Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say the government is right to impose minimum service levels on nurses

434 replies

Stackss · 16/02/2023 21:06

So today the nursing unions have announced they will be withdrawing from A&Es, intensive care units, chemotherapy and other key services. Now, I am not a conservative voter by any means and I do think nurses should get a fair pay rise (although I don’t think 10% is affordable).

However, I don’t think it is acceptable for unions to be putting lives at risk by refusing to provide life-saving care. The armed forces and prison officers are not allowed to strike- I would now support minimum service levels being extended to nurses to prevent the unions doing this.

I suspect I am not the only one and the unions need to be careful not to shoot themselves in the foot.

OP posts:
Autumndays123 · 17/02/2023 09:38

Botw1 · 16/02/2023 23:08

@Autumndays123

Do you have a chronic health condition?

When were you last in a hospital as a pt?

Interesting you always had a good view of the nurses st regardless of what hospital you were in

Some shifts are better than others. Even on the worst shift I make sure staff take at least 2 breaks and yeah, have a coffee mid afternoon while writing up notes if possible (lots of days it's not)

Im not sure why anyone would begrudge that or think that means they're lying about how poor staffing levels are or how hard the work is

Do you work 12 hour shifts? How many breaks do you take?

Last in hospital in October 2022.

You walk past the central desks to get anywhere on the ward. So if visiting, you see it on the way in, on the way out and if you go to speak to the nurses/to go to the canteen for whatever reason.

I'm not saying the nurses shouldn't be entitled to coffee breaks. I'm saying that the argument is often 'we are so rushed off our feet we work for 12 hours without stopping for a toilet, we must have more money '. In my experience, this is incorrect and actually there is quite a lot of down time where nurses could actually be tending to patients, but spend it gossiping and drinking coffee.

I've actually had a few family members die in hospital through quite poor care. Nurses came across as disinterested and only made any kind of fuss when the patient's family were nearby. I've actually spoken to a fair few older people in care homes, again when visiting family and friends and the message is very much, unless you have family/friends, you're pretty much ignored in hospital other than the absolute basics. Very sad. The older people used to be terrified of going to hospital because of the poor care.

KILM · 17/02/2023 09:37

Can't believe that people think nurses are well paid. Anyone working in tech will be able to tell you that nurses are on a PITIFUL wage. You can be on well over double what a nurse is for much, much less training (and much less money for training) without being degree educated, with WFH, better hours, less responsibility and not have to watch people die. Some people seem to have absolutely no idea what the wages are in the private sector for things you don't need anywhere near the level of training for. It's an absolute scandal how much responsibility and stress we expect nurses to be under for such shit money.

(Also sometimes I think wow, what a great job the papers have done at convincing people that anything over 30k is great money. It was 15 years ago maybe but now???)

Alexandra2001 · 17/02/2023 09:32

Stackss · 17/02/2023 09:20

@PuddlesPityParty

Which private sector employees are receiving 19.6% increases? The average private sector pay rise is 5% and I agree nurses should receive 7.5% (with higher for those who worked through covid).

BT workers got a 16% pay rise, avg private sector rises are 8%.

But if you know anything at all about negotiation, you would realise both sides start at the extremes and negotiate a compromise.

How do you plan on retaining staff?

OntarioBagnet · 17/02/2023 09:31

There may be more nurses but how does that equate to whole time equivalency? Most nurses are part time and reducing hours due to burn out. Vacancy rates are up

To say the government is right to impose minimum service levels on nurses
Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 09:25

DrawingdowntheMoon · 17/02/2023 09:12

You’re citing an article in Jan 2021…. And, as I recall, they did end up closing schools because covid rates went through the roof and a lot of people died.

A lot of people died and are still dying because of covid. The government could have invested in air quality improvement measures in hospitals and schools then we wouldn’t needed lockdowns.

But hey they didn’t. (Although funnily enough they’ve got air filters in Parliament).

OntarioBagnet · 17/02/2023 09:24

Workinghardeveryday · 17/02/2023 07:53

I agree too.

I get the cost of living crisis, it is hitting us hard - but I can’t demand a pay rise because of it.

I took my job on a wage I agreed, surely the nurses did the same?

If they had all started in the last 6 months you might have a point. But if you have started a job years ago, 20 years ago you expect the wage to keep up with inflation.

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 09:24

@Stackss

I asked earlier but you didn't answer, what does working through covid have to do with increasing nurses wages now?

How would that work, legally, for the small number of nurses who didn't work through covid?

Theyre working the same shifts today as everyone else. Trying to get through the shit show the covid response (amongst other things) has created

Stackss · 17/02/2023 09:20

@PuddlesPityParty

Which private sector employees are receiving 19.6% increases? The average private sector pay rise is 5% and I agree nurses should receive 7.5% (with higher for those who worked through covid).

