in it does qualify as fussy. If it's just not her preference, that's one thing but if she would go hungry at a pizza place, it sounds fussy to me.

If the best friend eats absolutely everything except green beans/broccoli, that doesn't sound fussy at all. If they don't eat any vegetables, that seems fussy to me.

To me, not liking up to about 3-4 things which are individual things not a whole category of food is fine - e.g. if there are 3 types of vegetables - but when you get into not eating any type of vegetable or any type of pepper/spice, it's getting into fussy territory

takealettermsjones · 17/02/2023 13:01

Dacadactyl · 17/02/2023 10:37

@cocksstrideintheevening yeah well we arent all going to agree! In this house, you eat what's in front of you. End of story.

Okay, but your belief that anyone who has a food dislike is "fussy" just because you don't personally have any at all is very odd. You're very unusual if it's true that you don't dislike anything at all.

My parents had the same attitude towards me, by the way. I was a very good eater as a child but didn't like two things. I was made to sit there, gagging and struggling, while I forced myself to eat a soup made almost solely of one of the things they knew I didn't like.

Funnily enough I still don't like the food now, and I don't like the parent much either. 🤷🏻‍♀️

takealettermsjones · 17/02/2023 12:58

ButteryNuts · 17/02/2023 12:51

I was called a fussy eater as a child. I'd eat everything - a whole fish, madras, every vegetable no matter how poorly cooked, whatever. Except I didn't like cheese - which is fed to children a lot. I'd have to turn down pizza, lasagna, cheeseburgers, sandwiches, paninis, toasties, quiche, dairylea dunkers, baby bell, cheese strings, wotsits, the list goes on.

So I was labelled fussy for not liking one ingredient.

I get this! I don't like cheese either and I once took a trip to the US that involved two long flights (7 ish hours each), then a couple of days of organised tours (with food provided) before I could just go off and do my own thing. Honestly everything was covered in cheese, for almost three days straight. I could have cried! I ate some of it but mostly lived on snacks I was able to buy from gas stations along the way, and lots of coffee 😆

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 17/02/2023 12:54

Singularity82 · 17/02/2023 11:55

@MRex tbe thing is though, “not spicy” varies wildly. Some peoples definition of spicy is anything with flavour (not saying that’s the case for anyone on this thread, just my experience in general). I love spicy food, my partner has no tolerance for it whatsoever. He once made a chilli that literally tasted like tomatoes and minced beef to me. He thought it was a bit spicy, to be it just had a hint of paprika in it. So not spicy isn’t always helpful to people who have a very low tolerance to it.

My mum is like this. She is an adventurous eater but she feels like she can’t breathe when she eats anything spicy, which includes korma. We ordered a margarita pizza from a kebab place once and it was too spicy for her 😂 however she has tried loads of weird and wonderful food including crocodile, kangaroo, octopus and so on, she eats sushi weekly, and can eat anything as long as it’s not spicy. I wouldn’t say not liking spice is fussy! (That being said she has plenty she can eat in Indian, Chinese, Japanese, Nepalese etc restaurants even if the food isn’t her favourite)