Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where all those who said that WFH would be good for business are now?

489 replies

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:38

Sorry, sort of a rant.
I work in a small local foodie business in the South West. I know there is a cost of living crisis, but I also feel that WFH culture is killing us.
So many said that they would spend more in their local high streets now they were WFH but that seems to have stopped.
People are online food shopping and then not leaving their houses. Three local businesses announced they were closing this week, two bakeries and one restaurant. I can count five since Christmas which have folded.
I know a lot are feeling the pinch from gas and electric but a lot of people are just WFH, squirrelling their money away, saving and then saying 'oh that's a shame' on the Facebook posts when a business announces they're folding. Why not support them? I'm not talking about those on the breadline but those who are financially comfortable.
If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

OP posts:
Ellie1015 · 16/02/2023 18:19

I wfh thankfully saving on petrol. But if I was back at work i would not be affording lunch or coffees like i would have previously. We are being careful even with the fuel
saving.

VeggieSalsa · 16/02/2023 18:19

It’s COL not WFH.

Post lockdown, for months, for my 1-2 days in the office I would always be out for lunch in the city catching up with friends / colleagues.

None of us do that any more as we can’t afford to. I just eat in the subsidised canteen now or take my own food.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 16/02/2023 18:18

theswoot · 16/02/2023 18:16

I’m just interested to see the evidence you have that says that home workers are always better off, that they are the same people who want mixed indie high streets but are also the ones still handing over £ to big corps! It feels like you’re making assumptions about this and choosing to make home workers the bogeyman.

Yup...

Honestly, the rate people's disposable income is being eroded, I really doubt the artisan shops would still be getting custom at the same rate as this time 3 years ago even if the wfh rates were identical.

turnthebiglightoff · 16/02/2023 18:18

Wfh means I can afford to eat and pay my bills. If I was commuting and having to spend £5 on a sandwich every day I wouldn't be able to do either.

Swings and roundabouts. I'm sorry about your business but my need to pay my bills overrides your desire for me to support small businesses, for me!

Bellalalala · 16/02/2023 18:18

I don’t think anyone said wfh would be good for all businesses.

That doesn’t mean it’s the responsibility of those that work in offices to commute to keep other businesses afloat by doing something they don’t want to. Would you make your life a lot harder and more expensive for the benefit of someone else?

A lot of businesses grew around commuting culture. That’s not the same so those businesses either change or accept there’s been a huge shift. Just like when online shopping started. Culture shifts happen all the time. Businesses are always impacted.

The only places between my house and my office, at the time I travel are big chain brands and I didn’t stop off before anyway. So me wfh has impacted no one.

We work hybrid. No one came in with coffees before, no one does now. Our office isn’t in a city. We don’t hop off a train and walk past 10 cafes on the way in.

When I wfh, I do go to local cafe that’s not open early enough for me to use on my way into the office. If I wfh, I order a sandwich on my way past with the dogs and pick it up on the way back from walking the dogs.

You also have to factor COL in this. That will impact it.

But also people are spending elsewhere. A colleague of mine had a local company do her garden with a play area for the kids, from the money she saved from commuting. I didn’t the same and had new windows done. Again by a local company.

also people who wfh, also have childcare costs. How are people who wfh saving on utilities?

Im99912 · 16/02/2023 18:17

We used to get a takeaway fish n chips once a week - 1 small cod & Large cod and 1 large bag of chips

This used to cost just under £12
it’s now just over £20

I can afford it COL hasn’t and probably won’t affect us one bit but I’m not paying £20 for fish & chips 😂

babasaclover · 16/02/2023 18:17

I feel for you abs your business.

I personally now working from home more am able to spend more locally: butchers, bakers, hardware stores. I never had the time before when in London all day every day.

Could you target a nee type of client? I often see people working 'from home' doing so in local cafes, there must be things they miss from working in person, can you tailor tp them?

