Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where all those who said that WFH would be good for business are now?

489 replies

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:38

Sorry, sort of a rant.
I work in a small local foodie business in the South West. I know there is a cost of living crisis, but I also feel that WFH culture is killing us.
So many said that they would spend more in their local high streets now they were WFH but that seems to have stopped.
People are online food shopping and then not leaving their houses. Three local businesses announced they were closing this week, two bakeries and one restaurant. I can count five since Christmas which have folded.
I know a lot are feeling the pinch from gas and electric but a lot of people are just WFH, squirrelling their money away, saving and then saying 'oh that's a shame' on the Facebook posts when a business announces they're folding. Why not support them? I'm not talking about those on the breadline but those who are financially comfortable.
If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

OP posts:
coffeecookie · 17/02/2023 06:56

If I do go out for something to eat or a coffee I always go to a local independent and will always shop in the independent shops if they stock what I need.

My issue is that I just can't afford to do it as often as I did. We are not on the breadline, we make good money between us but the cost of living has curtailed is immensely and actually DP being able to WFH most of the time saves a fortune in train fare etc yet still we can't go out that much.

Bellalalala · 17/02/2023 06:54

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:35

Ok so as a real example, in 2020/2021 plenty of people moved to our neck of the woods as they could now WFH forever. They were used to paying London prices and now were buying £60-£100 worth of groceries per week, enjoying their new disposable income and having a three bed for the price of a one bed in London.
They used to go on about the high street, how lovely it was, how unique and how all the indies made the area for them. They presumably still have the same jobs, they still pay the same rent or mortgage, but they've stopped coming, not just to us but to all the indie shops. So they will probably lose the one thing that made them love the area in the first place.
So yes you can call it a 'saving' buying a plastic cup of Starbucks from the fridge in Tesco but you cannot then moan that you're house price has gone down or that there is no local high street when things pick back up again for you.
Yes there will be those who are on the bones of their arse right now, as am I. But not all are, some are just being tight.

So you didn’t benefit from commuters pre covid. Because you are somewhere people moved to once they didn’t need to commute.

Your problem is people moving into the area and not spending money where you want them to.

You are in a foodie business. But not a cafe. So not something people come in and buy daily. And your analogy of Gio is completely irrelevant. Because Gio maybe running a business where people go in and spend time everyday.

CoL is impacting everyone. And people cut back on anything that they can. Even in our office, less people are buying from the local businesses that have food vans that come round. Because people don’t need to spend £6 on a sandwich and drink. If there’s a cheaper alternative, people will look to do or buy that. But you are convinced it’s wfh. Even though people going into an office wouldn’t benefit you.

You didn’t have these people as potential customers before the pandemic and they are choosing not you use you now.

Small businesses owners, have to understand that if people aren’t using them they need to look at their business model. There constant small shifts in culture and peoples spending habits. To have a successful small business you have to be constantly making small shifts in your business. And you need to at least look at the possibility that, if people aren’t using you, the problem is the business.

There’s a takeaway near us, that’s closing. The problem is that anytime anyone orders, the women who answers is rude and food can take anything from half an hour to 2.5 hours. If you call to chase your order the woman is awful. So lots of local people won’t use them. But the owners complain about people not liking good food, not supporting small business etc. People are supporting other small businesses just not theirs.

I do get, from your posts, a hint of the attitude that ‘outsiders’ have moved in and you feel they have to prove themselves. My friend lives in a village where people still mention she isn’t really from that village. She moved there before she was 2 and she is now 32. I feel there’s a lot of that in your post. These people have come from somewhere, where things are more expensive. So you feel they owe you in some way.

people can also support small business online. I am mixed race and use silk caps to cover my hair to sleep. No one near here makes them. I don’t want to buy mass produced ones. So I found a small business owned by a woman who had makes her silk/satin bonnets and order them from her, but it’s online. I use another small business for my hair oil, again online. I bought a piece of jewellery for my dds 18th. Again, the small jewellers in my town, are all still selling very old fashioned jewellery. Not vintage just things like rings that say ‘Mum’ on that were all the rage in 80s/90s. I would definitely use them for cleaning and repair, not buy from. So I bought from a small business, online.

These online businesses have the products I want. They are small businesses. The businesses locally, don’t meet my needs. That’s why I don’t buy from them.

Goodread1 · 17/02/2023 06:51

@ Hi Op

Why don't you diversity in some way, Like have a trial experiment, to see how effective this will be in various ways then?

why don't you sell some of your food online too as delivery service, or look at doing catering for events locally ect

RedRiverShore3 · 17/02/2023 06:46

OP obviously doesn't live in an average town, they don't have diverse high streets, they have a few pound shop type places, estate agents, barbers and nail bars and a Costa if you are lucky.

Ladyofthesea · 17/02/2023 06:42

If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

I feel that there are too many food options on the high street so I'm happy for some to fold.

RedRiverShore3 · 17/02/2023 06:37

If most people don't use these places anyway as OP says they don't, they are not going to miss them when they are gone. The sooner the high street goes the better as in most towns they are scruffy boarded up areas that just need to disappear and be used as housing rather than building on fields.

RachelSq · 17/02/2023 06:36

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:51

I suppose all I see is the advantage for those who work from home and the disadvantage for those who work out of the home.
We have to work in businesses which are struggling, pay childcare, pay travel costs and pay all the utility bills that are increasing. Those who get to work from home save on all of those, but also can't be bothered to spend money on their high streets. They don't seem to see the link between the comment 'oh no that lovely cafe has shut down' and their lack of support.

I get you’re frustrated but your attitude to people stinks.

I worked out of an office for 10 years and didn’t eat out for lunch more than a dozen times (despite my colleagues doing so daily).

When I switched to WFH I buy a coffee daily from an independent coffee shop when I’m on my “I need to get out the house” walk. I’ve done that until recently, when the cost is just making it not quite as doable every single day.

I felt awkward going in after missing days, but after an initial query from the owners they accepted my answer of costs (actually offered me free coffee if I needed it, which I declined) and we continued at a 2/3 times a week visits.

From your tone, your an entitled business owner who would rather berate someone go not being able to afford coming in daily anymore, rather than accepting they can come in sometimes, and make them feel unwelcome. Certainly I’d choose never to go to your establishment if I knew how much you blamed other people for choices that they’re entitled to make.

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 17/02/2023 06:30

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:12

@Nancydrawn thanks for getting it. I'm trying to listen but it feels like people want to have their cake and eat it too (if you'll pardon the pun). If people want to have high streets with independent businesses, their own identity, employers who pay a living wage then you have to support it. If WFH is saving you £££ on childcare and commuting then I feel you have some sort of obligation to share that wealth rather than just support Amazon or Tesco or whoever.

This is just nuts.

I share my 'wealth', such as it is, through taxation and charity. Not paying a premium for food I don't want or need.

And on days I don't WFH, I take my lunch, because I don't want to pay a premium for food in the city either. I can't afford to.

RedRiverShore3 · 17/02/2023 06:18

Not everyone saves by WFH, I had a nice part time job just over a mile from my house that I retired from because I hated WFH, if I had stayed there I would have lost a room in my house to work and had to have had my heating on more, just for work, definitely no costs saved on commute as I often walked.

BanningTheWordNaice · 17/02/2023 06:18

I’m still supporting local businesses over chains as I always have done. I just make a lot fewer mediocre purchases. If I eat out now it has to be really good, better than I can cook at home. Whereas previously I’d have purchased something a bit “meh”, now I won’t. Maybe it’s your product not people WFH? 🤷‍♀️

ItWillWash · 17/02/2023 06:02

I would really use a bread and milk delivery, a vegetable box delivery and healthy home delivery takeaway options. But I've no idea if those would make you any money either.

My friend has just opened a "healthy" takeaway and she said it's doing really well. They're on Uber and Just Eat. She does the staples that people want to eat but healthier eg smashed burgers made with lean minced beef and grilled instead of fried, served with crispy sweet potato fries and salad. "Tacos" in lettuce wraps instead of tortillas for people doing low carb are really popular she tells me.

Her stuff is relatively expensive for the area (she charges £12 for burger, fries and side salad, and the local pizza places charge £4/5 for a rubbery frozen burger and chips), so it proves people can still afford the occasional luxury if it is something they want. OP needs to find a gap in her local market and fill it like my friend did her takeaway and my butcher with his raw dog food delivery.

Anycrispsleft · 17/02/2023 05:54

I'm fortunate enough to have a well paid job and I don't need to cut down on things like cafe visits. But I work 50 hours a week so all those lovely cute cafes and bakeries are long shut before I get finished. I live in a place where you can't get your shopping delivered so I go to the supermarket once a week and if I forget anything that's it, we're not eating that this week.
I would really use a bread and milk delivery, a vegetable box delivery and healthy home delivery take away options. But I've no idea if those would make you any money either.

illiterato · 17/02/2023 05:52

One thing that I think hasn’t been fully considered ( came up on another thread and I thought it was interesting) is how wfh impacts how attractive certain jobs are vs other jobs at similar qualification/ salary levels. So ability to wfh in office jobs might increase labour shortages in already hard to recruit for sectors which cannot be done wfh. Of course there will always be people who don’t want a wfh job but often what you want plays second fiddle to what you can afford/ logistically manage. Ie you really want to be a teacher/ nurse but being an accountant is easier as you can wfh.

