Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think dp is too harsh on 2yr old?

233 replies

Whoissit · 16/02/2023 20:58

Please help me settle the never ending debate, sleep.

I'm perfectly fine with being told I'm the one being unreasonable but I really don't think I am.

Dp has become increasingly frustrated with dc, who is 2yrs 3months, not being able to fall asleep on his own. I keep telling him he has unrealistic expectations that aren't fair to put on dc given his age. That I remember my parents sitting with me reading a book, singing, or rubbing my head until I fell asleep in primary school. I'm getting annoyed at the constant arguments we are having about it because dp thinks dc should be able to lie down at night and just go to sleep on his own. I don't think it's unnatural for him to need soothing/comforting at night.

Once dc is asleep he may way once or twice, most the time he sleeps the whole night through.

Dp thinks I'm being too soft on him and wants to let him cry it out. I generally don't believe in doing that unless it's crucial, example being we are sleep deprived or he is. I think it's drastic measures and causes unnecessary stress to dc.

So who is being unreasonable here? It's our first child. Maybe 2 year olds all do just go to sleep on their own without a problem and I'm pandering....

OP posts:
Mariposista · 16/02/2023 22:19

There is a massive gap to fill between just shoving him in his room and letting him get on with it, and pandering to him for ages and ages.
Bedtime should be relaxing. Wind down time, teeth, pyjamas, story, kiss and cuddle and lights out.

Viviennemary · 16/02/2023 22:17

I think you should setna limit. decide on a time say 30 minutes or 45 even for stories and chat and then thats it. Goodnight and leave the room. I don't agree with sitting till they fall asleep.

TheShellBeach · 16/02/2023 22:16

Get the Ferber sleep training book. I used it when DD was the same age as your son.
It took two nights and then I was able to leave her to fall asleep by herself. I still read her a couple of stories and then left her to settle by herself.

WolfFoxHare · 16/02/2023 22:14

You could try doing a very regular routine of bath, teeth, bed, story, lullaby every night at the same time, with gradual retreat. So hold his hand for the first week, then sit at the end of his bed, then sit by the door, then potter around upstairs so he can hear you as he drifts off. Say ‘I just have to fold this laundry/change our bed/tidy up in the spare room but I’ll be back in five minutes…’ - in my experience he’ll fall asleep in those five minutes. If not, pop back in, quick kiss, then back out for another five minute chore. He’ll learn that it’s ok to fall asleep in his room alone, that you’re always nearby and responsive to his emotional needs, that you have jobs that you need to do but that you’ll always come back when you say you will. He’ll feel secure and relaxed, and will be able to fall sleep independently, which is a good skill to have.

Frezia · 16/02/2023 22:14

Your child is still so, so little. If you want to cuddle your little more than a baby to sleep every night please do so, regardless of what your husband or a bunch of randoms on Mumsnet who don't know you or your child think is ridiculous. I promise you it's not. In this country people still think they need to train small children not to need them. That sort of thing comes naturally when they're ready.
Do what you feel is right.
It will not last forever or even long, promise you that too.

Your husband doesn't want bedtime to eat into his relaxing night time but he'd happily listen to his own child scream for an hour instead during his relaxing night time? Horrendous.

Nanny0gg · 16/02/2023 22:13

Whoissit · 16/02/2023 21:03

@MrsBunnyEars tbh I think it's just laziness on dps behalf. He hates the fact that it eats into our night time. And although I too find it inconvenient I recognise its not going to be forever. Dc has started asking for books to be read at night and I have to encourage dp to read to him when it's his turn to put dc to sleep. If it had it his way he'd put him in bed, close the door and happily listen to him scream for us for an hr until he passes out from hysteria

I think DP Bashing is a good idea.

He's horrible and most parents love story time with their children

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/02/2023 22:12

I do think YABU sorry. It's not just about your child. I say that as someone who stays with my child, but this takes 15 min max and doesnt impact on our evening. If it takes 90 min then it's really impacting on your time together as a couple, and I'm not sure it's really working well (that's a long time to take to fall asleep which would suggest he isnt properly tired, or your presence is actually keeping him awake).

Your husband is at the opposite end of the spectrum and I think CIO is very harsh especially if you havent exhausted other options first.

