Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think dp is too harsh on 2yr old?

233 replies

Whoissit · 16/02/2023 20:58

Please help me settle the never ending debate, sleep.

I'm perfectly fine with being told I'm the one being unreasonable but I really don't think I am.

Dp has become increasingly frustrated with dc, who is 2yrs 3months, not being able to fall asleep on his own. I keep telling him he has unrealistic expectations that aren't fair to put on dc given his age. That I remember my parents sitting with me reading a book, singing, or rubbing my head until I fell asleep in primary school. I'm getting annoyed at the constant arguments we are having about it because dp thinks dc should be able to lie down at night and just go to sleep on his own. I don't think it's unnatural for him to need soothing/comforting at night.

Once dc is asleep he may way once or twice, most the time he sleeps the whole night through.

Dp thinks I'm being too soft on him and wants to let him cry it out. I generally don't believe in doing that unless it's crucial, example being we are sleep deprived or he is. I think it's drastic measures and causes unnecessary stress to dc.

So who is being unreasonable here? It's our first child. Maybe 2 year olds all do just go to sleep on their own without a problem and I'm pandering....

OP posts:
Whenwilliberich · 18/02/2023 10:47

Whoissit · 16/02/2023 21:01

@Sirzy it can vary. Sometimes (although be it very rarely) he doesn't need us at all. On a good day 20/30 mins. On a bad day (which is the majority) it can be up to a hour or hr and a half.

If every time it’s an hour to an hour and a half, I’m with your husband - he needs to learn.

if it’s taking him that long - is he even tired enough? does he have a nap?? I’d be looking to cut the nap.

LaDamaDeElche · 18/02/2023 10:42

I put YABU, but after reading your further posts, I think your DP is definitely unreasonable. However, I don’t think at that age you should necessarily stay with them until they sleep - 1.5 hours is crazy and you’re making a rod for your own back. Children do need to learn to go to sleep alone, but they also need a bedtime routine with a story and time settling them. Not just in bed, close the door and bye. I think your and your DP need to agree on what is reasonable and make a routine that you follow each night. After you leave, perhaps leave download some stories and leave them playing or I used to use a children’s sleep CD for DD, which was like a meditation thing for kids. What you don’t want is to get into a habit with a child who won’t sleep, keeps getting up and where you end up with hours of your night taken up for years trying to get them to bed. There needs to be a balance and as parents you need to put the work in when they’re little to promote healthy sleep habits when they get a bit older.

Mummab3ar2 · 18/02/2023 10:38

Its definitely possible for a 2 year old to be able to go to sleep by themselves, but it's unreasonable to expect them to be able to do so without ever having been "taught" how to do so.

It seems as though you and your partner are on the complete opposite sides with your views. But there's definitely lots of middle ground in between, which I'm sure you could find a way that would suit both of you.

It does depend though, on whether you want them to be able to fall asleep by themselves, or if you like being there for them when they fall asleep, and are happy to continue it?

I would definitely say the cry it out method is too harsh for my liking though, there are plenty of other methods which are much kinder to your little one and yourself, but still are very effective.

KSJR · 18/02/2023 10:30

I feel like I’m in the minority. Evenings with my OH are really important for us and our relationship. When the kids are in bed it’s our time to watch films chat uninterrupted cuddle whatever. My kids have always done bath teeth story and sleep. Takes half an hour and then the night is ours. I have never sat with them till they sleep. My five year old now does bath teeth reads his school book and most of the time will give me a kiss and take himself off to bed. 🤷🏼‍♀️. No way would I be sitting for an hour and a half rubbing and patting even at 2 years old.

DangerousAlchemy · 18/02/2023 10:24

Rosebel · 16/02/2023 21:37

I never sat with any of mine. Bedtime story and cuddles absolutely but never sat with them until they slept.
Of course it's up to you but my BIL and SIL did this and still have to sit with their 11 year old as he's reliant on them for getting to sleep which is starting to impact on all their lives.
Maybe he's a minority but just to make you aware.

I'm with you here @Rosebel - I had a friend with an elaborate bedtime routine for her son - tons of stories & songs then she lay on the bed with him til he fell asleep etc - can't really expect grandparents or the odd babysitter to do this every night! What about sleepovers (they often begin around age 8) & what about holidays? Really don't understand anyone who wants to spend an hour sitting with their kid when they've already spent all day with them!

Grizzledstrawberry · 18/02/2023 10:24

I still lay with my 6yr old til he needs to fall asleep, if he wants/needs the comfort then why would i deny him of that, I want him to always feel loved and secure and I'm sure he will grow out of it one day, and I bet I'll miss it when he does so I'm thankful for now (even if sometimes it can be frustrating)

I've never understood why adults are allowed the comfort of sleeping next to their loved one but a small child who is reliant on their parents for everything aren't allowed the same, its madness. I'm also so against CIO, I honestly think its awful, fair enough if you need a few minutes to collect yourself but to leave them to cry for hours, to me is child abuse and I wouldn't allow it to happen to my child. So you are not been unreasonable.

