Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's massive age discrimination after 50

106 replies

Livelifelaughter · 16/02/2023 22:05

My company recently made redundant some extremely competent experienced lawyers. All the ones below the age of 50 (40s)have got new jobs. None over 50 have even though they would accept the salary on offer to the 40 year olds.
Some have approached firms asking to retrain in other areas of law at a lower salary and have got no where even though many firms will re train women who have left for years to have families.
It seems very difficult to get a decent well paid job at 50 plus.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 18/02/2023 09:30

Timesawastin · 18/02/2023 09:27

My sis just puts a professional qualification she got in the mid 90s as her starting point, says they would assume she was 25 not 36 when she got it. Still working at 64!

Having O Levels dates you.

Timesawastin · 18/02/2023 09:27

Livelifelaughter · 17/02/2023 08:36

I read an article that suggested all dates are removed from a CV - well that only works if everyone does it or the recruiting company asks candidates to do so.
It's also impossible to re train.

My sis just puts a professional qualification she got in the mid 90s as her starting point, says they would assume she was 25 not 36 when she got it. Still working at 64!

CatnaryReturns · 18/02/2023 09:19

cakeorwine · 18/02/2023 09:13

The ironic thing is that those people who are younger and who discriminate against older people are going to be older and will face the same kind of discrimination.

We can't change our age and we all get older.

Yes but they all think that they are going to be in positions of sufficient power where age does not matter. Bluntly, it's older people who are less successful who suffer, because organisations still have an outdated notion that seniority and age progress together in a linear way and they can't compute an older person in a more junior role. I mean, think about it, we even say senior and junior to describe roles, and those word carry age connotations with them.

cakeorwine · 18/02/2023 09:13

The ironic thing is that those people who are younger and who discriminate against older people are going to be older and will face the same kind of discrimination.

We can't change our age and we all get older.

Sunriseinwonderland · 18/02/2023 09:01

Can't say I've noticed. My employer wants me to work until 70, I'm 60 now, as I have a wealth of experience.
BUT I work in the NHS and it's full of old people like me because young people don't want to do this job any more.

CatnaryReturns · 18/02/2023 08:59

"Too experienced" is a bullshit excuse, you are right. They deserve better. I think there will be two things at play here. If the rejections are pre-interview, the rationale is likely that pricing is put to clients in PQE bands (old fashioned but common) eg "we charge £500/hour for 4-6 PQE, £600 for 6-10" and in fact they need to staff their matters with people in the lower brackets in order to keep costs down. This could obviously be addressed by linking pricing to role (Associate/senior Associate/Legal Director) and simply offering the job at the appropriate level.

The other thing is, as you say, team dynamics. I can't personally see how the up and coming juniors would feel threatened if your colleagues were clear that partnership was not what they aspired to, and the firm also made it clear at recruitment that this was not a partnership track job. I know of juniors who work really effectively with time-served senior lawyers who have decided not to go for partnership. Done right, it frees up the young Turks to do more client relationship stuff, with a safe pair of hands back in the office to get the work done. And when those juniors do get made up, it is perfectly possible to have a workable hierarchy if everyone is sensible. My former trainee is now a partner with technical "authority" over me. I'm delighted to let him make commercial and strategic decisions that I could not be bothered with. He definitely comes to me for technical guidance, which I am happy to give, before I clock off at 5pm (I made the decision many years ago that time had more value to me than money).

SamanthaCaine · 18/02/2023 08:26

Ageism is a nightmare and amazing how some law firms get away with it. I think we all see it but thankfully it's the complete opposite in my field of engineering. The older you get, the more valuable you are and I've seen old fogies end up in upper management or technical specialist roles. Many go contracting and command higher rates than advertised due to experience. I've known contractors still going well into their 70's and on top rates.

Sorry if this sounds like an advert for engineering but we have a distinct lack of female representation! No lack of female intelligence but just a lack of interest ☹️

Livelifelaughter · 18/02/2023 08:09

CatnaryReturns · 17/02/2023 17:31

Interesting OP. Do you think that the lawyers who were made redundant were discriminated against in the redundancy process too?

YYou say that they were "willing to take the salaries on offer to the 40 year olds"- does that suggest that you/they ideally would have wanted higher salaries? Only I think that in law, while salary does tend to keep going up in line with PQE, it does hit a ceiling where, say 15 years' PQE is worth the same as 20 and more (assuming non-partner). The differentiating factors would be more around client following or very niche expertise, not simple time served.

Have any of them thought about becoming PSLs (more commonly "knowledge lawyers" these days)? That is a role where long experience commands a premium. We were recently disappointed when a woman in her early sixties turned down a role.

Thank you for your reply. I suspect there was an element of discrimination albeit possibly subconscious if I am being generous. I agree with your point about salaries plateauing, my point being that from a cost basis it doesn't cost a firm more to recruit an older person. I know former colleagues have been told that they are "too experienced" meaning I suspect that their recruitment would upset the junior lawyers working towards partnership.

OP posts:
SleepDreamThinkHuge · 17/02/2023 21:27

Ageism definitely exists. It is especially difficult if you have been in one field all your life. But if you have worked in different fields e.g. finance, civil service etc then it is more easier. As someone close to 30, the advice that I was given by older colleagues, family members is to not stick in one career all your life except in some exceptions e.g. being a doctor that job will never be made redundant there will always be demand for that. I have seen people get discriminated due to age which always baffles me cause it is discrimination. I have also seen people in their 50s learn new careers in a short period of time and thrive e.g. cyber security, coding etc..

Bakeoffcanbuggeroff · 17/02/2023 21:08

54 here and got promoted at 53 (in a male dominated industry). I also don’t like the focus on menopausal symptoms as it echos the prejudices around women who are having families. I feel lucky I was given the chance, although I was highly suited to the job. If I became disenchanted with the role I’d seek out a similar one elsewhere.

Really enjoying it and have no major plans to retire, although I could. 😀 It’s paid daycare!

antipodeancanary · 17/02/2023 20:32

NHS here and as most jobs in my specialty get no applicants at all, I could walk into any job I fancy aged 61. But they have pissed me off once too often so I have resigned and very much doubt I will work for the NHS again. Another one bites the dust! I will still be able to get plenty of private work though.

HundredMilesAnHour · 17/02/2023 19:26

Sugarfair · 17/02/2023 07:51

Yes ageism is rife. I am 51 and in a great quite senior job which I love. I never mention my age and hate all the talk about menopause at the moment as I think it just stigmatises women my age further. It’s a difficult one as it’s also good that it’s being spoken about, but I have sailed through menopause with no issues and mentally and physically I am back to the person I was before I had children in my late 20s.

Whereas I'm 52 and in a senior role but having to cover up how badly I'm suffering with menopause symptoms because it will put a spotlight on my age and that's the sort of attention that could put my job at risk.

Beeeard · 17/02/2023 19:19

I recruit lawyers and have candidates in their 60s who are in demand. However I used to recruit support staff and there was definitely ageism from employers.

VladmirsPoutine · 17/02/2023 19:13

Passivhaus · 17/02/2023 19:06

Point to where I said that.

This is what you wrote which frankly is astonishing:

"If you think we have problems with racism I suggest you live abroad because any other country I have been to has been far more racist"

Passivhaus · 17/02/2023 19:06

VladmirsPoutine · 17/02/2023 15:39

@Passivhaus You think ethnic minorities in this country should thank their lucky stars they are just about tolerated because elsewhere it would be much worse. Ok.

Point to where I said that.

CatnaryReturns · 17/02/2023 17:31

Interesting OP. Do you think that the lawyers who were made redundant were discriminated against in the redundancy process too?

YYou say that they were "willing to take the salaries on offer to the 40 year olds"- does that suggest that you/they ideally would have wanted higher salaries? Only I think that in law, while salary does tend to keep going up in line with PQE, it does hit a ceiling where, say 15 years' PQE is worth the same as 20 and more (assuming non-partner). The differentiating factors would be more around client following or very niche expertise, not simple time served.

Have any of them thought about becoming PSLs (more commonly "knowledge lawyers" these days)? That is a role where long experience commands a premium. We were recently disappointed when a woman in her early sixties turned down a role.

lieselotte · 17/02/2023 17:15

Although thinking about it, it's a hugely risky thing to ask - definitely a breach of good interview practice to avoid discrimination claims. It's a bit like asking a woman if she plans to have kids.

lieselotte · 17/02/2023 17:14

If someone asked me when I expected to retire I'd just say "the retirement age is 67, likely to rise to 68 for my age group. That's nearly 20 years."

(Probably wouldn't get the job, but it might at least challenge their assumptions a bit)

Headunderthecovers · 17/02/2023 16:05

I'm 52 and applied for an alternative professional job in my field with a different company.

The initial hurdle came up in the first informal phone conversation about the role when I got asked 'I probably shouldn't say this but when do you plan to retire'.

That's the trouble it's being thought of over 50 as you're already at upper end of pay scale and companies want to know how long they will retain you (despite the fact that many younger candidates won't intend to stay in a role more than a few years anyway). It's suddenly made me aware that I'm viewed close to retirement age!

Cornelious2011 · 17/02/2023 15:58

Not in my sector or in other sectors I know off. Lots of places can't recruit social workers, doctors, psychologists, solicitors etc. these roles rely on experience.

lieselotte · 17/02/2023 15:57

VladmirsPoutine · 17/02/2023 15:39

@Passivhaus You think ethnic minorities in this country should thank their lucky stars they are just about tolerated because elsewhere it would be much worse. Ok.

No, employers do try to do something about racism and sexism. Not so ageism.

JunkinDonuts · 17/02/2023 15:54

It applies to both sexes, not just women.
I know some men in their fifties who have applied for a lot of jobs and have never even heard back from the companies they've applied to, much less got an interview.
They work out your age from the dates of education on the CV/ application.
It's disgraceful.

whatkatydid2013 · 17/02/2023 15:51

VladmirsPoutine · 17/02/2023 15:39

@Passivhaus You think ethnic minorities in this country should thank their lucky stars they are just about tolerated because elsewhere it would be much worse. Ok.

I thought original comment more meant that overt racism/sexism in professional workplaces is less common and less tolerated than ageism. It seems like people would still feel comfortable to openly discuss not hiring someone due to age/how near retirement they are where they would be a lot less direct about other prejudices they may have.

Cyclebabble · 17/02/2023 15:43

I still here a lot of ageist comments in my workplace. My boss is a women and suggests she is really into equality but recently did a whole team presentation where she said what we need is more youthful enterprise in our team. At my appraisal I wanted to talk about career progression she mentioned early retirement...

VladmirsPoutine · 17/02/2023 15:39

@Passivhaus You think ethnic minorities in this country should thank their lucky stars they are just about tolerated because elsewhere it would be much worse. Ok.