RobinGood · 16/02/2023 18:17

Totally agree. A good chunk of my colleagues are still wfh most of the week and the idea they’re off to their local high street or coffee shop is a nonsense.

lemonybiscuits · 16/02/2023 18:17

WFH hasn't made much difference to me, but paying for childcare has! Pre-children I used to work in a city (in the SW) and would have lunch out of the office once or twice a month. Now I WFH mainly but even when I go into the city I cannot get myself excited about the prospect of a nice treat lunch because it's so expensive/so much of my disposable income I just cannot justify it.
Also, now I am part time, I'm doing a lot more of my day to day spending (groceries) in town. Previously I would always be out of the house 7.30am-5.30pm (commuting by car) so there was no opportunity to use the greengrocer. But now I take my daughter for a walk and do my shopping in town. We also sometimes buy a coffee and cake which is something I never would have done before, as I'd have been at work in my office every week day.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 16/02/2023 18:16

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:12

@Nancydrawn thanks for getting it. I'm trying to listen but it feels like people want to have their cake and eat it too (if you'll pardon the pun). If people want to have high streets with independent businesses, their own identity, employers who pay a living wage then you have to support it. If WFH is saving you £££ on childcare and commuting then I feel you have some sort of obligation to share that wealth rather than just support Amazon or Tesco or whoever.

I was with you on the first part, but the second sentence is ridiculous.

We've had spiralling inflation and a cost of living crisis, as you must have noticed. People saving money due to wfh are facing the same high costs as everyone else, they might very well need that money for the higher mortgage rate.

theswoot · 16/02/2023 18:16

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:12

@Nancydrawn thanks for getting it. I'm trying to listen but it feels like people want to have their cake and eat it too (if you'll pardon the pun). If people want to have high streets with independent businesses, their own identity, employers who pay a living wage then you have to support it. If WFH is saving you £££ on childcare and commuting then I feel you have some sort of obligation to share that wealth rather than just support Amazon or Tesco or whoever.

I’m just interested to see the evidence you have that says that home workers are always better off, that they are the same people who want mixed indie high streets but are also the ones still handing over £ to big corps! It feels like you’re making assumptions about this and choosing to make home workers the bogeyman.

squtable · 16/02/2023 18:15

Well the COL crisis is impacting people's spending but I agree with If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

Merangutan · 16/02/2023 18:15

You view it as ‘support’ for local cafes etc - I view it as an unnecessary extravagance for me to go out to get a ready-made sandwich and coffee when I’m working at home near to my fridge and kettle. Money is tight for people so they want to make it at home rather than pay more for something which no longer adds convenience. Like everything, when trends change businesses have to adapt.

You are being a bit judgemental when you claim people are financially comfortable and say they are squirrelling their money away: firstly, it’s their money to do what they like with; secondly, lots of people’s jobs and wages were hit in lockdown so it’s quite right that people are now keen to have a safety net of savings; thirdly, just because people are comfortable it doesn’t mean that they want to spend money unnecessarily on food they could just as easily make at home. If you aren’t offering something that they want, why should they buy it?

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:15

I should say that I don't work in a cafe, ice cream parlour or restaurant. I work in retail. Nothing novelty or kitsch.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/02/2023 18:14

Bubblebubblebah · 16/02/2023 18:12

While it sucks for businesses who before had trade from local workers, the times are changing and sadly it is very much adapt or go like with other sectors.
However, it is not just wfh. Even takeaways around are suffering massively since October. Massively. Their bills went up, customer's bills went up, so less money spent by customers, but more money spent by the business.
Again, they are all trying to adapt somehow to survive. But it is hard, you know that.

It was nlt this bad in 2008- credit crunch. It's worst many of my friends in hospitality seen for a VERY long time.

I don’t think people are obligated to spend their money anywhere. It’s their money so their choice.

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:14

@SomeCommonThing so those who work in customer service are exempt from those bills going up for them personally too?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 16/02/2023 18:13

We have a gorgeous local vegetarian cafe. It’s always packed because the food is delicious and it’s a lovely environment. If you give the people what they want they will come….