Cant you compromise by trying a very gradual retreat method?

miraveille · 16/02/2023 22:10

God forbid anyone should actually have to parent. To those on this thread saying 5 mins and leave, I bet you all made a big fuss about getting pregnant and all that and then here they are and no one can be arsed. Unbelievable. Just cos the sun went down.
No, it's not unreasonable to sit for an hour, you are correct.

WolfFoxHare · 16/02/2023 22:07

1-1.5 hours is ridiculous. Putting him in bed, turning out the light and leaving him to cry is cruel. 20 minutes if that includes a couple of stories, maybe a couple of lullabies, seems very reasonable. What you want to aim at is spending some time reading and talking/singing with him then being able to leave him sleepy and drifting off but NOT actually asleep.

PutItInTheFuckingBasket · 16/02/2023 22:07

My DS is 2.5, and I stay with him til he's asleep - usually takes up to 30mins, although we've just introduced a yoto player to start the process of gradual retreat and leaving him with a story on - mostly because I'm 6 months pregnant so need him to have some more independence, otherwise I'm not sure I'd bother tbh.

It isn't working for your family though, as 1.5hr is a very long time - does he need a later bedtime or a shorter nap? And the fact your husband wants it to change, means that some change is probably a good idea, as if he's constantly griping about it it's going to be such a pain in the arse

Nimbostratus100 · 16/02/2023 22:03

Theelephantinthecastle · 16/02/2023 21:56

Do they? We have always closed the door to keep it dark and quiet for the kids and ours have never liked it open. I remember being annoyed when my parents would leave mine open, I hated the feeling of vulnerability

depends on the child, obviously. Most little ones I have looked after want the door open,

Bluebell2020 · 16/02/2023 21:58

I have a 2 year 3 month old. We do usual bedtime routine ( bath (not every night), teeth,pjs, story and cuddle on chair). I then give her a kiss, put her in her cot and switch her grow clock to night time. I say night night and walk out. She usually sings herself to sleep then 😂. If we've had a late night out and about I can skip story etc and just do pjs, teeth and cot and she will still go to sleep on her own.

If you've not got a grow clock they're definitely worth trying. She knows "Blue means night time" and "night time is for sleeping". The only time she cries for me in the night is when she wants to go to the toilet (she's potty trained) and because her clock is blue she knows it's straight back to bed after potty so takes literally 2 minutes.

Some little ones do need a little extra help getting to sleep, but I personally think over an hour every night is way too long and would definitely be looking at how to change it.

NicLondon1 · 16/02/2023 21:57

There’s a really great book which offers up methods of more gradual retreat sleep training…”Teach your child to Sleep by the Millpond Institute.
They also offer a 1 hour consultation on the phone to help with a particular situation…

Theelephantinthecastle · 16/02/2023 21:56

Nimbostratus100 · 16/02/2023 21:12

why is the door closed?

bedtime story, kiss and leave

leaving the child in a comfortable set up, night lights? music? door open? almost all children want the door open, dont they?

sitting for over an hour unti lthey fall asleep is WAAAY OTT, but closing the door on a crying two year old is not normal either, a two year old can be told what is going to happen, and understand. shut alone into the dark sounds horrible

Do they? We have always closed the door to keep it dark and quiet for the kids and ours have never liked it open. I remember being annoyed when my parents would leave mine open, I hated the feeling of vulnerability

musicforthesoul · 16/02/2023 21:55

1.5 hours sounds ridiculous. You don't have to do CIO but I think it's worth considering other approaches if it's taking that long most nights.

ChildminderMum · 16/02/2023 21:55

I think you're both BU to be honest.

60-90 minutes of rubbing and patting is crazy.
No story and just shutting a distressed child in a dark room is cruel.

Cut down on any daytime napping, have a nice bedtime routine, story, tuck them in and either pop in and out or do some gradual retreat. Nightlight and some songs or audiobooks to listen to.

WoolyMammoth55 · 16/02/2023 21:53

Hi OP, haven't RTFT. Just popping on to say that all parents are different, all households have different rules/expectations, and you and DP need to compromise a way forward that you're both happy with and ignore everyone else because it's your family - so you get to decide!

In case it's useful to compare though, I have a 5yo and a 2yo. From very early we do a strong and regular bedtime routine, which varies only exceptionally, less than 10 times a year I'd say.

Dinner, then playtime, then milky drink, then bath. After bath it's pjs on, storytime, then they go to separate bedrooms. 5 yo gets lights off and musical rainbow nightlight on (www.argos.co.uk/product/4239808). We have cuddles and say goodnight and kisses and then go out.

