Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breastfed babies at weddings?

236 replies

Lavender14 · 17/02/2023 00:07

Dh and I have been invited to a full day wedding of friends which we'd really love to go to. Problem is I'm ebf and ds will have only just turned 5 months old by then so I'm not sure how to manage a full day away from him. He will take a bottle but only VERY rarely and definitely prefers feeding from breast (he's better with wind etc when not feeding from bottle too as he has a slight tongue tie - feeding has been a challenge so im hesitant about messing with it). I also have a big oversupply so worried about the impact of not being able to feed him for a full day, I'm not sure how much of the day I'd have to miss pumping and as there's no accommodation at the venue (I've been there before) I'm not sure where I could do that other than a toilet cubicle which isn't ideal. I also find i don't get anywhere near as good a letdown when I pump compared to feeding so worried about mastitis.

When I got married we didn't have any children at our wedding. So I fully understand why people don't want babies at a wedding when they've paid for videographer etc and they're taking a seat at the table and space is precious. However we did make an exception for any breastfed babies as I had a number of friends bf at the time who wouldn't have felt able to come otherwise.

Would it be unreasonable to ask the couple if they'd allow a breastfed baby? It's not in a hotel where a grandparent could have baby nearby etc or I'd have arranged that and just nipped out to feed. If they decline (which is their choice - its their wedding) is my other option to decline the invite or what alternative would you suggest?

First time parent so just trying to plan ahead!

OP posts:
HoboHotel · 17/02/2023 12:14

x2boys · 17/02/2023 12:09

It's up.to.the couple who are getting married to.have the wedding they want though ,and they are not banning babies they are having a child free wedding ,babies are children
yeah it's been a Pita,for me when I have had wedding invite that doesn't include children ,I have either had to decline or go alone without dh
but that's life .

I love getting invited to a child-free wedding. It gives you a cast-iron excuse not to go that no one can argue with.

ZekeZeke · 17/02/2023 12:13

What I mean is, you obviously didn't get 2 months notice. You have known about the wedding for some time. I'm sure the B&G are finalising numbers at this stage.

Decline and don't ask can you bring a 5 month old. It's their day not yours.

Also I see no difference between a bottle or breast fed 5 month old regarding needs or noise levels.

ZekeZeke · 17/02/2023 12:10

Lavender14 · 17/02/2023 10:40

Baby is 3.5 months now.

You got 2 months notice for a wedding?

x2boys · 17/02/2023 12:09

Catcharolo · 17/02/2023 12:01

Tbh I don’t get any of the wedding rules people put in place.
In my mind:black tie balls, gigs, Saturday nights in the pub, dinner parties: adults only.
Weddings, christenings, bbqs..big fun family events. People are so precious! And as for banning babies: honestly - I think it’s embarrassing. It feels like they’re saying “sorry, but this wedding is literally so especially amazing that your little baby will probably just ruin it”. They don’t take up space and don’t cost anything. And if parents want to go home early then just let them. If people don’t want to bring their children, they won’t.
Anyway - I think if you want to go, then ask them. But I wouldn’t stress out your baby in order to attend a party held by a couple of people who don’t have enough understanding and flexibility to ‘allow’ them to come.

It's up.to.the couple who are getting married to.have the wedding they want though ,and they are not banning babies they are having a child free wedding ,babies are children
yeah it's been a Pita,for me when I have had wedding invite that doesn't include children ,I have either had to decline or go alone without dh
but that's life .

Calphurnia88 · 17/02/2023 12:01

friendlycat · 17/02/2023 11:59

I too think the polite way to respond is to gracefully decline in writing stating you are EBF and can't leave baby, wish them a lovely day and that you are looking forward to hearing all about it afterwards.

Sit back and see what the response is. If you are then contacted with "of course you must bring baby" so be it , if no such response is forthcoming then that is your answer. I also think that they know you have a baby and it hasn't been mentioned to be included within the invite in the first place.

This is a good idea.

On reflection I think that asking the couple puts them in a difficult position.

