Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Generational finances

231 replies

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 12:45

I don’t expect I can word this right/fairly but essentially, if retired grandparents have some wealth (e.g., 5 figure savings or assets) and their adult children are bringing up young children on barely enough to pay rent/mortgage, energy bills, childcare and food - is this okay? What are your thoughts and beliefs about how to balance wealth and finances more fairly? What role should grandparents play financially?

OP posts:
RedRiverShore3 · 16/02/2023 13:47

Spendonsend · 16/02/2023 13:38

You should hit your retirement at the wealthiest you will ever be. Then its gets eaten away at until you die.

It always strikes me as such a shame that our childbearing years are really at the start when we have the least.

Yes this, we were certainly at our wealthiest at retirement and it will be eroded as we have to pay for and replace things

Riverlee · 16/02/2023 13:47

Fortunately for op, schools now have to provide swimming lessons, so society is providing that.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 16/02/2023 13:46

I totally get your point, but generational wealth being handed down is also contributing to inequality.

The wealthy families stay wealthy, the poor stay poor.

Houses are handed down, large inheritances propping people back up the property ladder etc.

mamnotmum · 16/02/2023 13:44

My sister and I disagree on this.

I believe my parents money is theirs and what they choose to do with it is completely their choice.

My sister talks about 'her' inheritance and 'what is a fair split' etc. I expect nothing and if my parents leave me something then that is very kind.

The same in life - sometimes they'll treat us to a meal out or even, in the past, pay for a family holiday but none of it is expected. Their money, their choice.

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 13:44

JizzlordTheCat · 16/02/2023 13:39

Why should “society” pay for your children to swim and visit farms?

For obvious reasons society should ensure swimming is too expensive for most and that only the wealthiest children get the opportunity to learn and avoid drowning. Having children drown more regularly is the sign of a healthy society nowadays.

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 16/02/2023 13:43

BubziOwl · 16/02/2023 13:34

I honestly can't fathom not sharing everything I possibly can with my children, and improving my children's (and potential future grandchildren's) lot in life is genuinely the main thing, by a long way, that gives my husband and I motivation to build wealth and assets.

I don't really understand what the point is otherwise - you can't take it with you...

The issue is if they give her lots of their money and then live longer than expected and run out of money and OP hasn't got anything left then they're elderly and fucked

IDontWantToBeAPie · 16/02/2023 13:42

@Onnabugeisha true but I assumed that was as well as a family home etc to go over the threshold

Nosleepforthismum · 16/02/2023 13:41

I really hate these posts. No adult is entitled to their parents money whilst alive or when they eventually pass away. Your parents didn’t know that properties they purchased years ago would inflate to the levels they are now. They would have had their own financial worries and concerns at the time.

You may also be remembering your childhood with rose tinted glasses. Holidays and music lessons may well have only been afforded by sacrificing something else.

You really shouldn’t begrudge your parents wealth as you could end up in a similar position with your own DC and DGC expecting you to help fund their lifestyle in years to come.

LatteLady · 16/02/2023 13:41

No, I don't think that parents should automatically offer to help out their children. My mother worked until she was 80 as a housekeeper and cleaner, I would not have thought of expecting anything from her or indeed my older sister. About 10 years ago I was made redundant, it took me nearly five years to move from temp work to a perm role... during that time, I go put onto meters and eventually lost my home. I never shared with any of my friends how bad it was, because it was my problem to solve and yes, it was bloody tough and no doubt they could have helped me BUT it was my job to push on through it.

Life is not fair, so all you can do is just work through it and hope that better days will soon be here.

MissMarplesGoddaughter · 16/02/2023 13:41

I'm a BB and a MiL and yes, I am so glad I am able to help my DC and DGC financially. I would hate to see them struggling financially. They do not ask, but I chose to help them. My parents and ILs were not in a position to help us, but we are, so we do.

DemonHost · 16/02/2023 13:40

Many are so afraid of having nothing when in their old-age that they keep it all until they die. You usually find the most generous people are those that do not have a lot to start with.

I will not be like this. I plan on funding my kids private pensions and LISAs when I take early retirement. I would rather die a pauper and make my children wealthy, but am currently aiming for a middle ground.

MarieRoseMarie · 16/02/2023 13:40

It really depends on the details. Imagine encouraging your children to make smart decisions and them making risky or foolish ones then them insisting that you owe them money.

I think parents owe children a great childhood and help as adults if needed but I don’t think an adult is owed a great quality living.

it sounds like you could have provided all of this for you mr children had you had one child. You chose to have sibling and to have a lower quality of life for them.

JizzlordTheCat · 16/02/2023 13:39

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 13:30

I haven’t actually got any ideas or thoughts about wanting anything. I don’t have a solution either. It’s half term and I’m feeling guilty that I can’t take my kids to do “nice” things like swimming at the leisure centre, half-term activity sessions, visits to a farm etc. Personally, I’d prefer that this was addressed by society as there’s plenty of other families like ours who don’t have grandparents with any wealth.

Why should “society” pay for your children to swim and visit farms?

Spendonsend · 16/02/2023 13:38

You should hit your retirement at the wealthiest you will ever be. Then its gets eaten away at until you die.

It always strikes me as such a shame that our childbearing years are really at the start when we have the least.

Tinkerbyebye · 16/02/2023 13:37

Grandparents should play no role in your finances. Your child, you pay.

Nevermind31 · 16/02/2023 13:34

Grandparents brought up their kids. Now they are supposed to bring up their grandkids as well?
yes, it would be nice if they helped a bit if the can.
but they shouldn’t have to. I wouldn’t want to see my kids struggle, but at some point, they are adults.

BubziOwl · 16/02/2023 13:34

I honestly can't fathom not sharing everything I possibly can with my children, and improving my children's (and potential future grandchildren's) lot in life is genuinely the main thing, by a long way, that gives my husband and I motivation to build wealth and assets.

I don't really understand what the point is otherwise - you can't take it with you...

Dyrne · 16/02/2023 13:32

Another one saying 5 figures having to last the next 20+ years isn’t actually that much; especially if you consider the cost of care home etc. in fact you’d actually need to be careful that you don’t then fall down the trap of deprivation of assets etc if they’re too free with giving out their money.

I get it’s tough but ultimately the responsibility is on you to have to support the lifestyle you want. For example if you had a sibling that chose to put off having children until they were in a better financial position, or made the heatbreaking choice to only have 1 when they actually wanted 2; would it be fair for your parents to give you more money than them?

On the other hand I think it would be fair to encourage them to think sensibly about estate planning if they have a larger amount of wealth (ie above IHT); as then it actually can make a great deal of sense for them to be at the very least maxing out their gift threshold every year.

Catspyjamas17 · 16/02/2023 13:31

Music lessons and holidays are a luxury, not essentials.

I disagree, I don't think music lessons and holidays should be unobtainable luxuries where you've got two adults working in highly skilled jobs.

Maray1967 · 16/02/2023 13:30

Stop travelling to see them, OP. When they ask, tell them that you can’t afford the petrol.

Onnabugeisha · 16/02/2023 13:30

IDontWantToBeAPie · 16/02/2023 13:22

They shouldn't play any role.

But if they choose to they could set up trusts for the kids or gift you a sum (hoping that they don't die for seven years and you're left paying IHT.).

Since they only have five figures, chances are they won’t owe any IHT

Dinkeigh · 16/02/2023 13:30

Have you ever worked out how long 5 figures would last 2 people? It's not a huge amount of money in retirement, but you want some of it? So what happens when they share it, they then run out, and you've done nothing to change your situation so now you all have no money. Best thing here is to change your position, whether that be cutting down, 2nd job, making sacrifices.....is there anything you can do to make your situation better?

Brunilde · 16/02/2023 13:30

I think that people should be able to choose what they do with their own money, but...

I would never watch my kids struggle. My mum regularly gives us chunks of cash to help out and has paid for some house renovations etc. She knows that we aren't frivolous with our own money but don't have a lot left for luxuries. But she is very careful with money and has enough put by to pay for care etc should they need it. If she hadn't helped us I wouldn't have thought badly of her. When my children are older I hope to be able to do the same as I'd get more enjoyment seeing my kids happy and not have to worry. But I can't imagine we will be as well off as them.

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 13:30

lalaloopyhead · 16/02/2023 13:19

I'm not sure about this to be honest. My parents are not wealthy but comfortable and have helped me out in the past with one off things, like a contribution towards house deposit etc. I am in a reasonable position now myself but even if I wasn't I don;t think I would expect them to give me anything substantial or a regular income.

What kind of help are you meaning OP?

I haven’t actually got any ideas or thoughts about wanting anything. I don’t have a solution either. It’s half term and I’m feeling guilty that I can’t take my kids to do “nice” things like swimming at the leisure centre, half-term activity sessions, visits to a farm etc. Personally, I’d prefer that this was addressed by society as there’s plenty of other families like ours who don’t have grandparents with any wealth.

OP posts:
Riverlee · 16/02/2023 13:27

It would be nice if they offer, but the children shouldn’t expect it, and shouldn’t begrudge their grandparents for passing their money on.

Music lessons and holidays are a luxury, not essentials.

If the money is in assets, then they could be asset rich but cash poor. Ie. Have a large house, but have little disposable income.

So basically, grandparents don’t need to play any role in helping their less wealthy relatives. Yes, it would be nice, but not mandatory.