Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where all those who said that WFH would be good for business are now?

489 replies

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:38

Sorry, sort of a rant.
I work in a small local foodie business in the South West. I know there is a cost of living crisis, but I also feel that WFH culture is killing us.
So many said that they would spend more in their local high streets now they were WFH but that seems to have stopped.
People are online food shopping and then not leaving their houses. Three local businesses announced they were closing this week, two bakeries and one restaurant. I can count five since Christmas which have folded.
I know a lot are feeling the pinch from gas and electric but a lot of people are just WFH, squirrelling their money away, saving and then saying 'oh that's a shame' on the Facebook posts when a business announces they're folding. Why not support them? I'm not talking about those on the breadline but those who are financially comfortable.
If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

OP posts:
ConfusedNT · 17/02/2023 13:05

ChampagnePuppy · 17/02/2023 12:34

@Salzburggirl I don't think it's progression to be honest. I think it's a step towards automation, uniformity and ultimately government control. We will look back at the days of towns having different identities, small businesses where shop owners are able to make decisions rather than being ruled by visa or Uber, being able to look at physical items and feel the material quality etc and when 16 year olds could have flexibility during exam periods rather than having a zero hour contract with a minimum shift of 12 hours and think why did we let ourselves sleepwalk into this?

I'm confused, is it people working from home causing the problem or government control? 🤔

Swiftswatch · 17/02/2023 13:02

ChampagnePuppy · 17/02/2023 12:34

@Salzburggirl I don't think it's progression to be honest. I think it's a step towards automation, uniformity and ultimately government control. We will look back at the days of towns having different identities, small businesses where shop owners are able to make decisions rather than being ruled by visa or Uber, being able to look at physical items and feel the material quality etc and when 16 year olds could have flexibility during exam periods rather than having a zero hour contract with a minimum shift of 12 hours and think why did we let ourselves sleepwalk into this?

Here’s an idea OP, run a business that actually offers your customers something.
You have to be good at something, either it’s excellent food, a great atmosphere or a great location. You can’t just sit back and demand that people spend money in shitty cafes because they don’t pay as much for their commute.
They have to earn their money so they can spend it how they choose.
You have to earn yours so make it work.
If your business plan isn’t good enough then ultimately tough luck. That’s no one else’s fault.
Seeing you bang on shot government control just makes me realise why people don’t want to support you.

It reminds me of my local area, it was pedestrianised and some businesses kicked up a massive fuss. Others pushed themselves to grow and change and they are not thriving. Those that arranged protests against the pollution measures brought in place showed people who they are and they aren’t thriving as much.

Bellalalala · 17/02/2023 12:57

ChampagnePuppy · 17/02/2023 12:34

@Salzburggirl I don't think it's progression to be honest. I think it's a step towards automation, uniformity and ultimately government control. We will look back at the days of towns having different identities, small businesses where shop owners are able to make decisions rather than being ruled by visa or Uber, being able to look at physical items and feel the material quality etc and when 16 year olds could have flexibility during exam periods rather than having a zero hour contract with a minimum shift of 12 hours and think why did we let ourselves sleepwalk into this?

Honestly, you sounds a little disturbed.

I am 40. I didn’t get flexibility at 16 for exams in my job. Neither did your friends.

People don’t want to shop in your business for a reason. And it’s not government control or wfh. Especially, since you didn’t rely on commuters before the pandemic, it’s definitely not wfh.

A huge part, of why people aren’t shopping in your business, is down to the business itself. Small businesses are only ever success if they change with the times. A small business that remains stagnant. Even when it’s clear it’s not working, will go under.

lieselotte · 17/02/2023 12:54

It's interesting about Salzburg because I thought the "death of the High St" was a UK (maybe even GB as Belfast seemed to have loads of shops and few empty units when I was there) thing. I went to Duesseldorf before Christmas and there are thousands of shops - it just seems to go on and on. And a friend lives in a town with around the same size population as mine in northern Germany and it has loads more shops as well.

Also interested in the experience in Scotland - I never quite understand the thing about independent shops as your experience is exactly the same as mine - they have capricious opening hours and often behave as if they are doing you a favour. Their returns policies are often not very customer friendly either. People say oh well you're keeping a local business alive, yes but if I shop in Sainsburys it's staffed by local people who spend locally too.

