Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the government is right to impose minimum service levels on nurses

434 replies

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:06

So today the nursing unions have announced they will be withdrawing from A&Es, intensive care units, chemotherapy and other key services. Now, I am not a conservative voter by any means and I do think nurses should get a fair pay rise (although I don’t think 10% is affordable).

However, I don’t think it is acceptable for unions to be putting lives at risk by refusing to provide life-saving care. The armed forces and prison officers are not allowed to strike- I would now support minimum service levels being extended to nurses to prevent the unions doing this.

I suspect I am not the only one and the unions need to be careful not to shoot themselves in the foot.

OP posts:
Captiancorrellistuba · 19/02/2023 03:57

The NHS loses £300 million a year by Health Tourism.

And before people say that it's only 0.3% of NHS spending it's still a drain that ought to be plugged.

I can't believe they haven't got enough non-medical staff to deal with this.

BankOfDave · 18/02/2023 20:08

This is one of those threads that reminds me I don’t think anonymity should exist on SM. OP isn’t just expressing an opinion against strikes, they are gunning for individual nurses being held accountable. Aside from the very obvious batshittery in that, let’s all know what OP does for living, where you live and see how you like all your family, friends, neighbours and colleagues knowing what a repugnant individual you are. Then we can also all complain to you directly.

Or don’t you like the sound of that?

mbosnz · 18/02/2023 18:44

Oooh, ooh, I know the answer to this one! You know, 'what makes nurses so special'. . .

Because without them, patients cannot be nursed, and patients die.

And because what they are currently being paid, means they leave nursing, or can't afford the luxury of nursing as a career, and that means we have less nurses. Oh, and because people look at the way nurses are treated and paid, and think 'fuck that for a game of soldiers, I'm buggered if I'm doing that, and I'll do everything in my power to discourage my kids from doing that'. And because the conditions are shit, and nurses are being forced more and more to take on ridiculous amounts of responsibility, with less and less safe conditions, which means they're up against the wall if something goes wrong, and it's more and more likely to go wrong, while being treated like shit, and paid something equivalent?

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 18:11

Folks. I think we have been visited by quite an effective intern from the Labour party. Why else would someone so persistently pedal indefensible tosh about nurses and insist they deserve a pay cut?

itsgettingweird · 18/02/2023 18:10

If we don't pay NHS staff what they're asking for, their won't be an NHS.

And I think that's job done for them.

I think it'll be very interesting to see what minimum service levels they set because the unions can very easily point out and prove where they are above a daily norm - backing up their point.

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 18:05

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:56

And yet you are happy to spout the lines pedalled by the same people who made the colassal mistake in the autumn with the countries finances.
Do you think that perhaps those who gambled with all our fortunes in the autumn should be held to account? Or should they be allowed to continue making a mess of the country?

There may be an extra n in my post, sorry.

DuncinToffee · 18/02/2023 18:04

From. December
Nuffield Trust's Chart of the week: What has happened to NHS staff pay since 2010?

www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/chart-of-the-week-what-has-happened-to-nhs-staff-pay-since-2010

These figures show again that NHS staff pay remained lower in real terms in 2021/22 than it was in 2010/11. As we saw in previous years, the drop has been sharpest among the highest paid, with the lowest paid somewhat protected. Doctors, nurses and all staff saw some recovery during 2020/21, with a relatively higher pay settlement and a slowdown in inflation as Covid-19 hit the UK, but this stalled or went into reverse during 2021/22.

NattyNamechanger · 18/02/2023 18:02

PomRuns · 18/02/2023 08:54

if you speak to nurses - they are leaving due to poor pay and conditions.
gosh it’s infuriating that people who don’t work in the nhs think they know more than people who do.

Agree
Also laughing that Nurses should have safe minimum staffing levels imposed on them.

Nurses have tried for years, campaigning to get safe nurse/ patient ratios -The Francis Inquiry anyone?
Nurses would welcome this!
It's really easy to see who is completely clueless and making up crap!

Botw1 · 18/02/2023 17:58

@Onnabugeisha

That will be a no then.

The RCN have been a tempting to get decent pay for nurses for years. It's not related to inflation or COL.

It's related to the tories and austerity

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:56

And yet you are happy to spout the lines pedalled by the same people who made the colassal mistake in the autumn with the countries finances.
Do you think that perhaps those who gambled with all our fortunes in the autumn should be held to account? Or should they be allowed to continue making a mess of the country?

Notonthestairs · 18/02/2023 17:56

"It wasn’t affordable…have you seen the debt we are in and our credit rating?"

Doesn't explain why pay has been eroded for a decade.

Notonthestairs · 18/02/2023 17:53

"If we supported and the government approved the 19% pay rise for nurses, this would cost £13.3 billion^. Which means zero agency staff on wards. Which means even lower staffing levels and yet more deaths. "

And it's been repeatedly pointed out and ignored by you that the RCN want to meet in the middle.

"Medacs Healthcare is providing millions of hours of agency staff to the NHS, where hiring freezes mean many trusts are unable to fill vacancies and must rely on temporary cover. Medacs is owned by the Impellam Group, a company in which Ashcroftt and his familyy own an interest.
Clarke points to TUC figures showing Medacs earns a profit of £31,9022_ per employee each year – much of which is coming from cash-strapped NHS trusts that are being forced to turn to expensive agency staff. NHS contracts have ‘rocketed’ in the past two years under the tough new budget conditions, he says."

www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2012-07-30/tory-donors-firms-landed-lucrative-government-contracts

At least the Conservative Party indirectly benefit - Ashcroft has donated in excess of £11 million.

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:52

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:50

It’s not a pay cut. How can I answer a hypothetical question that is irrelevant?

