Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the government is right to impose minimum service levels on nurses

434 replies

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:06

So today the nursing unions have announced they will be withdrawing from A&Es, intensive care units, chemotherapy and other key services. Now, I am not a conservative voter by any means and I do think nurses should get a fair pay rise (although I don’t think 10% is affordable).

However, I don’t think it is acceptable for unions to be putting lives at risk by refusing to provide life-saving care. The armed forces and prison officers are not allowed to strike- I would now support minimum service levels being extended to nurses to prevent the unions doing this.

I suspect I am not the only one and the unions need to be careful not to shoot themselves in the foot.

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:42

YetiTeri · 17/02/2023 08:36

You're consistently ignoring the point that the current staffing crisis means that minimum standards are not being meant on a non strike day.

So yes bring in minimum standards and then the Govt would have to do something to ensure the staff are there.

Exactly! The government refuses to analyse where the shortages lie and in which speciality, so how can they define minimum levels…

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 08:42

@Ecoo

Depends what your comparing it to.

Its fairly low for the level of skill and responsibilities

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 08:41

It's an odd argument to make anyway. Even if there wasnt a recruitment and retention crisis (there is, not just for nurses and not just in the UK but globally for all aspects of health and social care)

Hcp deserve a decent wage for the work they do.

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:36

Ecoo · 17/02/2023 08:09

Are Band 5 and 6 workers “lower paid?”

@Ecoo after things like student loan repayments and parking charges, do you think they’re high paid?

We have a problem in this country with low wages generally. The average wages are crap.

YetiTeri · 17/02/2023 08:36

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:16

@Askingforadvice78

The point is there are 650 MPs and hundreds of thousands of nurses (and millions of public sector staff, who would presumably demand similar rises). So to say a 10% pay rise for millions is affordable because 650 people have got 2.7% is nonsense.

You're consistently ignoring the point that the current staffing crisis means that minimum standards are not being meant on a non strike day.

So yes bring in minimum standards and then the Govt would have to do something to ensure the staff are there.

TheGoogleMum · 17/02/2023 08:35

Actually they do still have some Nurses working to meet their own minimum levels. The government idea is just to punish and make striking harder. Nurses care about patients they won't just leave them all to die

Sirzy · 17/02/2023 08:34

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:12

How have they “retired early” if they are of the age to retire with the NHS pension? And don’t most people in their fifties/sixties switch to less physically demanding jobs due to ageing?

My dad is a nurse. His pension scheme meant he could retire mid 50s, but he planned to keep on working beyond that as most people in the same position as his did.

this was 10 years ago and even then the impact of everything being cut and the bullying from management made him decide to walk away because it was no longer the profession he loved. He was amazing at his job but wasn’t being able to do his job anymore.

things have got a lot worse since.

Alexandra2001 · 17/02/2023 08:32

@Discovereads Half of the increase was overseas, non EAA nurses... there has been much debate on their training and language skills and the amount of additional supervision they need.

Add the work place/nhs related reasons to leave and its almost 50%....

Many vacancies are filled by using agency bank staff, not the most efficient way to manage staff or costs.

Anyway, the thread is about strikes and the Govts new laws on min service levels.. which the govt will mandate are way higher than on non strike days.. effectively banning strikes or you get the sack.

Versailles2023 · 17/02/2023 08:32

You’re missing the point lives are already at risk! I voted with my feet and left healthcare and the NHS. You have to look at the bigger picture. If everyone left like me there would be no service at all. The only answer is to pay more, train more and retain more. For me no amount of pay rise would tempt me back to healthcare and I am a 20 year specialist in my field no longer using any of my skills. So much happier though even if I am poorer.

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:28

Givenupghost · 17/02/2023 08:22

Thank you believeitornot you you beat me to it x

👍👍

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:28

And finally, the number of vacancies will be driven by how many posts the government chooses to fund.

So if the government decides to cut posts, they’d have fewer vacancies - that wouldn’t necessarily be a good thing!

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:26

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:21

89% of staff positions being filled at any one time isn’t haemorrhaging or so low as to cause the kind of complaints I’m seeing. You do expect to have a certain % of vacant positions due to regular turnover…which according to the stats is largely caused by retirement.

People may choose to retire because they’ve burnt out early, not because they’ve come to the end of an illustrious career….

And it is a failure of workforce planning to not have enough new trainees coming through; instead relying on an older workforce in a difficult and challenging workplace.

