Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think dp is too harsh on 2yr old?

233 replies

Whoissit · 16/02/2023 20:58

Please help me settle the never ending debate, sleep.

I'm perfectly fine with being told I'm the one being unreasonable but I really don't think I am.

Dp has become increasingly frustrated with dc, who is 2yrs 3months, not being able to fall asleep on his own. I keep telling him he has unrealistic expectations that aren't fair to put on dc given his age. That I remember my parents sitting with me reading a book, singing, or rubbing my head until I fell asleep in primary school. I'm getting annoyed at the constant arguments we are having about it because dp thinks dc should be able to lie down at night and just go to sleep on his own. I don't think it's unnatural for him to need soothing/comforting at night.

Once dc is asleep he may way once or twice, most the time he sleeps the whole night through.

Dp thinks I'm being too soft on him and wants to let him cry it out. I generally don't believe in doing that unless it's crucial, example being we are sleep deprived or he is. I think it's drastic measures and causes unnecessary stress to dc.

So who is being unreasonable here? It's our first child. Maybe 2 year olds all do just go to sleep on their own without a problem and I'm pandering....

OP posts:
Lollipop81 · 19/02/2023 07:53

I still lie down with my 3 and 4 year old whilst they fall asleep. I like spending that time with them at the end of a busy day and enjoy been close to them. I know one day they won’t need me so I like to make the most of it whilst I can. I know some people would say I’m mad but I don’t care. Do what’s best for you and your child.

PugInTheHouse · 19/02/2023 05:44

KSJR · 18/02/2023 10:30

I feel like I’m in the minority. Evenings with my OH are really important for us and our relationship. When the kids are in bed it’s our time to watch films chat uninterrupted cuddle whatever. My kids have always done bath teeth story and sleep. Takes half an hour and then the night is ours. I have never sat with them till they sleep. My five year old now does bath teeth reads his school book and most of the time will give me a kiss and take himself off to bed. 🤷🏼‍♀️. No way would I be sitting for an hour and a half rubbing and patting even at 2 years old.

In real life this is normal IMO. I really don't know many people who sat for hours with their kids, the only one i can remember had kids who didnt sleep well as couldn't settle themselves if they stirred in the night and then were up at 5am as they couldn't lay in their beds alone at all, she was permanently exhausted. Self soothing/settling is a skill all children need IMO.

PugInTheHouse · 19/02/2023 05:39

Grizzledstrawberry · 18/02/2023 10:24

I still lay with my 6yr old til he needs to fall asleep, if he wants/needs the comfort then why would i deny him of that, I want him to always feel loved and secure and I'm sure he will grow out of it one day, and I bet I'll miss it when he does so I'm thankful for now (even if sometimes it can be frustrating)

I've never understood why adults are allowed the comfort of sleeping next to their loved one but a small child who is reliant on their parents for everything aren't allowed the same, its madness. I'm also so against CIO, I honestly think its awful, fair enough if you need a few minutes to collect yourself but to leave them to cry for hours, to me is child abuse and I wouldn't allow it to happen to my child. So you are not been unreasonable.

CIO isn't actually a method at all, controlled crying is leaving for a few minutes then going back in to settle them. Who leaves a child crying for hours? That sounds like something people have made up when someone has called controlled crying CIO to be honest.

I haven't seen any posts suggesting this at all though. There's a massive difference between laying with a child for 1.5 hrs or letting them cry for hours, both to me are crazy. Do you think someone who doesn't lay with their child till they are asleep doesn't make their child feel loved and secure? A child who feels loved and secure to me is one who knows a parent is there if they need them but also feels secure enough to go to sleep without someone laying with them the whole time.

FlyingPandas · 18/02/2023 22:17

OP YANBU in wanting to avoid cry-it-out methods but equally I do have sympathy for your DP. I have three DC and it would have driven me absolutely nuts to have to lie with them for hours on end at bedtime. Much as I love and adore them all. Story time and cuddle time was a nightly routine in our house and we still have nightly hugs and chats even though most of mine are teens now - but settling themselves to sleep was the norm right from the early days.

