Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where all those who said that WFH would be good for business are now?

489 replies

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:38

Sorry, sort of a rant.
I work in a small local foodie business in the South West. I know there is a cost of living crisis, but I also feel that WFH culture is killing us.
So many said that they would spend more in their local high streets now they were WFH but that seems to have stopped.
People are online food shopping and then not leaving their houses. Three local businesses announced they were closing this week, two bakeries and one restaurant. I can count five since Christmas which have folded.
I know a lot are feeling the pinch from gas and electric but a lot of people are just WFH, squirrelling their money away, saving and then saying 'oh that's a shame' on the Facebook posts when a business announces they're folding. Why not support them? I'm not talking about those on the breadline but those who are financially comfortable.
If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

OP posts:
Andanotherone01 · 16/02/2023 18:53

Nothing to do with people WFH and everything to do with people having little to no disposable income

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:52

@MaireadMcSweeney I don't think that sounds ridiculous. I want to have choice, as a consumer, which is why I spend money in multiple small businesses rather than Amazon. We all have choices.

OP posts:
OdeToBarney · 16/02/2023 18:51

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:51

I suppose all I see is the advantage for those who work from home and the disadvantage for those who work out of the home.
We have to work in businesses which are struggling, pay childcare, pay travel costs and pay all the utility bills that are increasing. Those who get to work from home save on all of those, but also can't be bothered to spend money on their high streets. They don't seem to see the link between the comment 'oh no that lovely cafe has shut down' and their lack of support.

Home workers also pay childcare (well, the decent ones do) and they often have higher utilities due to being at home all day. Your anger is misplaced.

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 16/02/2023 18:51

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:40

@Christmaspyjamas no I completely blame the government too. But I also have family in Europe and know that their high streets will never die as people value relationships and community there in a way that Brits don't.
Gio who has his cafe on the corner in Milan will not lose out all of his custom to a local Starbucks as people love Gio and love his coffee. Here, British people just care about cost, fuck Gio and his family, they'll go across the street whilst he watches just to save a few pennies.

Is your utter disdain for the general public apparent day to day? Could it be that you’re part of the problem?

donttellmehesalive · 16/02/2023 18:51

I'm sorry that your business is struggling and that you are worried about your job.

But if you are selling stuff that people don't want at a price they're unwilling or unable to pay, you will have to adapt or fail.

You can't argue with people about what they ought to spend their money on. They know what their family commitments and priorities are, and you are not a charity.

MaireadMcSweeney · 16/02/2023 18:51

I haven't saved anything by WFH. I got a new job in an office twice as far as my old one so my fuel costs are the same and I am now paying double cost for double the amount of heating by being home in the winter. In fact this winter I bet WFH has been more expensive than commuting.

MrsJBaptiste · 16/02/2023 18:50

OP, I'm not sure why you're surprised on MN of all places. Everyone on here orders everything online and barely ever sets foot out of their house, let alone onto the high street.

MaireadMcSweeney · 16/02/2023 18:48

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:12

@Nancydrawn thanks for getting it. I'm trying to listen but it feels like people want to have their cake and eat it too (if you'll pardon the pun). If people want to have high streets with independent businesses, their own identity, employers who pay a living wage then you have to support it. If WFH is saving you £££ on childcare and commuting then I feel you have some sort of obligation to share that wealth rather than just support Amazon or Tesco or whoever.

What by making special efforts to go into town centres just for the purpose of spending money in local businesses? Do you realise how ridiculous that sounds?

Oblomov23 · 16/02/2023 18:48

I do partly understand and agree. If loads of companies close their offices and people wfh then sandwich places best offices, say in Canary Wharf don't have the same clientele.
But, Plus COL may mean these people aren't now buying lunch.
Plus there are people like me, who now working hybrid, when I do go into the office I walk into my local town, but I always took a sandwich /left over dinner, so never /rarely bought a lunch anyway.

Heynow3 · 16/02/2023 18:48

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:40

@Christmaspyjamas no I completely blame the government too. But I also have family in Europe and know that their high streets will never die as people value relationships and community there in a way that Brits don't.
Gio who has his cafe on the corner in Milan will not lose out all of his custom to a local Starbucks as people love Gio and love his coffee. Here, British people just care about cost, fuck Gio and his family, they'll go across the street whilst he watches just to save a few pennies.