The NHS workforce crisis is a real one and has been brewing for years and years.

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:24

So there has been a problem in the NHS workforce for a while.
Many of us notice this with the difficulty in getting a GP appointment but are led to believe it’s because GPs are being lazy post covid and hiding behind that. When the truth is, GP numbers were a problem before covid.

Unless you use the NHS regularly, you don’t notice low staffing levels but if you look, the clues are there. My kids have had care due to broken bones, etc over the years and I’ve noticed the state of hospitals and the long time sitting in a waiting room. The evidence is there.

People can be incredibly cynical and not want to believe it, and waste time googling to try and argue against what informed people are telling them. Telling them over and over again.

It is why the NHS had to be “protected” during covid - as it had been run down so much so couldn’t cope. And while everyone pretends covid was over - it actually did almost fall over this winter due to the very high covid numbers as covid made people ill (needing time off) and put them in hospital.

So unless these things are fixed, and people stop taking the government’s nonsense, then this will keep happening.

Quveas · 17/02/2023 08:23

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 07:55

Is there a statistic to back up the “haemorrhaging staff” claim? Because I look at retention stats and see things like these from
www.nurses.co.uk/blog/stats-and-facts-uk-nursing-social-care-and-healthcare/

There are 704,520 Nurses on the permanent NMC register in the UK as of March 2022. This is up from 681,525 the previous year.

This means the real-terms increase in new (joining for the first time) NMC Registered Nurses year-on-year is 18,198 (that's the difference between the number of people joining and those leaving).

So, how can there be “haemorrhaging” of staff if we are gaining 18,000 nurses per year? And wouldn’t an extra 18,000 nurses per year mean that the government is working to fix staffing levels?

Then I read this:
These are the top 10 reasons given to the NMC for leaving the register:
43% = retired
22% = personal circumstance
18% = pressure / stress
13%= workplace culture
12%= left the UK
12% = Covid-19
10% = revalidation concerns
8%= patient care quality
6%= staffing levels
5%= other

And read that the strikes are about staffing, patient quality of care, and pay…but staffing and patient care quality are only why 14% of nurses who leave, leave and pay isn’t even in the list!

The #1 main reason is retirement. It’s the ageing population causing higher numbers of nurses to leave and even so, we are still gaining 18,198 nurses year on year.

So, forgive me but I don’t see any evidence for the claims of “haemorrhaging staff” due to pay, patient care quality or staffing levels.

Being on the nursing register and working for the NHS are not the same thing!

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:22

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:16

the Health Select Committee did a report on NHS staffing last summer here

They concluded The NHS and social care face the greatest workforce crisis in their history, compounded by the absence of a credible government strategy to tackle the situation, say MPs. In the NHS, persistent understaffing poses a serious risk to staff and patient safety in routine and emergency care

Jeremy Hunt, our esteemed Chancellor, was on that Committee.

Thank you, I am going off to read this now so will be off the thread for a bit.

Givenupghost · 17/02/2023 08:22

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:16

the Health Select Committee did a report on NHS staffing last summer here

They concluded The NHS and social care face the greatest workforce crisis in their history, compounded by the absence of a credible government strategy to tackle the situation, say MPs. In the NHS, persistent understaffing poses a serious risk to staff and patient safety in routine and emergency care

Jeremy Hunt, our esteemed Chancellor, was on that Committee.

Thank you believeitornot you you beat me to it x

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:21

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:12

That same link also says That tells us that the NHS is attempting to operate at 11% under required staffing levels

oh.

89% of staff positions being filled at any one time isn’t haemorrhaging or so low as to cause the kind of complaints I’m seeing. You do expect to have a certain % of vacant positions due to regular turnover…which according to the stats is largely caused by retirement.

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 08:21

@Discovereads

Do you have any stats for nurses leaving ward roles for either community or specialised roles?

You do also realise that people can retire earlier than the otherwise would have because of pay and conditions?

You don't see the issue with replacing (or trying to, it's not working) nurses who have left (retiring or other reasons) with lots of years of experience with brand newly qualified nurses?

Senior roles (ward managers, deputy ward managers) are advertised and get no applicants.

I know of a combined assessment unit locally that has 20 WTE vacancies. It has been advertised for months with no applicants.

In previous years you could shortlist from tons of applicants. Now you're lucky to get 1 or 2. Quite often 0

So tbh I'm not really quite sure what your point is?

