Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the government is right to impose minimum service levels on nurses

434 replies

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:06

So today the nursing unions have announced they will be withdrawing from A&Es, intensive care units, chemotherapy and other key services. Now, I am not a conservative voter by any means and I do think nurses should get a fair pay rise (although I don’t think 10% is affordable).

However, I don’t think it is acceptable for unions to be putting lives at risk by refusing to provide life-saving care. The armed forces and prison officers are not allowed to strike- I would now support minimum service levels being extended to nurses to prevent the unions doing this.

I suspect I am not the only one and the unions need to be careful not to shoot themselves in the foot.

OP posts:
Givenupghost · 17/02/2023 08:11

The use of NMC registration statistics does not give a clear picture of what is actually happening in terns of working as a nurse.
To maintain your registration you only need to work 450 hours over 3 years.
I have a lot colleagues who have left nursing for other careers. They have maintained their pin by working either the minimum required hours or moving into a non nhs based role. T

Ecoo · 17/02/2023 08:09

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:08

YABU for falling for the Tory propaganda about safety levels.

and YABU for falling for the Tory propaganda about affordability.

I’ve dealt with union pay negotiations and you can find a way through - by recutting pay increases, offering different options etc and yes putting a bit more money on the table.

If this government pays nurses more, it will increase the spending power of a group of people who are lower paid.

It will help tackle the recruitment crisis (won’t solve it though).

It will reduce the reliance on universal credit.

This is why our economy is screwed, because the Tories keeps making short term economically illiterate decisions.

The government has a huge pot of money to play with, it has tax raising powers (not just on individuals but companies too). It should want to make people invest and work in the UK but instead it just keeps applying non economic rationales and we falter over and over again.

Are Band 5 and 6 workers “lower paid?”

Ecoo · 17/02/2023 08:08

Askingforadvice78 · 16/02/2023 21:14

Missing the point slightly, but we don't know 10% isn't affordable.

Yes, MP's payrise is only going to be 2.7% but that takes them to over £84,000 and way above the national average (Google told me this was £33,000). How about we call out the kinds of people they are and say there IS money to give the nurses what they deserve.

But you are right. It just isn't fair to affect people's life saving treatment and there should be a minimum service. Although not providing that is perhaps the (very harsh) point.

MPs’ pay should be above the national average, well above in fact. Have a think about why…

DrawingdowntheMoon · 17/02/2023 08:08

I think people need to understand that not all NHS Trusts are supporting the strike;

www.royalfree.nhs.uk/news-media/news/update-on-rcn-strike/

Nurses will demonstrate outside Lincoln County Hospital over pay and staffing. On Thursday, January 19, nurses plan to stand outside the hospital, despite not reaching the threshold to strike. (Lincolnshire Live)

www.blackpoolgazette.co.uk/health/reader-reactions-blackpool-victoria-hospital-nurses-are-not-taking-part-in-national-strikes-3918254

www.shropshirestar.com/news/health/2023/01/16/nursing-strikes-taking-place-at-county-health-trusts-this-week/

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:08

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:06

So today the nursing unions have announced they will be withdrawing from A&Es, intensive care units, chemotherapy and other key services. Now, I am not a conservative voter by any means and I do think nurses should get a fair pay rise (although I don’t think 10% is affordable).

However, I don’t think it is acceptable for unions to be putting lives at risk by refusing to provide life-saving care. The armed forces and prison officers are not allowed to strike- I would now support minimum service levels being extended to nurses to prevent the unions doing this.

I suspect I am not the only one and the unions need to be careful not to shoot themselves in the foot.

YABU for falling for the Tory propaganda about safety levels.

and YABU for falling for the Tory propaganda about affordability.

I’ve dealt with union pay negotiations and you can find a way through - by recutting pay increases, offering different options etc and yes putting a bit more money on the table.

If this government pays nurses more, it will increase the spending power of a group of people who are lower paid.

It will help tackle the recruitment crisis (won’t solve it though).

It will reduce the reliance on universal credit.

This is why our economy is screwed, because the Tories keeps making short term economically illiterate decisions.

The government has a huge pot of money to play with, it has tax raising powers (not just on individuals but companies too). It should want to make people invest and work in the UK but instead it just keeps applying non economic rationales and we falter over and over again.

Tiredmum100 · 17/02/2023 08:08

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 07:55

Is there a statistic to back up the “haemorrhaging staff” claim? Because I look at retention stats and see things like these from
www.nurses.co.uk/blog/stats-and-facts-uk-nursing-social-care-and-healthcare/

There are 704,520 Nurses on the permanent NMC register in the UK as of March 2022. This is up from 681,525 the previous year.

This means the real-terms increase in new (joining for the first time) NMC Registered Nurses year-on-year is 18,198 (that's the difference between the number of people joining and those leaving).

So, how can there be “haemorrhaging” of staff if we are gaining 18,000 nurses per year? And wouldn’t an extra 18,000 nurses per year mean that the government is working to fix staffing levels?

Then I read this:
These are the top 10 reasons given to the NMC for leaving the register:
43% = retired
22% = personal circumstance
18% = pressure / stress
13%= workplace culture
12%= left the UK
12% = Covid-19
10% = revalidation concerns
8%= patient care quality
6%= staffing levels
5%= other

And read that the strikes are about staffing, patient quality of care, and pay…but staffing and patient care quality are only why 14% of nurses who leave, leave and pay isn’t even in the list!

The #1 main reason is retirement. It’s the ageing population causing higher numbers of nurses to leave and even so, we are still gaining 18,198 nurses year on year.

So, forgive me but I don’t see any evidence for the claims of “haemorrhaging staff” due to pay, patient care quality or staffing levels.

Yes but nurses retire early to get out the profession and do other jobs. My cleaner is a nurse I worked with who has retired. Earning more per hour than she did and nearly as much as me and I'm a band 7 nurse!

MintJulia · 17/02/2023 08:04

@Discovereads

"Retired" covers a whole variety of circumstances. My dsis, a highly skilled nurse (paediatric intensive care, midwife etc) 'retired' from the NHS as soon as she could access her pension.

She hasn't retired. She works in a health centre for a high end leisure group. Better pay, steady hours, no aggressive violent relatives/patients, use of leisure facilities, free parking. She deals with sprains and strains, sun burn, poorly children.

BankOfDave · 17/02/2023 08:00

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:30

@Botw1

There has to be a balance between offering a pay rise that reflects the increased cost of living, while also making it affordable and not spurring inflation.

7.5% is a fair compromise in my view (in my view the RCN’s original demand for 19.6% was a terrible tactical move as it made it easy to dismiss their demands off hand).

I would offer 5% to other public sector workers like teachers.

Do you understand that increasing public sector pay doesn’t directly impact inflation in the way you’ve described?

Increases in private sector pay does as cost is directly passed on to the customer. In the public sector, services are not paid for ‘at the point of service’. Yes we all pay for it through taxation so it then comes down to government choices.

Read about it economically before stating it fuels inflation when it has a minimum effect.

Alexandra2001 · 17/02/2023 07:59

@Stackss TBF You don't sound like a Tory voter at all lol!

Other countries with min staff levels have a great deal of safe guards in place to ensure strike action is effective and RCN have said that life saving care will continue.. so thats a min service level.

Also, what sanction would have put against nurses who strike regardless of any new law?

But the point you are missing is that staff are leaving and unless this is halted and the NHS becomes an attractive option once again, then the level of service will continue to decline.. which i suspect is what the Govt wants.

On level of pay award.. the Govt found 10.1% to give to 12m pensioners, regardless of wealth, are giving every household regardless of wealth cheaper energy and are now giving £200 to 2m households not on mains gas.... again, regardless of wealth.

... there seems to be plenty of money to give to people more likely to vote Tory.

BigGreen · 17/02/2023 07:57

I still support the nurses. What else can they do in the face of such intransigence? Our current government won't even talk! Disgusting

MintJulia · 17/02/2023 07:56

Botw1 · 16/02/2023 21:13

Can we have minimum staffing levels on non strike days then please?

This.

And I'm a chemo patient so the announcement frightens me.

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 07:55

Cornettoninja · 17/02/2023 07:31

If there was a ‘like’ button.

OP, the NHS (and other public services) are haemorrhaging staff. The ones left striking are the ones who really want to do the job properly - dilute their means to highlight their issues and what do you think will happen? You’re advocating pushing the remaining staff into leaving because their options are exhausted and at some point self preservation has to kick in.

it’s short sighted and foolish by the government to think they can strong arm skilled people into working conditions they find untenable.

Is there a statistic to back up the “haemorrhaging staff” claim? Because I look at retention stats and see things like these from
www.nurses.co.uk/blog/stats-and-facts-uk-nursing-social-care-and-healthcare/

There are 704,520 Nurses on the permanent NMC register in the UK as of March 2022. This is up from 681,525 the previous year.

This means the real-terms increase in new (joining for the first time) NMC Registered Nurses year-on-year is 18,198 (that's the difference between the number of people joining and those leaving).

So, how can there be “haemorrhaging” of staff if we are gaining 18,000 nurses per year? And wouldn’t an extra 18,000 nurses per year mean that the government is working to fix staffing levels?

Then I read this:
These are the top 10 reasons given to the NMC for leaving the register:
43% = retired
22% = personal circumstance
18% = pressure / stress
13%= workplace culture
12%= left the UK
12% = Covid-19
10% = revalidation concerns
8%= patient care quality
6%= staffing levels
5%= other

And read that the strikes are about staffing, patient quality of care, and pay…but staffing and patient care quality are only why 14% of nurses who leave, leave and pay isn’t even in the list!

The #1 main reason is retirement. It’s the ageing population causing higher numbers of nurses to leave and even so, we are still gaining 18,198 nurses year on year.

So, forgive me but I don’t see any evidence for the claims of “haemorrhaging staff” due to pay, patient care quality or staffing levels.

Workinghardeveryday · 17/02/2023 07:53

Autumndays123 · 16/02/2023 22:48

I'm with you OP, I couldn't even imagine knowingly letting people (and children) die so I could have a few quid extra in my pocket. I thought nurses joined the profession because they want to help others, not sit back and watch people suffer. It leaves a very bad taste in my mouth.

Plus, where does it end? So they are happy for people to die now until they get their extra pennies. Presumably next year will be the same, and the next and so on. Terrible behaviour.

I agree too.

I get the cost of living crisis, it is hitting us hard - but I can’t demand a pay rise because of it.

I took my job on a wage I agreed, surely the nurses did the same?

bakebeans · 17/02/2023 07:52

The government has been able to afford a 10% increase from April to people on benefits. Justifiable given the rate of inflation. The fire service has been given a 7% pay rise. Again justifiable so please tell me why NHS staff are being denied a pay rise?
4% was awarded last year which was actually less than that due to pension contributions. The lowest paid NHS staff are on minimum wage?
Nurses starting salary is £27,055. The media keeping piping on about the average salary of £35k which again is incorrect facts. Most work more than 40 hours a week as they are unable to take breaks. One nurse per 8 patients who are all vulnerable or needing continuous observations and monitoring.

The government keep on pledging more nurses but given they keep refusing to give a pay rise, very few will want to join.
It will get much much worse and I already feel sorry for myself for when I will need to be cared for. I left the wards 12 years ago and you couldn't even pay me enough to go back! Absolutely horrendous! Talk about the impact on your mental health.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 17/02/2023 07:51

Cornettoninja · 17/02/2023 07:31

If there was a ‘like’ button.

OP, the NHS (and other public services) are haemorrhaging staff. The ones left striking are the ones who really want to do the job properly - dilute their means to highlight their issues and what do you think will happen? You’re advocating pushing the remaining staff into leaving because their options are exhausted and at some point self preservation has to kick in.

it’s short sighted and foolish by the government to think they can strong arm skilled people into working conditions they find untenable.

Yes, the OP and people who hold similar views don't seem to realise that trained nurses are a finite resource, that we require them and that we can't actually make them stay here and keep working based on whatever pay rise someone else might deem reasonable.

Tiredmum100 · 17/02/2023 07:47

Autumndays123 · 16/02/2023 22:48

I'm with you OP, I couldn't even imagine knowingly letting people (and children) die so I could have a few quid extra in my pocket. I thought nurses joined the profession because they want to help others, not sit back and watch people suffer. It leaves a very bad taste in my mouth.

Plus, where does it end? So they are happy for people to die now until they get their extra pennies. Presumably next year will be the same, and the next and so on. Terrible behaviour.

Thats part of the problem, nurses are seen as being a nurse out of the goodness of their heart, because they wanted to help people. Thats not the case. I have two different degrees in nursing. I'm not an angel. I have bills to pay, a mortgage, children to suoport. Its not just about pay. We haven't had safe staffing levels for years. My work place is running with a big deficit. We need to increase wages to recruit people and want them to stay in the profession. Maybe then we will have the safe staffing levels WE ALL WANT!! Nurses do not want to watch people suffer and die, but that IS already happening.

Cornettoninja · 17/02/2023 07:31

sashh · 17/02/2023 07:24

You do know it isn't just about pay don't you?

Minimum service levels would actually lead to more nurses on wards than there are at present.

If there was a ‘like’ button.

OP, the NHS (and other public services) are haemorrhaging staff. The ones left striking are the ones who really want to do the job properly - dilute their means to highlight their issues and what do you think will happen? You’re advocating pushing the remaining staff into leaving because their options are exhausted and at some point self preservation has to kick in.

it’s short sighted and foolish by the government to think they can strong arm skilled people into working conditions they find untenable.

sashh · 17/02/2023 07:24

You do know it isn't just about pay don't you?

Minimum service levels would actually lead to more nurses on wards than there are at present.

GoChasingWaterfalls · 17/02/2023 07:24

"The Department for Health & Social Care (DHSC) lost 75% of the £12 billion it spent on personal protective equipment (PPE) in the first year of the pandemic to inflated prices and kit that did not meet requirements – including fully £4 billion of PPE that will not be used in the NHS and needs to be disposed of."

committees.parliament.uk/committee/127/public-accounts-committee/news/171306/4-billion-of-unusable-ppe-bought-in-first-year-of-pandemic-will-be-burnt-to-generate-power

Absolute bollocks that we can't afford to give nurses an inflation matching payrise.

follyfoot37 · 17/02/2023 07:17

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:21

@FinallyHere

Personally I would make a best and final offer of 7.5% to nurses, with a 9% rise for those who worked through covid.

I would set a deadline of February 28 for this to be accepted, with the alternative being a 2% increase on the basis that this is the expected inflation figure for later in the year.

Well, goodness me, why aren't you General Manager of the whole world? How has everyone missed this straightforward and reasonable solution? What is your plan for the rail workers?
Maybe give the Chancellor and PM a quick ring this morning before you sort the war in Ukraine, find all the missing people, and ....

ivykaty44 · 17/02/2023 07:15

However, I don’t think it is acceptable for unions to be putting lives at risk by refusing to provide life-saving care.

however I don’t think it’s accept for the government to be putting lives at risk by refusing to negotiate on pay, there have already been strikes and the government isn’t being sensible.

Lapland123 · 17/02/2023 07:11

The government are at fault here! I can’t believe I’m still reading nonsense like ‘nurses should care’ and therefore continue to work for less and less money in below the minimum staffing levels EVERY DAY

Botw1 · 16/02/2023 23:11

The govt are putting lives at risk every day by not addressing the huge problems facing the NHS

OntarioBagnet · 16/02/2023 23:10

clarepetal · 16/02/2023 21:20

"Putting lives at risk"

You say this, but they are striking because conditions are so bad that people's lives are being put at risk all the time.

This. Staff are leaving in droves. Numbers for recruitment for training are significantly down nationally this year. People can’t afford to be nurses anymore.

Thepurplelantern · 16/02/2023 23:09

Doesn’t work we are in Ireland we’ve had blue flu where police phoned in sick because it is illegal to strike. It was just an illegal strike that they got paid for.