Simonjt · 17/02/2023 05:45

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:51

I suppose all I see is the advantage for those who work from home and the disadvantage for those who work out of the home.
We have to work in businesses which are struggling, pay childcare, pay travel costs and pay all the utility bills that are increasing. Those who get to work from home save on all of those, but also can't be bothered to spend money on their high streets. They don't seem to see the link between the comment 'oh no that lovely cafe has shut down' and their lack of support.

We work from home, since working from home we have reduced our childcare bill by £0, travel by £0, like others who work from home our utilities have increased as we’re now at home in the day, so using much more electricity, where as previously nothing was being used during the working day (beyond things like fridge freezer etc).

ItWillWash · 17/02/2023 05:40

I'm not rich by any stretch of the imagination. I'm relatively comfortable but nowhere rich. I rent and will probably never own a house but I do have a small amount of money left after essentials.

I wouldn't dream of buying hand-churned butter or fancy cheese with my normal grocery shop but every month when buying dog food? It doesn't feel like a massive stretch as it's an extra £6-10 on top of an essential cost of £50ish.

I wouldn't go looking for hand-churned butter or spicy cheese but if it's sold alongside something I need to buy...

Userusing1 · 17/02/2023 05:27

I doubt many people will be buying hand churned butter and artisan cheese if they can't afford to turn the heating on much.

JunkinDonuts · 17/02/2023 05:18

I've always been tight with money, even though I have a really good income.
I refuse point blank to pay out for coffee when I'm out and about.
Nor do I use bakeries etc.
I haven't set foot in my local town for over a decade. The last time I went it was full of charity shops and junkies. No thanks.
I do all my shopping online.
I'm the type that the op hates.
If you don't understand that there's a CoL going on, whether people WFH or not, then maybe you should shut up shop op, people aren't going to throw money over your counter when they're struggling to pay their bills.

FakingMemories · 17/02/2023 05:03

Business have to evolve to survive. Many industries died as society made new inventions and discoveries. Blacksmiths, carters, millers, etc have decreased in number considerably. Do you feel the same level of sadness that we no longer need people to drive horses and carts or to copy books by hand and so they lost their jobs?

ItWillWash · 17/02/2023 04:48

I don't think OP works in a cafe. She said food-related retail. She's mentioned meat and flour so I'm thinking fancy, free-range butchers, in which case her business can definitely survive in todays culture of online shopping.

We have a few local butchers who deliver locally. They usually have certain dates assigned to each area eg they'll visit my town every second wednesday and go to another every second friday etc.

They sell hand-churned butter, artisan cheese, homemade chutneys, jams and preserves, a small amount of seasonal fruit and veg and meat, obviously. Most importantly to me, they sell raw dog food and meaty bones. I order from there regularly. I know their meat hampers are very popular as is their bulk-buy chicken breast trays. I mostly buy dog food but I can never resist adding a few of their butters and cheeses to my order.

Another local butcher started making pies and hot and cold sandwiches and added themselves to Uber and JustEat. If I'm having a day off healthy eating I order a couple of their lamb and cheese pies and a slice of quiche for lunch and dinner.

Raw dog food is growing in popularity so if OP's business could expand into this market it would definitely help. If she has access to a mincer all she needs to mince up off cuts, mix it with bone and a small amount of veg. I buy 80/10/10 which 80% meat, 10% bone, 10% offal and I mix in my own but OP could think about selling a mix of frozen fruit and veg cubes to mix into it.

Lucylock · 17/02/2023 04:33

Lots of people WAH where I live. The local cafes are very busy. Maybe your business I

Dunnoburt · 17/02/2023 03:40

I've saved on childcare because I don't have the 2 hourly commute each day, which means I don't have to pay for pre and post school childcare. I do not work with my child at home.

leithreas · 17/02/2023 01:02

Lots of 'eateries' of various different types from cafes to really upmarket restaurants have closed in my nearest city. Every one has blamed the rise the utilities and food prices coupled with staff shortages. I really don't think people wfh is having as big an effect as you think. My dh worked from home for 2 years(I always did) and even now he is back hybrid working he still doesn't eat out, its too difficult to justify the cost at the moment.

Changechangechanging · 17/02/2023 00:57

Non-essentials are the first to go in a crisis. Interest rates and utility costs mean even the relatively well-off are feeling the pinch. You don’t buy coffee when you can make it yourself. Nor do you eat out as often. I am not sure what you expected would happen?

AzureOrchid · 17/02/2023 00:57

OutofEverything · 17/02/2023 00:55

You can have a separate workspace and still have family life in the background.
And in open plan offices and call centres you have noise in the background.

Call centre background noise is acceptable
Anything else - no

OutofEverything · 17/02/2023 00:55

You can have a separate workspace and still have family life in the background.
And in open plan offices and call centres you have noise in the background.

Swipe left for the next trending thread