2yo gets cuddled and breastfed to sleep, with white noise playing.

Once they're out of the bath it's very unusual for it to be more than 30 mins until me and DH are back downstairs watching Netflix :)

I think a strong bedtime routine is your friend, it cues a lot of sleepy hormones etc. Also enough fresh air in the day, not too long/late of a nap, enough to eat at dinner time, etc.

But basically I am soft with mine because really mindful that though the days are long, the years are short - I want these cuddles while I can get them! In 10 years time they'll be moody teens who won't want anything to do with me... :) Also we are not having any more kids so want to enjoy this baby time as long as I can since he's my last one.

Wish you all the best coming to a compromise with DH. I think CIO is much too harsh but there might be a middle way.

BiasedBinding · 16/02/2023 21:51

I like sitting with mine and they like me there, it’s a nice peaceful part of the evening for me. I read while they drop off. Mine share a room so perfectly doable with more than one child. Needing someone to sit with them when 11yo is definitely an outlier and probably would have needed that regardless of how parents handled it when younger.

jannier · 16/02/2023 21:50

Whoissit · 16/02/2023 21:01

@Sirzy it can vary. Sometimes (although be it very rarely) he doesn't need us at all. On a good day 20/30 mins. On a bad day (which is the majority) it can be up to a hour or hr and a half.

I'd resent the 90 minutes and be doing gradual withdrawal no crying involved.

SultanOfSwing · 16/02/2023 21:50

I don’t approve of CIO at all, but I did vote YABU. By 2 your child very much understands bedtime, and the system of lying with him and stroking his hair should never have been developed. A gentle bedtime routine with bed, cuddles and a story - maybe even two stories - a rhyme or song when lights are out and a kiss and a loving but definite goodnight is appropriate at that age and beyond.

Of course he is now used to never falling asleep on his own, but he’s still very little, so there’s still time to move on from this habit. Go through the routine and give a gentle but definite goodnight. If he cries give him a few minutes, pop back in, tuck him in again, another kiss, another goodnight. You’ll probably need to keep that up quite a few times the first few days. Never make him feel abandoned (I hate CIO) but nevertheless be definite that bedtime is bedtime. You can even say, Mummy and Daddy need to have their supper, talk, rest, whatever. A two year old is a proper person - you can’t reason with them, but you can introduce them to things that they will think about (Mummy and Daddy talk to each other without me? Mummy and Daddy get tired?). A two year old can begin to understand that other people have feelings and needs, and you should - very gently - begin to teach them that.

I have known children as old as 7 or 8 who still couldn’t go to sleep without a parent lying with them. I know that is extreme, but try to imagine how much more difficult it could be once this routine has become ingrained. How does it end?

Except for the CIO I am with your DH.

UnbeatenMum · 16/02/2023 21:48

Some children just don't settle well, I had one child I could easily leave and two I couldn't. Gradual retreat did work for us with DC2 though. It took months of sitting on the landing tbh but we got there. I'd never do CIO with a child of that age, he would be absolutely terrified.

ChildminderMum · 16/02/2023 21:46

Not necessarily 'too harsh' or 'too soft' just different parenting styles and preferences maybe.

I had my own children falling asleep alone by 12 months maybe and certainly wouldn't have been prepared to sit by a bed for 15+ minutes every night so I guess I am with your DH.

Circe7 · 16/02/2023 21:45

My 2 year old always fell asleep on his own and was perfectly fine with this until recently when he went into his own room. He now likes me to stay but finds my presence very distracting and only sleeps once I leave.

I’m happy to spend 30 mins or so with him reading and chatting as part of his bedtime routine but wouldn’t be patting for an hour while he tries to sleep. I’m a single parent with two children so it would be physically impossible to do that for both anyway and not a habit I’d want to get into.

VivaVivaa · 16/02/2023 21:42

Oof, DH or I sit with DS while he falls asleep but it takes 10-15 mins tops. While I agree with you that sitting with kids isn’t a bad thing, I couldn’t be dealing with 1 to 1.5h. I’d be looking at cutting down or stopping the nap, of making bedtime later, if you haven’t already.

Zanatdy · 16/02/2023 21:41

1.5hrs is excessive so if that was a regular thing then I’d be considering a different approach.

Swipe left for the next trending thread