Most nurses are in nursing for a reason, because they care about the people and the job. They won't want to leave, any who do will be torn by the decision. The fact some stick it out doesn't mean there aren't huge problems.

They are being broken by the govt failure to manage the NHS properly.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 17/02/2023 08:18

Yep, being registered with the NMC doesn't mean a nurse is working in the NHS. It's the wrong stat to use.

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:16

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:14

Ok, then link me to the evidence. Anecdotes are not robust evidence of staff “haemorrhaging” due to low pay, staffing levels and/or patient quality (the claims of the strikers).

the Health Select Committee did a report on NHS staffing last summer here

They concluded The NHS and social care face the greatest workforce crisis in their history, compounded by the absence of a credible government strategy to tackle the situation, say MPs. In the NHS, persistent understaffing poses a serious risk to staff and patient safety in routine and emergency care

Jeremy Hunt, our esteemed Chancellor, was on that Committee.

Cornettoninja · 17/02/2023 08:14

@Discovereads registering with the NMC doesn’t mean all of those nurses are even working in an NHS position.

are you looking at the most recent figures for staffing levels? How do they compare with ten years ago for instance and how would you explain the almost 47k nursing vacancies (September 2022 www.nursingtimes.net/news/workforce/nurse-vacancies-reach-record-high-of-almost-47000-in-england-01-09-2022/)?

Those retiring isn’t a great point to make either, this has been brewing (and warned of) for years because it’s fairly simple maths to look at a work force and deduce that there’s a problem coming well in advance.

I don’t know about you but I tend to trust the medical staff to know what they’re talking about when I seek their services. Why wouldn’t you trust them to assess the problems in their own industry?

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:14

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:12

How have they “retired early” if they are of the age to retire with the NHS pension? And don’t most people in their fifties/sixties switch to less physically demanding jobs due to ageing?

Early retirement means you retire before the official age but can draw down some of your pension early.

I think George Osborne changed that rule. It’s not difficult to understand.

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:14

Givenupghost · 17/02/2023 08:11

The use of NMC registration statistics does not give a clear picture of what is actually happening in terns of working as a nurse.
To maintain your registration you only need to work 450 hours over 3 years.
I have a lot colleagues who have left nursing for other careers. They have maintained their pin by working either the minimum required hours or moving into a non nhs based role. T

Ok, then link me to the evidence. Anecdotes are not robust evidence of staff “haemorrhaging” due to low pay, staffing levels and/or patient quality (the claims of the strikers).

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:12

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 07:55

Is there a statistic to back up the “haemorrhaging staff” claim? Because I look at retention stats and see things like these from
www.nurses.co.uk/blog/stats-and-facts-uk-nursing-social-care-and-healthcare/

There are 704,520 Nurses on the permanent NMC register in the UK as of March 2022. This is up from 681,525 the previous year.

This means the real-terms increase in new (joining for the first time) NMC Registered Nurses year-on-year is 18,198 (that's the difference between the number of people joining and those leaving).

So, how can there be “haemorrhaging” of staff if we are gaining 18,000 nurses per year? And wouldn’t an extra 18,000 nurses per year mean that the government is working to fix staffing levels?

Then I read this:
These are the top 10 reasons given to the NMC for leaving the register:
43% = retired
22% = personal circumstance
18% = pressure / stress
13%= workplace culture
12%= left the UK
12% = Covid-19
10% = revalidation concerns
8%= patient care quality
6%= staffing levels
5%= other

And read that the strikes are about staffing, patient quality of care, and pay…but staffing and patient care quality are only why 14% of nurses who leave, leave and pay isn’t even in the list!

The #1 main reason is retirement. It’s the ageing population causing higher numbers of nurses to leave and even so, we are still gaining 18,198 nurses year on year.

So, forgive me but I don’t see any evidence for the claims of “haemorrhaging staff” due to pay, patient care quality or staffing levels.

That same link also says That tells us that the NHS is attempting to operate at 11% under required staffing levels

oh.

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:12

Tiredmum100 · 17/02/2023 08:08

Yes but nurses retire early to get out the profession and do other jobs. My cleaner is a nurse I worked with who has retired. Earning more per hour than she did and nearly as much as me and I'm a band 7 nurse!

How have they “retired early” if they are of the age to retire with the NHS pension? And don’t most people in their fifties/sixties switch to less physically demanding jobs due to ageing?