Maybe you lost customers partly because of your attitude?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/02/2023 18:47

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:35

Ok so as a real example, in 2020/2021 plenty of people moved to our neck of the woods as they could now WFH forever. They were used to paying London prices and now were buying £60-£100 worth of groceries per week, enjoying their new disposable income and having a three bed for the price of a one bed in London.
They used to go on about the high street, how lovely it was, how unique and how all the indies made the area for them. They presumably still have the same jobs, they still pay the same rent or mortgage, but they've stopped coming, not just to us but to all the indie shops. So they will probably lose the one thing that made them love the area in the first place.
So yes you can call it a 'saving' buying a plastic cup of Starbucks from the fridge in Tesco but you cannot then moan that you're house price has gone down or that there is no local high street when things pick back up again for you.
Yes there will be those who are on the bones of their arse right now, as am I. But not all are, some are just being tight.

So in actual fact your area benefited massively from people transitioning to WFH. We're you not at all concerned for all those indie shops who lost £60-100 pw when those workers moved to your area? Did you urge them to reconsider moving as it would destroy their old High Street or did you welcome them with open arms and gladly take their cash?

Now the novelty has worn off and the cost of living had skyrocketed, so people are changing their habits. Yes, customers can help support local independents but the onus is on those local independents to offer something worth supporting (in the customers eyes).

RaininSummer · 16/02/2023 18:47

I go to work 5 days a week in a small city in the SW and never buy anything in a cafe or coffee shop. Way too expensive which isn't their fault with prices being what they are. I can't pay a tenner for something like avocado on toast and coffee. Me and partner had lunch in my hols recently and it was only fish cake and chips with a non alcoholic drink but cost over 30 pounds. Guess the times they are a-changing. Sad for business owners though.

OhmygodDont · 16/02/2023 18:46

Thing is that’s a sense of community for Geo we don’t have that where as a general rule apart from for village type cafes normally.

If I went into town the odd more independent is over double the price and it’s still not Geo working there it’s Isla on a gap year.

3LittleFishes · 16/02/2023 18:46

no I completely blame the government too. But I also have family in Europe and know that their high streets will never die as people value relationships and community there in a way that Brits don't.

Gio who has his cafe on the corner in Milan will not lose out all of his custom to a local Starbucks as people love Gio and love his coffee. Here, British people just care about cost, fuck Gio and his family, they'll go across the street whilst he watches just to save a few pennies.
Well you know what to do if Gio is so much happier in Europe.....I hope your anti Brit sentiment isn't so obvious when you're serving your customers 🙄

Roundandnour · 16/02/2023 18:46

During Covid a lot of people had extra time to visit the high street because they were furloughed. Have you forgotten this @ChampagnePuppy

Now they are back in their workplaces so money spent locally will be spent near work.

Highstreets have been in decline for a long long time even without the Col.

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:45

@Wishawisha I wish I could hug you. My DH is a butcher (I work in a near by shop, it's like Tobermory, our little life) and he says exactly the same! Valentines was dead this year, but phenomenally busy the week before. Christmas, for him, was down 60%. So difficult to predict.

OP posts:
ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:42

@HermioneHerman haha, you don't get coffee or tea in the NHS! Or at least the hospital I used to work at, not even milk!

OP posts:
HermioneHerman · 16/02/2023 18:40

WFH only saved petrol and parkings costs for me, everything else, particularly utilities and food, have increased because I'm home all the time and prices have risen dramatically. My husband's company closed all their physical offices so now they save on all those costs such as rent, electricity, occupational health, furniture and office supplies but they've been entirely passed onto us! Not so much me as I'm NHS but it's been a far better deal for husband's company than him! It's nonsense to say there are only advantages to WFH but the disadvantages (and benefits for the employer) aren't really talked about much. Even tea, coffee and milk that most offices provide now falls to employees. I very much doubt that the majority of WFHers want to or can afford to pay many times the price for a cuppa, just to keep someone else's business afloat. Conversely in my small town, many new cafés and eateries have opened in recent times and often full to bursting, with parents with kids, friends and older people in couples and groups...very few look to be WFH types (although could be wrong of course) but we're all at home...guess what...working!