GirlsAndPenguins · 18/02/2023 10:17

I have a 2 year old and a husband with similar views. I have to say though she does go to sleep quickly (he normally does bed time). There is no negotiation. We have a routine which involves EVERYONE having to brush their teeth together, playing spooky in the dark (daddy attacks her like a zombie, personally find it terrifying but she loves it) one story, kiss, hug, night night. Maybe 15 mins in total from going upstairs to leaving her. We did do some sleep training when she was younger. We did not leave her screaming for hours but wouldn’t go in the second we heard her, would give it 5 or so minutes. She always sleeps through, which tbf I think is just good luck.
If I’m doing bedtime (she knows I’m softer and easier to push) I may occasionally read a second book or let her select one of her Tonies to take to bed. Maybe you could consider a tonie box if you don’t have one?
So you read a story and then they choose one to listen to once you have left?
Just an idea 😊

amyds2104 · 18/02/2023 10:09

I sat there with my son when he was younger every night reading with him or cuddling him to sleep and at 9 he no longer wants me to do that so I treasure every evening with my daughter now because one day she won’t want me there either!

My hubby and I have different styles of parenting. I’m happy to sit there with my children at night while they go to sleep but he would rather view the evenings as his time to relax after work. Both things are fine in my eyes because the children arent missing out. Hubby can sometimes feel neglected when I fall asleep with the children but that’s more his issue and I’m not going to stop giving them the love and fuss so he can have his end away!

katepilar · 18/02/2023 09:34

Whoissit · 17/02/2023 14:51

@BiasedBinding I feel like the general consensus with it is that dad's are more hardy and mums are more soft/caring? I really don't know!

I think men in general are less able to read their childrens needs and also a lot of them deliberately but unconsciously dont recognise their needs because a/ thats what their parents did to them and b/ they happily put their needs above needs of their children.

89redballoons · 17/02/2023 22:48

Hatscats · 16/02/2023 22:43

My parents sat with me at bedtime for years, never let me cry myself to sleep, and guess what, I can fall asleep now as an adult and sleep all night. It’s almost like it doesn’t need to be taught 🙄

Same here. My dad used to tell me and my brother bedtime stories and stay with us until we fell asleep until I was at least 7 or 8 (brother 2 years younger). It's a really happy childhood memory for me and I can remember drifting off feeling safe and loved.

I now have a 3yo and a 10 month old. I rock the 10 month old til very sleepy and then put him down and stay singing to him til he's fast asleep. I then go and sing to the 3 year old as well until he falls asleep. Both normally sleep through for 10+ hours now. Sometimes the baby wakes a couple of times but hey that's babies. From going upstairs to them both being asleep can take 60/90 minutes but that's ok, they're adorable babies and it won't be forever.

Before he fully dropped his nap at 2 years 9 months my DS1 did sometimes not fall asleep until gone 9. Now it's gone he's always asleep by 7.45 latest.

OP, if your DH wants some childfree quality time with you why don't you suggest he cooks a lovely grownup meal while you're putting your little one down and then you can have a nice late-ish date night at home once she's asleep?

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 17/02/2023 22:13

SaySomethingMan · 17/02/2023 22:00

”she can cosleep if she wants”? Are you 12?
🤣🤣🤣🤣

Actually that’s doing tweens a disservice . Are you 5?

You sound very clever.

What's wrong with saying she can cosleep if she wants to? The pp is viewing that as a setback whereas I view that as giving her child comfort and closeness - as I imagine the OP does.

SaySomethingMan · 17/02/2023 22:00

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 17/02/2023 21:27

She can cosleep if she wants.
Your post was patronising. Comprehensive enough to know you're a knob.

”she can cosleep if she wants”? Are you 12?
🤣🤣🤣🤣

Actually that’s doing tweens a disservice . Are you 5?

You sound very clever.

FavouriteSlippers · 17/02/2023 21:37

We do teeth, book, cuddles, lights out door shut.

Always had a book and cuddle. Never and nor would i ever sit till they fall asleep im afraid.

prescribingmum · 17/02/2023 21:33

Sorry not RTFT, only OP’s posts but front that, it sounds like you’re at opposite ends of the spectrum.

It is definitely reasonable to have some sort of a bedtime routine - at 5 and 6yrs old, we still do bath, story, cuddles and sleep. But I think your husband is also reasonable in saying that spending more than 1 hour sitting in his room is too long if it is a regular occurrence.

You need to meet in the middle somewhere and it will take time to achieve if you want to minimise tears but I don’t think there’s anything unreasonable in him not wanting to spend so long putting him to bed. I do think he’s being unreasonable if he thinks he will go sleep with no wind down or adult input at all though

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 17/02/2023 21:27

TheBeautifulMoors · 17/02/2023 17:41

Maybe you should read my post again. Do you lack comprehension skills? The OP’s desire to reverse any little progress they’ve made and now co-sleep is what i’m referring to. Her husband’s choice of word. Also “it makes me wonder” if …🙄

She can cosleep if she wants.
Your post was patronising. Comprehensive enough to know you're a knob.

vanillamint · 17/02/2023 21:22

I would recommend starting to help him sleep alone.

I'm still settling my 4 year old dd to sleep for up to a hour and my 22 month old ds. I'm losing my tether and it's a rod I created off my own back.

I'm looking for solutions as I have to wean ds too off the breast.

I'm envious of my friends who just say good night and their children fall to sleep independently!

Watching for tips!

TheBeautifulMoors · 17/02/2023 17:41

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 17/02/2023 15:59

So just because the timeline if cosleeping doesn't match yours it turns into "pandering"?
Absolutely ridiculous.

Maybe you should read my post again. Do you lack comprehension skills? The OP’s desire to reverse any little progress they’ve made and now co-sleep is what i’m referring to. Her husband’s choice of word. Also “it makes me wonder” if …🙄

Favouritefruits · 17/02/2023 16:59

Nice warm bath
two stories
a little chat
kiss goodnight
pop back after five mins

Lcb123 · 17/02/2023 16:51

You're both right in some ways - at that age you can work towards falling asleep alone. Child needs to know you're around and available but I think you could try leaving him to sleep alone (but not cry loads).

ETref · 17/02/2023 16:46

Not a chance would I sit patting a 2yo for 1.5hrs until they fell asleep. OK yeah a 6month old on a difficult night but at age 2 there is no way. If my dh wanted to do that then I'd leave him to it. I'd be there for bath, stories, cuddles etc but then I'd leave him to crack on with pandering to the madness.

We've always done bath, teeth, stories, tuck them into bed, sing a lullaby/have a chat (depending on age), cuddles and kisses then leave the room. They both have the main light off, lamp on and the door closed. Ages 4 and 7 now and we never have any issues at bed time. I don't think we've had any issues at bedtime since they were babies.

musicalgymball · 17/02/2023 16:45

My baby's only one but I spend an average of 30-60 minutes a night settling and would keep doing this at two years old I'm sure, and that's after we've sleep trained him several months ago (not with cry it out though).

We sleep trained at seven months with a method of waiting 5 minutes of letting him cry a little initially before soothing then going and patting him to sleep. But if he's crying a lot he gets patted to sleep immediately or picked up and soothed. This worked to stop him waking constantly, but he does still need help getting to sleep initially. I no longer wait 5 minutes but go in after about 30 seconds to help him if he's crying.

I agree that it's a bit harsh not to go and help a two year old. They're only little and the emotional support of knowing mummy and daddy are coming in to help them must be very reassuring.

Like a pp said, the caveat would be that if the sleep deprivation is causing you issues due to how often you have to wake up to soothe him or how long you have to soothe him for, then I would consider more drastic measures.

PugInTheHouse · 17/02/2023 16:27

We would read a book/books to our DCs and ensure they were settled but my personal opinion is that you need to teach your child to be able to get to sleep themselves. I'm not necessarily talking about leaving them wide awake but a bit sleepy and not fast asleep. This will probably resolve the night waking also. I'm not saying about controlled crying at all, just gradually encourage them to settle alone.

A PP mentioned they sit with their 9 yo to get them to sleep. That definitely isn't part of being a parent, being a parent is teaching your children skills for life appropriate for their age. I don't know of anyone with children that age who still sit with them until they fall asleep.

Movingsoon21 · 17/02/2023 16:20

OP that’s far too long to be doing it most nights. This would drive me insane. You don’t need to do CIO. Maybe try the gradual retreat method instead? Our 5 month old learnt in 5 days with that method. I’m with your DH on this one I’m afraid. The current method isn’t working (and is robbing your son of an extra hour of sleep)

Totallyanonymousplease · 17/02/2023 16:18

Also agree 1.5 hours most nights is really quite excessive - from my experience I don't think it's normal for a child to need this to go to sleep - but it's not about what everyone else does, it's about if this is working for you as a family and sounds like it isn't.

At that age I think it's all about them knowing exactly what's happening and making them feel safe - are there ways you can make your DC feel safe that isnt sitting and patting for 1.5 hours? The ideas about "mummy will check on you in 1 minute is a good one. then check on you in 2 minutes, then in 3 etc...

maddiemookins16mum · 17/02/2023 16:17

90 mins is ridiculous. Here’s the thing, if someone was engaging (which is what you’re doing basically) with me for 90 mins every night, I sure as hell wouldn’t be dropping off to sleep. You could be doing this for years.