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 09:20

DrawingdowntheMoon · 17/02/2023 09:15

Yep and a select number of people made an absolute killing out of covid…. Reading that article you can see those at the bottom end suffered the most.

Those at the top did not as they could hoard cash and there’s an argument that their spending to make up for it (or “pent up demand”) is why prices are going up, as businesses see more profit to be made.

LynneBenfield · 17/02/2023 09:15

This government does not give a toss about patient safety, don’t kid yourself OP.

watchfulwishes · 17/02/2023 09:15

user1471453601 · 16/02/2023 21:09

Yes, I'd support it too, as long as the government agreed minimum levels of service on non strike days, which they don't

Totally agree.

The government are bullshitting when they claim to care about patient safety.

Our local a&e is overwhelmed permanently. Government don't give a shit about how many die.

This proposal is just window dressing to appease the gullible.

DrawingdowntheMoon · 17/02/2023 09:15

Here's the cost of the Covid lockdowns

www.theguardian.com/business/2021/mar/22/a-year-of-covid-lockdowns-has-cost-the-uk-economy-251bn-study-says

MarshaBradyo · 17/02/2023 09:13

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 07:55

Is there a statistic to back up the “haemorrhaging staff” claim? Because I look at retention stats and see things like these from
www.nurses.co.uk/blog/stats-and-facts-uk-nursing-social-care-and-healthcare/

There are 704,520 Nurses on the permanent NMC register in the UK as of March 2022. This is up from 681,525 the previous year.

This means the real-terms increase in new (joining for the first time) NMC Registered Nurses year-on-year is 18,198 (that's the difference between the number of people joining and those leaving).

So, how can there be “haemorrhaging” of staff if we are gaining 18,000 nurses per year? And wouldn’t an extra 18,000 nurses per year mean that the government is working to fix staffing levels?

Then I read this:
These are the top 10 reasons given to the NMC for leaving the register:
43% = retired
22% = personal circumstance
18% = pressure / stress
13%= workplace culture
12%= left the UK
12% = Covid-19
10% = revalidation concerns
8%= patient care quality
6%= staffing levels
5%= other

And read that the strikes are about staffing, patient quality of care, and pay…but staffing and patient care quality are only why 14% of nurses who leave, leave and pay isn’t even in the list!

The #1 main reason is retirement. It’s the ageing population causing higher numbers of nurses to leave and even so, we are still gaining 18,198 nurses year on year.

So, forgive me but I don’t see any evidence for the claims of “haemorrhaging staff” due to pay, patient care quality or staffing levels.

The shortage figure is a target set by NHS and it is arbitrary

So there can be a target met and once it is an increased 40k target can be created which then translates to shortage

More or Less did a good piece recently, as they usually do, on what shortage actually meant.

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 09:12

@Believeitornot

I think in the private sector they are forecasting and average of 5% wage increase.

Obviously that means that the highest wage increases will be much more. Some are forecasting at 15% and these will be on very high wages already

Do you think the govt will step in and say no? That will increase inflation, you can't do that!

Of course they won't

Funny how on threads about higher earners its always argued they deserve their ridiculous high wages because they work hard and we have to be competitive to prevent brain drain.

Yet talks about NHS wages it's always oh they should just accept a pittance and be grateful for it!

Makes no sense

DrawingdowntheMoon · 17/02/2023 09:12

Stackss · 17/02/2023 08:47

The other key point the unions miss is that we’ve just spent almost 2 years in lockdowns to ‘protect the NHS’. These have cost hundreds of billions of pounds- I suspect we would have more money to fund pay rises had lockdowns not taken place.

And yet, the unions constantly demanded harder and longer lockdowns.

I agree.

Starmer was leading the call for more Lockdowns -

www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/jan/03/keir-starmer-calls-for-immediate-lockdown-in-england-as-covid-cases-soar

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 09:06

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 08:58

Did you know that there were more billionaires created during lock down/the pandemic than at any other time?

I wonder what the govt is doing to tackle the impact of greed on inflation?

^This

Inflation is driven by greed.

It is backward thinking to claim that paying a decent living wage is the cause of inflation.

Businesses seek to protect profit - and they will raise prices to do so. And those price rises cause inflation (look at the massive profits made by energy companies).

Businesses could raise wages (and are) and take a temporary hit to profit, but still make a profit. The world won’t end.

Businesses don’t have to raise prices unless they are running out of cash but they do to keep making profits. Energy companies are a great example - we are told that our high energy prices are because of the war in Ukraine - well if so, then why aren’t they struggling? Where are the high costs falling exactly? The reason goes back to greed. People with resources will choose to exploit that by raising prices. It’s the nature of capitalism and isn’t a law of nature. It’s humans being greedy!

The government have choices. They could choose to make pay awards just below inflation. This would help with recruitment and retention, improve tax takes as it will help the economy as more people have money to spend. If businesses choose to put up prices to take advantage- that’s because they’re greedy and want more profit.