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:40

@Christmaspyjamas no I completely blame the government too. But I also have family in Europe and know that their high streets will never die as people value relationships and community there in a way that Brits don't.
Gio who has his cafe on the corner in Milan will not lose out all of his custom to a local Starbucks as people love Gio and love his coffee. Here, British people just care about cost, fuck Gio and his family, they'll go across the street whilst he watches just to save a few pennies.

OP posts:
Cornishsausageroll · 16/02/2023 18:40

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:35

Ok so as a real example, in 2020/2021 plenty of people moved to our neck of the woods as they could now WFH forever. They were used to paying London prices and now were buying £60-£100 worth of groceries per week, enjoying their new disposable income and having a three bed for the price of a one bed in London.
They used to go on about the high street, how lovely it was, how unique and how all the indies made the area for them. They presumably still have the same jobs, they still pay the same rent or mortgage, but they've stopped coming, not just to us but to all the indie shops. So they will probably lose the one thing that made them love the area in the first place.
So yes you can call it a 'saving' buying a plastic cup of Starbucks from the fridge in Tesco but you cannot then moan that you're house price has gone down or that there is no local high street when things pick back up again for you.
Yes there will be those who are on the bones of their arse right now, as am I. But not all are, some are just being tight.

No, a lot of the people who moved down have moved back.

The South West didn't provide many people with the life, schools, colleges, jobs and salaries that people were hoping for.

3 of my neighbours on my street have moved back to the South East because they didn't realise the SW was this deprived! The people who purchased their homes are not people who WFH. They are people in their 50s who took early retirement.

OhmygodDont · 16/02/2023 18:40

I’ve always worked from home. I also have no interest in cafes or the such either. But it’s going to be col your item is not a priority for those who need to save.

On the flip slide the company I also run works on the basis on people who rent office space but again those rentable office spaces are not near high streets either but those buildings always existed too.

theswoot · 16/02/2023 18:39

@ChampagnePuppy home workers will have all the things you’ve mentioned to worry about too, except the bus fare, and as many many others have mentioned on this thread, all that other stuff is costing much more than it was, which is probably eating into any savings they make and preventing them from spending money at your foodie business. And being a home worker doesn’t mean you’re not walking around with a target on your head for redundancy!

Sure there will be some people who are doing better with their current arrangements than they were pre pandemic, but that’s not representative of the population as a whole and I don’t know how you can absolutely definitively say that they are not still spending at local business?

Wishawisha · 16/02/2023 18:39

I can see this. We have a few local businesses we make a point of supporting - butchers, nicest pub etc - but we were talking to the butcher recently and he said that demand wasn’t the issue, in fact they have more custom than ever, but it’s so random now because of wfh. So the busy days are less busy and the quiet days are now busy.. but also not at all predictable. So Tuesday was a big day last week and they prepare for this Tuesday to be busy too .. and then it isn’t. They were saying that managing supplies is getting really difficult.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 16/02/2023 18:38

But not all are, some are just being tight.

People are allowed to be 'tight' if they want - or how about cautious, frugal, sensible?

It's not just immediate things that are effected by COL - the value of savings and pensions is being eroded by rapid inflation; property prices slumping means the option of downsizing to release equity becomes less viable as a nest-egg option.

Heynow3 · 16/02/2023 18:38

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:35

Ok so as a real example, in 2020/2021 plenty of people moved to our neck of the woods as they could now WFH forever. They were used to paying London prices and now were buying £60-£100 worth of groceries per week, enjoying their new disposable income and having a three bed for the price of a one bed in London.
They used to go on about the high street, how lovely it was, how unique and how all the indies made the area for them. They presumably still have the same jobs, they still pay the same rent or mortgage, but they've stopped coming, not just to us but to all the indie shops. So they will probably lose the one thing that made them love the area in the first place.
So yes you can call it a 'saving' buying a plastic cup of Starbucks from the fridge in Tesco but you cannot then moan that you're house price has gone down or that there is no local high street when things pick back up again for you.
Yes there will be those who are on the bones of their arse right now, as am I. But not all are, some are just being tight.

It’s not tight not to want to spend on the high street. Get real.

Swipe left for the next trending thread