I also think it's odd how so many cafes and the like don't open on bank holiday Mondays or similar when you'd think there'd be loads of trade.

MaggieFS · 17/02/2023 12:53

The thing is, we can hark back to the 'good old days' but for shopping, were they? I'll accept perhaps for some items they were, but for most things, if you worked M-F the ONLY option was to head to a high street on a Saturday, possibly pay over the odds for parking, muscle past everyone else also doing their shopping and then head home exhausted. Wouldn't be my choice of how to spend a weekend.

OR you were a housewife who didn't work because you could afford to raise a family on your husband's income alone, but that's a whole different thread Grin

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/02/2023 12:46

ChampagnePuppy · 17/02/2023 12:34

@Salzburggirl I don't think it's progression to be honest. I think it's a step towards automation, uniformity and ultimately government control. We will look back at the days of towns having different identities, small businesses where shop owners are able to make decisions rather than being ruled by visa or Uber, being able to look at physical items and feel the material quality etc and when 16 year olds could have flexibility during exam periods rather than having a zero hour contract with a minimum shift of 12 hours and think why did we let ourselves sleepwalk into this?

I don’t think it is anything at all to do with government control😂it’s to do with convenience.

As a secondary school teacher, no 16 year olds have ever had flexibility during exam period. That would defeat the object.

And ultimately with a different government l think zero hours contracts will go.

ChampagnePuppy · 17/02/2023 12:34

@Salzburggirl I don't think it's progression to be honest. I think it's a step towards automation, uniformity and ultimately government control. We will look back at the days of towns having different identities, small businesses where shop owners are able to make decisions rather than being ruled by visa or Uber, being able to look at physical items and feel the material quality etc and when 16 year olds could have flexibility during exam periods rather than having a zero hour contract with a minimum shift of 12 hours and think why did we let ourselves sleepwalk into this?

OP posts:
Salzburggirl · 17/02/2023 12:16

I live near Salzburg and I'm a musician.
Salzburg is a city of music with several professional orchestras and a world-renowned conservatoire. The place is heaving with musicians and students from all over the world.

Even here the only sheet-music shop in the city isn't viable. There was uproar about 3 years ago as it had to close with various petitions going on to keep it open. Basically it wasn't bringing enough money in to survive after paying the rent. It has now moved to a very small premises in the "Kunstquartier", has hardly any music in the shop to buy and is basically a place where people can go in, browse what little sheet music there is and then place an order with them for their online shop if they can't find the music they want.

When I first came here ca. 15 years ago I used to get the bus into the city, call in to the music shop and browse, maybe buy something (though the prices were extortionate even then), wander around for a bit, go to a nice cafe, attend to whatever business I had in the city and then get the bus home.

But it's all changed, and long before WFH and the pandemic and CoL. Why go into a music shop when you can sit at home and order any music online from the comfort of the sofa to have it delivered in a couple of days? I didn't have the time to go in to the shop to see if they had something (which they usually didn't) and then have to order it and then go back in again to pick it up 10 days later when it eventually arrived. The shop itself has expanded its online business too.

The online model has taken over and yes it's a shame but there's nothing you can do to stop it. I can send my students a link to a book to purchase and they can order it online easily (I do try to send them a couple of links to two different online shops, smaller retailers where possible). Similarly, my teacher just sends me links - just a couple of clicks from his WhatsApp message and the book is on the way, usually arriving in 2 or 3 days. I'm very busy too and I can order online at any time of the day or night, taking just a few minutes, instead of having to plan in a long trip into the city.

As a student I used to shop at Banks music in York - back in the 90s they had everything under the sun in stock, in cardboard boxes, and I ended up spending a fortune on stuff from there. But their selection gradually dwindled and they moved a lot online and are part of the musicroom. com family now.

Things have changed and businesses have to adapt to survive and if a sheet music shop can't survive in Salzburg that really shows how far things have progressed.