Catcharolo · 17/02/2023 12:01

Tbh I don’t get any of the wedding rules people put in place.
In my mind:black tie balls, gigs, Saturday nights in the pub, dinner parties: adults only.
Weddings, christenings, bbqs..big fun family events. People are so precious! And as for banning babies: honestly - I think it’s embarrassing. It feels like they’re saying “sorry, but this wedding is literally so especially amazing that your little baby will probably just ruin it”. They don’t take up space and don’t cost anything. And if parents want to go home early then just let them. If people don’t want to bring their children, they won’t.
Anyway - I think if you want to go, then ask them. But I wouldn’t stress out your baby in order to attend a party held by a couple of people who don’t have enough understanding and flexibility to ‘allow’ them to come.

friendlycat · 17/02/2023 11:59

I too think the polite way to respond is to gracefully decline in writing stating you are EBF and can't leave baby, wish them a lovely day and that you are looking forward to hearing all about it afterwards.

Sit back and see what the response is. If you are then contacted with "of course you must bring baby" so be it , if no such response is forthcoming then that is your answer. I also think that they know you have a baby and it hasn't been mentioned to be included within the invite in the first place.

Calphurnia88 · 17/02/2023 11:56

Optionally · 17/02/2023 11:31

So just to be clear, you think it is in any way acceptable to treat a breastfed baby differently to a formula fed baby when it comes to making exceptions at child free events? I had some sympathy with you OP but that’s really nasty.

Its practical, not nasty. The NHS does it (breastfeeding mums get food if their babies are in hospital, other parents don’t). It’s the physical reality that the baby is physically dependent on it’s mum.

That’s not true for FF babies. It’s not a value judgment or a dig at FF, it’s that pesky reality biting.

Exactly.

Breasts are literally attached to you so if you have a bottle refuser then anything over a couple of hours for an EBF baby is going to be problematic.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 17/02/2023 11:56

What would you have done wrt your own wedding if you had known any parents with small ff babies OP?

Lavender14 · 17/02/2023 11:41

SpideyCraw · 17/02/2023 11:28

So just to be clear, you think it is in any way acceptable to treat a breastfed baby differently to a formula fed baby when it comes to making exceptions at child free events? I had some sympathy with you OP but that’s really nasty.

I do think there are some differences. If a baby is happy taking a bottle whether pumped or formula and parents are happy to leave them with granny then that's an option that parent has which frees them up to socislise or whatever they want to do. A ebf baby who won't take bottles physically cannot be left for long periods so babysitting is simply not an option, the parent has no choice but to stay with their baby. Never mind adding in the impact on supply/ mothers physical health through risking mastitis and some women like myself struggle with pumping and would be very uncomfortable physically if away too long. I fully get why any parent may not want to leave a very young baby and I wouldn't expect anyone to leave a newborn regardless of feeding method but where do you draw the line at something like a child free wedding? Do you include a seven month old/ nine month old/ one year old who's weaned and could be babysat because the parent doesn't want to leave them or is that the parents decision to make based on what they feel is best for their child? My point is simply that for a ebf baby the parent doesn't have the choice they have to be with the baby so it's not a matter of comfort or not wanting to leave them. They physically need to be there to feed on demand. I think that's a big difference in circumstances as babysitting isn't an option for long periods in the same way.

OP posts:
Optionally · 17/02/2023 11:31

So just to be clear, you think it is in any way acceptable to treat a breastfed baby differently to a formula fed baby when it comes to making exceptions at child free events? I had some sympathy with you OP but that’s really nasty.

Its practical, not nasty. The NHS does it (breastfeeding mums get food if their babies are in hospital, other parents don’t). It’s the physical reality that the baby is physically dependent on it’s mum.

That’s not true for FF babies. It’s not a value judgment or a dig at FF, it’s that pesky reality biting.

SpideyCraw · 17/02/2023 11:28

Lavender14 · 17/02/2023 10:26

@indiadreamer In our case there were no bottle fed babies so it was a non issue. But I do think it's at least possible to get a baby babysat if they can take a bottle whereas if they're ebf and don't take a bottle or parent is trying to establish breastfeeding then the baby cannot be left. Then it's the parents choice whether or not they're comfortable leaving them.

@CjCreggs and @Nicecow I've already said i fully understand why they may not allow children and that it's their day. I'm not expecting them to say yes and I asked on here because I don't want to put them under pressure which is why i want sure whether to message at all or not... not sure that makes me sanctimonious or entitled. Plus i did allow very small babies at my wedding because their parents who were bf couldn't have come otherwise but we didn't have space to allow children who could be babysat and who's parents had the choice.

So just to be clear, you think it is in any way acceptable to treat a breastfed baby differently to a formula fed baby when it comes to making exceptions at child free events? I had some sympathy with you OP but that’s really nasty.

Calphurnia88 · 17/02/2023 11:22

You can ask, but be prepared for them to say no.

I EBF so I understand the issues around bottle refusal and discomfort (for you), but saying yes to you could put them in a really difficult position if there are guests that are closer to the couple e.g. family who have had to arrange childcare the day.

Whammyyammy · 17/02/2023 11:19

RampantIvy · 17/02/2023 11:14

Brilliant @Whammyyammy
😁

Always thought I would do the same if I saw it happen. Never have, and probably wouldn't.
But I really don't see why people find breastfeeding offensive?

RampantIvy · 17/02/2023 11:14

Brilliant @Whammyyammy
😁

Whammyyammy · 17/02/2023 11:12

Breastfeeding is natural, if anyone has a problem with it, then that's on them.

I remember reading about a man complaining about a woman breast feeding in a coffee shop, saying she should feed the baby in the toilet

A member of the woman's group got up, took the man's coffee and cake into the toilet and came back and told him to eat in there...

illtakeit · 17/02/2023 11:07

Just ask OP and then you can make your decision depending on what they say.

ThighMistress · 17/02/2023 11:06

A small baby (bf or otherwise) isn’t really a problem, even if it cries.

The problem imo is when people start off with the baby and then say they can’t leave Henry (4) and Phoebe (2) either. Multiply by 10 friends with their own broods.

ItsaMetalBand · 17/02/2023 11:04

Option 3 - when my Sis was maid of honour at her friend's wedding and had a bottle refuser 3mo.
She had a room upstairs in the venue and her phone on silent. Granny would text whenever the baby needed a feed and Sis would discreetly leave. Obviously she gave a big feed before the ceremony, immediately after then did photos. Another quick feed before the meal and she was able to leave after the first dance.

RampantIvy · 17/02/2023 11:03

@Warrensrabbit I agree. I suggested upthread the best answer was to say she couldn't go and why.

I don't think the OP sounds entitled at all.

mewkins · 17/02/2023 10:58

I suspect that if they have over invited and are hoping people will decline, it will be a no. If they want everyone they have invited to be there then they will say of course bring them along.

I've taken tiny babies to weddings before and it was really nice and low-stress.

Warrensrabbit · 17/02/2023 10:58

@RampantIvy the issue is when breastfeeding mothers say “I wont go because you wont let me bring baby” which makes it sound like they are taking a stand against the rule or trying to make a point. Just say “sorry we cant come” and then no one feels snubbed. It’s parents (not bridezillas- it is probably both the couples choice) pushing it back on the couple getting married when in reality they don’t actually need to give a reason

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/02/2023 10:56

I’ve known more than one at weddings, inc. my own.
As long as parents will quickly take a baby out if it starts crying during the ceremony or speeches, I can’t for the life of me see why small babies should be excluded. It’s not as if they need an expensive meal.
If I were not allowed to take a small baby (BF or not) to a wedding, I would just decline to go.

x2boys · 17/02/2023 10:55

RampantIvy · 17/02/2023 10:52

The issue is that bridezillas then feel snubbed because the breastfeeding mother can't go.

We are going round in circles with this.

That's on them then,childfree weddings are a Pita,for many parents not just breast feeding ones ,but if that's what the Happy couple want that's their choice
but they will.also .have to.accept some guests won't be able to.attend.

RampantIvy · 17/02/2023 10:52

Warrensrabbit · 17/02/2023 10:49

Yawn. When I say no kids at my wedding, that’s what I mean. Not an exception for you because you don’t want to leave your baby, or an exception for Henry because I’ve always been his favourite, or an exception for that one blah, blah, blah.
people are happy to agree with child free weddings so long as it doesn’t apply to them.

The issue is that bridezillas then feel snubbed because the breastfeeding mother can't go.

We are going round in circles with this.