Let me try simplifiying the question for you.
If last year I could afford to buy 5 widgets a week, but this year I can only buy 9 a fortnight, am I richer or poorer?

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:50

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:49

So if was affordable to spaff billions on a bonkers experiment by Truss and Kwarteng, but not affordable to pay people properly. Right, makes perfect sense.

It wasn’t affordable…have you seen the debt we are in and our credit rating?

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:50

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:49

Well, if thousands of nurse are striking and not at work, then it’s not a stretch to conclude patients are going without care. Unless the NHS were over staffed? But everyone says and the data says there’s actually a shortage. So let’s see, making a staff shortage worse is going to cause a further decline in patient care which will cause further deaths.

why you think this pay dispute has anything to do with COL
The pay demand is literally inflation plus 5%.
Inflation is why cost of living has increased and is increasing.

I am glad that we can agree that making a staff shortage worse is a bad idea.
Why then are you insisting that nurses should have a pay cut, thus making the staff shortage worse?

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:50

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:46

I take it you cannot explain why you think nurses should have a pay cut. That is the question that you need to answer, if you are to retain any credibility.

It’s not a pay cut. How can I answer a hypothetical question that is irrelevant?

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:49

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:43

Only shows how unaffordable yet another £13.3bn in welfare for nurses is…when they are already taking home more pay than over 50% of other workers…

So if was affordable to spaff billions on a bonkers experiment by Truss and Kwarteng, but not affordable to pay people properly. Right, makes perfect sense.

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:49

Botw1 · 18/02/2023 17:45

@Onnabugeisha

Ive asked several times already but so far no one has answered.

Do you have any evidence that pts are at more risk of death on a strike day than a non strike day?

Also interested to know why you think this pay dispute has anything to do with COL

Well, if thousands of nurse are striking and not at work, then it’s not a stretch to conclude patients are going without care. Unless the NHS were over staffed? But everyone says and the data says there’s actually a shortage. So let’s see, making a staff shortage worse is going to cause a further decline in patient care which will cause further deaths.

why you think this pay dispute has anything to do with COL
The pay demand is literally inflation plus 5%.
Inflation is why cost of living has increased and is increasing.

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:47

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:43

Only shows how unaffordable yet another £13.3bn in welfare for nurses is…when they are already taking home more pay than over 50% of other workers…

You think that the person who is responsible for keeping you alive if you are seriously injured isn't worth paying properly. May as well just pay them the minimum wage, in fact why do we pay them at all?

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:46

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:41

It’s not irrelevant at all. Why do you think nurses are so special that they can be insulated from the cost of living crisis affecting everyone’s wages?

Why do you think it is ok to do to others what the government did to you?

I take it you cannot explain why you think nurses should have a pay cut. That is the question that you need to answer, if you are to retain any credibility.

Botw1 · 18/02/2023 17:45

@Onnabugeisha

Ive asked several times already but so far no one has answered.

Do you have any evidence that pts are at more risk of death on a strike day than a non strike day?

Also interested to know why you think this pay dispute has anything to do with COL

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:43

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:41

If a pay increase for nurses did cost 13.3 billion, much of that would end up back in the treasury as nurses pay tax, but stuff that is taxed and so on.
More to the point if 13.3billion is unaffordable, then I would ask how much did Liz Truss' experiment cost? How much did Rishi Sunak waste on buying PPE that did not work from his mates?

Only shows how unaffordable yet another £13.3bn in welfare for nurses is…when they are already taking home more pay than over 50% of other workers…

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:41

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:35

What anyone else has or hasn't managed to negotiate is irrelevant. Why do you think nurses should have a pay cut?

The government are indeed letting patients die because they are not prepared to fund the NHS properly. Did you read my early post on this thread about my experience when my daughter was on ICU? I will happily repost it and you can tell me if there were safe staffing levels.

It’s not irrelevant at all. Why do you think nurses are so special that they can be insulated from the cost of living crisis affecting everyone’s wages?

Why do you think it is ok to do to others what the government did to you?

jgw1 · 18/02/2023 17:41

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:38

But by all means continue to support spending £3 billion a year on agency staff. It's far better that cash goes towards agency companies.

You know most of that cash goes towards the labour costs of hiring agency nurses.

If we supported and the government approved the 19% pay rise for nurses, this would cost £13.3 billion^. Which means zero agency staff on wards. Which means even lower staffing levels and yet more deaths.

So you see my point? A 19% pay increase isn’t going to improve patient quality of care. It will mean zero agency staff plus a £10.3bn hole in NHS finances.

^calculated from the BBC article which says each 1% increase in pay costs £700m. www.bbc.co.uk/news/63988517

Its not as simple as pay nurses more and everything will be la de da

If a pay increase for nurses did cost 13.3 billion, much of that would end up back in the treasury as nurses pay tax, but stuff that is taxed and so on.
More to the point if 13.3billion is unaffordable, then I would ask how much did Liz Truss' experiment cost? How much did Rishi Sunak waste on buying PPE that did not work from his mates?

Onnabugeisha · 18/02/2023 17:38

But by all means continue to support spending £3 billion a year on agency staff. It's far better that cash goes towards agency companies.

You know most of that cash goes towards the labour costs of hiring agency nurses.

If we supported and the government approved the 19% pay rise for nurses, this would cost £13.3 billion^. Which means zero agency staff on wards. Which means even lower staffing levels and yet more deaths.

So you see my point? A 19% pay increase isn’t going to improve patient quality of care. It will mean zero agency staff plus a £10.3bn hole in NHS finances.

^calculated from the BBC article which says each 1% increase in pay costs £700m. www.bbc.co.uk/news/63988517

Its not as simple as pay nurses more and everything will be la de da