1stTimeBoyMumx · 17/02/2023 12:08

Wow wish we knew the name of this foodie place so we could boycott. It’s absolutely none of your business where people spend there money! Why would someone pay £4.50 for a coffee when it’s £2.50 in a supermarket cafe in the middle of a cost of living crisis it’s not doable! Other than convenience I didn’t save a penny working from home, if anything it’s more costly because your using more gas and electric which in case your not aware costs an absolute fortune at the moment! Food shops increased dramatically in price! Whereas an an example we may have had £500 disposable income this time 12 months ago we may only have £100 which results in people cutting down on luxuries and they have absolutely no obligation to spend it in your clearly overpriced trampy foodie place. You are living on another planet.

flowerycurtain · 17/02/2023 11:28

Interesting thread.

I do think the OP has a bit of a point about choices - everyone is happy with cheap and cheerful until it means building
A massive Amazon warehouse in their locality or a broiler unit pops up. I also think there are implications for us as a society. I genuinely don't think Ubering yourself a pastry and a coffee is great for anyone's mental health let along the environment.

However, I'm on my holidays in a Scottish border town. Went for a mooch about after breakfast looking at the shops thinking about this thread. They were all open from 10.30 - it's half term and the local big hotel is heaving so why not work an extra hour and catch some trade. At 9.58 I saw the jewellers open their door to a lady waiting and barking "we open at 10 don't you know". It really wasn't the lovely local experience you'd imagine it to be.

There was an independent clothes shop where they opened at 9 and had a friendly lady. £100 and a 2 dresses later that shopkeeper has had a good morning.

SleeplessInEngland · 17/02/2023 11:25

DrMarciaFieldstone · 17/02/2023 07:55

Parking has killed off our local high street. They’ve taken away most of the spaces on the high street, in favour of two car parks at the back of town. Nobody wants to pay and walk (and carry heavy shopping) when they can nip to the retail park for free in half the time.

Yeah, I'm sure it was lack of parking and not... the giant boom in online shopping.

LimeCheesecake · 17/02/2023 11:22

@ChampagnePuppy - do you think perhaps you are guilty of assuming the immediate changes while covid restrictions were still in place, would be permanent?

you are in an area that benefitted for a temporary period from ex commuters moving to the area, having low living costs (so more disposable income), and at the same time, limits on what they could spend their disposable income on- they couldn’t go on far flung holidays, it was hard to get building materials so house renovations had to wait, nights out were limited to meals or drinks in local restaurants with only small groups of people. Theatre, gigs, not an option. So why not spend your money in that nice local cafe for lunch? Not like you could do a big night out instead. feel nervous about going into the big shopping mall fearing you’ll catch covid? Go to the relatively overpriced local boutique instead.

these were temporary changes and it’s not surprising when there is more to do than walk to the local high street and buy an overpriced cake, people do different things with their now limited money.

Cornishsausageroll · 17/02/2023 11:19

OP won't come back because this thread has been discussed in our local City FB group. And everyone says the same. That's she's a bit deluded and probably scared off her customers 😂

PandasAreUseless · 17/02/2023 10:51

I'll also add, DH and I have shifted to spending money on our home and garden, rather than on food and drink.
We no longer support the pubs and cafes like we used to. But we are supporting the local independent garden centre, double glazing company and timber yard!
We went for a basic Chinese meal out the other week and it was £75! The experience was a bit crap and over in 90 mins. For just 12 times that cost, I'm just about to buy a solid oak, double door larder cupboard for our kitchen, which we'll own for the rest of our lives.
We've also just bought a coffee machine for £400. It arrives today. I had a coffee at Costa this morning - the place was filthy (at opening time!) and the lady serving was so stretched, she practically threw my coffee into the cup and spilt it all over the handle. So with our new machine, I won't bother going again.
We're becoming more and more self sufficient and I'm afraid I won't compromise that to keep someone in a job.
I work for a corporate law firm and revenues are down 30% compared to last year. I don't see anyone worried about my job!

Lochroy · 17/02/2023 10:04

Wonder if the OP will come back...

turnthebiglightoff · 17/02/2023 10:03

OP, if you come across as charming in real life as you do on this thread, then you might have a reason your business isn't performing that well.

BarbaraofSeville · 17/02/2023 09:59

You also can't criticise people who do have spare money for prioritising their own financial stability.

Many people struggled during the pandemic if they'd been furloughed or otherwise saw their income drop, if they had no savings. That, along with a reduction in the availability of things to spend money on, highlighted how much they'd previously spent on non-essentials, like food and drink out of the house.

So they may be choosing to spend less on these things, because they can see the value in reducing the frequency of visits as it allows them to build up savings that they can use in future if they lose their income again.

xogossipgirlxo · 17/02/2023 09:52

Business is business, some go bankrupt and new ones open. No one needs to apologise for their choices. Life is very expensive now, so obviously people eat out less.

Dotjones · 17/02/2023 09:51

I suspect like many others when I WFH I'm not "squirrelling money away" the money I'm not spending is taken by inflation.

Businesses that can adapt best are the ones that survive. If your business relies on workers being in the office then you need to adapt to a world where there are fewer of this sort of customer. People don't owe you a living, especially given the increased cost of living. Businesses that sell luxuries like sandwich and coffee shops are always the first to struggle when the cost of living bites.

Your real target of anger should be the companies that are not giving payrises in line with inflation (which is just about all of them). Start taking your frustration out on them. If people have more money than they need to survive, they will spend it on luxuries. If they don't, luxuries are the first thing to go.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 17/02/2023 09:42

It is no one’s responsibility to keep your small business afloat. If people aren’t shopping with you I would ask yourself why rather than blaming them for not coming. Could you advertise more? Are you too expensive? Do you actually sell what people want to buy? How could your online offering be improved? Do you offer next day delivery?

People generally want to shop locally. As a result of Covid and flexible working I visit my local village high street regularly. I use the two butchers and baker on at least a weekly basis and one of the coffee shops daily. The produce I get from butchers and baker are far superior to that elsewhere so I’m happy to pay more. The coffee shop is one of several but it is the only one to open before 8am and on a Sunday which is when I visit, so it’s the only one I use. I don’t visit the boutiques as I don’t have time to try on and they don’t offer a refund in store. They only open office hours and close Sundays. I can order online but delivery is 2-5 days. I live 10 mins away. I can order the same brands online elsewhere and get them next day. What incentive is there for me to shop there?

If local shops want to survive they need to take a thorough look at their business practices and get with the times. People often don’t have time to browse, however lovely and idyllic the high street is. They would do far better investing in strengthening their online offering with next day delivery and ensuring they offer more flexible opening hours.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 17/02/2023 09:37

Because a £3.50 latte in a cafe is no better than the 30p coffee I can make at home with my aeropress. In fact the last independent coffee place I went to yesterday had bitter tasting beans so they'd obviously not given enough consideration to their grinding methods/temperatures, and this is meant to be a treat?

It's because until you order, the £3.50 latte from the press-a-button place up the road isn't distinguishable from the £3.50 "I import my beans from x, and I use y machine and z temperature because reasons" place.

I don't want to buy crappy, carb laden food at a premium price to sit at a sticky table, or on an uncomfortable seat. I don't want a toastie with cheese that doesn't go to the edges, I don't want a tiny salad for £5 with fuck all topping and a shitty splash of vinaigrette. I don't want to piss £3 up the wall for a croissant when I know you just go to bookers, buy them frozen in a box of 50 for about £7.

I don't want to go to the toilet and discover there's no soap, no loo roll, or it smells like piss.

I don't want to commute, wasting petrol and causing pollution.

BarbaraofSeville · 17/02/2023 09:16

Yes, that's another downside to coffee shops.

You often have to queue for an age to get your coffee, and they're often full of other people constantly talking loudly. And these are somehow supposed to be enjoyable, relaxing places to go?

JimHensonWasAGenius · 17/02/2023 09:13

RedRiverShore3 · 17/02/2023 08:05

A lot of people buy nice coffee machines to use at home now, especially if they are at home more so they get the use out of it.

Exactly.

I buy a bag of v.nice ground coffee for £3:50 and that lasts me 5 days.

Why on earth would I pay a similar amount for a single cup of not v.good coffee in an often dirty and busy cafe?

I am constantly amazed how busy coffee shops are!

We are v.fortunate to be comfortable but I still refuse to pay it.

HerbalTeaAndCake · 17/02/2023 09:10

Also the sheer cost of everything is putting people off tbh. If it's going to cost me an arm and a leg to nip out for lunch, I'm going to be more likely to stay at home and make something nice 🤷🏻‍♀️

HerbalTeaAndCake · 17/02/2023 09:08

Can you change your business OP to offer catering to people in their homes for eg? Lunch deliveries, hampers for gifts etc?