But as I said, I’m trying to find evidence that it’s increased pay that causes inflation as opposed to businesses wanting more money.

Cornettoninja · 17/02/2023 09:03

Discovereads · 17/02/2023 08:21

89% of staff positions being filled at any one time isn’t haemorrhaging or so low as to cause the kind of complaints I’m seeing. You do expect to have a certain % of vacant positions due to regular turnover…which according to the stats is largely caused by retirement.

Putting aside your issue with the word haemorrhaging (pretty sure you’d have issues if you lost 11% or your blood volume) what exactly do you attribute the problems you’re seeing to then?

Botw1 · 17/02/2023 08:58

Did you know that there were more billionaires created during lock down/the pandemic than at any other time?

I wonder what the govt is doing to tackle the impact of greed on inflation?

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:57

I am still looking for the evidence but I can only find anecdotes not actual evidence that increasing wages leads to inflation.

It was something that was bandied about in the 1970s when inflation was already high and to argue against giving payrises, but no credible link made between the two.

I will keep looking but I suspect it may be a junk theory spouted by economists who want to support neo-liberal extreme capitalism which, funnily enough, always seems to favour the very wealthy.

LakieLady · 17/02/2023 08:52

Givenupghost · 17/02/2023 08:11

The use of NMC registration statistics does not give a clear picture of what is actually happening in terns of working as a nurse.
To maintain your registration you only need to work 450 hours over 3 years.
I have a lot colleagues who have left nursing for other careers. They have maintained their pin by working either the minimum required hours or moving into a non nhs based role. T

I was going to point this out, too. I know a couple of people who do enough hours each year to maintain their registrations, but whose main employment is not nursing. One of them does it so that if she gets pissed off with whatever she's currently doing, she can jack it in and do agency work while she looks for something.

My MP is a nurse and maintains her registration too, she never tires of mentioning it in every interview she does.

Still, she'll be glad she did when she loses her seat at the next GE and has to get a proper job.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/02/2023 08:52

Stackss · 17/02/2023 08:47

The other key point the unions miss is that we’ve just spent almost 2 years in lockdowns to ‘protect the NHS’. These have cost hundreds of billions of pounds- I suspect we would have more money to fund pay rises had lockdowns not taken place.

And yet, the unions constantly demanded harder and longer lockdowns.

@Stackss Are you going to answer the point several previous posters have made on minimum staffing levels not being met on non-strike days or are you going to carry on ignoring that and continue to argue your point in bad faith?

Believeitornot · 17/02/2023 08:51

Stackss · 17/02/2023 08:47

The other key point the unions miss is that we’ve just spent almost 2 years in lockdowns to ‘protect the NHS’. These have cost hundreds of billions of pounds- I suspect we would have more money to fund pay rises had lockdowns not taken place.

And yet, the unions constantly demanded harder and longer lockdowns.

We needed lockdowns because the NHS was crumbling and the government did not act fast enough. Unions could see that their staff were at the front line - and the government failed to make them safe. Did you miss the scandals of no PPE at the start of covid? Did you miss the utter failure to put air filters across hospitals and schools to keep the air disease free?

And plenty of companies did very well out of lockdown. Plenty of companies continued to make profits, not every business was negatively affected.

You sound like a Daily Mail AI bot who lacks critical thinking.

PuddlesPityParty · 17/02/2023 08:50

Stackss · 17/02/2023 08:47

The other key point the unions miss is that we’ve just spent almost 2 years in lockdowns to ‘protect the NHS’. These have cost hundreds of billions of pounds- I suspect we would have more money to fund pay rises had lockdowns not taken place.

And yet, the unions constantly demanded harder and longer lockdowns.

Sorry I missed where the nurses made that decision?

and why is it only public sector pay rises that spur inflation? Why not private sector?

Sorry but get your head out of the sand and look towards what the actual issue is - the Tories.

Notonthestairs · 17/02/2023 08:49

Stackss · 17/02/2023 08:47

The other key point the unions miss is that we’ve just spent almost 2 years in lockdowns to ‘protect the NHS’. These have cost hundreds of billions of pounds- I suspect we would have more money to fund pay rises had lockdowns not taken place.

And yet, the unions constantly demanded harder and longer lockdowns.

Maybe if we hadn't had so many staff vacancies, more beds, more nurses trained to use ventilators, appropriate PPE or even a pandemic plan we might have been able to have shorter (preferably no) lockdowns.

Stackss · 17/02/2023 08:47

The other key point the unions miss is that we’ve just spent almost 2 years in lockdowns to ‘protect the NHS’. These have cost hundreds of billions of pounds- I suspect we would have more money to fund pay rises had lockdowns not taken place.

And yet, the unions constantly demanded harder and longer lockdowns.

OP posts: