Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Generational finances

231 replies

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 12:45

I don’t expect I can word this right/fairly but essentially, if retired grandparents have some wealth (e.g., 5 figure savings or assets) and their adult children are bringing up young children on barely enough to pay rent/mortgage, energy bills, childcare and food - is this okay? What are your thoughts and beliefs about how to balance wealth and finances more fairly? What role should grandparents play financially?

OP posts:
TeaCosyApplePie · 16/02/2023 14:19

I'm in a family where wealth was passed on either in inheritances, help while people were alive or houses. Until it reached my parents who have spent much of it and refused to help any of us in a meaningful way. Neither earned any of it and retired before 40. I on the other hand will be working until my late 60s and have earned everything I have. Rightly or wrongly, It's a hard pill to swallow. As a result we have done our damndest to ensure we can help our kids as much as possible, albeit with smaller resources. I want them to have an easier life than me so if I can help them in any way I will.

firstworldprob · 16/02/2023 14:18

I know millennials and those younger have it tougher. However many of them won’t be moaning when they come into their Boomer parents’ assets in the years to come.

A small violin here for those at the tail end of Gen X without wealthy parents…

We still paid quite a hefty sum for property in the south, didn’t have the glorious work-life perks that those younger have and our very old or soon to be deceased folks didn’t quite accumulate the wealth of the baby boomers.

And yet the younger generation will financially leapfrog us once the inheritances trickle down.

Bide your time and in the mean time, cut your cloth accordingly.

And the poster above who suggested there is little benefit of inheriting age 55+ - umm bring it on I say! Some of us will still have kids at uni or school then!

Flammkuchen · 16/02/2023 14:16

Just as youth is wasted on the young, wealth is wasted on the old.

The problem now is that decent wages are not enough to buy a decent house, so the young are reliant on family wealth to get started. In that situation, yes, I think parents who afford it have an obligation to help out. I couldn’t live in a comfortably 5 bed home while my grandkids lived in a small flat.

bobbytorq · 16/02/2023 14:15

5 figures is nothing and will be eaten up very quickly with a few unplanned for spends.

Boisey · 16/02/2023 14:14

£100k at age 65 could buy you £3,800 a year until you die. £300-ish a month. Add in the state pension and you are hardly wealthy. I wouldn’t try retiring until I had considerably more than 5 figures saved up.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/02/2023 14:13

No, I don't think there should be a cultural expectation that money should just roll down the generations.

When you have children then you take on the responsibility and risks of raising them. That's a decision you make.

Wexone · 16/02/2023 14:12

Am on the fence, my in laws are wealthy and have been very generous in the past to us. However they could live another 20 years and things aren't cheap, that money has to last them till they die and cover all costs. Their health insurance is currently 5k a year, they car insurance is nearly 2k - this is due to their age ( can not get any cheaper). Keep chipping away like that and it wont last long. They pay for dinner when we go out and if come shipping will pay for everything if they are let. They also pay for their grandkids expensive school fees - this i think is wrong, There are cheaper schools ( and a lot better aswell) that they could go to. SIL guilt tripped them into paying in my opinion and this comes under a lifestyle choice aswell, not struggling, My own parents are terrible with money aswell as being mean, would never pay for a cup of coffee let alone a meal. They would never suggest helping out either. Though tome its both their money and up to them on how they spend it. Helping out doesn't not always mean giving money.

Happypanda22 · 16/02/2023 14:12

Should they for fairness - no
But in any situation where one group has a lot less money than another (friends or family) it will create awkwardnesss.
and they may not like the trade offs eg if you count the cost of petrol for a year of visits and realise it can pay for music lessons
maybe they don’t realise or don’t want to realise how tight things are. Think one of challenges for some over 60s is they think life is equally hard for them as for you when young and assume if you ate less avocados then you could have the lifestyle they had at your age
Maybe be upfront and tell them - you have been through budget carefully. It is very tight and you are making x y z economies to eg afford music lessons so they could now drive to you half the time
that isn’t then about you asking for money but may bring it home
also possible they are worried about future (5 figures isn’t much for 30 years of retirement

StopGrowingPlease · 16/02/2023 14:09

If you are on a low income leisure centres usually have discounts available to help you out. Me, dp and our toddler can go swimming for under £6 with this help so it’s definitely worth looking into 😊

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 14:08

It’s not your wealth that is required to be distributed ‘fairly’. It’s theirs, and it’s totally up to them what they do with it. You may think they have a moral obligation to help you, but unless they have the same feeling then the reality is that you’re shit out of luck. That you’re upset about this isn’t their problem to solve, it’s something you have to come to terms with yourself.

I’ll ‘admit’ that my parents helped set me up financially, but they did it because they wanted to, and if they hadn’t that would have been perfectly okay too. Their money isn’t something that I am, as an adult, in any entitled to.

EL8888 · 16/02/2023 14:08

SleeplessInEngland · 16/02/2023 12:59

My thoughts are: if you're a boomer and were not totally incompetent at work then you won the economic lottery and could probably afford a much nicer house and lifestyle than millenials of the same ability/standing.

Does that mean they have to redistribute their wealth it to younger generations? No. But you'd hope for a bit of understanding and yeah, if they're feeling charitable, perhaps a bit of financial help if it's within their means.

Quite. For people of that generation then it appears they had to be rather lazy and / or made a number of stupid decisions.

They don’t necessarily need to distribute it. But dialling down the stupid comments would be helpful e.g. my mother keeps on asking about why we don’t have a wrap around extension. Errr we can’t afford it?! Mortgages are expensive and salaries have been static for years. Very galling as my husband and l have worked way longer hours and are more qualified than all of our parents. Plus they got thousands of hours of free childcare. We don’t get any

Friendofdennis · 16/02/2023 14:06

My parents helped me and I have helped and will help my child. The kindness of my parents (now deceased ) prevented us from hitting rock bottom financially I will always be grateful to them for saving us from homelessness

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 14:05

Swiftswatch · 16/02/2023 14:03

Why can’t you teach them? The ‘otherwise children will drown’ card you’re trying to cram into this argument is making you seem pretty unreasonable.

My point was it costs money to visit the local pool.

OP posts:
Lozois99 · 16/02/2023 14:04

SleeplessInEngland · 16/02/2023 12:59

My thoughts are: if you're a boomer and were not totally incompetent at work then you won the economic lottery and could probably afford a much nicer house and lifestyle than millenials of the same ability/standing.

Does that mean they have to redistribute their wealth it to younger generations? No. But you'd hope for a bit of understanding and yeah, if they're feeling charitable, perhaps a bit of financial help if it's within their means.

^THIS ^

Swiftswatch · 16/02/2023 14:03

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 13:44

For obvious reasons society should ensure swimming is too expensive for most and that only the wealthiest children get the opportunity to learn and avoid drowning. Having children drown more regularly is the sign of a healthy society nowadays.

Why can’t you teach them? The ‘otherwise children will drown’ card you’re trying to cram into this argument is making you seem pretty unreasonable.

Terven · 16/02/2023 14:02

Five figure savings is not “wealth”. If you think that this is a lot for a retired couple you have no clue. If you start chipping away at their savings, are you taking responsibility for any unexpected expenses in the future?

WallaceinAnderland · 16/02/2023 14:01

How old are they and how many years does their savings/asset have to last?

If they are in good health, aged 68, they may have 20 years left in them. This means they can only spend about 5k a year before they run out. If they are living off pension with 5k to top it up, it's not a lot is it.

Choconut · 16/02/2023 14:01

Surely you mean 6 figures? Otherwise what they have is really very little in retirement, if they need their roof redone they could say good bye to a 5 figure sum for example. Do they have huge pensions? Own multiple properties?

It's not really clear why you would think they are so well off that they should be giving you money if all they have is a 5 figure sum in the bank.

ScribblingPixie · 16/02/2023 14:00

Five figures is £10,000 to £99,000 in savings or assets (house?)? That's not much to see you through the whole of old age, OP.

Zanatdy · 16/02/2023 14:00

If I could afford it I wouldn’t sit by and watch my children struggle. Especially because those grandparents with plenty of money probably only have it through benefitting from rising property prices etc.

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 16/02/2023 13:59

I think about this more than I should.

My parents aren't able to help, unfortunately, which is fine. But I'm already putting a plan in place to help my boys when they're older. We've opened up savings accounts for them. We've invested about £5k each for them. I'm looking at buying a property that they can move into when they're older.

If I was a multimillionaire, they'd never have to worry!

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 16/02/2023 13:52

I think it's hard. My mum in her 80s has hundreds of thousands in the bank. It's money she and my Dad earned and left to her by my grandparents. Too late to redistribute it now. If there is any left when she goes, my bit will be used on house deposits for my adult children.
Me and dh are working and help our adult dc with rent and childcare expenses. We own our home but now are saving for our retirement. So whilst we are asset rich, it's not liquid.

EmmaEmerald · 16/02/2023 13:51

Ponoka "Personally in their position I'd be offering the difference between your full and part time wage for three years, or if there's a lot of you a few £k each for a few years."

with five figures in the bank, you'd offer that?

Ponoka7 · 16/02/2023 13:48

I don't get it either. I'm from a WC background. I live in a deprived area. The GPs I know and did know (now deceased) living on state pensions loved to be able to slip their GC the odd £5, pay for a school/christening/baptism etc outfit, or a trip out. I think that there's a level of truth in those with less being more generous. It makes more sense for money to be distributed when the children are small, than a 55+ year old inheriting. As a LP if my Mum had have helped me when I was widowed, I would have been able to get better qualified and we'd have had a better quality of life. Personally in their position I'd be offering the difference between your full and part time wage for three years, or if there's a lot of you a few £k each for a few years.

Tailstock · 16/02/2023 13:47

My parents have done nothing but moan about the inheritance tax paid from their parents estate then an unexpected death of a younger sister who had no children all significant sums of money, but equally haven't passed any of this money on to their own children. Both retired early prior to receiving 3 lots of inheritance as both had saving and decent public sector pensions. I cannot understand why they moan about it but then don't attempt to distribute it! It will end up sitting in a bank account and double taxed