SomeCommonThing · 16/02/2023 18:12

Nancydrawn · 16/02/2023 18:01

I think it's really shitty, OP. It's like people who are sad to see their local bookstore go but buy all their books on kindle.

Of course no one owes anyone a living. But choices have ethics. If your ethical basis is that money shouldn't all go to corporations, or that having a thriving city centre is important, or that zero hours, low wage contracts are a problem, then ordering everything in and ignoring your local high street shops, at least when you can afford to do otherwise, is hypocritical and unethical.

If you don't think that, then it's perfectly reasonable. Just don't complain when the high street is boarded up and your only shopping and banking options are online or in big suburban centres you have to drive to.

That's all well and good but when people's energy bills are 100-200 pound per month more expensive, people have far less spare for frivolous spending. Which lunch in your local eatery is. Regardless of your "ethics"

BamBamBilla · 16/02/2023 18:12

I'm saving my lattes and avocado on toast money for a house deposit.

Bubblebubblebah · 16/02/2023 18:12

While it sucks for businesses who before had trade from local workers, the times are changing and sadly it is very much adapt or go like with other sectors.
However, it is not just wfh. Even takeaways around are suffering massively since October. Massively. Their bills went up, customer's bills went up, so less money spent by customers, but more money spent by the business.
Again, they are all trying to adapt somehow to survive. But it is hard, you know that.

It was nlt this bad in 2008- credit crunch. It's worst many of my friends in hospitality seen for a VERY long time.

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:12

@Nancydrawn thanks for getting it. I'm trying to listen but it feels like people want to have their cake and eat it too (if you'll pardon the pun). If people want to have high streets with independent businesses, their own identity, employers who pay a living wage then you have to support it. If WFH is saving you £££ on childcare and commuting then I feel you have some sort of obligation to share that wealth rather than just support Amazon or Tesco or whoever.

OP posts:
Devonhousehunter · 16/02/2023 18:10

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:08

@Devonhousehunter
You realise there is more to the SW than tourism right? Like there's whole cities where people work and commute that have their own industries. We don't all have farms or live by the sea.

I know my darling, I live here 😉

There's also more to cafes than pretentious fluffy pancakes and shit coffee by the sea

cocksstrideintheevening · 16/02/2023 18:10

It's not wfh. My local cafe is charging £9 for a meal deal. Sandwich crisps and a drink. I can afford it but won't on principle. I bought lunch in order the other day, it was £10, the sandwich filling was way reduced from pre covid.

I understand why bot won't be doing that again.

I think you need to direct tour anger somewhere else not wfh.

CrinkleCutChips · 16/02/2023 18:10

You’re getting annoyed at the wrong people. It’s not the fault of the people who work from home not buying your goods. A lot of them probably never came to your shop anyway 🤷‍♀️ These people have seen their bills going up, as have you, and have to tighten their belts accordingly. If that means them changing shopping habits then so be it. Get annoyed at British Gas who have reported tripling their profits whilst people are hungry and cold.

If you start a self employed business then you have to be prepared for the good times and the bad, sorry. Maybe it’ll pick up or maybe consider getting another job.

rexythedinosaur · 16/02/2023 18:08

Nancydrawn · 16/02/2023 18:01

I think it's really shitty, OP. It's like people who are sad to see their local bookstore go but buy all their books on kindle.

Of course no one owes anyone a living. But choices have ethics. If your ethical basis is that money shouldn't all go to corporations, or that having a thriving city centre is important, or that zero hours, low wage contracts are a problem, then ordering everything in and ignoring your local high street shops, at least when you can afford to do otherwise, is hypocritical and unethical.

If you don't think that, then it's perfectly reasonable. Just don't complain when the high street is boarded up and your only shopping and banking options are online or in big suburban centres you have to drive to.

I do agree with all of this, but I still think the reality is that people will behave how they behave and good luck with changing that on a large scale (cynical I know).

The businesses that surive will always be the ones which adapt to people's behaviour, rather than the opposite.