It's not unrealistic to want a toddler to be able to self-settle. But you can gently teach them how to do it, not leave them to scream. There are so many gentle sleep training methods - they require patience and consistency but they will work if you are persistent. We found a regular routine, stories, white noise, lullaby lights etc all worked really well. I would also try dropping the daytime nap if a toddler is taking ages to fall asleep - lots of DC need to drop a nap somewhere between 2 and 2.5.

Sleep threads always tend to bring out a few extremist 'you can ONLY raise secure children if you cuddle them to sleep every night and if you don't cuddle them to sleep every night THEN THEY WILL NOT KNOW THEY ARE LOVED AND YOU WILL HAVE FAILED AT PARENTING' posters. But you know what, it is absolutely possible enjoy spending time with your children, and to raise happy, confident, secure individuals who know that they are loved, WITHOUT needing to cuddle them to sleep every night.

Equally, of course, if you enjoy lying with your DC and cuddling them to sleep every night then that is absolutely fine. But your DP is not wrong to find it frustrating, either. It's not selfish to want free time in the evenings - it's healthy. There has got to be a balance between reassuring your toddler and having time to yourself. Martyrdom doesn't help anyone, least of all your child.

SaySomethingMan · 18/02/2023 21:43

Forgooodnesssakenow · 18/02/2023 19:56

If someone offers to look after ours they're doing the bedtime and staying with them or they don't babysit, which is fine. Generally it's people asking to have them not us doing the asking. 2 is very different to 8. It's weird to me people don't want to spend time with their children, the idea it's weird I'd want to is bonkers

You think parents “don’t want to spend time with their children” because they dont want to spend an hour and a half ‘putting them to bed’?

There are so many better opportunities to spend time together during the day

Matt007 · 18/02/2023 21:33

interesting post, didn’t realise so many parents choose to sit with children after bed time.

we don’t for all the reasons outlined by others, but I found it interesting all the reasons and I’m sure some of the older children will remember all that time and care when their teenagers and beyond.

Blueash · 18/02/2023 20:59

Unless you are being abusive your parenting is your business - I don't know if I would have your amount of patience. That said I was lucky in that mine went down easily.

Yesiamtiredactually · 18/02/2023 20:51

i can completely understand you not wanting to leave him to cry it out, have you tried something like a Tonie box? They do bedtime stories and white noise etc that don’t have any screens so can be really good for situations like yours? Also it could be challenging but maybe he’s getting ready to reduce his nap? We dropped the nap and moved bedtime forward with a very fixed routine (CBeebies bedtime hour, bed time episode of Blue Clues and then bed) and our 2 and a half year old really took to it!

Forgooodnesssakenow · 18/02/2023 19:56

DangerousAlchemy · 18/02/2023 10:24

I'm with you here @Rosebel - I had a friend with an elaborate bedtime routine for her son - tons of stories & songs then she lay on the bed with him til he fell asleep etc - can't really expect grandparents or the odd babysitter to do this every night! What about sleepovers (they often begin around age 8) & what about holidays? Really don't understand anyone who wants to spend an hour sitting with their kid when they've already spent all day with them!

If someone offers to look after ours they're doing the bedtime and staying with them or they don't babysit, which is fine. Generally it's people asking to have them not us doing the asking. 2 is very different to 8. It's weird to me people don't want to spend time with their children, the idea it's weird I'd want to is bonkers

Newuser82 · 18/02/2023 18:44

Purplepepsi · 16/02/2023 21:04

I'm not sure if it helps but we still sit with our 9 year old till he's asleep and I know a fair few other parents who still do, at least on occasion! Yes it is frustrating but it's parenting!

I'm sorry but I'm really surprised at this. I don't know anyone who still sits with their nine year old.

madamovaries · 18/02/2023 18:43

Drfosters · 18/02/2023 15:40

The one thing you realise once your kids are older is that all these things when they were toddlers are utterly silly things to worry about because they all grow up to be fully functional numbers of society who can go to bed on their own and eat normal foods. I used to spend hours stroking my son to sleep. He didn’t sleep through until the age of 7 (well I don’t think he sleeps through now tbh but he can sort himself out). He used to get into bed with us every night. At one point when he was a bit younger we had his cot at the bottom of the bed and I’d sleep with my head at the bottom of the bed with my hand on his belly. But now he’s a teenager he puts himself to bed and gets up for school without me having to get him up. Swings and roundabouts. Stop worrying about it- it will pass. Definitely not something abnormal but exhausting whilst you are going through it.

This is so lovely and wise! Thank you for saying that from another Mum worrying about the same thing x

BridieConvert · 18/02/2023 18:28

DD is 2y 9m. She was a nightmare at bedtime to get to sleep until she stopped sleeping during the day (around 4 months ago maybe).
Now she gets an agreed 3 stories then gets left to go to sleep

macaronicheese123 · 18/02/2023 18:12

My child is 20 months self soothes and doesn’t need help. we put him to bed and leave the room and he goes to sleep on his own but i know that’s very rare. i don’t know what ‘right’ and what isn’t, but i know if i had a two year old that didn’t i would sleep train. so i’m with DH. you need and deserve sleep and rest OP!

Jafferz · 18/02/2023 17:44

YANBU. DS is exactly the same age as yours and identical in terms of falling asleep. Needs myself or DP to stay with him until he's asleep then usually sleeps through but sometimes wakes once or twice especially if teething or unwell. I mean of course it would be ideal if we could say goodnight and close the door but in the grand scheme of things I think this is an okay situation. We all get enough sleep - most of the time. Plenty of two year olds don't sleep through even some of the time.

Drfosters · 18/02/2023 15:40

The one thing you realise once your kids are older is that all these things when they were toddlers are utterly silly things to worry about because they all grow up to be fully functional numbers of society who can go to bed on their own and eat normal foods. I used to spend hours stroking my son to sleep. He didn’t sleep through until the age of 7 (well I don’t think he sleeps through now tbh but he can sort himself out). He used to get into bed with us every night. At one point when he was a bit younger we had his cot at the bottom of the bed and I’d sleep with my head at the bottom of the bed with my hand on his belly. But now he’s a teenager he puts himself to bed and gets up for school without me having to get him up. Swings and roundabouts. Stop worrying about it- it will pass. Definitely not something abnormal but exhausting whilst you are going through it.

Lifeisapeach · 18/02/2023 14:59

I wouldn’t have the patience to sit for long plus I had other younger siblings to tend to. So my kids got a clear routine, bath book bed sleep. And I would leave the door ajar and they would drift off alone within ten mins. Not everyone works like this though and I know people who sat with their kids but it had to stop when other siblings arrived

madamovaries · 18/02/2023 14:47

I'm 100% on your side. Have a son almost exactly same age (tiny bit younger) and we're still lying with him at night to get him down. Luckily my husband does it most nights now as I did it for the first 20 months as I was breast-feeding him to sleep.

You're doing better than us, in that most nights he wakes up once and ends up in our bed (but he does go straight back to sleep there, so I think he's just craving the comfort of knowing we're there).

UsingChangeofName · 18/02/2023 14:43

Mummab3ar2 · 18/02/2023 10:38

Its definitely possible for a 2 year old to be able to go to sleep by themselves, but it's unreasonable to expect them to be able to do so without ever having been "taught" how to do so.

It seems as though you and your partner are on the complete opposite sides with your views. But there's definitely lots of middle ground in between, which I'm sure you could find a way that would suit both of you.

It does depend though, on whether you want them to be able to fall asleep by themselves, or if you like being there for them when they fall asleep, and are happy to continue it?

I would definitely say the cry it out method is too harsh for my liking though, there are plenty of other methods which are much kinder to your little one and yourself, but still are very effective.

This.

I am definitely in the camp of teaching them to go to sleep on their own.
Am quite surprised how many people think it normal to sit or lie with their child until they go to sleep.
To me that sounds pretty unrealistic, or at least a habit I am glad we never go in to.
What do you plan to do when the next child comes along ?
Or even if you want to go out for the evening?
Or you have other things you need to do?

Imisssleep2 · 18/02/2023 14:39

At night, my son (who is 2 years 5 months) has a bath, gets his PJ's on has a story and milk then we have a cuddle and i put him to bed fully awake, he goes to sleep on his own no issues at all and this has been the case since he was about 8 months old possibly earlier. Some times he goes straight to sleep, sometimes he chats or sings for anything up to 30 mins before drifting off.

Controversially or not we used the Ferber method to teach him to get to sleep on his own, it took 3 nights to get to the stage of no crying at all and i dont regret it, at the time we were at our wits end and seriously sleep deprived something had to give. The ferber method i have read is more effective and quicker the younger they are once 2/3 years old they have more stamina to keep going longer so may take a few more days to achieve results.

TeenLifeMum · 18/02/2023 13:54

My dc are 11-15 and looking back with hindsight I’m so glad I cuddled my dc to sleep when little and even occasionally now when sad they ask for mummy cuddles (including the 15 yo). Sleep is when we’re vulnerable so you are your dc safe person.

Pinkfrogs45 · 18/02/2023 13:45

I’m with your DH. Cuddles, stories most definitely but I wouldn’t be sitting next to me child for 1-1.5hr waiting for them to fall asleep. My DC have lots of stories and talking time but then they are left to fall asleep if they haven’t fallen asleep already.

i do extra work in the evenings, go for a run or do a quick clean. It works for us but if your happy sitting for that time with your kids then it’s not an issue. If your DH wants to spend more time together on a evening you may need to compromise

Xol · 18/02/2023 12:45

I used to really value my time sitting and reading a bedtime story to my children when they were little. But I do think taking 60-90 minutes over the process is a bit mad. Are you trying to get your child to bed too early for him?

Nosleepforthismum · 18/02/2023 12:13

I think you have the patience of a saint to be patting/soothing your DC for an hour and a half most nights. I don’t think your DP is right by shutting the door and letting him scream but some middle ground should be able to be found. I think it’s an important skill to fall asleep without your parents input so I think the goal should be creating a calm and solid bedtime routine and work on leaving your DC for short amounts of time on his own to try and settle by himself. My DS is younger at 18 months but once he’s in bed, it’s a kiss goodnight and teddy tucked in next to him and we leave straight away. We occasionally have a minute of crying when we initially leave but after that we can usually hear him chatting away to his teddy before falling asleep. However, he’s always been quite chilled so it’s certainly not our parenting skills but I think you do deserve to have your evenings back a little!

FamilyLife2point4 · 18/02/2023 12:01

To be fair I see both points:
dc do need soothing / reading to etc and their far too young to understand.
1-1.5 hours is excessive imo - if it was 20-30mins I’d say yeah that’s grand to continue.

With DC at similar age, I did CC but only for short periods. Eg: spend the 30mins reading & cuddling, put down and explain that’s enough. Leave room for 5-10mins, if still crying, go in, place hand on them to reassure (no picking up, no speaking) leave and repeat until sleeping.
I did this for no more than a week till DC effectively learned this is what it would take.
it didn’t stop the waking through the night - we repeated the CC method (no speaking, no picking up) until they knew we’d always be there too soothe, but it’s sleep time.
Grow clock as DC got older really helped early morning rises too.

I had to do this as due to childcare I needed to work 1-2 hrs per evening and couldn’t do this with DC wanting that time for ‘bed time’ from me (DH just would not do) as I’d be up till after midnight working and exhausted next day

Soakitup37 · 18/02/2023 10:54

My ds needed settling till he was school age, I still sometimes tuck him in now (8) and always check on him.

I used have to lay with him and fake sleep till
he did. It’s a common and acceptable thing to do with a toddler, your dp is being unreasonable!