Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where all those who said that WFH would be good for business are now?

489 replies

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 17:38

Sorry, sort of a rant.
I work in a small local foodie business in the South West. I know there is a cost of living crisis, but I also feel that WFH culture is killing us.
So many said that they would spend more in their local high streets now they were WFH but that seems to have stopped.
People are online food shopping and then not leaving their houses. Three local businesses announced they were closing this week, two bakeries and one restaurant. I can count five since Christmas which have folded.
I know a lot are feeling the pinch from gas and electric but a lot of people are just WFH, squirrelling their money away, saving and then saying 'oh that's a shame' on the Facebook posts when a business announces they're folding. Why not support them? I'm not talking about those on the breadline but those who are financially comfortable.
If you want a diverse high street, you have to support local businesses or we won't be here in a years time.

OP posts:
KnutonHardz · 16/02/2023 19:26

The change in WFH patterns has results in huge changes, with some winners and some losers. On a personal level for me it's enabled me to work remotely while being based at our family farm, as there needs to be someone here at various points in the day while my father is going to treatment. I'm still able to do a good job, and deal with a few things that come up from time to time.

We're a few miles from a small town. Decades ago it used to be a more prosperous thriving town, but in more recent years, well before COVID, it would be classified as a bit of a dump. Many local businesses were not doing well already and WFH makes it even worse. Interestingly though the one good coffee shop and tea shop are probably doing better than ever (my cousin in the police force tells me casual drugs is booming too). Change, with some winners but lots of losers.

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:25

@noworklifebalance I can... you reap what you sow. Customers are often awful. It's only when one of their little darlings gets a shop job before uni that they realise.

OP posts:
Sunsetmom · 16/02/2023 19:25

As someone who works from home, I don’t save on childcare because I still have to work, I don’t save on utility bills because I’m at home all the time with my laptop plugged in, lights on when needed, heating etc. I don’t think WFH is killing the high street I think it’s the COL crisis and people tightening their belts! Why would I use my high street if I can get the same product for less, delivered to my door! I’m all for supporting small and local businesses but not if it’s going to cost me more!

Pirateships · 16/02/2023 19:25

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:22

@PandasAreUseless I agree with some of that but there's reasons for this.
1.) there's a recruitment and retention crisis. If we advertise for staff and we are already need them to work weekends then we have to compromise by offering 9-5 or similar. If we ask for people to work until 8 or 9pm we won't get any applications and people will leave.
2.) we also have children and so we can't stay open until 7/8pm as there is no childcare that provides those hours.
3.) retail is physically hard and so you can't ask people to be on their feet lifting and carrying stock from 7am until 9pm. Big shops can do it by offering split shifts but if we just need one individual to run a shift then we can't ask them to work a 12 hour shift.

I mean you've sort of answered this yourself. You just can't compete with the opening hours of chains and therefore have less custom. Here they all shut Sundays as well, I get staff need a break but when people are off and probably have the time to get a coffee and food seems ridiculous. You have to offer something chain's can't to remain competitive, and what is that if you're being honest with yourself?

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:23

@MarieRoseMarie good luck getting your local grass fed meat and local stoneground flour made loaf from Amazon!

OP posts:
noworklifebalance · 16/02/2023 19:23

That’s shocking @MarieRoseMarie - I can’t imagine being deliberately rude to someone for no reason let alone if it is detrimental to my business

LlynTegid · 16/02/2023 19:22

Working from home works for me. The extra electric bills are more than compensated for by lower food costs and less spent on clothes. I spend much more in the local high street than I did, especially at the twice weekly market where all my fruit and veg now comes from.

I recognise it does not work for many other people and in many jobs, there is no choice but to travel to a place of work that is not your home or near to it. However, the genie is out of the bottle, and given the difficulties in recruiting staff in many areas of the economy, some potential employees and current ones have in a sense the upper hand.

I think high energy costs (because of limited investment in local energy sources and no proper windfall tax), Brexit and the poor Covid 19 response have harmed business more than some people working from home. Business rates are an anachronism that should have been replaced by one based on turnover many years ago. It does not lessen the pain for those who have lost business though.

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:22

@PandasAreUseless I agree with some of that but there's reasons for this.
1.) there's a recruitment and retention crisis. If we advertise for staff and we are already need them to work weekends then we have to compromise by offering 9-5 or similar. If we ask for people to work until 8 or 9pm we won't get any applications and people will leave.
2.) we also have children and so we can't stay open until 7/8pm as there is no childcare that provides those hours.
3.) retail is physically hard and so you can't ask people to be on their feet lifting and carrying stock from 7am until 9pm. Big shops can do it by offering split shifts but if we just need one individual to run a shift then we can't ask them to work a 12 hour shift.

OP posts:
MarieRoseMarie · 16/02/2023 19:20

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:00

@DogsDryWineAndCheese come on, it's true! If you said to a British person, what's the name of one person who served you in a shop today, they wouldn't know it. If you said to them, what does the person who serves you coffee in the morning look like, or where are they from very few could say. As a nation, we are very distanced from those who work in the service industry. I have worked in this industry, in many different roles, for decades. I love it, I wouldn't want to do anything else. But how can you let the same person serve you something for years and not even ask anything about them? I do think there is a link between this and the British public not caring when businesses go under. It's capitalism personified. Not seeing a person or a family but seeing either a viable business or something which can't compete with market rate. No maybe I can't compete with a huge business but I also pay my staff well, I pay sick pay, I pay lunch breaks. Would you rather have a country of zero hour contracts, profits over people and the same five shops in every high street?

Yes because British shop keepers are rude and entitled like you! You 100% represent the customer service mentality of your local shop. Rude, resentful, bitter and full of contempt for your customer! You think everyone else is beneath you.

I work from home and I buy from my local butcher btw but he’s just like you: rude, slightly hostile, moaner. I buy because the meat is local and good quality.

I buy from my local baker who is sure to keep me outside waiting 10 minutes past opening time despite seeing me and then serves me as if I'm doing him a favour by buying.

The local greengrocer sneers and walks off half way through discussions and it’s 3 times the cost of even organic supermarket veg but it lasts longer than any supermarket veg you can buy.

What is my crime? Living in a village but not being a born local. Being new to the area is a sin, apparently. I’m not even in the SW, I’m in Cambridgeshire so it’s not envy. They’re richer than me. People tell me not to worry. Once I’ve been here longer, I’ll be accepted and they’ll be nice as pie apparently.

No wonder Amazon can come in and wipe the floor with all of you.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 16/02/2023 19:16

I agree with all the comments about not being able to afford it - that’s just economics.

But I live in a large well-known commuter town in the SE and we’ve had three new bakeries/cafes open on or near our high street in the last 12m. And they seem to be doing good business.

PandasAreUseless · 16/02/2023 19:16

I work in my nearest city 2 days a week, the rest from home. As I'm only paying for my £15 a day train commute twice, rather than five times a week, I justify buying a coffee on one of my days in the office, and on one of my days at home. So WFH makes me spend more as I couldn't justify these treats before.
The problem is, I can only support chains because:

  • in the city, only chains can afford the rent
  • in my little home market town, all of the independent cafes open at 9am, but I need to be sitting down to have my coffee at 8am to get back in time for work. So I drive to a Costa 2 minutes away.
And then I'm only free again from 5.30pm, when all of the little independents are closed. So again, for anything I need, I head to Wilko, which is open until 6pm. Independents need to move with the times and adapt their opening hours.
OdeToBarney · 16/02/2023 19:15

@ChampagnePuppy I haven't seen that post but I have seen others which say they have saved money but don't specify how. Perhaps they no longer need to pay for wrap around care since they don't have a long commute. I booked my DD's place at nursery when she was 8 weeks old and she will be going every day we are working. You cannot parent and work, you'll end up with the worst of both worlds, being a crap parent and a crap employee.

I used to spend a couple of hundred pounds a month on food and coffee when out at work. I absolutely will not be doing that when I go back as childcare and COL will cripple me and I cannot afford £10 a day on lunch. I will be taking my own from home.

Again, your anger is misplaced.

gwenneh · 16/02/2023 19:15

So you think because people WFH they've become shut-ins?
WFH doesn't mean you never leave the house, you know.

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:15

@FiddleLeaf thank you. I'm not like this usually, I'm just having a rant as I'm tired of the social media 'oh no, we'll really miss you' brigade when a business closes. If all the people who posted sad emojis had actually shopped their once a week, they might not have gone.

OP posts:
FiddleLeaf · 16/02/2023 19:13

Still WFH and still buying from the locals 🤷🏻‍♀️

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 16/02/2023 19:12

Most people would absolutely love to support local businesses but for many, they simply cannot afford to. This isn’t a choice for a lot of people. It’s a matter of being able to make ends meet and luxuries like eating out are things that don’t qualify as necessities.

This. If I have 'lunch out' such as a bought sandwich, it is a treat - something I might do at most once a month. I absolutely do choose local and independent providers because if I'm paying for it, I want it to be worthwhile and not supermarket cardboard. But I can't afford to do this routinely; less so now than ever. I save nothing WFH because I don't have childcare needs and I walked to work. If anything it costs me more in heating/my own electric for the laptop etc.

Luana1 · 16/02/2023 19:11

but also can't be bothered to spend money on their high streets.

That's nothing to do with WFH though, I don't spend money on lunch near the office when I do go in either. A year ago I would have but can't afford to now. So I think your issue is more to do with the economy that people WFH.

donttellmehesalive · 16/02/2023 19:10

Cafes doing well around here cater for those wfh, plenty of sockets to charge phones and laptops.

You'll just have to adapt op. I support local where I can. If there's a bit of a price difference, I buy locally. But if it's twice the price, I don't. I don't make a habit of giving money away unnecessarily.

noworklifebalance · 16/02/2023 19:09

DH and I are high earners, however, we both take coffee and lunch from home to work. All these extras add up - one coffee per day, 5 days per week would cost £1500 per year.

One day I missed my train so popped into the local cafe (not a chain) and bought a pain au raisin - £3.50 (take away)! That is a ridiculous price for a pastry - I can easily afford it but it was massively over priced and not even that nice.

As for Amazon and online delivery, without either we would not be able to work full time and have children - we would spend so much time going from one shop to another every week. I suspect that may be the reality for many households.

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 16/02/2023 19:07

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:00

@DogsDryWineAndCheese come on, it's true! If you said to a British person, what's the name of one person who served you in a shop today, they wouldn't know it. If you said to them, what does the person who serves you coffee in the morning look like, or where are they from very few could say. As a nation, we are very distanced from those who work in the service industry. I have worked in this industry, in many different roles, for decades. I love it, I wouldn't want to do anything else. But how can you let the same person serve you something for years and not even ask anything about them? I do think there is a link between this and the British public not caring when businesses go under. It's capitalism personified. Not seeing a person or a family but seeing either a viable business or something which can't compete with market rate. No maybe I can't compete with a huge business but I also pay my staff well, I pay sick pay, I pay lunch breaks. Would you rather have a country of zero hour contracts, profits over people and the same five shops in every high street?

You seem to be overlooking one key fact - your business is the responsibility of NOBODY but you.

My business has had a quiet month. I’ve not blamed the general public. They owe me fuck all. What I have done is offer a cheaper option, set myself up more for export, look into different ways of advertising, asked people what they DO want.
If my business ever folds, that’s MY problem.

Honestly I think you’re the problem here.

Folklore9074 · 16/02/2023 19:07

I think your generalising massively about people that wfh. Far from squirrelling their money away they have childcare cost too (if they are not taking the piss), bill increases, food increases - the lot. People were more inclined to shop locally during lockdown because it was something to do and we didn’t have the inflation we have now. I truly am sorry you are finding things tough but I think you’re not seeing the real picture here. You say lots of businesses in your area have folded since Christmas but don’t connect that with cost of living.

Pirateships · 16/02/2023 19:06

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 19:00

@DogsDryWineAndCheese come on, it's true! If you said to a British person, what's the name of one person who served you in a shop today, they wouldn't know it. If you said to them, what does the person who serves you coffee in the morning look like, or where are they from very few could say. As a nation, we are very distanced from those who work in the service industry. I have worked in this industry, in many different roles, for decades. I love it, I wouldn't want to do anything else. But how can you let the same person serve you something for years and not even ask anything about them? I do think there is a link between this and the British public not caring when businesses go under. It's capitalism personified. Not seeing a person or a family but seeing either a viable business or something which can't compete with market rate. No maybe I can't compete with a huge business but I also pay my staff well, I pay sick pay, I pay lunch breaks. Would you rather have a country of zero hour contracts, profits over people and the same five shops in every high street?

Personally I find where I am chain bakeries and coffee shops are better. I've tried coffee many times from the local cafe and its pretty crap to be honest. I went in with DS and one singular slice of toast with a tiny scraping of butter was £3. Hard choice on whether to buy an entire loaf of bread, some spread and electric to cook the bloody toast or sit in the cold on a rickety table to eat a slice of toast. Abroad I've found the opposite, small hospitality businesses much better value, quality and more of an enjoyable experience. Perhaps the issue isn't just with the public but with the businesses themselves?

Tinkerbyebye · 16/02/2023 19:05

I wfh, I do online shopping because it’s easier for me, and cheaper as I don’t browse and pick up stuff. Where’s my ‘extra’ money gone? On rising food and fuel costs. That’s where

clairelouwho · 16/02/2023 19:05

ChampagnePuppy · 16/02/2023 18:14

@SomeCommonThing so those who work in customer service are exempt from those bills going up for them personally too?

It seems that you’re being intentionally obtuse.

we know that bills have gone up for everyone. That is why there is so little disposable income around at the moment to spend in the high streets.

Most people would absolutely love to support local businesses but for many, they simply cannot afford to. This isn’t a choice for a lot of people. It’s a matter of being able to make ends meet and luxuries like eating out are things that don’t qualify as necessities.

It’s not even just the CoL at the moment but what is to come down the line. With the uncertain rises in energy bills and potential council tax rises many are having to forecast and plan ahead for even harder times.

maybe stop blaming the consumer for responding to the economic times that we’re in and look at the government who’s choices have led us here.

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/02/2023 19:05

It's sad but people shouldn't artificially support an industry they don't actually want to use.

I love bakeries and regularly walk to my local for baguettes and cakes, cause I love cake. But I don't make a beeline for the dry cleaner, just to keep them going.

Coffee shops etc don't really offer society much in my opinion. Most of their produce isn't healthy. Most of their staff are minimum wage and not treated particularly well (broad statement but generally it's a tough job with little return or respect). So I'm not really sad that there's fewer.

Some industries have nose dived whereas others have boomed. The tech industry. Some of our local gyms are majorly popular now as it's a key way of exercising now people WFH and people have more time to do it. The dog accessory industry must be winning!

I think it's just a case of survival of the fittest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread